June 12, 2018 — City Council Study Session

Transcript

Captions from City of Boulder YouTube recording.

[1:10] THE WAR ON. IN THE IN THE WAY

[2:22] MORE SHE KNEW

[3:00] THUS THUS THUS THUS THUS THE DECAY. LET'S GET STARTED. WELCOME EVERYONE TO THE JUNE TWELFTH STUDY SESSION WITH A JOINT SESSION BETWEEN THE CITY COUNCIL IN OPEN SPACE FOR TRUSTEES. I'D LIKE TO ON BEHALF OF COUNCIL WELCOME ABOARD TO THE MEETING TONIGHT A REAL PLEASURE TO HAVE YOU HERE THANKS FOR JOINING US WE LOOK FORWARD TO REALLY GREAT DISCUSSION TONIGHT AND I WANT TO MAKE SURE WE GET TO COUNCIL MEMBERS MISSING FOR SEVEN OF US WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL TWELVE FOLKS HERE HAVE EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES TO SPEAK EVERYONE'S INPUT IS VERY MUCH VALUED AND LOOK FORWARD TO THAT FULL DISCUSSION FROM EVERYONE PRESENT SO THAT BEING SAID WE DO HAVE ON THE MIKE WE DO HAVE A FACILITATOR WITH THE SITE IS GOING TO START US OFF HERE FROM STAFF SO YOU WANNA KICK US OFF AND TELL US HOW YOU'RE GOING TO LEAD US TO THIS MEETING TONIGHT. YES HIGH IN

[4:01] L A BORN WITH DESIGN OR SHOUT THANK YOU FOR HAVING US HERE TONIGHT AND WILL START OFF WITH HAVING TEA AND BEGAN THE INTRODUCTIONS WERE LACKING A LITTLE SPACE HEATERS. I JUST WANTED TO QUICKLY SET THE TONE FOR A LITTLE BIT TONIGHT TO STUFF A MINUTE OR TWO OF A BRIEF INTRODUCTION MY NAME IS AMBER INTERIM DIRECTOR FOR OPEN SPACE SMALL PARKS A TITLE THAT I'VE WORN OUT MY NAME TAG FOR ABOUT TEN DAYS SO WITH WITH THE NEWNESS OF MY POSITION THAT MEANS THAT I HAVEN'T HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO PERSONALLY MEET ALL OF YOU YET AND GET TO KNOW YOU AND THAT'S SOMETHING THAT I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO GETTING TO DO. NEPTUNE A DO OVER THE NEXT COUPLE OF MONTHS AND YEARS SO AT FIRST JUST WANT TO SAY I REALLY LOOK FORWARD TO THAT OPPORTUNITY AND ALSO JUST WANT TO PERSONALLY THANK EACH ONE OF YOU FOR ALL YOUR TIME AND GUIDANCE AT THIS CRITICAL JUNCTION IN OUR MASTER PLANNING PROCESS. IT'S A CRITICAL SORT OF MILESTONE RIGHT NOW SO ITS REALLY APPRECIATE THE EXTRA TIME AND EFFORT THAT YOU'RE PROVIDING

[5:04] AT THIS POINT SO THE WORK THAT YOU'LL SEE AND THAT WILL DISCUSS HERE TONIGHT AS IS REALLY THE COMBINATION THE RESULT OF AN EXTENSIVE INNOVATIVE ENGAGEMENT PROCESS AND EFFORTS IN WHICH THE STAFF WHEN OUT AND HEARD FROM MANY VOICES THAT REPRESENT A DIVERSE CROSS SECTION OF OUR COMMUNITY AND WHAT WE'RE ASKING YOU TO DO IS TO CONFIRM THE MANAGEMENT TEAMS THAT RESULTED THAT CAME OUT OF THESE DISCUSSIONS THAT OCCURRED AND THE FEEDBACK THAT HAS OCCURRED OVER THE PAST FEW MONTHS. WE OF COURSE ARE CALLING THOSE MANAGEMENT TEAM'S FOCUS AREAS AND FOCUS AREAS WILL ACTUALLY BECOME THE FOUNDATION IF YOU WANT TO VIEW IT THAT WAY OF THE MASTER PLAN DOCUMENT AND THE FOCUS AREAS WILL THEN HELP US TO DETERMINE THE MANAGEMENT OF OUR OPEN SPACE SYSTEM OVER THE NEXT FIVE TO TEN YEARS WITH THE FOCUS AREAS ALSO HELP TO DO IS TO REALLY CONFIRM

[6:01] THE LEGACY AND THE DEEP FOUNDATION THAT IS BENEATH US HERE AS AN OPEN SPACE SYSTEM AND TO ALSO TO ANTICIPATE AND TO LOOK FORWARD TO THE NEXT FEW DECADES AND WHAT'S IN STORE FOR US IN TERMS OF MANAGING THE OPEN SPACE SYSTEM. IN ADDITION TO THE RICH FEEDBACK THAT WE'VE GOTTEN I ALSO LIKE TO SAY THAT THE FOCUS MERE AREAS ALSO RECEIVE SOME AWESOME CLARITY AND SOME MASSAGING AS PART OF THE RICH EXPERIENCE AND OF OUR OPEN SPACE STAFF WE HAVE A LOT OF EXPERIENCE AND PROFESSIONALISM WITHIN THE STAFF AND THEY ALSO HELP SHAPE THE FOCUS AREAS THAT WILL BE DISCUSSING HERE TONIGHT SO NO PROMISE TO BE BRIEF. I JUST WANT TO DO SOME BRIEF INTRODUCTIONS OF SOME STAFF MEMBERS THAT ARE HERE TODAY TO HELP SUPPORT THIS CONVERSATION THAT ARE ALL ABOUT TO LAUNCH INTO. OF COURSE TO MY LEFT WE HAVE KAREN WAITER WHO IS OUR MASTER PLANNED PROJECT

[7:00] MANAGER AND LEFT IT BARE AND MARK DAVIS AND OUR MASTER PLANNED PROJECT SPONSOR THE HEAVY LIFTERS IF YOU WILL OF THIS PROCESS AND OF COURSE ARE SUPPORTED BY A LOT OF EXPERTISE THAT'S IN THE ROOM TONIGHT WITH STAFF. I JUST WANT TO PERSONALLY POINT DEL MAR CURSE MEN WHO WILL ACTUALLY BE ASSUMING THE PROJECT MANAGER ROLE FOR THE MASTER PLAN DURING GARRETT'S THE PRINT TO LEAVE THAT'S GOING TO BE UP COMING LATER THIS SUMMER AND FALL YEA SO I MARK WILL BE ASSUMING THE HELM FOR A LITTLE BIT THERE AND BEHIND ME WE HAVE BRIAN AND A CAR SCIENCE OFFICER AND STEVE ARE INSTEAD OUR INTERIM DEPUTY DIRECTOR AND JOHN POTTER OUR RESOURCES STEWARDSHIP SUPERVISOR JULIET NOW THAT MY CRUISE ALSO SUPPORTING THE MASTER PLAN TEAM AND I'M SURE THERE'S MORE BEHIND ME BUT WITH THAT BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF TIME TONIGHT AND I COULD TAKE UP IN YOUR TIME TO TURN THINGS RIGHT OVER TO ANNA WHO WILL HELP US GET STARTED. THANK

[8:00] YOU AND THERE SO I'LL REVIEW A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE MEETING AGENDA AND PURPOSE WHY WE'RE HERE TONIGHT SO WITH HELP FROM THE PROCESS COMMITTEE OR SNP STAFF DESIGNED AND PERMITTED TO ENGAGE WINDOWS TO DEVELOP AND CONFIRM THE FOCUS HERE IS THAT YOU'LL DISCUSS TONIGHT AND AM GOING TO TELL YOU A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THOSE IN A MOMENT SO WE'RE HERE TONIGHT TO HEAR YOUR THOUGHTS ON THESE RESULTS OF ENGAGEMENTS BEFORE ASK YOU TO APPROVE FINAL FOCUS AREAS IN JULY WERE ALSO ANDERSON HEAR YOUR EARLY INPUT ON THE RELATED TOPICS THAT WILL DESCRIBE EACH FOCUS AREA BUT YOU'LL NOT BE ASKED TO FORMALLY APPROVE THESE FOCUS AREAS ARE NOT DIRECTIONAL IN OTHER WORDS WE'RE NOT ASKING YOU TO MAKE A DECISION NEXT MONTH ABOUT HOW WE SHOULD IMPLEMENT OR FANCY SPOKE A SERIOUS DISCUSSIONS ABOUT STRATEGIES OR POLICIES WILL BE BEGIN THIS FALL AND CONTINUE THROUGHOUT NEXT YEAR OR SO GAGNON GOING TO TELL YOU A LITTLE MORE ABOUT THE PROCESS AND WHERE WE ARE

[9:00] TONIGHT. THANK YOU AND I EVERYONE REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR TIME TONIGHT WHEN IT'S JUST REMIND YOU THAT WHEN WE STARTED ENGAGING WITH BOARDING COUNCIL THAT WAS TO DEVELOP OR PROJECT MANAGEMENT PLAN AND SO WE GOT APPROVAL FROM COUNCIL TO MOVE FORWARD IN JANUARY WITH THAT APPROACH AND HAVE SINCE AS ANNA SAID AND I CONDUCTED TWO ENGAGEMENT WINDOWS. THE FIRST WAS FOCUSED ON AROUND ASKING THE COMMUNITY NOW USE HOPES AND CONCERNS FOR THE FUTURE OF OPEN SPACE THAT WAS GROUNDED BY THE RELEASE OF A SYSTEM OVERVIEW REPORT WHICH WE HAVE COPIES OF SITTING AROUND THE TABLE IF ANYBODY IS INTERESTED AT SOME POINT BEEN FLIPPING THROUGH THAT WAS AN INTENTION TO BE IN ALIGNMENT WITH THE ENGAGEMENT STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK AND TO SET A STRONG FOUNDATION OF INFORMATION TO BUILD A SENSE OF INQUIRY IN THE BEGINNING PHASE OF THE PROJECT AND THEN WE CONDUCTED A SECOND ENGAGEMENT WINDOW TO ESSENTIALLY CONFIRMS THE ANALYSIS THAT CAME OUT OF THE FIRST ENGAGEMENT WINDOW AND EXPLAINED THAT IN A LITTLE BIT MORE DEPTH NOW TO POINT OF INTEGRATING

[10:01] THE FEEDBACK THAT WE'VE HEARD IN BOTH OF THESE TWO ENGAGEMENT WINDOWS AND THIS IS OPPORTUNITY AS I AND DAN HAVE SAID FOR BOARDING COUNCIL TO WEIGH IN AND HELP US UNDERSTAND HOW BEST TO MOVE FORWARD AND THEN AGAIN THREE OR E WHAT ANNA SAID THAT THE NEXT ENGAGEMENT WINDOW WILL BE FOCUSED ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF STRATEGIES AND THAT'S WHAT WE REALLY BEGIN TO TALK ABOUT HOW WE IMPLEMENT AND ADVANCE THE FOCUS AREAS AND RELATED TOPICS THAT ARE DESCRIBED IN ERIE FOR THOSE IN EARLY NINETEEN WOULD BE OUR FOURTH ENGAGEMENT WINDOW WHERE WE START TO NARROW IN AND WE FURTHER REFINE THE STRATEGIES WE FURTHER DEVELOP SOME IDEAS OF PRIORITIES. WE WOULD ADMINISTER A STATISTICALLY VALID SURVEY TO UNDERSTAND FROM OUR COMMUNITY HOW OF AC THE STRATEGY SHAPING UP IN RELATION TO EACH OTHER SO THIS IDEA OF TRADE OFFS THAT CAME OUT CAME UP DURING THE PROJECT MANAGEMENT PROCESS MANAGEMENT PLANNING PROCESS WE WOULD BE ADDRESSING IN THAT STATISTICALLY VALID SURVEY AND THEN WE WOULD ALSO BE

[11:00] DEVELOPING A SET OF THREE FINANCIAL SCENARIOS WHICH WILL HELP US UNDERSTAND DIFFERENT REVENUE FUTURES AND HOW BEST TO GROUND TRUTH. OUR APPROACH THAT WE DEVELOP IN THE MASTER PLAN AGAINST THOSE FINANCIAL SCENARIOS AND OUR GOAL IS TO COMPLETE THE FINAL PLAN IF WE CAN BY LATE SUMMER OF NEXT YEAR. SO JUST A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THE ENGAGEMENT WINDOWS ON THE MEXICAN TO SHOW YOU A WONDERFUL LITTLE VIDEO WITH OUR FORMER DIRECTOR INTRODUCING THAT VIDEO THE FIRST ENGAGEMENT WINDOW AS I MENTIONED WAS AN EFFORT TO HEAR THE VALUES HOPES AND CONCERNS OF OUR COMMUNITY AND WE REALLY DID THAT IN A BROAD INCLUSIVE WAY WHERE WE WERE ABLE TO ENGAGE DIRECTLY WITH TWO THOUSAND PEOPLE AND WE GOT FIFTEEN HUNDRED WRITTEN RESPONSES BACK AS A PART OF THAT PROCESS AND WE DID UP THROUGH A SERIES OF WHAT WE CALLED MY CREATIONS ARE WE DOING SOME SOME SHORT DURATION ENGAGEMENTS OUT IN THE COMMUNITY. IN ADDITION TO HOLDING EVENTS ARE ASKED FOLKS TO COME TO OUR MASTER

[12:00] PLAN EVENTS AND WE REALLY DO APPRECIATE. I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THE PROCESS COMMITTEE MEMBERS THE AIR AND MARY TOM INCURRED FOR YOUR GUIDANCE IN HELPING TO SHAPE THE APPROACH TO THAT ENGAGEMENT WINDOW AND ALSO IN THE AFTER ACTION ACTION AFTER ACTION REVIEW THAT WE DID WITH YOU JUST WANNA THANK YOU FOR THE POSITIVE FEEDBACK THAT WE HEARD IN RELATION TO THAT I THINK THAT WE'RE EXCITED TO HAVE MOVED FORWARD IN A NEW WAY WITH ENGAGEMENT AT OPEN SPACE AND THEN AS A MENTIONED ENGAGEMENT THE WINDOW TOO WAS AN EFFORT TO SAY HOW WELL DID WE HEAR YOU BECAUSE WE EVALUATED THE FEEDBACK IN THAT FIRST WINDOW TO DEVELOP SOME PROPOSED FOCUS AREAS AND THEN RELEASE THOSE TO THE AND GAS THROUGH A BRIEF ONLINE QUESTIONNAIRE HOW WELL THE COMMUNITY WAS RESONATING WITH THOSE WE GOT ABOUT FOUR AND FIFTY ONLINE RESPONSES TO THAT SOMEONE SHOW YOU THIS BRIEF VIDEO. IN THERE WITH ME

[13:03] JUST ONE SECOND. THERE'S ALWAYS A BUT IT'S COMING COMES THIS VIDEO IS A SUMMARY MOSTLY OF OUR FIRST ENGAGEMENT WINDOW BUTTONS ARE REALLY NICE CELEBRATION OF THE DIVERSITY OF VOICES THAT WE HEARD AND SO WE JUST WANTED TO SHARE WITH YOU HOW HOW THAT'S INFORMATIVE ALUM OF THESE FOCUS AREAS THE HOLE IN SPACE AND MEL PARK'S LANDSCAPE A LANDSCAPE THAT IS THE FIRST FLOOR IT WITH THE BACKDROP PRAIRIE GRASSLAND STREAMS CREEKS FORESTS. YOU NAME IT IT'S A SPECIAL PLACE THAT HAS COMPELLED US TO PROTECT IT AND RESPONSIBLY ENJOY IT FOR AS LONG AS ANYONE CAN REMEMBER AS WE HAVE TO LOOK

[14:02] FORWARD WITH THE OPEN SPACE AND MOUNTAIN PARKS MASTER PLAN. WE WORKED CLOSELY WITH THE PROCESS COMMITTEE TO GUIDE US AND SUPPORTED BY THE ENGAGEMENT STRATEGY SUPPORTED BY COUNCIL OPEN SPACE FOR THE AND OR COMPEL COULD CONNECT TO THE COMMUNITY THE WAY THAT IS INCLUSIVE SO THAT WE HEAR A DIVERSE SET OF VOICES SO THAT WE'RE SURE TO PROTECT AND ENJOY THIS PLACE INTO THE FUTURE FOR MANY YEARS TO COME AND SO I HOPE YOU ENJOY THIS SHORT VIDEO THAT SEEKS TO DEMONSTRATE THAT INCLUSIVE APPROACH AS YOU ALSO SEE THIS VIDEO THE DIVERSE VOICES SHARED VALUES AND HOPES FOR THE FUTURE. I AM SO GRATEFUL TO BE A PART OF THIS PROGRAM AND I LEAVE HAVING FELT HONORED AND PRIVILEGED TO BE

[15:00] PART OF THIS PROGRAM PART OF THIS CITY APART OF THIS COMMUNITY SEE ON THE TRAIL HERE IN BOULDER. THE SPECIAL OPEN SPACE LEGACY THAT'S THE ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY YEARS THE THE BOULDER IS WORKING TO ENSURE A REMARKABLE LEGACY INJURIES FROM THE EARLIER THIS YEAR WE KICKED OFF THE MASTER PLAN THE COOL SHADE THE COMMUNITY MEMBERS IN THE THE NEAR POST AND THE TEAM TO THE EMBERS AND THE CITY RECEIVES NEARLY ONE THOUSAND COME TRAIN WILL HELP THE FUTURE OF YOUR LAND

[16:03] IN THE AM THE WEEK THE RIGHT TO YOURS WE NEED TO FOCUS ON THE SYSTEM. THE ISSUE THE ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGES THE HERD THE SUN ENJOYING THE TREES IN THE RECESSION DEEPENED COMMUNITY CONNECTION THE INCREASE IN THE WE SHOULD FOCUS ON SUSTAINABLE FUNDING FOR THE FUTURE COMMUNITY HAS LONG BELIEVED THAT OPEN SPACES FOR CHILDREN THE CHILDREN AND THEIR CHILDREN THE OFFER A WIDE

[17:01] RELEASE THE STREAM THE FOCUS OF THE OF THE YEAR TURNED INTO THE OPEN SPACE THUS OVER THE NEXT YEAR TO THE HOUSE THE IDEAS FOR THE FUTURE THE POLICE TEAM ALL GO TO THE WIND WAS INSANE TO RECEIVE THE HONOR DUE THE VERY NICE THANK YOU PERCEIVE THAT WE WANTED TO JUST SHARE SOME OF THE THAT WHAT WE FELT LIKE GROUPS KEEPING SCORE SOME OF THE SUCCESSES AND TO JUST HELP CELEBRATE HOW WE DID HEAR FROM THE COMMUNITY AND USE THAT ENGAGEMENT AND FEEDBACK TO SPOIL THAT OVER AND TO DEVELOP THE FOCUS AREAS AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT ONE AND ALSO HOPE TO

[18:02] UNDERSTAND IS HOW WILL MOVE FROM THAT ENGAGEMENT INTO THE DEVELOPMENT OF FOCUS AREAS AND REALLY AGAIN WHERE WE GO FROM THERE AND I'M JUST HAS BEEN ANOTHER COUPLE OF MINUTES AND THEN LET ANNA LEADERS IN THE DISCUSSION SO WE DID HEAR HIM THE ENGAGEMENT PERIODS OF CONFIRMATION OF OUR BASIC CHARTER PURPOSES WHICH ARE MOST BASIC COMMITMENTS TO THE COMMUNITY ABOUT HOW WE PROTECT AND MANAGE OPEN SPACE AND THE SUPPORTING VALUES THAT WE HEARD FROM OUR COMMUNITY REALLY DID AFFIRM THOSE CHARTER PURPOSES AND REALLY ACT AS A AS A BRIDGE BETWEEN THE CHARTER PURPOSES AND THE FOCUS AREAS THAT WILL BE TALKING ABOUT TONIGHT AND THOSE FOCUS AREAS ARE REALLY AS DOES DAN AND ANNA HAVE INDICATED AN OPPORTUNITY TO SAY WHAT ARE WE NEED TO FOCUS ON NOW WHAT ARE THE THINGS THAT ARE PRESSING FOR US WHAT ARE THE THINGS IN OUR CURRENT FOUNDATION OF OF POLICY AND MANAGEMENT APPROACHES THAT NEED TO BE CONFIRMED AS WE MOVE FORWARD AND HOW DO WE DEVELOP A SET

[19:01] OF STRATEGIES THAT COME OUT OF THAT AND SUSANNA SAID TONIGHT AND IN JULY WILL BE FOCUSED ON YOUR APPROVAL OF THOSE FOCUS AREAS BUT TODAY WILL ALSO BE TALKING ABOUT THESE RELATED TOPICS WHICH HAVE EMERGED AS A WAY TO CONFIRM AGAIN WHAT WE HEARD FROM THE COMMUNITY AS WELL AS SOME OF THE NEEDS AND OPPORTUNITIES THAT STAFF IDENTIFIED IN RELATION TO SOME OF THESE TOPICS AND THOSE ARE WAY TO HELP US BRIDGE FROM THE FOCUS AREAS TO THE STRATEGY IS SO IN THE FINAL PRODUCT OF THE MASTER PLAN WE MIGHT NOT SEE RELATED TOPICS AS IN AS A STRUCTURE HIM THE ACTUAL DOCUMENT THEY REALLY JUST A WAY TO HELP US GET TO STRATEGIES WHEN WE START DOING NOT IN THE FALL. I ALSO WANTED TO EMPHASIZE TO THAT WE DESIGNED OUR PROCESS AND OUR APPROACH HERE IN ALIGNMENT WITH GUIDANCE FROM CITYWIDE MASTER PLANNING APPROACHES AS WELL AS EXISTING MASTER PLANS WITH PARKS AND RECREATION FOR EXAMPLE IN THE TRANSPORTATION MASTER PLAN AND SO ARE DEVELOPING APPROACH IN PRODUCTS AND IN ALIGNMENT WITH THE PREVIOUSLY

[20:00] SUCCESSFUL APPROACHES I ALSO JUST WANTED TO SHOW BRIEFLY A DIAGRAM THAT WAS INCLUDED IN THE PROJECT MANAGEMENT PLAN THAT BOTH BOARD AND COUNCIL SUPPORTED ABOUT SIX MONTHS AGO AND I DID SEE THAT AS WE THINK ABOUT INPUTS TO DECISION MAKING HE WANTED TO BE TRANSPARENT WITH WHAT THOSE WERE AND THAT WAS A REQUEST AGAIN THAT CAME OUT OF THE ENGAGEMENT STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK AND SO OF COURSE WE START WITH THE CITY CHARTER AND WE'VE DONE OUR CROSSWALK BETWEEN THE CITY CHARTER PURPOSES IN THE EMERGING FOLKS THERE IS AGAIN WILL BE TALKING ABOUT TONIGHT AND THE FEEDBACK HAS LARGELY INFORMS THE FOCUS AREAS WE'VE ALSO PULLED THROUGH SIGNIFICANT FINDINGS FROM OUR SYSTEM OVERVIEW REPORT THAT AGAIN WE KICKED OFF THE PROCESS WITH AS WELL AS ADDITIONAL REPORT AND READ REPORTS AND RESEARCH THAT ARE AVAILABLE TO INFORM THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE FOCUS AREAS AS WELL AS INPUT FROM STAFF AND CONSULTING EXPERTISE HERE SO JUST BY WAY OF EXAMPLE WHEN WE GET INTO DISCUSSION WHEN ANNA IS GOING TO LEAD US THROUGH THAT WHEN WE TALK ABOUT EACH OF THESE FOCUS AREAS YOU'LL SEE A SLIDE THAT LOOKS LIKE THE BEST ANSWER JUST ONE AND

[21:01] WE'RE JUST GONNA LEAVE THE SLIDES UP FOR YOU AS A REFERENCE DURING THOSE DISCUSSIONS AND SO WE WON'T TALK AT THEM JUST RIGHT NOW JUST TO HELP YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU'LL BE SEEING WHEN WE DO THAT. SO UNDERNEATH EACH OF THE FOLKS ARE TITLES YOU'LL SEE A STATEMENT AND THAT'S THE SUPPORTING VALUE STATEMENT THAT EMERGED FROM COMMUNITY INPUT. YOU'LL SEE ON THE RIGHT HAND SIDE A BRIEF SUMMATION OF WHAT WE HEARD IN RELATION TO EACH FOCUS AREA FROM THE FIRST ENGAGEMENT WINDOW AS WELL AS FROM THE SECOND AND THEN ON THE LEFT YOU'LL SEE A LIST OF RELATED TOPICS THAT HELP DESCRIBE THE FOCUS AREA AND AGAIN AND HELP HELP US BRIDGE THE STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT THE WAY YOU SEE THEM IS AS REVISED AS WE ARE PROPOSING AS REVISIONS AFTER THE SECOND ENGAGEMENT WINDOW BECAUSE IN THE FEEDBACK PROCESS WE DID HEAR SOME SUGGESTIONS ABOUT WAYS TO IMPROVE THE WAY WE TALK ABOUT THINGS TO HELP BUILD A LIME IN UNDERSTANDING ABOUT WHAT IT IS THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT AND SO THOSE HAVE BEEN INDICATED WITH EITHER REVISED THAT'S WHAT'S

[22:00] IN PARENTHESES OR ADDED. AND SO THAT'S WHAT YOU'LL SEE. SO ANOTHER EXAMPLE HERE'S WITH FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY AND SO JUST TO DESCRIBE HOW WE'VE USED BOTH WINDOWS AS WELL STAFF AND EXPERTISE TO DEVELOP THESE FOCUS AREAS THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF WHERE IN THE FIRST WINDOW WE ONLY HEARD ABOUT EIGHTY PERCENT OF OUR COMMENTS RELATED TO FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY. BUT IN LIGHT OF OUR SON SITTING SALES TAX INCREMENTS AND OUR AMATEUR SYSTEM THAT WE NOW HAVE WE'RE IN A POSITION OF NEEDING TO FOCUS ON TAKING CARE OF WHAT WE HAVE CITY WIDE AWARENESS IS AND PLANNING AROUND OBTAINING REVENUE FUTURES THAT WE FELL A STAFF IN THE LINE WITH CITY WORK THAT NEEDED TO BE A CONVERSATION THAT WE ELEVATE AS A PROPOSED FOCUS AREA AND IN THE SECOND OCCASION WHEN YOU'LL SEE THAT THE COMMUNITY RESPONDED VERY STRONGLY IN SUPPORTING THAT PROPOSAL WHERE WE HEARD NINETY ONE PERCENT OF RESPONDENTS TO THE ONLINE QUESTIONNAIRE SAY YES THIS TOPIC IS FOCUS AREAS EITHER IMPORTANT OR VERY

[23:00] IMPORTANT FOR THE FUTURE OF AUSTIN PEAY AND SO THAT UNDERSTAND THESE LINES THAT'S OUR BRIEF INTRODUCTION AND THE NANAIMO WHAT YOU TAKE IT FROM HERE SO YOU SEE IN FRONT OF YOU A PAGE THAT LISTS I'M THE FRAMING QUESTIONS FOR THIS EVENING THAT WE WANTED RECTOR TENSION TO THE FIRST ONE IS THAT OVERALL ALL THE PROPOSED FOCUS AREAS ARE THE RIGHT OVERARCHING THEMES TO GUIDE OR SKIMPY MANAGEMENT OVER THE NEXT FIVE TO TEN YEARS WITH AN EYE TO THE NEXT FIFTY YEARS THAT'S ALL WE ASK YOU TO DIRECT MOST OF YOUR EMPHASIS IS EVENING AND TO THAT QUESTION FOR EACH OF THE FOCUS AREAS WILL ALSO BE LOOKING FOR JIMMY REFINEMENT OF THIS FOCUS HERE THAT WE SHOULD CONSIDER BEFORE US BT AND CITY COUNCIL CONFIRMED THE FIVE FOCUS AREAS FOR THE MASTER PLAN AND THEN ARE THERE ANY REFINEMENTS TO THE RELATED TOPICS. SO THOSE ARE THE SMALLER TEXT YOU SEE BELOW THAT BIG HEADER WANTED TO KNOW IF THERE'S ANY THINGS THAT WOULD HELP CONVEY THE MOST IMPORTANT

[24:00] CONVERSATIONS THAT WILL HAVE TO HAVE FOR THE COMMUNITY THIS FALL TO DEVELOP AND PRIORITIZE STRATEGIES. SO THAT'S SOME FOCUS FOR THIS EVENING OF OUR DISCUSSION SAID IN A CASKET PROCESS QUESTION HERE IN RELATED TOPICS ARE THOSE IN FOR DAN AS WELL ARE THESE PRESCRIPTIVE LIKE IF WE DON'T GET ONE IN HERE NOW IS THAT JUST OFF THE TABLE FOR DISCUSSING WHEN WE GET TO STRATEGIES OR WILL THERE BE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BRING IN NEW TOPICS OVER TIME. YEAH WE'RE NOT EXPECTING THIS IS COMPREHENSIVE BUT THIS TIME IS TO MORE HELP INFORM WHAT IF WHAT'S THE FOCUS AREAS ARE ALL ABOUT THE CITY TAKES A LITTLE PRESSURE OFF OF THE CHOOSING OF THOSE THESE ARE INTENDED TO BE REPRESENTED BUT NOT LIMITED TO. THAT'S RIGHT STAY FOCUS AREAS OF THE MAIN FOCUS TONIGHT IF THE WELL OF WHERE WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE FEEL LIKE WORK. THOSE ARE SOLID AND SO THERE ANY SURPRISES IN JULY WHEN YOU GET TOGETHER AND WANT TO GO ABOUT APPROVING THESE EXCELLENT SO I'M GIRL TONIGHT IS TO HAVE A DIALOGUE WITH OPEN SPACE

[25:00] BOARD TRUSTEES AND CITY COUNCIL TO CONFIRM THE PRELIMINARY FOCUS AREAS THIS IS REALLY A CHANCE FOR CONVERSATION AROUND NOT JUST THE FOCUS SERIES BUT ALSO IF YOU WANT TO PROVIDE SOME GUIDANCE ON THOSE TOPICS YOU CAN ASK FOR CLARITY ON THESE AREAS AS WELL AS ANY REFINEMENT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR BUT THERE'S ALSO AN AND AN OPPORTUNITY FOR FOLLOW UP WITH THE OPEN SPACE FORTRESS T STUDY SESSION TO KEEP IN MIND THAT THE VALUE OF THIS MEETING TONIGHT IS DIALOGUE BETWEEN THE TWO GROUPS SO WE WANT TO HELP INFORM THEIR NEXT DISCUSSION AND MY ROLE TONIGHT IS THE WATCHDOG FOR THE HOUR AND FORTY FIVE MINUTES THAT WE HAVE FOR THIS MEET FOR THIS MEETING SO I ALSO HELP FACILITATE THE DIALOGUE SO HELP DIRECT A LITTLE BIT SO WE STAY ON TRACK WITH THESE FOCUS AREAS AND THE FRAMING QUESTIONS AS WELL AS THE ITEMS WITH THE TOPICS THEY WANT TO FOCUS ON SO I'M ALSO SURE THAT YOU HAVE QUESTIONS FOR STAFF WHO ARE HERE THERE FOR REASON OF IF YOU WANT TO DIRECT YOUR DISCUSSIONS THEM I'LL

[26:00] PROBABLY ASK YOU DO YOU NEED KNOW THAT NOW TO INFORM YOUR DISCUSSION TONIGHT JUST GIVEN THAT AMOUNT TIME WE HAVE AND IF SO JUST AS HAPPY TO JUMP IN AND GIVE YOU A QUICK RESPONSE TO THAT BUT IF NOT IF IT'S NOT NEEDED NOW THUSLY BE ASSEMBLING INFORMATION AND RESPONDING TO YOU AND THEY'RE TAKING DETAILED NOTES BE ABLE TO PROVIDE THAT FEEDBACK AT A LATER TIME. YOU'RE ALSO WELCOME TO FOLLOW STAFF SEPARATELY SO AS TO MAXIMISE USE FOR TIME WE ASK THAN ANY NON SUBSTANTIVE ITEMS THAT YOU BELIEVE DON'T REALLY REQUIRE GROUP DESCRIBED DISCUSSION LIKE SAY YOU WANT TO CHANGE THAT WORDING SOME OF THE TOPIC AREAS YOU CAN NOTE THAT ON THE WORKSHEET YOU HAVE IN FRONT OF YOU AND WILL JUST COLLECT THOSE AFTERWARDS. THAT'S THE WAY THAT YOU DON'T HAVE TO BRING THAT TO THE FLOOR IF YOU THINK IT'S AN AREA THAT YOU DON'T NEED FULL DISCUSSION ON AND REMEMBER IF WE DO RUN OF THE TIME FOR THIS MEETING IN JUNE THIRTEENTH TOMORROW THERE WAS THIS BOARD OF TRUSTEES WILL BE MEETING AND THEY CAN HELP CONCLUDE THAT

[27:01] DIRECTION SO I'M THINKING ABOUT THE TIME IF WE WERE TO DIVIDE EACH OF THE FIVE FOCUS AREAS EVENLY FOR FOR ATTENTION THEY GIVE US ONLY FIFTEEN MINUTES PER TOPIC FOR FOUR PER FOCUS AREA AND THEN THIRTY MINUTES FOR CONCLUSIONS AND WRAP UP. SO IN ADVANCE OF THIS MEETING WE ASKED IF THERE ANY ADDITIONAL FOCUS AREAS THAT YOU WANT TO BRING TO THIS MEETING FOR DISCUSSION JUST SO THAT WE COULD UNDERSTAND HOW TO ORGANIZE OUR TIME AND THERE WERE A COUPLE THAT WERE BROUGHT UP SO I DEFINITELY DIDN'T LEAVE ENOUGH TIME FOR THOSE AS WELL IN THE DISCUSSION AN INTERESTING CONVERSATION THERE. SO GIVEN THAT WE ASK THE PROCESS COMMITTEE IF THEY HAVE ANY SUGGESTED TECHNIQUES TO ANTICIPATE HOW TO BEST ALLOCATE OUR TIME WITH THIS LARGE OF A GROUP AND THEY INFORM US THAT BEFORE WE BEGIN A DISCUSSION WE SHOULD ASK YOU ALL FOR A HEAD NOD TO INDICATE IF YOU'RE COMFORTABLE IN CONFIRMING A FOCUS AREA THAT WAY WE'LL KNOW IF WE SEE A LOT OF HAVE NOTS PROBABLY DON'T NEED TO SPEND QUITE AS MUCH TIME AND THAT FOCUS AREA IN DISCUSSION WE CAN GIVE MORE ATTENTION TO

[28:00] THE ONES THAT HAD FEWER HAD KNOTS SO WE'LL START WITH THAT WAY AND THEN WILL I WILL ACTUALLY GO THROUGH ALL FIVE OF THEM WILL OPEN UP FOR DISCUSSION. SO WITH WITH BATS WILL PROCEED BY JUST REVIEWING EACH OF THE FIVE AND ASKING YOU FOR A HEAD NOD IF YOU'RE COMFORTABLE CONFIRMING A FOCUS AREA IS THE RIGHT OVERARCHING THEME SO START WITH THE FIRST ONE HERE IS THE QUESTION INTO THE MIKE THERE ANOTHER CLARIFYING QUESTION TO PARALLEL YOURS ABOUT THE TOPICS UNDERNEATH THE FOCUS AREAS ARE THE FOCUS AREA IS THE EXACT WORDING ARE WE LEAVING TONIGHT WITH AN EXACT WORDING THAT WE ALL AGREE TO OR WILL THERE BE SOME POSSIBILITIES FOR EDITING. AFTER TONIGHT OR WE LOVE TO HEAR WHAT YOUR EDITS ARE FOR THOSE WHO NEED FULL CONFIRMATION TONIGHT BUT I

[29:00] THINK THINGS ARE ASKING THAT QUESTION CANDIDATES IT'S AN IMPORTANT ONE THAT WILL COME UP THE BASIC CONCEPTS NEED TO BE IN STONE WORDING OF IT WE'RE CERTAINLY HAPPY TO HEAR IF YOU HAVE SUGGESTIONS OR NOT MIGHT BE AN OPPORTUNITY USE THE WORKSHEET WHERE IF IT'S JUST SORT OF A WORDSMITH THING SUGGESTION THEM PLEASE CAPTURE THAT BEAR AND THEN IF WE IN FINAL STAGES OF APPROVAL NEED TO DO A LITTLE BIT MORE WORST THING THAT'S OKAY AS LONG AS THE CONCEPTS AND TACT AND THEY JUST MIGHT KNOW HIM THE FOCUS AREAS THEMSELVES THERE'S ONLY LIKE SIXTEEN WORDS TOTAL. SO THAT'S NOT A LOT OF WORKS MEETING ONE OF THE FUN TO SEE CHARLIE WERE TALKING THE EXACT WORDING OF THE FOCUS IS THEMSELVES THE RELATED TOPICS WE COULD GO ON FOREVER WORDS MISSING THOSE THAT MIGHT BE EXACTLY WHAT MAKES NOTES TO ANY OTHER ANY OTHER PROCESS QUESTIONS BEFORE WE DIVE IN THE FIRST VICTORY CAME WE MIGHT NEED AN EXTENDED HAD NOT TAKEN TO SCAN A NOTE AROUND THE ROOM HOW MANY WERE GETTING THE VERY FIRST WINE A VERY BIG HEADER AT THE TOP ECOSYSTEM HEALTH. THAT'S THE FOCUS AREA AND COULD I

[30:01] GET A HEAD NOD FROM FOLKS IF YOU'RE WILLING TO BE COMFORTABLE CONFIRMING THAT ONE CAN SEE ONE THREE FOUR OR SIX TIMES AT THE OK TO HEAR THE A LOT OF INFORMATION AROUND THAT ONCE WE MAY NOT NEED TO SPEND QUITE AS MUCH TIME ON THAT ONE CAME ONTO THE NEXT YEAR I'M GOING TO GO THROUGH THE FIVE AND THEY WILL COME BACK FOR FULL DISCUSSION AFTERWARDS WE JUST NEED TO UNDERSTAND WHERE WILL DIRECT MOST OF OUR TIME IN A TIN OF EMPHASIS TONIGHT AND THAT ONE DOESN'T NEED QUITE AS MUCH BUT I'LL BE COMING BACK ASK YOU ALSO FOR A FEW QUESTIONS ABOUT WHY DID YOU CONFIRM THAT ONE BECAUSE WE ALSO WON HERE THE POSITIVE SIDE OF IF ONE REALLY STOOD OUT TO YOU AND UNDERSTAND THAT SO ONTO THE NEXT RESILIENCE TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE. I GET HEAD NODS AROUND THE ROOM IF YOU'RE CONFIRMING COMFORT WITHOUT ONE OR THUMBS UP BUT EASIER TO HOLD SO IT LOOKS LIKE WE HAVE A COUPLE THAT WHEN YOU COME BACK TO DISCUSS FOR A

[31:01] COUPLE FOLKS CAN ENJOYMENT OF RECREATION AND MANAGEMENT SOME LOOKING AROUND THE ROOM SAYING SOME COMFORT BUT WILL NEED TO COME BACK TO THIS ONE FOR A COUPLE OF PEOPLE ON THE NEXT COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION. WE DO ON THE BOOK A FEW PEOPLE WANT TO TALK ABOUT THIS ONE BUT FOR THE MOST PART WE'VE GOT SOME FERNS THE MOUND. OK AND FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY THE LAST ONE. ARRAYED AROUND THE ROOM WE DON'T NEED TO DISCUSS THAT ONE MUCH LOOKS LIKE YES I DID WANT TO ASK IT BECAUSE YOU DID HAVE SOME THE QUESTION IN ADVANCE ABOUT ARE THERE SOME ADDITIONAL FOCUS AREAS YOU WOULD LIKE TO

[32:00] BRING UP I'D LIKE TO AT THIS TIME ASK IF ANYONE WANTS TO BRING UP THOSE FOCUS SERIES THE COMEBACK THROUGH ALL THESE AGAIN. HE SERVED IN THE MIKE MARY I DO THE CULTURE RESOURCES SAID MARY WANTS TO BRING UP A FOCUS AREA OF CULTURAL RESOURCES TO BE CONSIDERED WITH THE MEANS OR COME BACK TO LIVE SO THAT WAS ONE OF THE CHOICES I GUESS THAT WAS OUT THERE TO THE COMMUNITY THAT DID NOT RECEIVE THE VOTES SUPPORT HENCE WHY BRING IT UP BECAUSE IF WE'RE IF IT WAS ABOUT VOTES I GUESS I THINK THE COMMUNITY SO THAT WAS ANOTHER ONE THAT WILL ADD ON TO LIST HERE AND WE CAN COME BACK AND DISCUSS IN A MOMENT IF EVERYONE'S OKAY THAT I BELIEVE THERE'S ONE OTHER ONE IS WEALTH WE WANT

[33:02] TO NOTE THAT THERE ARE SEVERAL RELATED TOPICS THAT ARE SCATTERED AMONGST THE OTHERS ABOUT AGRICULTURE AND I WOULD PROPOSE THAT THE CHARTER PURPOSE THAT A HUGE PART OF OUR LAND BASED AND IT'S GOING TO A CRITICAL TIME PERIOD SO I WOULD SUGGESTED HIS INVISIBILITY OKAY GREAT. CAN'T WAI TO GO BACK TO THE FIVE AND JUST BEFORE WE MOVE OFF THE PHONE GET A I'M SOME NOTES ABOUT THE ONES THAT WE DID HAVE A LOT OF CONFIRMATION ON AND JUST HERE A FEW REASONS WHY SPEND A COUPLE MINUTES ON THAT AND THEN IF WE GET TO SOME OF THE MORE YOU DID NOT CONFIRM THAT WE WOULD LIKE TO KNOW IT BE THEIR FUTURE REVISIONS FOR IT OR IF THERE SOME OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS AROUND THOSE FOCUS AREAS. SO WITH THAT LOOK LIKE THE ONE THAT WAS ME THAT HE IS MOST AGREEMENT THAT THIS IS ONE WE COULD AFFORD WITH CONFIRMATION IS THE FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY SO COULD I GET

[34:00] A COUPLE COMMENTS ABOUT WHY THAT WAS ONE THAT YOU FELT COMFORTABLE CONFIRMING AND MARY. I HAVE A QUESTION AS TO ACTUALLY YOU CAN'T DO ANY OF THIS AND YOU CAN'T HAVE EVEN HAVE OPEN SPACE WITHOUT FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY SO IT'S ALMOST LIKE THAT ONE GOES WITHOUT SAYING AND SO ON MY QUESTION IS WHY WOULD HE BE CONSIDERED AS A FOCUS AREA HOME BECAUSE IT IS SOMETHING THAT IS ALL ENCOMPASSING THAT GOES WITHOUT SAYING FOR EVERYTHING AND THAT'S THE SAME QUESTION THAT I HAVE FOR COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS THAT KIND OF UM BOTH OF THOSE TO ME SEEM LIKE THERE THEY GO WITHOUT SAYING AND SHOULD BE ALL ENCOMPASSING EVERYTHING THAT WE DO SO. IT'S A GREAT QUESTION MARY AND I DO KNOW THAT PART OF THE REASON THAT BECAME ONE OF THE FOCUS AREAS IS BECAUSE LOOKING AT OTHER

[35:00] MASTER PLANS THAT THIS COMMUNITY HAS TAKEN ON. THEY ALSO HAD THAT BECAUSE THE TRANSPORTATION WOMAN HAD A FOCUS AREA OF FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY AND THAT BECOMES SOMETHING THAT YES IT'S ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL IN THERE SOME PRESSING NEEDS TO DO TO ADDRESS THAT NOW THAT WAS MAYBE DIFFERENT IN THE PAST OR THAT IS EVOLVING AND IT'S AN AREA THAT WE KNOW WILL BE EXPLORED FURTHER IN THE MASTER PLAN YOU IN THE INTERIM THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM SUSTAINABILITY I THINK THERE ARE TWO THINGS IN HERE THAT I THINK THE SHOULD REALLY THINK ABOUT AND THAT'S WHY I THINK IT SHOULD DEFINITELY STAND THERE AS A KEY THING BECAUSE WE'RE A LITTLE DIFFERENT FROM OTHER DEPARTMENTS. ONE OF THEM IS THAT WE HAVE TEXAS THAT PEOPLE ARE VOTING FOR SPECIFICALLY FOR OPEN SPACE AND THAT'S PREVIOUSLY BEEN FOR ACQUISITION WHICH IS THE OTHER THING HERE PRIORITIZING TIME AND MONEY AND I THINK THAT AS WE MOVE FORWARD. PART OF THE MASTER PLAN THAT MIGHT BE REALLY HOPEFUL THAT I THINK WOULD BE

[36:00] ADDRESSED BY THIS IS THINKING ABOUT MOVING FROM ACQUISITION PRIORITIZATION TO MANAGEMENT PRIORITIZATION AS A TAX SYSTEM FOR THAT STILL WORK WELL OR WE NEED TO CHANGE HOW WE DEAL WITH FUNDING FOR THIS DEPARTMENT AND HOW IT'S MANAGED AND I THINK THAT THAT'S A REALLY KEY QUESTION OF A TRADEOFF THAT THE SHOULD ACTUALLY PROBABLY WEIGH IN ON HIM WHICH COMES TO FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY OF THIS IS CAN WE KEEP PUTTING MONEY INTO ACQUISITION DOES THAT REALLY HAVE TO PAY OUT THAT WE WANT AND THERE'S A BROAD ACKNOWLEDGMENT THAT OUR MANAGEMENT HAS NOT BEEN ADEQUATE FOR OUR CURRENT RESOURCES AND THAT'S PROBABLY GOING TO TAKE CONSIDERABLY MORE FINANCIAL INPUT SO AND WE'RE RUNNING OUT OF MONEY WELL RUNNING OUT OF THE TAX FUND AND MONEY AND I THINK THAT THAT'S WHEN WE BROUGHT IT UP AS A BOARD IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS OUR RESPONSE HAS BEEN JUST WAIT FOR THE MASTER PLAN BECAUSE THAT'S WHEN THE WILL GET TO WEIGH IN ON THAT AND I THINK IT'S A REALLY VALID QUESTION AND TOM AND

[37:00] CINDY I COULD JUST QUICKLY SPEED ON THE FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY POINT IF ONE IS DIFFERENT THAN ALL OF THE OTHERS IN THIS RESPECT IF YOU ARE TO LOOK AT ALL OF THE NINE MAJOR PLANS THAT OPEN SPACE HAS PUT TOGETHER OVER THE YEARS THE ONE THING THAT WOULD BE ABSENT ESSENTIALLY FROM ALL OF THEM IS REALLY THE QUESTION OF HOW WE CAN TO PAY FOR THIS BECAUSE FOR MOST OF OUR HISTORY WE'VE HAD THE LUXURY THAT THAT REALLY WASN'T A MAJOR CONSTRAINT WE COULD JUST DECIDE SORT OF WHAT WE WANTED TO DO KNOWING THAT A LARGE EXTENT THE MONEY WAS THERE BUT I THINK WE HAVE REACHED THE POINT WHERE THAT IS NO LONGER TRUE AND WE NEED TO MAKE SOME PRIORITIZATION AND STRATEGIC DECISIONS ABOUT WHAT'S MOST IMPORTANT IN A WORLD WHERE WE WE CAN'T HAVE EVERYTHING I THINK THERE ARE SOME IMPORTANT POLICY QUESTIONS THAT WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO TACKLE TWO GOOD THOUGHTS ON WHY THIS SHOULD BE AN OVERARCHING THEME APPRECIATE THAT. SO MY RECOLLECTION IS AND I'M SURE SOMEONE CAN CORRECT ME IS

[38:00] THAT SOME OF THE TAXES THAT WERE VOTED THROUGH OVERTIME THE BOND ISSUES WERE SPECIFICALLY TO SPEED UP ACQUISITION AND THEN HIS ACQUISITIONS WERE COMPLETED THE FINANCING WOULD GO BACK TO THE UNDERLYING MAINTENANCE AND MANAGEMENT OF THE RESOURCE BUT HAVING SAID THAT ONE OF THE THINGS I WANTED TO MAKE JUST A BROAD STATEMENT ABOUT THE FOCUS AREAS WHICH IS THAT IT'S VERY DIFFICULT TO SEE WERE GOING IF WE DON'T KNOW WHERE WE ARE OR WHERE WE PENNED SO WHAT ARE THE FINANCES KNOW FOR EXAMPLE YOU KNOW AND WHAT'S GOING WHERE AND ARE THOSE THE ADEQUATE THINGS IT SEEMS I DON'T KNOW SPECIFICALLY. I MEAN IT'S AN AREA OF EXPERTISE. UM SAME THING WITH STEWARDSHIP. I MEAN WHERE ARE WE YOU KNOW WE SAY THE ECOSYSTEM HEALTH IS AN OVERRIDING FACTOR BUT WHERE ARE WE. AND IN LOOKING THROUGH THE PAMPHLET THAT YOU HANDED OUT ON THIS PAGE SHOWS

[39:00] HOW FEEDBACK WILL BE LISTED YOU'VE GOT ALL OF THESE MONITORING DEVICES BUT THERE ISN'T ANY INFORMATION ABOUT WHERE WE ARE AND IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT IN TWO THOUSAND AND FIVE I THINK THERE WAS A OPEN SPACE LANDED JORGENSEN WAS CHAIR THAN A PLAN GOING FORWARD ABOUT A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT LIKE THIS A LAUNDRY LIST OF DIFFERENT MONITORING ASPECTS WHERE IS THE DATA FROM THAT DAY JUST DISAPPEARED IT GO AWAY YOU HAVE IT AND COULD WE SEE THAT BEFORE WE DON'T GO INTO LOOKING AT SOMETHING LIKE THIS BECAUSE WITHOUT THAT KIND OF INFORMATION FOR ME AT ANY RATE IT'S KIND IT'S DIFFICULT TO GO FORWARD THE DATA. I APPRECIATE THAT AND NOT JUST TRYING TO VIEW A BRIEF RESPONSE AS IT RELATES TO THE QUESTION ABOUT FINANCES I DID WANT TO POINT OUT AND ACTUALLY ALL THE QUESTIONS I THINK THAT THE SYSTEM OF AIRPORT WAS OUR BEST ATTEMPT AT TRYING TO PUT TOGETHER A BROAD SET OF INFORMATION AND A SOMEWHAT DIGESTIBLE WAY INTO FOR EXAMPLE WE DO HAVE A CHAPTER ON FINANCES AND CENTER

[40:00] OPERATIONS ACTUALLY STARTED TO GIVE A GENERAL PICTURE WHERE WE ARE NUMBERS IT DOES YEAH YEAH ABSOLUTELY CERTAINLY IT CAN PRESENT ALL OF THE NUMBERS AND SO WE STAFF ARE HAPPY TO PROVIDE ANY ADDITIONAL QUITE RESPOND ANY ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS THAT SOME MAY HAVE A BOSS AND RECENT CONVERSATIONS WITH THE BOARD IN PUTTING TOGETHER OUR CIP PACKAGE A COUPLE IMPROVEMENTS PLAN PACKAGE HAD SIMILAR QUESTIONS ABOUT WANTING TO KNOW MORE WANTING TO HEAR CONVINCING WAYS OF TELLING THE FINANCIAL STORIES SO THAT THE UNDERSTANDS WHERE WE ARE AND THE DISCUSSION AT THAT TIME WAS LET'S LET'S DO THAT IN THE MASTER PLAN BECAUSE AS KEVIN WAS INDICATING THIS IS THE OPPORTUNITY TO BRING EVEN MORE INFORMATION A BARREN TELL THAT STORY IN A LITTLE BETTER WAY AND SO I DID WANT TO ASA POINTS TO A POSTER THAT IS IN THE BACK ROOM THERE BEHIND YOU AND IT'S ALSO A REFERENCE AN ATTACHMENT B OF YOUR STUDY SESSION PACKAGE WHICH IS TO SAY THAT AS WE MOVE FROM FOCUS AREAS TO DEVELOPING THE STRATEGIES WE WILL ALSO AS I JUST INDICATED BE BRINGING ADDITIONAL SUPPORTING INFORMATION TO

[41:00] BEAR AS WE DEVELOP THE STRATEGIES SO WE KNEW AT THE BEGINNING THAT WE COULDN'T DO IT ALL IN THE SYSTEM OVERVIEW REPORT IT WAS OUR FIRST ATTEMPT AND RECOGNIZING THAT WE WOULD HAVE MORE DEEPER QUEST DEEPER QUESTIONS IN RELATION TO STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT PROCESS COMMITTEE GUIDED US TO DEVELOP WHAT WE WERE CALLING DEEPER DIVES WHICH IS TO SAY THAT ONCE WE HAVE CLEARLY ABOUT THESE FOCUS AREAS AND THE RELATED TOPICS THAT GIVES US A BETTER LENS THROUGH WHICH TO SAY OK HERE'S THE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO BRING TO BEAR SO WHILE I'M ON THAT PARTICULAR WHEN I SAW ONE OF THE SLIDES THAT YOU DID TOWARDS THE BEGINNING HAD ONE TWO THREE FOUR AND THERE WAS THAT SAID SOMETHING ABOUT DATA AND THERE WAS AN ASTERISK ON IT SO I WAS HOPING THAT THEIR ACTUAL REFERENCE POINT IS THAT I THANK YOU FOR SAYING THAT THAT'S A FULL DIRECTLY FROM THE BUDGET MANAGEMENT PLAN THE FASTEST ON THAT SAID THAT IN SOME CASES WE MAY NEED TO USE PROXY DATA WHICH IS TO SAY THAT WE'LL DO OUR BEST TO BRING FORWARD THE INFORMATION

[42:00] THAT WE HAVE AVAILABLE TO US AND IN OTHER CASES WHERE THAT'S NOT AVAILABLE WILL LOOK TO THE INDUSTRY BEST PRACTICES IN OTHER AGENCIES THAT MIGHT HAVE SOME INFORMATION TO BACK THEM GREAT. WELL MAYBE WE CAN GET INTO THAT LITTLE BIT MORE AS WE MOVE THROUGH THE AIR AS ME ONE MORE RESPONSE ABOUT EXPLANATION OF WHY THE FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY ONE HAS YOU ON HOW TO EXPLAIN THE SHARP EYES ON THE MASTERS JUST THE ONE FOUND TO AGREE WITH WHAT'S BEEN SAID ABOUT THE NEED FOR SOME FOCUS ON FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY THE THING TO ME THAT MERITS A FOCUS ON THEM IN THE NEXT FEW YEARS THIS PARTICULAR IS THE SUN SETTING TEXAS AS THEY WERE GOING TO HAVE TO FIGURE OUT WHAT TO DO IN THE WAKE OF THOSE EXPIRE AND SO I'M PERHAPS AND IN FIVE OR TEN YEARS WILL BE IN MORE OF A STEADY STATE WHERE WE WILL HAVE TO THINK ABOUT THIS WILL JUST BECOME PART OF THE BACKGROUND LIKE MARY TALKED ABOUT THAT JUST ONE OF THOSE THINGS HAVE TO WORK WITH ALL THE TIME BUT NO WE WE ARE GOING THROUGH SOME

[43:00] FINANCIAL CHANGES NEXT YEAR SO IT'S IMPORTANT THERE IS GREAT IF YOU HAVE ANY MORE THOUGHTS ON THAT ONE WHAT YOU WANT TO WRITE THEM DOWN WILL DEFTLY RECORD THOSE FOR LATER IT'S HELPFUL TO KNOW YOUR RATIONALE BEHIND IT. UM I GUESS COMMENT ON MARY'S SECOND SUGGESTION WHICH HAS TO DO WITH THE COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION BEING SOMETHING THAT IS SHE IS AND SHOULD BE PART OF ALL THE OTHER FOCUS AREAS AND I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU ON THAT I DON'T KNOW HOW WE CAN DO ANY OF THESE FOCUS AREAS WITHOUT THEY EDUCATION AND COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSIVENESS AND SO I WOULD AGREE WITH YOU THAT I THINK IT WOULD BE BEST NOT TO HAVE A SPECIFIC FOCUS AREA ABOUT THAT BUT TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S INCLUDED AS PART OF ALL THE OTHER FOLKS SERIOUS ONE BUT HE WENT TO THE ONE THOUSAND X WHEN I WAS GOING TO PULL UP AN END NOTE THAT THAT WAS ONE THAT WE HAD A LOT OF PEOPLE CONFIRMING THAT THEY'VE SEE THAT AS A FOCUS AREA. I THINK MAYBE HAVING

[44:01] THEM RESPOND AND SAY MAYBE WHY THAT IS AND MAYBE THEY SEE IT YOUR WAY AS WELL ABOUT THAT PERHAPS THE NEED TO BE A TOPIC UNDER EACH OF THESE FOCUS AREAS OF MY FAMILY AND UNDERSTANDING YOU CORRECTLY THAT IT THAT THE COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION MAYBE INSTEAD OF BEING A FOCUS AREA YOU SEE IT AS BEING A TOPIC UNDER EACH OF THEM THAT RIGHT. OK DOES ANYONE TAKE THAT ON AND TALK ABOUT WHY THEY CONFIRMED THAT AS A FOCUS AREA COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION TO ME. WELL IT SEEMS TO BE SOMETHING THAT'S VERY IMPORTANT IN TERMS OF OPEN SPACE GIVEN THE BROAD GROUP OF PEOPLE THAT USE IT AND USE THE RESOURCE AND UM I THINK MARY IS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT IN POINTING OUT THE CULTURAL AND EDUCATION IS THE THING THAT SEEMS TO ME UNDER WHICH SO MANY OF THOSE THINGS GOING ACROSS SO MANY DIFFERENT DIVIDES AND I WOULD HOPE ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE WOULD DO AS WE DID DO WITH ECO

[45:00] CYCLE IN THE VERY BEGINNING HIM THE VERY EARLY DAYS WAS GOING TO THE SCHOOLS BECAUSE THAT WAY YOU CUT ACROSS A WIDE IN TERMS OF INCREASED CITY YOU CUT ACROSS A WIDE SWATH OF YOUNG PEOPLE FROM ALL KINDS OF BACKGROUNDS AND UM IT'S A GOOD PLACE TO START AND AS WITH ECO CYCLE ONCE ONE GETS INTO THE PRACTICE OF DOING THEY'RE KIND OF THING IT DOWN BECOMES KIND OF SECOND NATURE RECYCLING AND I WOULD HOPE WITH RECOGNIZING DIFFERENT CULTURAL ASPECTS DIFFERENT IS AND THE INCREASE OF EIGHTY OF IT AND I'M SURE AMERICAN COURT OF HONOR WAS JUST GOING TO BRING UP THE FACT THAT WE HAVE A RESOLUTION ON THE CITY SO THAT KIND OF SETS THE TONE FOR EVERYTHING THAT WE DO AND I THINK THAT AS YOU HAVE ALSO BEGUN DOING THE OUTREACH FOR THIS PROCESS YOU'VE ALREADY

[46:00] INCLUDED THAT IN A VERY UM IT'S GOT A GREAT FOUNDATION OPERATING THAT THEY ARE THE WAY YOU ARE UNDERTAKING THIS PROJECT AND SEW A THING TO CONTINUE TO DO THAT AND TO BUILD ON THAT I DON'T THINK IT IS IN AN OF ITSELF A FOCUS AREA. I THINK IT IS SHOULD BE PART OF EVERYTHING THEY HAVE KIND OF GO WITH A YES AND THIS STATEMENT I AGREE WITH WHAT BOTH THESE TWO PEOPLE SAID BEFORE IT'S BEEN REALLY I THINK OBSERVANT THAT EVERYTHING NEEDS TO INCLUDE THIS BUT AS A PERSON WORKS FOR AN ENVIRONMENTAL ORGANIZATION THAT STRUGGLED WITH DIVERSITY AND HAVING SEEN THE DEMOGRAPHICS FOR VISITATION THERE. IT'S REALLY SKEWED WE DO NOT HAVE A GOOD REPRESENTATION FOR THE DIVERSITY OF THE COMMUNITY THAT LIVES IN THE GREATER BOULDER AREA AT ALL AND IN MY OWN ORGANIZATION ALTHOUGH I WORK FOR AN ENVIRONMENTAL ORGANIZATION WE HAVE AN ENTIRE DIVERSITY COMMITTEE

[47:01] THAT'S OVER A HUNDRED PEOPLE ITS FOCUS IS HOW DO WE DO DIVERSITY AND THAT'S LED TO A SLEW OF DIFFERENT HIRING PRACTICES AND DIFFERENT ACTIVITIES THAT WE'VE DONE WITH AN ORGANIZATION TO TRY AND MAKE IT A MORE DIVERSE AND OPEN TO DIVERSE SET OF VALUES IN COMMUNITIES AS OUR GROUP AND I THINK THAT BOULDER OPEN SPACE NEEDS THAT TOO. I THINK THAT HAVING THAT IN EACH OF THESE THINGS SEPARATELY IS A GREAT IDEA BUT HAVING A SPECIFIC FOCUS THAT ALLOWS US TO SAY WHY ARE WE MISSING SO MUCH OF THE LATINO COMMUNITY IN OUR OPEN SPACE. WHY ARE WE NOT DEALING WITH THE AGE DEMOGRAPHICS THAT ARE PART OF OUR COUNTY EXPLICITLY AND SEPARATELY AND THEN ALLOWING THAT TO BE CHANNELED INTO EACH OF THESE THINGS IS PROBABLY A CRITICAL THING THAT WE COULD DO I THINK IT'S A BIG ENOUGH PROBLEM WITH THEIR DEMOGRAPHICS MISMATCH THAT IT SHOULD BE SOMETHING TO INCLUDE BUT I DO AGREE EXACTLY WHAT YOU'RE SAYING COUNSELING YOUNG SHOULD BE IN EACH OF THESE SEPARATELY AS WELL BUT I JUST THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT THAT WERE

[48:01] MISSING A LOT THE BOWL THE MISTAKEN THAT HE COULD RESPOND SO I WAS I AGREE IN PART THEY'RE REALLY TWO DIFFERENT KINDS OF TOPICS EMBEDDED WITHIN THIS TOPIC ONE IS WHERE EDUCATION IS BEING USED AS A TOOL TO AFFECT YOU ATE SOMETHING ELSE LIKE BEING A RESPONSIBLE DOG GUARDIAN OR RESPONSIBLE STEWARD WHERE THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. I WOULD INCLUDE THAT WITHIN THE SUBSTANTIVE TOPIC RATHER THAN TO THINK OF EDUCATION ABSTRACTED PEOPLE FOR TRYING TO ADDRESS DOG ISSUES IN EDUCATION IS A TOOL THAT LETS DISCUSS EDUCATION IN THAT PARTICULAR CONTEXT BUT THERE'S ALSO A NUMBER OF OTHER ISSUES IN THE COLD IN THE COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS SECTION WHICH REALLY ARE TOOLS FOR CARRYING OUT ONE OF THE OTHER FOCUS AREAS BUT IT REALLY ENDS UNTO THEMSELVES I THINK A LOT OF INCLUSIVENESS COMES IN THERE AND FOR THAT REASON I WOULD KEEP IT AS ITS OWN FOCUS AREA BUT WHERE IT'S JUST A TOOL TO CARRY OUT SOMETHING ELSE I

[49:01] WOULD MOVE THAT INTO SOMETHING ELSE TO DO TO ENTER SPAWNED I HAVE A QUESTION FREEZE WELL. OH YEAH I DID WANT TO RESPOND AND I WOULD AGREE WITH KEVIN WHAT HE SAID ABOUT HOME THE VISITATION NOT BE REFLECTIVE OF THE WHOLE COMMUNITY BUT THE REASONS FOR THAT ARE NOT JUST SOME PEACE CHARGE I THINK THAT THOSE NEED TO BE ADDRESSED AT THE CITYWIDE LEVEL AND WITHIN THE CITY STRUCTURE WITH EIGHT WITH AN APPROACH THAT AS ALL ENCOMPASSING OF EVERYTHING THAT THE CITY DOES SO TO JUST FOCUS ON AN SNP WILL NOT ADDRESS THE ISSUES RELATED TO UM TO THE LACK OF REPRESENTATION. SO THAT'S THAT'S WHERE I THINK WE NEED TO FOCUS IN THE OVERALL APPROACH THE CITY TAKES THE CALL MYSELF YOUR EGO ASIDE I LIKED THE IDEA OF THIS FOCUS AREAS TO ME I WAS

[50:00] ACTUALLY GOING AS TO SUGGEST TO THE TOPIC THAT WAS THERE WAS MORE ACTIVE ABOUT EXPLICIT OUTREACH TO UNDERSERVED AND UNDERREPRESENTED COMMUNITY AND IN OPEN SPACES HESITATION AND IN TRYING TO DO OUTREACH AND EDUCATION POOR PEOPLE AND MORE. MAY I RESPECT YOUR PAINTING VERY MUCH ON THIS ISSUE I DIE I AGREE THAT THIS NEEDS TO BE A CITYWIDE FOCUS THAT WE NEED TO WORK ON THIS IN ALL AREAS OF THE COMMUNITY SO I WOULD ASK WHAT DO YOU THINK COULD NOT BE HELPFUL TO CALL IT EXPLICITLY HERE AS WELL AS SOMETHING THAT WE WANT TO MAKE SURE IN DUE TO POLL ALL MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY AND INTO OPEN SPACE YET I THINK PUTTING IT UNDER EACH FOCUS AREA AS IT WOULD BE A WAY TO DO IT BUT I WHAT I DON'T WANT TO SEE HAPPEN IS THAT THE EFFORTS ARE UM

[51:01] COMPARTMENT PLACED AND YOU'RE FOCUSING ON DIVERSITY AND NOT KIND OF ADDRESSING WHY IT'S LIKE YOU'RE JUST GIVING AN EXAMPLE UM UM PEOPLE THINKING THAT WHAT YOU NEED TO DO IS JUST HIRE MORE PEOPLE OF A CERTAIN RACE IN THE END THEY IN THE ORGANIZATION WHATEVER CONDITION MIGHT BE AND SHOULD HAVE PUT US ON THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE THAT YOU HIRE OF THAT RACE. WELL WITHOUT LAYING THE FOUNDATION AND UNDERSTANDING WHY PEOPLE AREN'T STAYING. THAT'S NOT GOING TO DO ANYTHING SO COMPARTMENT ALLIES. I THINK HAS UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES TIME HERE COUPLE OF COMMENTS ABOUT TAKING THE KEY CONNECTIONS INCLUSION FOCUS AREA AND INSTEAD AM BETTING IT UNDER EACH OF THE FOCUS AREAS AND REMOVING IT AS A FOCUS AREA HAD A COUPLE PEOPLE SAY THAT MANY OTHERS

[52:00] HAVE DIFFERENT POINT OF VIEW OR WANT TO SHARE THAT POINT OF VIEW HOW ABOUT YOU HAVING ANY CONSIDERATIONS ABOUT COMMUTING CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION AS A TOPIC AREA UNDER EACH OF THE FOCUS SERIOUS OR AS ITS OWN FOCUS AREA FOR ONE MORE THING FOR ME IT'S IMPORTANT THAT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT THE DEPARTMENT WORKS ACTIVELY ON CERTAINLY OPEN TO HAVING IT CALLED OUT EXPLICITLY SEPARATELY UNDER EACH ONE MAKE SURE THAT THREADS THROUGH THE WHOLE INITIATIVE AS LONG AS WE DO PLENTY WORK ON IT AND GOT WELL THERE ARE SO MANY IMPORTANT RELATED TOPICS UNDER THAT FOCUS AREA THAT IT SEEMS THAT IF WE TAKE IT OUT AND JUST EMBEDDED IN EACH HOUR EACH OF THE RELATED TOPICS GOING TO MAKE THEIR WAY IN. SO LIKE RECOGNIZING NATIVE AMERICAN CULTURE AND RELATIONS DOES THAT FIT UNDER EACH TOPIC OR FOSTERING NEW

[53:03] WAYS OF LEARNING TO ENJOY AND PROTECT THE ENVIRONMENT. I GUESS I PICTURE THAT AS OUR KIDS PROGRAMS AND YOU KNOW HOW DOES THAT I GUESS I LIKE IT AS A SEPARATE TOPIC SO THAT WE CAN INCLUDE ALL OF THESE REALLY MATTERS BETTER HAND THAN ME CINDY AND SAM I SEE VALUE IN KEEPING THIS A FOCUS AREA AS WELL BECAUSE I THINK UNDERPINNING TO A LOT OF THESE RELATED TOPICS IS THAT WE'RE TRYING TO ACTIVELY BUILD THAT FUTURE GENERATIONS OF OPEN SPACE TOO AND IF WE LOSE SIGHT OF THAT. I THINK THAT HE COULD BE HIGHLY UNLIKELY BUT POSSIBLE THAT THERE WILL BE FUTURE GENERATIONS OF LEADERS IN OUR COMMUNITY. YOU DON'T FEEL A NEED TO PROTECT OPEN SPACE OR TO PRESERVE THAT BUFFER IN THE WAY THAT WE DO TODAY AND SO BY BILL ACTIVELY GOING OUT AND BUILDING AND MAINTAINING

[54:00] THOSE CONNECTIONS TO BRING UP THE FUTURE OPEN SPACE STEWARDS I THINK WE'RE GOING TO SEE GREAT BENEFIT FOR OUR SYSTEM AND I AGREE WITH ANDREA AND WITH MARY. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT AS WELL TO HAVE THIS AS ITS OWN AREA SO THAT THE LARGER COMMUNITY SEES THAT THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT FOCUS AS YOU ARE SAYING IS SO THAT THEY KNOW THEY WERE ALL CONSIDERING THIS GOING FORWARD IN AN IMPORTANT VERY IMPORTANT WAY SO I WOULD BRING IN SOMETHING ELSE THAT MARY MENTIONED EARLIER WHICH IS CULTURAL HERITAGE AND SAVE IT. I COULD SEE US HAVING PRESERVING CULTURAL RESOURCES AS THE ASSESSMENT HAS BEEN THERE AS BEING A WAY OF GIVING IT SOME OF THE GOALS OF CALLING IT OUT SEPARATELY BUT MAKING SURE THAT THE INCLUSIVE BODY IS INCLUDED IN EACH ONE OF THE FOCUS AREAS SO I JUST WANTED TO MARRY THAT YOU MENTIONED SOME CULTURAL HERITAGE AND CULTURAL

[55:00] RESOURCES. I WAS CURIOUS A BABY THAT COULDN'T THAT BE IN THE FIFTH ONE AND FOUR PLACES THAT DON'T HAVE AN OBVIOUS WAY TO PUT THE INCLUSIVE OF THE OTHER ONES IT MIGHT BE ABLE TO GO THERE BUT ANYWAY I LIKED THE CULTURAL PRESERVATION COMPONENT AS WELL AND GOOD ENOUGH I MEAN WE HAVE A VARIETY OF OPINIONS CLEARLY NEED TO KEEP TALKING ABOUT THIS BUT WE'RE NOT FINALIZING THINGS TONIGHT RIGHT LET'S MOVE ON TO ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AS WELL THEN THAT WAS ONE THAT WE HEARD THE THUMBS UP BUT NOW I GET TO HEAR THAT MOST AWKWARD HE COMES UP ON THAT ONE. SO NOW I DO AND TAKE MOMENT TO HEAR FROM THOSE OF YOU THAT GAVE IT A THUMBS UP AND WHY THAT WAS ONE THAT YOU ARE CONFIRMING AND THEN TURN TO THOSE THAT HAD SOME EITHER CLARIFYING POINTS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT IT AND FEELS COMFORTABLE WITH IT. HEAR FROM YOU YOUR THOUGHTS ON IT AS WELL SO I'M ANYONE WANNA OFFER UP AN ECOSYSTEM HEALTH SOME THOUGHTS OR MEAN BUT

[56:00] MARY SAID THAT THE FINANCIAL PRESERVATION IS KIND OF A BACKGROUND OR I FIND THIS ALMOST TO BE A BACKGROUND OR I MEAN THE WHOLE POINT OF DOING WHAT WE'RE DOING WITH PRESERVING OPEN SPACES TO PRESERVE THE HEALTH OF THE ECOSYSTEMS AND SO HAPPY THAT WE CALL IT OUT BUT THIS IS LIKE MOTHERHOOD AND APPLE PIE KIND OF THING IN THAT THIS IS ONE OF THE FOUNDATIONAL CHARTER REASONS THAT WE'RE DOING THIS FALL SO I THINK IT'S GOOD TO CALL IT OUT BUT YOU KNOW IT ALMOST GOES WITHOUT SAYING LIKE THE FINANCIAL RESILIENCE AS WELL BECAUSE WE WERE NECK AND GIVEN A HIGHER PURPOSE FOR THE OPEN SPACE PROGRAM AND PRESERVING THE ECOSYSTEM HEALTH YET I DON'T KNOW IF ON THE OPEN SPACE IF THE TRUSTEES GOT AS WELL THIS CITY COUNCIL GOT A LETTER FROM THE ER. THAT'S WHAT ONE COULD CALL IT AN E MAIL FROM THE OLDER ENVIRONMENTAL COALITION. THEY DID NOT AT LEAST IN MIND IDENTIFY ALL OF WHOM THEY

[57:00] ARE BUT I KNOW OR IN THE PAST IT HAS BEEN GROUPS LIKE AUTUMN AND BOULDER COUNTY NATURE ASSOCIATION NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY ET-CETERA AND ONE OF THE THINGS THEY POINT OUT THAT I THINK IS REALLY INTERESTING IS THAT IT'S NOT RESILIENT TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE BECAUSE ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE HAPPENS BUT THAT IT'S RATHER THE CONSTANT AND IT'S THE CONSTANT AND CONTINUOUS SOUND IMPACT OF HUMANS ON THE SYSTEM ITSELF THAT IS HAPPENING AND SO THAT WHAT WE MIGHT BE DOING IS AGAIN MEASURING THE CONDITION IS THE MEASURE IN BASIS FOR DETERMINING THE TYPES OF FACTS AND IMPACTS OF THE SOURCES OF CHANGE AND THEN HOW WE DEAL WITH THOSE DID EVERYONE GET A COPY OF THIS I THOUGHT IT WAS REALLY IT WAS COMPELLING IN TERMS OF

[58:01] OF THE RESILIENCE SO THAT IS THE FOCUS AREA FROM THAT IS COMING FOR TWO S NOW IT'S MORE IT'S REALLY RESILIENCE TO HUMAN CHANGE ON THE CLIMATE ON THE ON THE RESOURCE RATHER THAN OTHERWISE. WHAT THE ENVIRONMENT DOING TO IT AND HOW WE DEAL WITH CHAD AND I JUST WONDERED IF YA HAD ANY THOUGHTS TO THAT THE TRUSTEES ABOUT THAT ARE WE TALKING ABOUT ECOSYSTEM HEALTH MORE RESILIENT TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE RACES RESILIENT TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGES BECAUSE WE ARE ON AND KEEP THIS EMAIL SHERRY ME WE CAN WRAP UP ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AND THEN WE CAN DO THAT NEXT WEEK AND I THINK THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN THE TWO OF THEM THERE BUT YA JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE I WASN'T SOMEHOW SLEEP WHEN WE DID ECOSYSTEM OUT THERE THERE WAS FURTHER THOUGHTS ON ECOSYSTEM HEALTH OTHER THAN THAT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT YOU DIDN'T COME. THE ONLY THING I'D ADD THAT I THINK WAS A REALLY GOOD POINT THAT IS

[59:01] PART OF THIS I MEAN I DON'T THINK ANY OF THESE ARE GIVEN I THINK THAT EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THESE THINGS SHOULD BE SOMETHING THAT THE AS COMMENT ON BECAUSE EVERY ONE OF THESE REPRESENTS A SIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN THE WAY WE'RE TALKING ABOUT DOING THINGS AND ECOSYSTEM HOW ONE OF THE THINGS THAT SAT ON THE LAST ON THE LIST IS RESEARCHING AND MONITORING ECOLOGICAL HEALTH AND WE HAVE A LOT OF OPPORTUNITIES TO DO THAT AND I THINK THE SETTING UP A RIGOROUS SYSTEM WHERE THAT WE ARE REGULARLY ASSESSING THE VALUE OF OUR BIO DIVERSITY AND WHAT'S DECLINING ARE IMPROVING WOULD BE A GREAT BENEFIT FOR US FOR ALL OF OUR MANAGEMENT AND IT'S NOT DONE IN A RIGOROUS SCIENTIFIC WAY HERE SO I THINK THAT THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WOULD BE A NEW TOPIC THAT WE WOULD BE ABLE TO DISCUSS IS PART OF THIS PLAN HOW WE WOULD DO THE SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH TO KNOW ARE DOING AN OKAY JOB OF MANAGING SO I THINK THAT'S WHY I WAS GENERALLY I THINK IS IN THE WAY THIS FOCUS AREA SET UP EVERYONE CAN AGREE

[60:00] GOOD IDEA BUT WHAT'S IN IT I THINK BECOMES REALLY VALUABLE TO TALK ABOUT TONIGHT BECAUSE ALL ARE DOING HERE THE ANYONE ELSE ON THIS ONE BEFORE WE MOVE ON CONFIRMING ARE HAVING OUR QUESTION CLARIFYING QUESTION. TRENDS COME AND ECOSYSTEM HEALTH. YEAH I UM I WANT TO BUILD ON WHAT KEVIN SAID WHICH HAS TO DO WITH THE LIST OF MONITORING PROJECTS THAT ARE IN THE PACKET AND WHAT I FOUND THIS I WAS THINKING ABOUT THIS FOCUS AREA IS A LACK OF UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT THE NEEDS ARE AND A LACK OF KNOWING WHAT TRENDS ARE BEING SHOWN BY THE MONITORING PROJECTS THAT ARE LISTED ON THE SPORT PAGES WITHOUT THAT IT'S VERY DIFFICULT TO TO REALLY CONCEIVE OF WHAT THIS FOCUS AREA IS ABOUT FOR INSTANCE WHEN I LOOKED AT

[61:00] THE TOPICS I SAID TO MYSELF I DON'T SEE ANYTHING ABOUT INVASIVE HERE AND AS I UNDERSTAND THAT THAT'S ONE OF THE HUGE THREATS TO ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AND YET THERE'S NO DATA ABOUT THE NEED TO ADDRESS IT IN THE MATERIALS THAT WE'VE BEEN GIVEN THERE'S NO LISTING IT AS A RELATED TOPIC BUT TO ME THAT'S A PRIME EXAMPLE OF WHAT WE CARE ABOUT IN TERMS OF HEALTH OF THE ECOSYSTEM FOR THE SYSTEM AS A WHOLE AND SO I QUESTION WHAT THE DEFINITION OF THIS ONE IS IT SHOULD INCLUDE SOME CONTROL AND ELIMINATE PROLIFERATION OF NON NATIVE INVASIVE SPECIES FOR INSTANCE AS A TOPIC AND IT'S THAT INTENDED FOR THIS FOCUS AREA OR AM I TOTALLY OFF BASE ABOUT WHAT IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE ABOUT. I APPRECIATE THAT I CARED AND I THINK THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR BEING IN TERMS OF YOUR ROLE TONIGHT AS A GROUP TO WEIGH IN ON

[62:00] RELATED TOPICS TO HELP BETTER DEFINE THE KINDS OF STRATEGIES THAT WE NEED TO EXPLORE IN THE PROCESS SO I THINK WE INTENDED THAT TO BE INCLUDED UNDER THE IDEA OF PROTECTING BIODIVERSITY AND AS IT RELATES TO OUR EXISTING CONDITIONS AND IN RELATION TO THAT WE DID TRY AND PRESENT AN OVERVIEW OF THAT AND AGAIN IN THE SYSTEM OVERVIEW REPORT RECOGNIZING THOUGH AGAIN THE IN STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT WE WOULD BRING MORE INFORMATION THE BEAR AS NEEDED WHEN WE GOT DOWN TO MORE FINE SCALE BUT AGAIN I THINK THIS IS ANOTHER OPPORTUNITY THAT IT SOUNDS LIKE PERHAPS CAN ARE YOU SUGGESTING A NEW TOPIC OF THIS THE GREAT MANY OTHER COMMENTS BUT THE TOPICS UNDER THE SYSTEM HEALTH BEFORE YOU MOVE ON TO OTHERS TO BUILD OFF OF WHAT KAREN SAID I GET THAT WE'RE GOING TO HAVE IT IN HERE BUT I WILL SAY IS COMING INTO THIS KIND OF ON THE NEWER SIDE IT REALLY WOULD BE NICE TO SEE WHERE THESE TRENDS ARE GOING TO THAT STATES IT IS DIFFICULT COMING INTO THIS NOT KNOWING ANYTHING OR NOT KNOWING AS

[63:01] MUCH AS YOU GUYS DO AND NOT HAVING THAT INFORMATION THERE AND AS FAR AS I UNDERSTAND THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF STUDIES FOR A REALLY LONG TIME SAID TO ME THAT'S INCREDIBLY PERTINENT INFORMATION WHICH HAD BEEN INCLUDED AND I'LL BRING OUT MORE ABOUT THIS IN TERMS OF THE INVOLVEMENT WITH COMMUNITY WHEN WE GET TO THAT TOPIC BUT JUST COMING FROM COUNCIL CITES YET REALLY WOULD BE HELPFUL. YET IN THE SYSTEM AN OVERVIEW DOES HAVE AN ENTIRE CHAPTER ABOUT TRENDS THAT HELP TO DEFINE SOME OF THAT GIFT THAT DIRECTION ABOVE WHAT WE DO KNOW TODAY SO THERE IS SOME AND IN THIS BIG VOLUME HERE THAT YOU'LL SEE ABOUT THE TRENDS BUT YOU'RE RIGHT THIS WAS A SNAPSHOT SUMMARY ABOUT WHAT ARE THE STUDIES THAT HAVE BEEN CONDUCTED AND MOVE ON. NO SEAMS WITH IT. IT SEEMS TO ME. BUILDING ON WHAT OTHERS HAVE SAID STARTING WITH KEVIN IS THAT THIS COMES TO THE FIRST TOPIC UNDER THE RESILIENCE IS INVESTIGATING SHIPS IN THE DISTRIBUTION OF PLANT AND ANIMAL SPECIES SO SHIPS HAVE

[64:03] TO DO WITH INCREASES HAVE TO DO WITH AND AND THERE IS THE NEXT ONE IS PLANNING FOR DECLINING WATER AVAILABILITY AND UP ABOVE IN THE ECOSYSTEM HEALTH IS PROTECTING WETLANDS PRESERVE IN FLOOD PLAINS AND I'M WONDERING IF THESE TWO THINGS AREN'T SORT OF TIED TOGETHER THOSE TWO FOR FIRST FOCUS AREAS AND THAT COULD BE DONE WITH SOME CLARITY WAS SOME DATA PROVIDED ABOUT WHERE WE ARE AND WHERE WE THINK THEY HAVE TO GO WELL FOR ABOUT AN HOUR REMAINING CLASS AND WE WANT TO LEAVE SOMETIME AT THE END FOR CONCLUSIONS. SO SPEND TIME ON THE TWO THAT WAS NOT QUITE AS MUCH CONFIRMATION ON AS WELL AS HIT ON THAT. THE TWO THAT WERE SUGGESTED FOR ADDITIONAL FOCUS SERIOUS BECAUSE CERTAIN RESILIENCE SHOULD RETURN TO THE CONTENT OR FAIL TO SEE MARY WITH HER HAND UP THERE THE NIGHT CINDY CAN ATTACHED ON HOW INTEGRAL THE ECOSYSTEM

[65:04] HEALTH AND RESILIENCE TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE THAT TO ME I HAVE A HARD TIME SEPARATING EACH OF THOSE AND YOU KNOW LIKE RESTORING RIPARIAN AREAS THE MITIGATING SOME FIRE AND FLOOD RISK SITS THERE LIKE THEY'RE TWO SIDES OF THE SAME COIN AND SO PERHAPS THESE TWO SHOULD BE COMBINED. I WONDER UM AND PERHAPS REFER TO THEM TO SOMETHING LIKE RESILIENCE AND ECOSYSTEMS SUSTAINABILITY AS MUCH AS I DISLIKE THAT WORD SUSTAINABILITY IT'S SO OVERUSED AND MEANINGLESS NOW BUT UM BUT SOME SOMETHING THAT THAT BRINGS THEM BOTH TOGETHER AND HEAR FROM A COUPLE OTHERS THAT MAY BE SET RESILIENCE AND ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE WAS NOT ONE THAT THEY'RE COMFORTABLE CONFIRMING AT THIS POINT AND HERE'S WHAT YOUR THOUGHTS ARE

[66:00] ON THAT ONE HAVEN'T BEEN SORRY. SO WHAT YOU JUST SAID I THINK THESE FIRST TWO SHOULD BE COMBINED. JUST FOR THE PEOPLE WHO AREN'T IN THE SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY AND THE ENVIRONMENT RESILIENCE IS THE NEW SUSTAINABILITY. IT'S THE NEW BUZZ WORD THAT EVERYONE IF YOU EVER USE SUSTAINABILITY NOW THE EDGES USING RESILIENCE OF THE SAME THING IN TERMS OF LIKE PRACTICAL APPLICATION. UM SO IT'S KIND OF A COOL BUZZ PHRASE BUT I THINK REALLY EVERYTHING THAT'S IN THE RESILIENCE EXCEPT FOR A COUPLE OF MINOR THINGS ARE WHAT YOU'D NEED TO MAINTAIN ECOSYSTEM HOUSE IN THE LONG TERM WITHOUT ANY OF THOSE YOU WOULD NOT HAVE ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AND CAN FIRSTLY NONE OF THE MATTER. IF YOU DON'T HAVE ECOSYSTEM HEALTH BECAUSE MANAGING THE DISTRIBUTION OF PLANT AND ANIMAL SPECIES WHEN YOU HAVE BAD ECOSYSTEMS IS MANAGING A BUNCH OF WEEDS SO SO I THINK YOU COULD PUT THEM BOTH TOGETHER AND HAVE ONE FEWER TOPIC AND YOU COVER ALL THIS BASES EXCEPT FOR MAYBE A COUPLE OF THINGS LIKE ECOSYSTEM SERVICES WHICH ARGUABLY IS THE HUMAN BENEFIT

[67:02] FROM AN ECOSYSTEM AS OPPOSED TO THE ECOSYSTEMS BENEFIT FOR ITSELF BUT I'D BE FINE BELIEVE THAT IN THERE JUST HAD TO SAMPLE SAY I HAD SOME SPECIALIST ARM SO I AGREE HUNDRED PERCENT AND I READ THE WORDS TO USE CARE AND I LIKED MAINTENANCE AND MANAGEMENT AND SO I THINK IT COULD BE SOMETHING LIGHT MAINTENANCE AND MANAGEMENT OF ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AND CAPTURE BOTH THE RESILIENCE PEACE AND HEALTH PEACE AND SHOW US ALL OF YOUR EXPERTISE CERTAINLY NOT MORE THAN MY OWN THAT THE ONLY THING IN HERE THAT SEEM SO IMPORTANT THOUGH IS PREPARING FOR PRESSURES FROM ENERGY DEVELOPMENT AND SO WOULD THAT STAY IN THE COMBINED KNIT SCENE IN THAT SAME VEIN A WEEK. HOW ARE WE GOING TO START PRIORITIZING THESE RELATED

[68:04] TOPICS. FIRST YOU KNOW WE ARE RECOGNIZING THAT THERE ARE SOME TOPICS THAT MIGHT BE SEEN AS MORE CRITIC OR PRESSING THAT WHERE WE NEED A LEVEL OF EMPHASIS IN TERMS OF HOW WE DEFINE OUR WORKLOAD BETWEEN NOW AND CAN GAUGE WHERE WE'RE DEVELOPING STRATEGIES SO IF THERE ARE SOME THAT ARE THAT THAT SEEM AT THIS TIME TO MORE IMPORTANT THAT WE FOCUS COMMUNICATION AROUND ME FOCUS ADDITIONAL DATA GATHERING AROUND AND CERTAINLY WE'RE OPEN TO HEARING THAT TONIGHT BECAUSE THAT WILL HELP US REFINE OUR APPROACH TO ENGAGEMENT IN THE FALL. SO JUST WANTED TO SHARE THAT AS AN OPPORTUNITY. ALSO WE ARE SUCH AN EARLY STAGE OF THE PROCESS WHEREAS WE CONTINUE TO GO THROUGH THE PROCESS AND WORK WITH THE COMMUNITY WILL DEVELOP STRATEGIES WILL PRIORITIZE STRATEGIES WILL DEVELOP THOSE FINANCIAL SCENARIOS WHERE WE START TO SORT THOSE OUT ACROSS THOSE POTENTIAL REVENUE FUTURES AND THEN WE FINALLY GET TO THE DRAFT AND FINAL PLANNED SO IT'S REALLY

[69:01] WHERE THE BEGINNING NOW OF DEFINING THE UNIVERSE OF THINGS WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT IN THE FURTHER DOWN THE PROCESS WE GET THE MORE REFINED AND PRAYER TIES AND CLEAR WE WILL GET AND SOMETIMES CAN CALL MYSELF AND TO IN TERMS OF THE RESILIENCE OF THE EMAIL OR LETTER FROM THE BOULDER OUTDOOR GROUP OF NATURAL ORGANIZATION WHAT HE THINK YOU I THOUGHT THE EXCELLENT POINT THAT THEY MADE WAS THAT WILL ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGES GOING ON ALL THE TIME IT DOESN'T STOP AND SO WAS THE FOCUS HERE EAT IT BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT ECOSYSTEMS TODAY THERE IS CHANGE THEY RESPOND TO IT TO ME THIS IS REALLY ABOUT RESPONDING TO CLIMATE CHANGE MORE THAN ANYTHING ELSE IS THAT YOU KNOW WE KNOW THAT THAT ARE OUR CLIMATE IS CHANGING THAT THEIR WORLD IS CHANGING AND HOW DO WE AS HUMANS AND STEWARDS OF OUR NATURAL SYSTEMS HERE SUPPORT KIND OF THE ECOSYSTEMS THROUGH THAT TRANSITION AND

[70:00] THOSE CHANGES SO AT IT AND THAT'S NOT CALLED OUT SPECIFICALLY HERE SO I THINK SOME OF THE THINGS THAT WERE SAID ABOUT COMBINING ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AND RESILIENCE MAKE SENSE TO ME BUT WHAT I WOULD BE LOOKING FOR WOULD BE CALLING OUT THAT HAD HAD A WE HAD TO ACCOMMODATE CLIMATE CHANGE AS WE UNDERSTAND MORE FULLY AND WHAT WE HAVE TO DO TO HELP THE ECOSYSTEMS WITH THAT AS MY THOUGHTS I THINK CINDY AND KIM WISHED I WAS JUST GOING TO ASK A QUESTION ABOUT THE TIMELINE SUMMER IN IN THE READING IT SAID THAT IF IT WOULD TAKE SIX MONTHS TO DO SOMETHING LIKE BRING TOGETHER SOME OF THE DATA SETS AND I'M WONDERING IF THAT ISN'T AN EXAGGERATION IF YOU DON'T HAVE OTHER ONGOING PIECES THAT YOU CAN REFER TO NOW I KNOW FOR EXAMPLE THE BOULDER COUNTY NATURE ASSOCIATION HAS FORTY YEARS OF HISTORY OTTOMAN DOES BRING BIRD COUNTS ET-CETERA SO AND THE NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY DOES BUNCH OF DIFFERENT THINGS SURE SO I THINK THINGS IN YOUR FRIENDS ARE COMING IN

[71:01] THE BORDER MCCONNELL COALITION LETTER ABOUT THAT TIME ESTIMATE THAT CAME FROM ACTUALLY A CONVERSATION THAT WE HAD WITH THE PROCESS COMMITTEE BACK IN APRIL AT THE END OF THE FIRST ENGAGEMENT WINDOW WHEN WE GOT A SIMILAR LETTER FROM THE BORDER MAMMAL COLLECTION ASKING FOR ADDITIONAL DATA IN REVISIONS TO THE SYSTEM OVERVIEW REPORT AND SO PRIOR TO A PROCESS COMMITTEE MEETING HER WE DID AN ANALYSIS OF WHAT IT WOULD TAKE TO HAVE BEEN ABLE TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS IN THAT FIRST LETTER IN A THOROUGH WAY AND SO THERE'S THAT WAS WHERE THERE'S TIME ESTIMATES CAME FROM AND THAT IT'S NOT A SURLY REFLECTION ON HOW HOW MUCH TIME IT WILL TAKE TO BRING IMPORTANT INFORMATION TO BEAR ON STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT FOR THE FALL. IN OTHER WORDS WHAT THE PROCESS CAN HELP TO SORT OF REFINE WAS TO SAY WE IN FACT ASK THE QUESTION AT THAT TIME DO WE HAVE A SUFFICIENT FOUNDATION OF INFORMATION TO MOVE FORWARD IN THE MASTER PLANNING PROCESS AT THIS TIME THE PAST MANY SAID YES AND SO WE MOVE FORWARD. THAT'S WHEN

[72:01] WE MADE THAT AGREEMENT THOUGH ABOUT. WE RECOGNIZE THAT HAVING THESE RELATED TOPICS AND FOCUS AREAS WILL AGAIN GIVE US THAT LENS THROUGH WHICH WE DETERMINE WHAT INFORMATION WE NEED TO BRING TO BEAR. SO RATHER THAN THE FULL UNIVERSE OF OPPORTUNITIES THERE ARE SOME DATA SETS AND CERTAINLY YOU KNOW WE HAVE OR SCIENCE OFFICER HERE WHO CAN SPEAK FAR MORE ELOQUENTLY TO THIS THAN I CAN BUT DID YOU NEED SOME ANALYSIS AND TIME SPENT TO REALLY SIFT THROUGH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT THE CURRENT STATUS AND TRENDS WHERE THERE ARE OTHERS THAT CAN BE MORE QUICKLY BROUGHT TO BEAR AND I SUPPOSE THE HOPE IS THAT WE WOULDN'T SPEND TOO MUCH TIME STUDYING LOOKING FOR NEW DATA IF CURRENT IF THERE'S CURRENT DATA THAT EXIST AND THAT'S THAT'S THE ONLY THING THAT WE WOULD JUST KEEP PUSHING THINGS BACK SO I HAVEN'T HEARD FROM THE SIDE THE TABLE TOO MUCH ABOUT OUT OF THE FOCUS AREAS IN GENERAL SO I WANT TO SEE IF THERE ARE SOME COMMENTS ON THIS SIDE OF THE TABLE ABOUT THIS ONE OF RESILIENCE TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE BUTTERFLY BUT THIS IS A GOOD ONE TO CONFIRM OR IF

[73:00] YOU HAD SOME THOUGHTS HEARING FROM THE OTHERS THEIR THOUGHTS ABOUT THAT. THEY ORGANIZE THE IDIOMS ANYONE ON THE SPOT BESIDE CAN I THINK THEY CERTAINLY ARE OVERLAPPING YOU COULD COMBINE THEM. MY ONLY CONCERN IS THAT IT'S GOING TO MAKE YOU MY ONLY CONCERN IS THAT SUCH AN ENORMOUS TOPIC AND IT'S SO FUNDAMENTAL TO ALL OF THE OPEN SPACE CHARTER PURPOSES THAT IF WE MAKE IT ONE TOPIC ARE WILLING TO PUT ENOUGH EMPHASIS ON THAT THERE'S A NATURAL TENDENCY TO SAY OK WE'RE GOING TO DO FOR STRATEGIES FROM EACH FOCUS AREA AND WE COMBINE THESE TWO WE LOSE SOME REALLY IMPORTANT THING SO THAT'S MY ONLY THOUGHT OF CAUTION ABOUT THAT BUT CERTAINLY LOGICALLY THEY GO TOGETHER PRETTY WELL IN CHEM AND I JUST WANT TO

[74:01] ADDRESS SOME OF THE STUFF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT I THINK CLIMATE CHANGE IS DEFINITELY A KEY FOCUS AREA IS GOING TO SHOW YOU A GREAT GRAPHIC I JUST DREW THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF RESILIENCE. SO IF YOU IMAGINE THIS BIG BLUE BOULDER IS IN THE VALLEY AND YOU WANTED TO PUSH IT OUT TO BE PRETTY HARD THIS BIG BLUE BOULDER AND THIS VALUE BE VERY EASY TO PUSH OUT. THIS IS NOT RESILIENT AND THIS IS RESILIENT AND WE AFFECT SOME ECOSYSTEMS WE DID BASICALLY KNOCKED DOWN THE SIDES OF THIS VALLEY IN TERMS OF THEIR STABLE STATE OF THE ECOSYSTEM SO WE MAKE THEM LESS RESILIENT TO CLIMATE CHANGE OR OIL AND GAS OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT AND SO A KEY ASPECT OF RESILIENCE IF YOU WILL IS IDENTIFYING WHAT ASPECTS OF AN ECOSYSTEM MAKE IT MOST VULNERABLE TO THE CHANGES THAT WERE MAKING IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND THEREFORE BY ADDRESSING THAT WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO ALLOW THEM TO REACT NATURALLY TO THINGS LIKE CLIMATE CHANGE WITHOUT AS MUCH OF A DISASTROUS EFFECT OR TO OIL AND GAS OR WHATEVER THE PROBLEM. SO WHAT'S YOUR THOUGHT ON THIS

[75:00] ONE BEING ITS OWN FOCUS AREA FOR SAYS COMBINING. I WAS THE FIRST ONE TO SAY WE SHOULD COMBINE TO UM I THINK THAT EVERYTHING HERE AGAIN IF YOU TRY TO SEPARATE THE PROBLEM IS YOU MIGHT TRY TO GENERATE ECOSYSTEM HEALTH IN A WAY THAT ACTUALLY IS NOT GENERATING ECOSYSTEM RESILIENCE AND VICE VERSA SO I THINK THEY'RE ALL GO TOGETHER. I AGREE IT'S A PRETTY BIG TOPICS I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU TRY TO MAKE SURE THIS KID COULD FOCUS BUT I REALLY DO THINK THAT THEY ARE PART OF SYSTEM SYSTEMATIC MANAGEMENT FOR LONG TERM ECOSYSTEM ALL OTHER THOUGHTS ON A RESISTANCE TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE BEFORE WE MOVE ON TO ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT K STEWART JOINED IN RECREATION MANAGEMENT. THERE WAS LITTLE BIT LESS CONFIRMATION ON THIS ONE SO LET'S HEAR FIRST FROM THOSE THAT WERE NOT QUITE SO SURE ABOUT THIS THIRD ITEM

[76:02] FOR A FOCUS AREA. YOU LEARN OK HEARING NINE I WILL TURN TO THOSE THAT DID HAVE CONFIRMATION FOR THIS AND YOU CAN ADD ON LATER IF YOU HAD SOME DISAGREEMENT ABOUT CONFIRMING THIS ONE GUY I CAN BUT AS THIS IS IMPORTANT AND I THINK THAT THE WAY THAT MOST OF OUR COMMITTEE MEMBERS EXPERIENCE OPEN SPACES THROUGH RECREATIONAL BY GOING OUT ON THAT AND I CAN OR BIRD WATCHING OR NOT BUT WHATEVER MIGHT BE SO I THINK IT'S AS TO THINK IT MERITS A FOCUS AREA AND WHO DOESN'T LIKE ENJOYMENT. WHAT STINKS IN MY MIND. UM ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT ELEMENTS OF THIS FOCUS AREA IS IS FIGURING OUT HOW ARE GOING TO DEAL WITH THE GROWTH IN NUMBER OF

[77:02] VISITORS AND I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THAT PUT FRONT AND CENTER IT AS PART OF THE DEFINITION OF THIS FOCUS AREA BECAUSE IF WE DON'T COME TO GRIPS WITH THAT IN THIS PLAN WILL NOT HAVE RELEVANCE IN MY MIND WE'VE GOT TO DEAL WITH THE QUESTION THE COUNCIL LAST TEN YEARS AGO OR MORE OF HOW ARE WE GOING TO DEFINE WHEN WE HAVE TOO MUCH AND WHEN WE ARE LOVING THE SYSTEM TO DEATH AND AND SO IN MY MIND THIS IS MORE THAN JUST ENJOYMENT. IT'S HOW WE DEAL WITH MANAGING VISITATION GROWTH AND DEAL WITH USE OF THE SYSTEM SO ARE YOU LOOKING AT THAT NUMBER TWO ON THIS LIST ARE EXPLORING A FRAMEWORK FOR MANAGING HIS ABUSE AND VISITATION GROWTH AS AN CRITICAL TOPIC THAT WE

[78:01] ARE SUGGESTING I THINK EXPLORING A FRAMEWORK IS FAR TOO INTO THE DISTANT FUTURE I WOULD ELIMINATE THAT WORD THAT'S GREAT FIRST YEAR HERE BUT YOU SEE OTHER SAID KAREN JUMPED RIGHT INTO WHERE I WANTED TO GO THIS HAS TO POINT MY NOTES SO I WOULD AGREE WITH THAT STRONG I THINK THAT WE NEED TO ADDRESS IT HEAD ON. I THINK WE ALREADY HAVE A MASSIVE ISSUE WITH. I THINK LAST COUNT WAS WHAT SIX POINT TWO FIVE MILLION VISITORS SO WE'RE UPPING OUR OPEN SPACE A LITTLE TOO MUCH I THINK THE MOMENT WHICH IS GREAT BUT WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT A WAY NOW AND I THINK THAT IF WE DON'T MAKE THIS A PRIORITY WE'RE GOING TO RUN INTO SOME SEVERE ISSUES WITH OVER USE PLANS SO I WOULD REALLY LIKE TO SEE THIS HIGH HIGH PRIORITY WITHIN THIS AREA AND HEARING THAT TOPIC AS A IMPORTANT ONE FOR EMPHASIS IN ENGAGEMENT FROM MARY NOTICE

[79:05] AND BE MERRY. SO IT JUST IN GENERAL I THINK OUR LANGUAGE AS WE APPROACH THIS PROJECT WE ARE SEPARATING OURSELVES HUMANS FROM THE ECOSYSTEMS. I THINK THAT WORD TENDING TO FORGET THAT WE ARE PART OF THE ECOSYSTEMS AND SO WHEN I READ ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT WHOSE ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION AND I WE THINKING ABOUT IT HOLISTIC LEE AND TERMS OF US AS BEING AS HUMANS AS BEING PART OF THE ECOSYSTEMS AND HOW WE ALSO MANAGE OURSELVES. SO THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING IS I DON'T THINK THIS LANGUAGE IS YOU KNOW TO ADDRESS INCLUSION INCLUSIVE ENOUGH OF WHOSE ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION AND

[80:02] IN IN UM IN BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS. OFTENTIMES WHEN A SPECIES IS OVER POPULATING THEY WILL REGULATE THEMSELVES OR AT OR OR SOME SORT OF A FOOD SOURCE IS RUNNING OUT THEY WILL REGULATE THEMSELVES ON THE USE OF IT OR UM AND SO I THINK THAT THAT I THINK IT NEEDS TO BE A DIFFERENT TERM RATHER THAN RECKLESS ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT. IT JUST SOUNDS SO COLD AND SOME KIND OF SEPARATING OURSELVES FROM IT SO I I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE LANGUAGE WOULD BE BUT SOMETHING THAT ACKNOWLEDGES THAT WE ARE PART OF THE ECOSYSTEM OURSELVES EXPERIENCE. CINDY I READ THE LETTER FROM MARK WILL AND I DON'T KNOW HOW HIS LAST NAME IS PRONOUNCED IT WAS IN

[81:00] THE PACKET WITH INTEREST WHAT AND HE TALKED ABOUT THE AGAIN THIS PARTICULAR AREA. HE TALKED ABOUT THIS PARTICULAR AREA OF HOME AND TALKED ABOUT CARRYING CAPACITY AND SUGGESTED CHANGING THE TERM CARRYING CAPACITY TO ACCEPTABLE USE LEVELS OR APPROPRIATE USE LEVELS TO RECOGNIZE AGAIN THE IMPACT HUMANS HAVE ON THE RESOURCE AGAIN AND JUST TO GIVE AN EXAMPLE OF THAT HERE'S A HERE'S A GREAT NUMBER THAT I FOUND IN MY E MAIL OPEN SPACE MOUNTAIN PARKS IS HAVING A LITTLE CLEAN UP THIS WEEKEND UP SANITIZED VALLEY AND IT'S TALKING ABOUT DOGS AND ONE OF THE AREAS UNDER HERE'S MANAGING DOGS AND IT SAYS THEY'RE ASKING PEOPLE TO COME HELP. UM DO YOU LOVE YOUR DOG FRIENDLY TRAILS AND THEN IT TALKS ABOUT THAT THEY SAY DOGS ARE ENCOURAGED TO JOIN AND THEN IT'S PICKING UP THROUGH AND THEY SAY DOG

[82:00] WASTE CAN BE A MAJOR SOURCE OF WATER CONTAMINATION BECAUSE IT CONTAINED CONTAINS HARMFUL BACTERIA AND PARASITES HOUR FORTY FIVE THOUSAND ACRES SEEDS SIXTY THOUSAND POUNDS OF DOG LEFT BEHIND EVERY YEAR. NOW THAT'S THE KIND OF SPECIFICITY THAT I THINK CAN BE HELPED. THIS IS FROM OPEN SPACE THAT CAN BE HELPED US IN TERMS OF MANAGING CONDITIONS AND I THOUGHT THIS WAS KIND OF QUEUE SO THAT I'D SHARE IT IT'S OUT THERE IF ANYONE WANTS TO SPEND THEIR SATURDAY HELPING CABIN BUT I THINK THAT THAT KIND OF THING AGAIN ACCEPTABLE USE LEVELS AND APPROPRIATE USE LEVELS THERE ARE THERE'S AT SOME POINT WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT LIMITS IT SEEMS WILL CONSIDER THAT WITHIN THE TOPIC SOUNDS LIKE APPROACH HIM. I JUST TRY NOT TO BE CONTRARIAN BUT I REALLY REALLY LIKE THE NAME OF

[83:00] THE FOCUS AREA ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT. THIS IS ONE OF THE FIRST TIMES THAT WE'VE ACTUALLY HAD THE EXPLICIT STATEMENT THAT PEOPLE SHOULD ENJOY OPEN SPACE IN THEIR VISITATION AS BEING A CRITICAL PART OF IT AND I THINK THAT EVERYTHING ELSE HERE OBVIOUSLY BRINGS JOY BUT THIS IS HOW DO WE MANAGE RECREATION TO MATCH TO MINIMIZE IMPACT AND MAXIMIZE CHOICE AND I THINK THAT THAT MEANS THAT WE WOULD PROBABLY END UP CHANGING THE WAY PEOPLE USE TRAILS AND HOW WE DESIGN TRAILS WHERE TRAILS ARE SO THAT THERE'S A FOCUS TO MINIMIZE IMPACT BUT ALSO INCREASE PEOPLE'S PLEASURABLE EXPERIENCE AND A LOT OF THINGS THAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE PROBLEMS WITH IN TRAILS IS IT PEOPLE GO OR WHERE THEY WANT TO GO NOT WHERE THE TRAIL IS AND PROBABLY WE NEED TO THINK ABOUT THAT FROM RECREATION MANAGEMENT STANDPOINT I ACTUALLY HAVE A BOOK CALLED PARKS IN CARRYING CAPACITY THAT I JUST READ RECENTLY AND

[84:00] IT'S VERY INTERESTING. THEY DON'T REALLY STAY TO CARRYING CAPACITY IS A FUNCTION ALL IS NOT A REAL THING. THERE'S NORMS ASSOCIATED WITH HOW PEOPLE FEEL ABOUT THE CROWDING BUT AS TIME GOES ON PEOPLE WOULD CHANGE WHAT THEIR NORMS ARE TO MATCH WHAT'S AROUND THEM. SO SETTING A CARRYING CAPACITY FROM A BIOLOGICAL STANDPOINT WON'T WORK BUT SETTING AN IDEA ABOUT HOW TO DISTRIBUTE PEOPLE AND TO MINIMIZE THE IMPACTS THAT WERE HAVING AND SET AN ACCEPTABLE LEVEL OF IMPACT IS VERY DOABLE. WE CAN SAY HERE'S HOW BAD THE DAMAGE SHOULD BE TO AN ECOSYSTEM AND NO MORE AND THEN YOU CAN TRY TO MANAGE PEOPLE IN A WAY THAT THEY ARE NOT CAUSING MORE DAMAGE TO ONE SPOT SO THEY CAN THEN I CAN HANDLE. SO FOR EXAMPLE CHAUTAUQUA MIGHT BE A PLACE THAT WE CAN HAVE HIGHER NUMBER OF PEOPLE GO THERE THIS POINT IN TIME BUT OTHER PARTS OF OPEN SPACE WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO AT ANY GIVEN TIME AND THAT MANAGEMENT BECOMES

[85:01] MUCH MORE ABOUT WHAT RECREATION EXPERIENCES PEOPLE ARE LOOKING FOR AND HOW WE DIRECT THEM AS OPPOSED TO SETTING A FIRM LIMIT ON SOMETHING AND I THINK IT'S JUST MUCH MORE CONVOLUTED QUESTION AND THAT'S BEST ANSWERED BY THINKING ABOUT PEOPLE'S ENJOYMENT AND MANAGING THEIR CREATIONS TO GET THE ENJOYMENT WHILE MINIMIZING THE IMPACT WHICH IS WHY LIKE THAT THINKING AND DETAILED QUESTION ABOUT TRYING TO WORDSMITH BUT IN ONE OF THE TOPICS HERE WAS ASSESSING THE APPROPRIATENESS OF NEW OR POTENTIAL PASSIVE RECREATION ACTIVITIES ARE NEW AND POTENTIAL DIFFERENT. I MEAN THERE IS AN ACT OF THE SAME THING I KNOW I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT BUT IT'S PROBABLY JUST IN AN ATTEMPT TO SAY THAT THERE ARE THINGS COMING IN THE FUTURE THAT WE DON'T KNOW YET. HOVER CRAFT FOR EXAMPLE EXACTLY THE CASE

[86:04] OF ME JUST THEN I SEE YOU HAVE YET. WELL KEVIN I THINK YOU SAID WHAT I'M THINKING MARCH ACCURATELY BUT I WAS JUST AS A IN TERMS OF CARRYING CAPACITY SEEMS LIKE A MEMBER OF THE THINGS THAT ARE ON HERE ALREADY SORT OF ENGAGE WITH THAT AND SO LOOKING AT HOW WHERE THAT INTERPLAY IS FOR EXAMPLE ADDRESSING PARKING AND TRANSPORTATION NEEDS THE FITS WITHIN THE NEXT I'M ASSUMING WITH CARRYING CAPACITY WE'RE NEVER GOING TO PUT YOU KNOW ROUNDERS THAT YOU PUT A QUARTER AND IT SHUTS OFF AT SOME POINT WHEN ITS REACH TO MANY PEOPLE IT'S MORE ABOUT WORKING TO LIMIT PARKING HERE OR WE'RE GOING TO YOU KNOW CREATE NEW TRAIL SYSTEMS AND I'M SORRY YOU TO PUT UP A VERY GOOD POINT ABOUT DOGS WHICH ALSO GOES INTO CARING CAPACITY AND WOULD LOVE DOGS I JUST HAVE TO SAY TO US IT'S NOT ABOUT DOGS DIDN'T KNOW TOTALLY YET I HAD WITH MY PARTNERS OF ALL THE TIME BUT

[87:00] IT WOULD BE INTERESTING TO KNOW YOU KNOW THE DOG IMPACT VERSUS HUMAN IMPACT YOU HAVE TO ASSUME IT'S TWO OR THREE TIMES OR MORE YOU KNOW HUMAN IMPACT AND SO THE NORWEGIAN ADJUST FOR THAT WITH THE EQUIVALENT OF THE DOGS AND ANY OTHER COMMENTS THAT ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT. WE JUST WANT TO REITERATE WHAT A COUPLE PEOPLE HAVE SAID I MEAN VISITATION ON OUR LAND HAS GONE UP BY THIRTY THREE PERCENT IN THE PAST FOURTEEN YEARS OR SO AND WE'VE ONLY GOT ACCORDING TO WHAT WE'RE SAYING THERE ABOUT FIVE THOUSAND MORE ACRES TO ADD TO FORTY FIVE THOUSAND ACRES SO THE USE OF OUR SPACE IS INCREASING MORE QUICKLY THAN WE'RE ACQUIRING MORE OF IT AND SO I THINK WE WOULD BE REMISS IF WE DIDN'T TRY AND UNDERSTAND WHAT ARE MOST EFFECTIVE MITIGATION TECHNIQUES ARE FROM AN ECOSYSTEM HEALTH PERSPECTIVE SO FOR THOSE THAT ARE SUMMING UP SUMMARIZING ABACK

[88:00] I WANT TO UNDER SCI FI UNDERSTAND THIS THAT THE CHALLENGE IS TO CONFIRM A ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT I HEARD ONE THAT THE NAME ITSELF IS THE CHALLENGING PART OF IT AND WHETHER OTHER REASONS WHY THIS ONE IS NOT FAVORABLE TO CONFIRM AT THIS TIME FOR MOTHER'S DAY CAPTURE THAT CORRECTLY BUT IT'S MORE THE NAME OF ITS ENJOYMENT RECREATION MANAGEMENT THERE IS ONE BAND FAVOR AND ONE NON DAYS IN FAVOR OF THE NAME ITSELF BUT IT'S THE CONTENT ITSELF. MARY AS IS THE CONTENT SOLID IN YOUR MIND NOT ENTIRELY BUT IF YOU COULD WORK IN THE WORDS REVERENCE AND APPRECIATION. I THINK THAT WOULD BE GREAT AT POINTING OUT THAT EACH OF THESE FOCUS AREAS HAS KIND OF A PURPOSE STATEMENT WITH IT SO THE ONE FOR THIS IS WE ARE UNITED BY OUR ENJOYMENT OF NATURE AND OUR OBLIGATION TO PROTECT AND I THINK THAT THE OBLIGATION TO PROTECT IT SPEAKS TO THE THEMES THAT YOU ARE TRYING TO BRING UP OUR MEAT CONNECTION WITH NATURE AND HOW WE HAVE TO BE

[89:00] THE STEWARDS OF ALL ARE ENJOYING A RECTORY AND I THINK EACH OF THESE PURPOSE STATEMENTS OR SOMETHING THAT'S REALLY IMPORTANT CARRY ON WITH JUST THAT I DID IT JUST THE TITLE ISN'T ENOUGH IT'S THAT PURPOSE STATEMENT THAT CREATES THE MOTIVATION BEHIND EACH OF THESE FOCUS AREAS AND I THINK THEY'RE VERY IMPORTANT THING SAID BUT I APPRECIATE THE CONCEPT AND I ALSO JUST WANNA SAY THAT IN REFERENCE TO THE CONVERSATION WE'RE HAVING EARLIER ABOUT COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION WHETHER WHAT TO DO WITH THAT IS THAT LIVE ON ITS OWN DOES IT GET INTEGRATED ONE OF THE DRIVING SETS OF COMMENTS BEHIND THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE FOCUS AREA WERE ACTUALLY SOME REALLY INTERESTING COMMENTS AROUND. THESE ARE MENTAL WELL BEING THAT IS GAINED IN RECREATING IN NATURE WHEN WHEN WHEN WE GO OUT AND WE REALIZE WE ARE PART OF SOMETHING LARGER OR ACTUALLY A LUSH NUMBER OF COMMENTS THE INTERESTING LEE ACKNOWLEDGED THAT WERE PART OF THE BROADER ECOSYSTEM AND THAT THAT IS WHERE THEY DERIVE VALUE FROM OPEN SPACE AND SO IF DEPENDING ON IN

[90:02] UNDERSTANDING YOUR FEELINGS ABOUT THAT MARY I THINK THAT WE COULD AND DEPENDING ON WHERE WE GO WITH OCONEE CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION FOCUS AREA THERE MIGHT BE A WAY TO INTEGRATE THE CONCEPT TOGETHER WITH THIS ONE AND I KNOW HE'D MOVE ON TO THE TWO OTHERS THAT WERE SUGGESTED AS ADDITIONAL FOCUS AREAS SO I WANT TO SEE IF THERE ANY LAST COMMENTS ABOUT THE SWINE OR ANY OF THE FIVE BEFORE WE GET INTO THOSE OTHER TWO HAD WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PURPOSE SYSTEMS STATEMENTS CAN BE GIVEN TO THE FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY ONE REAL QUICK I JUST WAS GOING TO ASK FER SOME MORE INSPIRATIONAL LANGUAGE HERE BECAUSE HIS PRESERVING OUR LEGACY LAND SYSTEM AND THAT DOESN'T SPEAK TO KIND OF THE GLORY OF OUR OPEN SPACE SYSTEM SO I JUST I'D LOVE TO SEE SOME DIFFERENT LANGUAGE THEY'RE BREAKING LAURIE HELEN REFERENCES TO IT LIKE

[91:01] THE FACT THE CASE I'M READY TO MOVE ON PARLIAMENT'S MOVE ON TO THE OTHER TWO THAT SUGGESTED ONE WAS AGRICULTURE AND THE OTHER ONE WAS CULTURAL RESOURCES THEY BELIEVE AB SO AGRICULTURE WAS TALK ABOUT THAT ONE FIRST AS IF ITS OWN STANDALONE FOCUS AREA AND I THINK FIRST OF ALL LINE TO UNDERSTAND IF THAT IS ONE THAT PEOPLE PEOPLE AND STREAMER FEELING NICE A STAND ALONE IT'S PLAYED SIMILARLY TO THESE OTHER FIVE YOU'VE LOOKED AT OR IF IT'S ONE THAT TIME MAYBE SEE IT IN THESE TOPICS ARE READY IF THAT'S ENOUGH EMPHASIS OR IF IT NEEDS TO BE MORE CRITICAL. SO WANNA TALK ABOUT IN A LITTLE BIT ABOUT AGRICULTURE. TOM CAN GET A CLARIFICATION ON WHAT THIS TOPIC WOULD INCLUDE THE CULTURE BUT YET GIVE ME SOME ARE TALKING ABOUT ACQUISITION OF MORE WE TALK ABOUT MANAGING OF WHAT GETS US SO THIS WAS SUGGESTED AS ANOTHER FOCUS AREA BY SOMEONE ON THE BOARD SO HE COULD THIS EXPLAIN MORE CLEARLY SHOW

[92:01] RUNNING THE EASIEST PLACE TO START IS JUST TO TAKE THE RELATED TOPICS IN EACH FOCUS AREA THEY'RE RELATED TO AGRICULTURE AND SO THE FIRST ONE IS INTEGRATING SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL PRACTICES IN RESOURCE PROTECTION. THE SECOND ONE IS SUPPORTING THE AGRICULTURAL COMMUNITY IN A TIME OF ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL CHANGE AND THEN THE THIRD ONE IS CONNECTING COMMUNITIES TO AGRICULTURE AND I THINK EACH OF THOSE IS A FOCUS OF MAJOR INITIATIVES GOING ON RIGHT NOW COMING OUT OF THE EGGPLANT BUT ALSO COMING OUT OF OTHER AREAS AND WE'RE GOING TO GENERATIONAL CHANGE WITH OUR LESS EASE OR WANTING TO ESTABLISH NEW TYPES OF AGRICULTURE AND SUPPORT THAT WE HAVE ALL THE CONSERVANCY THAT IS FOCUSING ON AGRICULTURAL INITIATIVES. SO GIVEN HOW MUCH OUR LAND BASE IT OCCUPIES A GIVEN THAT A SEPARATE CHARTER PURPOSE. I JUST THINK IT DESERVES TO

[93:01] VISIBILITY FOR ITS ON SITE EVAN DIDN'T TOM HAVE THEM OH SORRY I'M SORRY TOM WHEN SHE STARTED FOR HER I'VE WRESTLED WITH THIS ONE A BIT BUT I DO THINK IT'S IMPORTANT REMEMBER THAT IT'S LESS THAN ELEVEN MONTHS AGO WHEN COUNCIL APPROVED THE AG PLAN AND I THINK THE REAL QUESTION IS IS THERE ENOUGH THAT WASN'T ALREADY ADDRESSED IN THAT PLAN TO CONSTITUTE ITS OWN FOCUS SYRIA'S I THINK IT WOULD BE A MISTAKE TO USE THIS AS A WAY TO REVISIT ISSUES THAT REALLY JUST DECIDED DURING A FAIRLY ROBUST PROCESS THAT INVOLVES A LOT OF COMMUNICATION WITH AT VARIOUS FARMERS ANOTHER LESS EASE AND MY SENSE IS THAT WHILE THERE'S CERTAINLY SOME IMPORTANT AG ISSUES INCLUDING AG ISSUES PEOPLE ARE GOING FORWARD AN AWFUL LOT OF THAT WAS JUST DECIDED IN A PROCESS THAT'S GOING TO BE VERY CRASS TO GET YOU KNOW WHAT'S ALREADY AN INCREDIBLY

[94:00] AMBITIOUS LIST OF FOCUS AREAS AND TOPICS COMPLETED AND REALLY JUST SLIGHTLY MORE THAN A YEAR HAVE TO DO SOME SORT OF PICKING OF BATTLES AND NOT RE INVENTING OF WHEELS BIKE AND USES TWO METAPHORS AND THIS STRIKES ME AS ONE WHERE FOR THE MOST PART THE WHEELS BEEN INVENTED THERE ARE SOME ADDITIONAL THINGS I THINK WE DO NEED TO COVER BUT I WOULD SAY THOSE CAN BE PICKED UP SORT HERE AND THERE ARE NOT A FULL BLOWN EGG SPECIFIC TOPIC THAT'S NOT THE SALES ARE IMPORTANT BUT I THINK A LOT OF THE WORK HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE BY THE STAFF BOARD AND COUNCIL ON THIS CAN CAN AND BOUGHT SOME AND MAY I MEAN I HAD A CONCRETE THOUGHT AND TOM JUST BLEW IT OUT OF THE WATER BUT I AGREE WITH TOM WAS SAYING WE HAVEN'T HAD PLANNED. I THINK THE TIMELINESS OF THE WAY THESE THINGS GET UPDATED THOUGH I WORRY THAT ONE WOULD FALL OUT OF DATE WHILE THE OTHER ONE SO DAG PLAN MY FALL OUT OF DATE AND THEN THIS WOULD BE WHAT WE GENERALLY HAVE US AS OUR OBJECT ON HAND SO I ALMOST THINK A COPY PASTE OF SOME OF

[95:00] THE KEY TOPICS FROM THE AG PLAN WOULD BE VALUABLE IN THIS TO BRING THE REST ACCOUNT SO IF YOU HAVEN'T REALLY THOUGHT ABOUT THIS SOMETHING WE ARE RUNNING MILLIONS OF DOLLARS WORTH OF AGRIBUSINESS ON OUR LANDS WE HAVE LEASES WITH A VARIETY OF DIFFERENT PEOPLE AND ALL OF THIS THEY HAVE TO MAINTAIN PROFITABILITY WE HAVE OUR OWN SET OF STANDARDS OF WHAT TYPE OF AGRICULTURE PRACTICES ACCEPTABLE IN THIS ALL INTERACTS WITH ECOSYSTEMS IN RECREATION AND SUCH A LARGE SCALE WAY MORE PEOPLE ARE REGULARLY RECREATING ON TRAILS THAT ARE ALSO USED FOR GRAZING OR FOR FARMING AND THE USE OF TYPES OF HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES AFFECT NEIGHBORHOODS. I THINK THAT THIS IS A BIG ENOUGH TOPIC THAT MAKES SENSE TO HAVE SOME OF THE TOP LEVEL STUFF FROM THE AG PLAN SHOULD HEAR IF ONLY TO BE DUPLICATING IT AND THEN TO SAY WHEN WE GET READY TO DO THE NEXT AG PLAN AT LEAST WE HAVE SOME OF THE THINGS THEY AGREED ON THAT PLAN SHOULD HEAR SO THAT IT HAS EQUAL PROMINENCE TO THE OTHER THINGS AND THIS IS THE ONLY

[96:03] REASON WHY I WOULD THINK IT REALLY SHOULD BE IN HERE BECAUSE YOU THINK THAT'S GREAT BUT TO KICK IN TO CLARIFY A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHAT YOU MEAN BY IT SHOULD BE IN HERE I WANT TO CHECK GUESS I'M HEARING SOME DIFFERENT OPINIONS ABOUT THIS LINE OF WHAT IT BE GIVING THIS IMPORTANCE OF SAYING THIS IS A CRITICAL TOPIC AND GIVING MORE EMPHASIS IN THE ENGAGEMENT ENOUGH ON ITS OWN OR DOES IT NEED TO BECOME A FOCUS AREA SO WHEN SUGGESTING THERE IS SOME OF THESE TOPICS CLEARLY WILL GET MORE ATTENTION AS WE GO FORWARD AND WE NEED MORE EXPLORATION OF THE. I'M WONDERING IF THAT'S ENOUGH FOR IF WE REALLY SEE THIS IS STANDING ALONE SINCE I'M HEARING A DIFFERENT OPINION FROM TOM OF MAYBE SOME IDEAS OF MAYBE WHY IT WOULD NEED TO BE QUITE IN FOCUS AREA BUT SO WHAT WAS YOUR THOUGHT ABOUT SAYING NICE BEING HERE. I MEAN I'M I'M I'M CLEAR CLEAR THAT I THINK IF I HAD A MASTER PLAN SHOULD SAY HERE'S THE AGRICULTURAL ASPECT AS A FOCUS AREA THAT NEEDS TO BE SOMETHING THAT'S HEAVILY DEBATED BY THE GIVEN WE JUST

[97:03] HAD TO ADD PLAN NOT SO SURE ABOUT. I'LL LEAVE IT TO STAFF THE RESULT THAT THE KING AND I SEE COUPLE THINGS I THINK MARY SPENT WAITING. MARY SPENT WAITING FOR A WHILE I THINK AND CARE IN THE WINTER YOU CAN CARRY SO I I THINK THAT IT SHOULD BE INCLUDED BUT CHECK TO CHECK DONE. UM I AGREE WITH WHAT KEVIN SAID ABOUT THIS AND ALSO YOU KNOW IT GOES TO FINANCIAL THE FINANCIAL PIECE OF THAT ALL THESE KIND OF IN HER LATE SON MORE THAN OTHERS BUT THIS ONE. YOU KNOW WHERE YOU'VE GOT FIFTEEN THE RELEASE OF THE SEAS DOING THE WORK OF FIFTEEN FULL TIME STAFF MEMBERS I THINK IT ALMOST NEEDS TO BE INCLUDED FOR THAT REASON ALONE AND SO I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO INCLUDE. I ALSO THINK THAT THIS WIN IS ANOTHER ONE THAT CAN BE COMBINED WITH THE CULTURAL

[98:01] RESOURCES AGRICULTURAL AND CULTURAL RESOURCES BECAUSE THE AGRICULTURAL PIECE OF THE OF THE ASSESSMENT. IT MENTIONS STRUCTURES AS WELL STRUCTURES AND CULTURES SO THOSE TWO ARE KIND OF INTERRELATED SO THAT'S JUST WHAT I WANTED TO COMMENT SOME ALSO HEARING FROM AREA COMBINATION POSSIBLE. OUR CULTURE PLUS CULTURAL RESOURCES THAT MANY OF THE CULTURAL RESOURCES ARE SO AN AGRICULTURAL LAND WE THINK CAN MY PERCEPTION OF THE PURPOSE OF THE MASTER PLAN IS TO SPEAK TO NEEDS IS THAT CORRECT. SO WAS PRESSING WHAT WE NEED REST NOW FIVE TEN YEARS SINCE SO THAT REQUIRES US TO ADDRESS THE ITEMS IN THE AGRICULTURAL PART OF OUR SYSTEM THAT HAVE NEEDS THAT NEED TO BE

[99:03] ADDRESSED RIGHT INVERSELY COULD BE SAID THAT THOSE NEEDS ARE BEING ADDRESSED BY THE VISION PUT FORWARD IN THE PLAN WE NEED TO GIVE THAT SOME TIME TO ACTUALLY PLAY OUT BEFORE WE TRY AND PLAN AGAIN I THINK WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT THIS ALOT AND I CAN CARE FOR IT I THINK THERE'S A TENSION BETWEEN I THINK WE PROBABLY ALL UNDERSTAND THE AGRICULTURE AND AGRICULTURAL MANAGEMENT IS A CRITICAL PIECE OF THE OPEN SPACE SYSTEM. WE DID ALSO JUST FINISHED A VERY THOROUGH AGRICULTURAL MASTER PLANNED TO THE QUESTION HOW THE RESULT THAT THE UNIT IN GOING FOR IN TERMS OF MAKING ITS OWN FOCUS AREA COMBINING IT SAID MAYBE THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE LET THE OPEN SPACE PORT. TALK ABOUT MORE FELIPE TOMORROW AND MAY CORRECT ME BECAUSE THIS IS A BIT OF A TENSION BETWEEN THOSE TWO THINGS I SEE I I HAVE A SPECIFIC BOOK COVERS BOTH AG AND FINANCES

[100:02] WHICH REFERS TO A LETTER WE GOT FROM REBECCA DRAFT AND ASKING ABOUT OPEN SPACE AND MOUNTAIN PARKS LEASING THE BUILDING FOR A DOLLAR TO BUY ASK IS THAT TRUE I MEAN SO THIS IS AN APPEAL THAT I'VE REALIZED FROM WHAT'S GOING ON THIS EVENING BUT I WOULD LIKE SOME INFORMATION ON THAT BOTH IF IT'S HAPPENING JUSTIFICATION HOW MUCH MONEY IS COMING OUT OF OPEN SPACE IN ORDER TO SUPPORT THAT JUST AS AN ASIDE BECAUSE IT CAME UP IN A PIECE OF EATERS STUDY SESSION TONIGHT IN A LETTER FROM THE AND I APPRECIATE THAT WE ALSO GOT AN EMAIL FROM MISS MOORE'S OKAY YOU CAN BE HERE TONIGHT TO HOTLINE AND SO IS PART OF THAT SAME REQUEST WILL BE ASSEMBLING A RESPONSE TO THAT AND SENDING THEM OUT WITHIN THE WEEK. GREAT ENDING BUT LEE SAID IN A DRESS BOTH ITEMS TO MY ONE AND THREE AND THAT YES EXACTLY STARTS IN THE ABSOLUTE RIGHT TO RESPONDING TO BOTH YOU AND I

[101:02] THINK YOU ABOUT SOMEONE AND JUST WANTED TO QUICKLY AGREE WITH MARY BUT I THINK YOU CAN DO CULTURE RESOURCES AGRICULTURE AND YOU CAN REFERENCE TO THE FOP BAD PLAN AS WELL AS A WAY OF INCORPORATING BY REFERENCE WITHOUT HAVING TO BRING THE WHOLE THING INTO THE MASTER PLAN. OK WELL IN THE INTEREST OF TIME I WAN TALK A LITTLE ABOUT THE CULTURAL RESOURCES THAT WAS BROUGHT UP AS WELL AS A FOCUS AREA AND THIS ANYTHING MORE TO ADD UP TO THAT ONE OR IS IT CLEAR THAT COMBINING THESE ISN'T AN APPROPRIATE APPROACH OR IS THERE ANY INTERESTING HOW THAT MIGHT BE SEPARATED OUT IN THE SIDE JUST WANTED TO ADDRESS THE REASON THAT I BROUGHT IT UP THE WHITE WITH ME AT FIVE THIRTY THIS MORNING IN A QUICKLY EMAILED SO LAST WEEK THERE WAS A DELEGATION IN BOULDER FROM HOME PEOPLE OF THE NORTHERN ARAPAHOE AND SOUTHERN ARAPAHOE TRIBES AND I PARTICIPATED IN SOME EVENTS

[102:02] AND A MEETING AND A LOT WAS SAID ABOUT HOW IMPORTANT THE AREA IS TO THEM AND STILL IS THEY STILL CALL IT HOME AND AND WOMEN THINGS THAT WE DID WAS GO OUT TO THE FARM THAT WAS JUST PURCHASED AND WATCH THEM JUST LOOK OUT AT THE VISTAS WERE THERE AND HOME AND IMAGINE WHAT HAD BEEN IN THE PAST AND THE HISTORY OF THE PLACE AND TO THINK THAT THEY PERHAPS HAVE ANCESTORS BURIED THERE I JUST THINK THAT THE BECAUSE OF THAT WE SHOULD CONSIDER THE CULTURAL RESOURCES AND TO ME JUST THAT EXPERIENCE EXPRESSED THE NEED TO INCLUDE CULTURAL AND AS WELL AS FEEDBACK FROM FROM THEM TOO

[103:01] AS AS PART OF OUR ALL INCLUSIVE OUTREACH. SO ASK THE SAME QUESTION TAKE AS I DID ABOUT AGRICULTURE TEND TO CLARIFY LITTLE BIT ABOUT HOW THIS MIGHT FIT TOGETHER IN THE HIERARCHY. DO YOU SEE CULTURAL RESOURCES REPRESENTED WELL AND ARE TOPICS THAT WERE COULD LIVE UNDER THESE FOCUS AREAS BUT SOME OF THESE FOCUS AREAS REFERENCE VARIOUS PARTS OF CULTURAL RESOURCES DO YOU FEEL LIKE THAT'S GIVING ENOUGH ATTENTION HARDY THINK THAT THEY COULD RISE AS ONE OF THE CRITICAL TOPIC AREAS I'LL LEAVE IT TO THE OUTREACH TO THE I THINK BUT I THINK YOU KNOW THAT THAT CERTAINLY THE COMBINING OF THE TWO IS IS ONE THING THAT THAT'S IMPORTANT FOR THE REASON THAT A LOT OF THE CULTURAL ASSETS AND RESOURCES ARE ON AGRICULTURAL LAND. SO OKAY I THOUGHT AND

[104:00] CULTURAL RESOURCES SAID COME BUT I WONDER WHO MIGHT ALSO CONSIDER THINK ABOUT IT IS HISTORIC RESOURCES AS WELL MY CULTURAL AND HISTORIC SO THAT MIGHT LINK TOGETHER IN LINKING WITH AGRICULTURAL AS WELL AS THOSE THREE THINGS SEEM TO TYPE OR WILL THE CURSE OF THE HISTORY OF THE AREAS AND IN AGRICULTURE AS WELL SO I THOUGHT PAY ANY OTHER DISCUSSION OR DIALOGUE HE LIKED TO HAVE BEFORE TOMORROW NIGHT WHEN THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES GETS TOGETHER AGAIN. K THEN I THINK WE ARE IS TIME TO ADJUST TO THE RICE IS WELL APPRECIATED THE RESPONSIVENESS TO THE INPUT IN THE LAST ENGAGEMENT WINDOW I THOUGHT THAT THE RELATED TOPICS WERE IMPROVED BY THE RESPONSES TO THAT TO APPRECIATE THE ENGAGING WITH IT AND THEN HOW STEFAN ALL THAT AND ADDED THINGS EXCELLENT. I THINK WHEN READY TO SWITCH TO THE SUMMARY AND PREVIEW WHAT WE HEARD AND SEE EVERYONE I KNOW WE COULD COLLECT THIS RECORDING CAN APPROPRIATELY WHETHER ANY OF THINGS YOU'D LIKE TO CHANGE SO THAT

[105:02] TOMORROW O S B T HAS THE CHANCE TO REFLECT ON ON THESE PARTICULAR QUESTIONS AND ITEMS FOR CLARIFICATION TO MY OH SO WITH THE HAT WHEN YOU SWITCH THE SCREEN I BELIEVE THAT POSSIBLE ONE MOMENT JUST ONE SECOND OKAY SO THEY'VE BEEN WORKING IN THE BACK TO TRY AND SUMMARIZE THIS WEEK AND REVIEW AND SEE IF ARE ON POINT SO WE'RE GOING TO BE ASKING IF THERE ARE ANY CHANGES TO THIS THAT YOU LIKE TO CONSIDER BEFORE HE GETS REVIEWED FURTHER TOMORROW NIGHT. SHE CAN BUILD UP A LITTLE LARGER ON OUR SCREEN AS WELL. I CAN REVIEW IT SO IT SOUNDS LIKE WE CONFIRMED TO THAT FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY HAS ONE THAT WE HAD A LOT OF AGREEMENT AROUND THAT CONTAINING FLORIDA AS A FOCUS AREA SO THAT ONE WILL REMAIN PART OF THAT OF THAT THINK HE WOULD PROBABLY NEEDS LITTLE

[106:00] DISCUSSION TOMORROW NIGHT BUT WE DID HEAR SOME THOUGHTS IN THAT ONE ABOUT HOW IT IS ALL ENCOMPASSING AS WELL SO THE FOCUS HERE IS A NEED FOR DISCUSSION WE HEARD COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND INCLUSION TO EITHER CONSIDER INTEGRATING IT OR LEAVE IT ON ITS OWN FOR THE TWO OPTIONS DISCUSSED THE COMBINED ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AND RESILIENCE WAS ANOTHER SUGGESTION TO CONSIDER THE ENJOYMENT AND RECREATION MANAGEMENT. ADJUST THE LANGUAGE POTENTIALLY BUT OTHERWISE WE HEARD A LOT OF CONFIRMATION AROUND THAT PARTICULAR ONE AM AND I'M ADDING AGRICULTURE CULTURAL AND HISTORIC RESOURCES OF THAT WAS THE LAST ADJUSTMENT HAS GOT AND THEN THINK OF THE FOURTH AREA. SO IN ADDITION GENTLE SUPPORT RELATED TOPICS WITH SOME ADDITIONAL REFINEMENTS OF THIS IS RELATED TO THE TOPICS NOT THE FOCUS AREAS BUT THE TOPICS OF ADDING CONTROL AND ELIMINATING

[107:00] THE PROLIFERATION OF INVASIVE SPECIES UNDER ECOSYSTEM HEALTH. ADDING HOW DO WE COME A DAY CLIMATE CHANGE UNDER ECOSYSTEM HEALTH AND RESILIENCE AND ADDING EXCEPT THE LEVELS EXCEPT TO USE LEVELS ENJOYMENT OF RECREATION AND SOME OTHER ITEMS THAT I AM SO BAD ONCE BT WILL CONTINUE TO DISCUSS AND FIND THE FIVE FOCUS AREAS INCLUDING THE NEWLY PROPOSED AGRICULTURE CULTURE RESOURCES AND HISTORIC RESOURCES I BELIEVE AND ANY ADDITIONAL RELATED TOPICS SO IF THERE ARE THINGS THAT WE MISSED TONIGHT BUT YOU'RE THINKING THESE HAPPY PART OF THE TOPICS AS WELL TO HELP DIRECT CONVERSATIONS WITH THE IN THE NEXT ROUND. I'M NOT THAT THEY ARE COMPLETE BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT THE STRATEGIES THERE JUST TO HELP INFORM THE DEVELOPMENT OF STRATEGIES HE WANNA KNOW ALSO FOR ANY ADDITIONAL RELATED TOPICS TO INCLUDE SO HOW'D WE DO HAS ADDED SOME

[108:00] MAY HAVE FIXED UP SO THIS MOTHER SOME CLARIFICATIONS FOR ONE THING I WOULD LIKE OR READING THROUGH THE PACKET AND SEEING THE COMMUNITY ENGAGED I THINK YOU STEPPED AN AMAZING JOB TRYING TO BRING IN DIVERSE CREW I THINK ONE THING THAT CONCERNS ME IS HAVING A VALID INPUT WHEN YOU DON'T HAVE ALL THE DATA CAN SKI THE WAY RESULTS COME THROUGH SO AS YOU CONTINUE TO MOVE FORWARD WITH COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT. I WOULD LOVE TO SEE THE INFORMATION BUT SOME OF THE STUFF THAT WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT IN TERMS OF THE STUDIES AND THE TRENDS THAT ARE EXISTING WITH HAN POPULATION ARE INVASIVE WEEDS ARE X Y AND Z THERE SO MANY YEARS OF STUDY IN SO MANY GREAT GROUPS HAVE COMPILED DATA. I THINK THE COMMUNITY I MEAN WE ARE REALLY EDUCATED INCREDIBLE COMMUNITY AND THEY NEED TO SEE THAT TO MAKE A

[109:01] FULLY INFORMED DECISION OR REMARKS THAT WILL HELP GUIDE US BECAUSE WITHOUT THAT I WAS FEEL LIKE IT'S IT'S GREAT TO HAVE ENGAGEMENT BUT THEY'RE NOT SEEN THE WHOLE STORY THAT'S HARD. SO DOES THE MORE WE CAN GIVE THEM IN TERMS OF THE DATA AND THE TRENDS WOULD BE FABULOUS COMING ANY OTHER CLARIFICATIONS OR TO LOOK WHEN WE CAPTURED IT HERE THE SUMMARY ACCURATE ACCURATE OF NEXT STEPS. SKIP AM SEEING HAD ANOTHER IN THE ROOM AND NO OTHER COMMENT SO THE HOUR AHEAD OF TIME. THAT'S NOT ACCEPT THE UN TO THE BONUS ROUND BECAUSE WE'RE DOWN A COUPLE MEMBERS ALPS THE CITY HAS SOME CONCLUSION SUMMARY THAN AT THIS POINT SORRY JUST A COUPLE MORE MINUTES TO SPARE I JUST WANTED TO

[110:03] REITERATE NEXT STEPS. SO THINGS STILL HAVE TO BRING IN THAT FIGHT UP. THIS IS REALLY JUST A REDIRECTION AND TERMS OF WHERE WE ARE. WE WILL COME BACK WITH REFINEMENTS THAT WE AFTER THE BOARD SESSIONS BARN EXCUSE ME I SHOULD SAY WE WILL HAVE ADDITIONAL DISCUSSIONS WE WILL COME BACK WITH REFINEMENTS THAT EMERGE FROM THAT DISCUSSION BACK TO THE BOARD ON JULY ELEVENTH AND WE WILL BE ASKING FOR THEIR FORMAL RECOMMENDATION THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVES THE FOCUS AREAS ON JULY SEVENTEENTH. SO A FEW DAYS AFTER THAT THEN WE WOULD BE COMING BACK TO CITY COUNCIL AND AGAIN ASKING FOR THE FORMAL APPROVAL OF THOSE FOLKS SERIOUS. SO THAT'S THE POINT AT WHICH WE HAVE CLEARLY IN TERMS OF THE BASIC FOUNDATION OF OUR MASTER PLAN AND WE USE THAT TO THEN MOVE FORWARD IN TERMS OF WHAT TO DO ABOUT THAT HOW TO ADVANCE THOSE STRATEGIES IN RELATION TO THOSE RELATED TOPICS AND SO THAT'S WHAT ENGAGEMENT STARTS TO BE AROUND IN THE FALL AND THAT'S WHEN WE START TO GET A BETTER

[111:00] UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT OUR FUTURE WILL LOOK LIKE AND AS WE MOVE THROUGH THE PROCESS AGAIN WE GET MORE AND MORE PRAYER TIES MORE AND MORE CLEAR SO THAT WE END UP WITH A FINAL PLAN HOPEFULLY BY THE END OF SUMMER NEXT YEAR WHERE WE HAVE A VERY CLEAR VISION FOR FUTURE THAT'S GROUND TRUTH AGAINST FINANCIAL REALITIES AND THE COMMUNITY INPUT AND THE STUDIES AND RESEARCH THAT HAVE GONE INTO DEVELOPING THAT VISION. SO JUST A BROAD SKETCH JUST REITERATE WHERE WE WHERE WE ARE NOW AND WHERE WILL MEET BE MOVING AND I ALSO JUST WANTED TO CLOSE BY SAYING THANK YOU SO MUCH ERIN FOR YOUR HELP TONIGHT FOR THE PROCESS COMMITTEE'S INPUT ALL ALONG WE REALLY ARE SO APPRECIATIVE OF THAT STRUCTURE AND BEING GUIDED TO BE INCLUSIVE AND BALANCED AS WE DEVELOP THE ENGAGEMENT AND PLANNING APPROACH. SO THANK YOU ESPECIALLY FOR THAT EXTRA TIME DEVOTED TO THAT EFFORT THOSE EVERYONE'S TIME HERE TONIGHT INCLUDING MARY AND TOM YOU'RE HERE FOR SUSPICION TO NAME SO AGAIN THANK YOU I RECOGNIZE THAT YOU HAVE A

[112:00] SPECIAL MEETING STARTING ABOUT TEN MINUTES SO WE WILL WRAP UP VERY QUICKLY AND GET OUT OF YOUR WAY TO MAKE THAT HAPPEN SO HE WILL THINK YOU JUST IN A HUGE THANK YOU STEPH FOR ALL YOUR HARD WORK IT'S BEEN REMARKABLE AND EXTREMELY HIGH QUALITY I THINK WE'RE ON A VERY GOOD PATH AND THANKS TO THE OPEN SPACE BOARD DISCREET TO HAVE YOU HERE TONIGHT GIVE US THE CHANCE TO SOME CROSS POLLINATION WITH DIFFERENT IDEAS ABOUT ARE SO WELL LOW TO OPEN SPACE SYSTEM. SO WITH THAT THING SO MUCH GOING TO TAKE A FEW COUPLE MINUTES TO MOVE THINGS AROUND AND THEN WILL CARE FOR ESPECIALLY THE GETS WRAPPED UP IN

[113:02] PLASTIC. YES THE HOUSE OF D D D D D D D THE AND IN THE DAY IN

[114:04] THE TO WE THE WOMEN COULD THUS THUS THUS ROOM WAS UH THE AIR IN THE ER TO

[115:08] IN THE WIND IN

[116:07] WAY NINTH THE WAR

[117:14] SHOW SHIP THE MORE SHIP

[118:02] THE HEAD IN THE IN SHIP THE HEAD OF THE MORE SHE

[119:22] THE YEAR IN IN THE WAY WAY IN THE ONE THE WAY THE YOU IN THE RAIN AND WINTER NOW U

[120:10] THE AND IN THE DAY IN

[121:01] ROOM IN THE ER. THE AIR IN THE MOOD TO THE WHO IN THE WAY TO THE IN THE YOU IN

[122:18] YEARS THE WIND IN UNIT THUS WAY THE U DUH THE SHIFTS

[123:11] THE IT'S THE K THE RADIO. I WILL NOW CALL THE JUNE TWELVETH TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN SPECIAL MEETING OF THE BOULDER CITY COUNCIL TO ORDER PLEASE TAKE THE ROLE WITH THE MIKE ON THE YEAR SAID HERE THE ROUND HERE. GRR I KNOW THE JONES HIS OWN NAME WRONG. HERE WE ARE HERE YATES HERE AND YON. OK MARY OF A QUARTER OF THE GREAT THING SO MUCH GREATS WHO WERE GOING TO START WITH A COMMUNITY BROADBAND ITEM HIS

[124:06] KINETIC SOFTWARE FROM SAP GOOD EVENING THANK YOU FOR A MEETING WITH US THIS EVENING THE TOPIC OF OUR PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION IS COMMUNITY BROADBAND. THE PURPOSE OF THIS ITEM IS TO COVER CONSIDER A MOTION TO PROCEED WITH THE DEVELOPMENT OF A BACKBONE AND ALSO TO DETERMINE WHETHER A BALLOT ITEM SHOULD BE PROPOSED TO FUND THIS EFFORT. WE'RE GOING TO GO THROUGH A BIT OF MATERIAL TO GIVE CONTEXT AND BACKGROUND TO WHERE WE ARE HOW WE GOT HERE AND THE OPTION THAT WE'RE CONSIDERING THIS EVENING AS WELL AS TALK THROUGH FINANCING OPTIONS FOR THE PROPOSED OPTION WE WILL ALSO REVIEW SURVEY RESULTS FROM OUR PARTNER AND RC WHO HAS CONDUCTED A STATISTICALLY VALID SURVEY AND WE LITERALLY GOT THOSE RESULTS YESTERDAY SO WILL REVIEW A DRAFT OF THOSE RESULTS WITH YOU THIS EVENING WE'LL TALK ABOUT NEXT STEPS AND MOVE INTO QUESTIONS THE HEARING AND DELIBERATION SO STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION IS

[125:00] A MOTION FROM YOU ALL TO DIRECT STAFF TO PROCEED WITH THE DEVELOPMENT OF A FIBER BACKBONE IN SUPPORT OF THE CITY'S BROADBAND EFFORTS WITH FINANCING THAT MAY OR MAY NOT REQUIRE A BALLOT ITEM AS A REMINDER FOR WHY WE'RE DOING THIS PROJECT THE CITY'S VISION IS FOR BOULDER TO HAVE A WORLD CLASS COMMUNITY COMMUNITY TELECOMMUNICATIONS INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE TWENTY FIRST CENTURY AND BEYOND RECOGNIZING THAT CONNECTIVITY IS ESSENTIAL. EVERYONE SHOULD HAVE ACCESS. THIS IS THE CORE URBAN SERVICE AND WE NEED IT TO FUTURE PROOF OUR CITY BASED ON THE AMOUNT OF TRANSFORMATION HAPPENING AROUND US IN THE BEGINNING OF THE YEAR WE REFINED OUR GUIDING PRINCIPLES TO THIS PROGRAM AND THE FIRST IS CITY WIDE ACCESS TO EQUITABLE AND INCLUSIVE FUTURE ORIENTED A COMPETITIVE MARKETPLACE. NET NEUTRALITY IN AN OPEN ACCESS SO THESE ARE THE CORE TENANTS OF THE WORK THAT WE'VE BEEN DOING AND WHY WE WILL PURSUE A BROADBAND BACKBONE FOR

[126:01] THE CITY JUST A REFRESHER ON OUR PROJECT TIMELINE WE HAVE BEEN WORKING AT THIS FOR A FEW YEARS AND BEGAN WITH FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS AND TWENTY SIXTEEN. WE REVIEWED WITH COUNCIL OF TECHNICAL ANALYSIS EARLIER THIS YEAR ALONG WITH OPTIONS. MEN ARE MOVING NOW INTO PHASE THREE WHICH IS THE SELECTION OF AN OPTION IN DISCUSSION ON THAT OPTION. OUR NEXT STEPS WILL BE THERE TO PREPARE A BALLOT ITEM OR PREPARE THE MECHANISMS FOR FUNDING THE BACKBONE BASED ON YOUR RECOMMENDATION THIS EVENING AS A REMINDER. OPTION TWO IS WHAT CAME OUT OF OUR MAY STUDY SESSION IN TERMS OF THE GUIDING GETTING DIRECTION FROM COUNCIL THE BACKBONE IS CORE INFRASTRUCTURE THAT IS IN CONCENTRIC CIRCLES AROUND THE CITY BASED ON THE MAP THE CIA TO BREAK THE BACKBONE IS ESSENTIAL IF A STRUCTURE TO ANY FUTURE BROADBAND OR INTERNET SERVICE IN THE CITY

[127:01] IT ALSO IS NOT FIBER TO THE HOME OR FIBER TO THE PREMISE WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT COUNCIL IS CLEAR THAT THAT'S NOT THE OPTIONS ARE CONSIDERING AT THIS TIME THOUGH THE BACKBONE IS NECESSARY TO GET TO THOSE OPTIONS IN THE FUTURE BENEFITS OF A BACKBONE. IN ADDITION TO SERVE SMART CITY SCHOOLS LAKE WORK WE CAN DO IN OUR UTILITIES FACILITIES FOR SAFETY TRANSPORTATION AND PARKS AND REC. WE BELIEVE THAT THIS IS FUTURE PROOF OR MUNICIPAL INFRASTRUCTURE SO WE NEED THIS TO BE ABLE TO KEEP PACE WITH THE CHANGE OF MUNICIPAL MANAGEMENT AND ALSO ALLOWS US FLEXIBILITY IN THE FUTURE BASED ON CHANGES THAT ARE HAPPENING IN THE NETWORKING AND TELECOMMUNICATIONS WORLD AND IN THE COMMUNITIES AROUND US AS WELL AS THAT THIS ENABLES THE FEW FIRST STEP IN ACHIEVING OUR GUIDING PRINCIPLES ARE CALLS FOR THIS PROJECT TURNED OVER TO CHRIS THANKS TO LEAH. SO IN MAY

[128:00] STUDY SESSION THEN WE HAD ONE OF THE QUESTIONS THAT CAME UP AND PART OF OUR CONVERSATION WAS RELATED TO JOINT CONSTRUCTION WITH ANY FUTURE POTENTIAL MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC UTILITY SEPARATION CONSTRUCTION WORK AND WE STARTED TO TALK ABOUT MAYBE THERE COULD BE SOME JOINT BORING WHICH THE GRAPHIC IN THE MIDDLE OF THE SCREEN IS KIND OF A SECTION CUT IF YOU WERE TO LOOK UNDER THE GROUND JOINT BORING IS WHERE YOU PUT TWO PIECES OF CONDUIT THOSE ARE THE LITTLE CIRCLES IN THE MIDDLE OF THE DIAGRAM TOGETHER AND YOU PUT THEM IN ONE BORE HOLE SO THE PHOTOGRAPH ON THE LEFT HAND SIDE SHOWS TWO PIECES OF CONDUIT THAT WERE BORED AND ONE HOLE AND THE IDEA WAS THAT CREATES INEFFICIENCIES IN CONSTRUCTION. WE DID SOME ANALYSIS OF THE COST OF WHAT IT WOULD BE IF WE WERE TO DO JOINT CONSTRUCTION WHEREVER A BROADBAND BACKBONE AND SEPARATION CONSTRUCTION WOULD OCCUR IN THE SAME PLACE ON IT'S ABOUT FOUR POINT SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS OF ADDITIONAL COST ON ADDITIONAL LEAD IN

[129:01] SPEAKING WITH EXCEL ENERGY FOR ANY OF THE ELECTRIC ON FACILITIES THAT THEY WOULD ON OWN AFTER SEPARATION. THEY WOULD REQUIRE A MINIMUM OF TWELVE INCHES OF SEPARATION WHICH IS WHAT THE GRAPHIC ON THE VERY RIGHT HAND SIDE SHOWS WHICH MEANS YOU HAVE TO DO SEPARATE BORING FOR THOSE TOO SO WE'RE NOT SURE THERE'S A LOT OF EFFICIENCIES IN TERMS OF JOINT CONSTRUCTION AT LEAST IN THOSE AREAS THERE MAY BE IN AREAS WHERE WE WOULD OWN INFRASTRUCTURE SO WE WANT TO JUST CLOSE THE LOOP ON THAT ONE ITEM ON THAT OR THERE MAY BE SOME OPPORTUNITIES BUT NOT MAYBE THE ENTIRE OPPORTUNITIES THAT WE SAW BEFORE. SO THAT'S ON JOINT CONSTRUCTION NOW I'M GOING TO DO IS WALK THROUGH SOME OF THE FINANCING OPTIONS AND WHAT I MIGHT DO IS TRY TO WALK THROUGH EACH OF THEM AND THEN IF THERE'S SOME QUESTIONS ALL PROBABLY HAVE CHERYL TALLEY OR CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER COME UP AND JOIN US APPEAR TO HELP ANSWER SOME QUESTIONS BUT WE'VE LAID OUT FOR DIFFERENT APPROACHES FOR FINANCING THIS BROADBAND

[130:01] BACKBONE TWO OF WHICH WOULD NOT REQUIRE A VOTE AND TWO OF WHICH WOULD REQUIRE A VOTE ON THOSE TWO THAT WOULD NOT. OUR CASH FINANCE AND CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION WITH EXISTING REVENUE AND THEN THE TWO THAT WOULD REQUIRE A VOTE WOULD BE A LONG TERM BOND WITH EXISTING REVENUE OR A SHORT TERM NOTE WITH NEW REVENUES SO I WALK TO REACH THOSE HERE REAL QUICK CASH FINANCE APPROACH IS ESSENTIALLY WHERE WE WOULD IN ONE YEAR OR IN TWO YEARS TAKE EXISTING CASH AND FINANCE THE CONSTRUCTION AND ON. IN HONOR OF A KIND OF THE FULL SPECTRUM OF OPTIONS WE PUT THIS ONE OUT THERE ON WE DON'T SEE A FEASIBLE REVENUE SOURCE FOR THIS OPTION WE DON'T HAVE THIS SORT OF ACCESS RESOURCES TO FUND THIS APPROACH BUT ON IF WE WERE TO TRY AND DO THAT WE WOULD HAVE TO EITHER ELIMINATE OR ON MAKE SIGNIFICANT REDUCTIONS TO CURRENT SERVICES TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE IT SO WE DON'T SEE THIS IS A VIABLE

[131:01] OPTION. THE NEXT OPTION IS CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION AND EXISTING REVENUE SO CERTAIN CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION ARE BACKED BY COLLATERAL ON THE CITY ON SUCH AS BUILDINGS AND THEN WE WOULD USE THOSE CERTIFICATES ON TO ISSUE MORE BE THE DEBT THAT THEN WE WOULD REPAY OVER TWENTY YEARS AND SO THAT'S ROUGHLY ONE POINT ONE MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR FOR THE NEXT TWENTY YEARS IS WHAT WE WOULD NEED IN TERMS OF PAYMENTS SO WE ANTICIPATE THAT MOST LIKELY REVENUE SOURCE FOR THAT IS THE GENERAL FUND SOME OF THE BENEFITS OF CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION ARE THAT THEY CAN BE ISSUED AT ANY TIME DURING THE YEAR SO THAT GIVES US SOME FLEXIBILITY OF EXACTLY WHEN WE WOULD DO THAT IT WOULD REQUIRE IN TERMS OF ON SOME OF THE CONS A RE ALLOCATION OF THE EXISTING BUDGET AND TO BE ABLE TO ESSENTIALLY FIND THE FUNDING TO BE ABLE TO

[132:00] FIND THOSE ANNUAL PAYMENTS ON AND THEN ADDITIONALLY IT WOULD REMOVE SOME ADDITIONAL COLLATERAL IF WE WANT TO SAVE THAT AND USE THAT FOR OTHER CITY PROJECTS FOR CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION BUT THE DECISION MAKING ON THIS APPROACH WOULD BE AT THE COUNCIL LEVEL NO BALLOT ITEM WOULD BE REQUIRED. CHRIS COOK QUESTION IS THE ARMY IS JUST COMING OUT OF NEW CAPITAL FUND IN THE GENERAL FUND POTENTIALLY COULD CURB YEAH IT'S HELPFUL I CAN WALK THROUGH THE OTHER TWO HERE REAL QUICK AND THEN MAYBE WE CAN DIVE AND THEN CHERYL CAN ANSWER MORE OF THE DETAILED QUESTIONS I WORK SO THE NEXT APPROACH WOULD BE DOING A LONG TERM BOND BUT STILL USING EXISTING REVENUE SO THE DIFFERENCE IN THIS IS INSTEAD OF USING CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION WE WOULD ISSUE A BOND WHICH DOES REQUIRE VOTER APPROVAL ON WITH TABOR AND SO THIS WOULD BE AN OPTION THAT WE WOULD PRESENT TO THE VOTERS WHERE IT WOULD BE WITHOUT RAISING TAXES CAN THE CITY BORROW ON

[133:01] FINDING BORROW TO TO FIND THE BACKBONE SO IT DOES RETAIN THE FLEXIBILITY OF USING OUR CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION ON FOR FUTURE NEEDS ON BUT AGAIN THIS WOULD REQUIRE A VOTE AND THERE'S OBVIOUSLY A CHANCE THAT THAT WOULD NOT BE APPROVED BY VOTERS IN THE LAST OPTION IS ON DOING A SHORT TERM NOTES ON WITH NEW REVENUE SO THIS IS WHERE THAT WE WOULD PROPOSE A NEW TAX A SHORT TERM TAX SOMEWHERE KIND OF TWO TO FIVE YEARS TO FUND THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE BACKBONE AND THEN WE WOULD JUST BORROW ON A SHORT TERM FUNDING NEEDED. AMEN AND PAY THAT BACK TO BE ABLE TO FUND CONSTRUCTION OF THE BACKBONE AND SO WE'VE LOOKED IN ON DIFFERENT LEVELS IF WE WERE TO DO A POINT TWO FIVE CENT INCREASE FOR TWO YEARS THAT WOULD GIVE US ENOUGH REVENUE TO FUND THE BACKBONE OF FIFTEEN MILLION DOLLARS OR IF WE WERE TO DO FIVE YEARS IT WOULD BE A POINT ONE ONE INCREASE ON TO BE ABLE TO FIND THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE BACK

[134:00] ON AND SO THIS OBVIOUSLY GIVES US THE FLEXIBILITY WHICH WE COULD FUND THE CONSTRUCTION WITHOUT A LONG TERM DEBT ISSUANCE AND ADDITIONALLY IT WOULD BE A NEW REVENUE SOURCE THAT WE WOULD NOT HAVE TO RE ALLOCATE ANY OF THE OTHER FUNDS AND IN THE CIP ON BUT AGAIN THIS WOULD REQUIRE VOTER APPROVAL AND TO GO ON THE BALLOT THIS NOVEMBER SO ALL PAS THERE AND WE CAN ANSWER QUESTIONS ON XANAX FINANCING FROM COMETS APPEAR CHRIS TO CHANNEL IS WHAT THE INCREMENT OF PROPERTY TAX WOULD BE TO FROM THIS AS WELL. WE HAVE LOOKED AT SEWING TO ASK CHERYL TO MAYBE COME UP AND JOIN US APPEAR TO LOOK AT THAT THOUGH SHE'S ON THE OTHER NT PERFECT SORRY WE GO I WE HAVEN'T ACTUALLY DETERMINE THE EXACT MILL AMOUNT BUT IT'S PRETTY COMPARABLE SO ONE MILL OF PROPERTY TAX IS ABOUT THREE POINT SIX MILLION WHEREAS POINT ONE CENT OF SALES TAX

[135:02] IS THREE POINT THREE MILLION SO THEY'RE PRETTY COMPARABLE THEIR HUMILITY BUT THE POINT ONE PERCENT CORRECT TO THE TRIBUNE AND LOOKING AT THIS E APPEASE AN EXISTING REVENUE IT WE WOULD NEED TO REQUIRE REAL RE ALLOCATION OF EXISTING BUDGET IN REDUCTIONS TO CURRENT SERVICE LEVELS HAVE YOU LOOKED AT WHAT THOSE MIGHT BE DO WE HAVE THE ROOM FOR THOSE BECAUSE THE FIRST OPTION WHERE WITH NO BALLOT ITEM WOULD BE REQUIRED IS NOT VIABLE RACE THAT'S HALF A TABLE SIZZLING NON BALLAD VIABLE OPTION BECAUSE IT REALLY VIABLE YOUR MIND GIVEN THESE RE ALLOCATIONS SO EVIL TO A COUPLE DIFFERENT FUNDING SOURCES IN THE FIRST WOULD BE THE GENERAL FUND CAPITAL WHICH THIS YEAR WAS ABOUT THREE POINT SIX MILLION AND IF YOU RECALL YOU'VE ALREADY DEDICATED ABOUT SEVEN HUNDRED AND FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS OF

[136:00] THAT FOR THE NEXT FOUR YEARS FOR POLK AND PAN CAST SO THIS ONE POINT ONE MILLION THAT WERE TALKING ABOUT ISSUING FOR TWENTY YEARS WOULD RESTRICT THAT BY ONE POINT ONE MILLION FOR THE NEXT TWENTY YEARS SO THAT WOULD BE ONE SOURCE WE ALSO HAVE OTHER OUTSTANDING ITEMS FOR GENERAL FUND CAPITAL WE HAVE A LOT FROM OUR FACILITY SAID A BACKLOG THEY'RE PRETTY SIGNIFICANT ALSO IN ITE AND THEN OTHER THINGS SUCH AS OP ALPINE BALSAM AND THOSE ITEMS THAT ARE ON THE HORIZON IN THE SECOND ITEM WOULD BE TO REDUCE OR ELIMINATE A PART OF THE OPERATING BUDGET IN THE GENERAL FUND IN WE HAVE NOT DETERMINED WHAT THAT WOULD LOOK LIKE THAT WOULD HAPPEN THROUGH OUR TWO TWENTY NINETEEN BUDGET PROCESS BUT RIGHT NOW AS YOU RECALL WERE ALREADY LOOKING AT ABOUT A FOUR MILLION DOLLARS SHORTFALL BECAUSE OF TAXES SO THAT WOULD BE IN ADDITION TO

[137:03] THAT AND THEN I MEAN WE THERE'S OTHER OPTIONS WE TRANSFER MONEY TO THINGS SUCH AS PARKS OPEN SPACE. THOSE ARE SOME OPTIONS AS WELL ALONG WITH RESERVES BUT WE DEFINITELY DON'T THINK RESERVES IS A VIABLE OPTION OF A BIG REASON IT'S A ONE TIME DOLLAR AMOUNT AND WE'RE AT ABOUT EIGHTEEN PERCENT RIGHT NOW SO WE WOULD NOT WANT TO REDUCE THAT QUESTION I HAVE THREE QUESTIONS ON THIS COST OF CONSTRUCTION WHICH IS IMPORTANT FINANCING IT ASSUMES LITTLE OR NO REVENUE FROM THE NETWORK WE WOULD BUILD IS A CORRECT THAT'S CORRECT. SO WITH THE WAY WE ASSUME THAT WOULD BE THAT WE DON'T BASE ANY POTENTIAL FUTURE REVENUE OF LEASING MANY STRANDS AS WITHIN THE BACKBONE TO GO TOWARDS THE DEBT SERVICE SO WE WERE WE DECIDED WE WANTED TO AND WERE ABLE TO LEASE OR

[138:01] SELL FIBER ALONG THE ROUTES HAVE TO BUILD THEM THAT WOULD BE UPSIDE IN THAT WOULD POTENTIALLY REDUCE THE IMPACT OR YEARS IN A WORST CASE SITUATION HERE WHERE WE SPEND MONEY BUT WE DON'T HAVE MUCH IN THE WAY REVENUES AT RIGHT THAT'S CORRECT. WE'RE ALSO KIND OF MEN SURVEYED OUR PARTNERS WHO WE WORK WITH ON THE NETWORK NOW AND WE SUSPECT THAT THERE COULD BE INTEREST IN USING THAT AS A BACKUP OR REDUNDANCY BUT NOT AS KIND OF MEAN ARTERIAL FOR THOSE ORGANIZATIONS SO WE HAVE A SENSE THAT THERE IS INTEREST POTENTIALLY BUT HAVE KEPT THAT AS A VERY LOW ESTIMATE IN TERMS OF GOOD NEWS MY ANSWER TO THE SCREEN SECOND IS US ON THE PACKET THAT WE ESTIMATE THAT THE DESIGN CONSTRUCTION TIMEFRAME WOULD BE EIGHTEEN TO TWENTY FOUR MONTHS RIGHT SO THIS ELEVEN MILLION DOLLAR OUTLAY WOULD HAPPEN THIS EARLY ALL IN TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN WOULD BE IT WOULD BE OUT LATE OVER A PERIOD OF MAYBE TWO OR THREE YEARS AND THAT IT COULD BE INCURRED AS IT WAS NEEDED SO WOULDN'T NECESSARILY BE ELEVEN MILLION DOLLARS

[139:00] TOMORROW MORNING IT WOULD BE ELEVEN MILLION DOLLARS OVER THE NEXT COUPLE YEARS I WRITE AND THEN FALL QUESTION PRESUMABLY WE WENT DOWN THE ROUTE OF COPD IS INTENDED TO TEST EACH SHOW SUGGESTED AT LEAST INITIALLY INTO THE PRESERVE WHICH POINTED OUT PRESUMABLY AT SOME POINT I WE CAN REFINANCE THAT DEBT WOES WERE NOT LOCKED IN FOR TWENTY YEARS WE DID SEE A PIECE FOR THE FIRST COUPLE OF YEARS TO FINANCE CONSTRUCTION BUT THEN WE DECIDED WE WANTED ROLLED IN AS PART OF OTHER DATA DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT WITH IT. WE ARE WE COMMITTED TO THOSE TWENTY YEARS OR COULD WE REFINANCE OR NOT COMMITTED TO TWENTY YEARS ON FEDERAL GOVERNMENT JUST A WAY WITH ADVANCE RE FINDINGS OF GOVERNMENT SO WE WOULD WANT TO IF THAT WOULD IF THAT'S THE DIRECTION YOU'D WANNA GO WE'D WANT TO STRUCTURE THE DAD WITH AN EARLIER CALL FEATURE IF WE WANTED TO REFINANCE AT A CERTAIN DAY SO THAT'S SOMETHING YOU COULD USE THE FLEXIBILITY THERE YEAH I MEAN IT'S IT'S A LITTLE MORE COSTLY DOING IT

[140:00] WITH THE EARLIER CALL FEATURE BUT WE CERTAINLY COULD DO IT OKAY GREAT THANK YOU INTO QUESTION FROM FOR ANYTHING ELSE ON FINANCING FOR MOVE TOWARD STUNT. WHAT'S NEXT. OK SO ONE OTHER AREA THAT WE TALKED ABOUT IN THE STUDY SESSION IN MAY WAS EXPLORING UNDER SERVED AREAS OR AREAS OF LOW INCOME RESIDENTS THAT MAY NOT HAVE CURRENT MORE ADEQUATE INTERNET SERVICE SO SINCE ON THEM A STUDY SESSION WE'VE HAD CONVERSATIONS WITH THE BOULDER VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT ON BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS AS WELL AS COMCAST AND WHAT WE LEARNED IS ON THERE ARE CERTAIN PROPERTIES THAT HAVE PRETTY DECENT PENETRATION WITH INTERNET SERVICE AND THEN THERE'S OTHER AREAS THAT HAVE VERY LOW OR ZERO INTERNET PENETRATION AND THEN THE OTHER THING WE DID AS WE LOOKED AT AND THIS IS WHAT'S ON THE SCREEN HERE. YES

[141:01] THE LOCATION OF BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS PROPERTIES ARE AFFILIATED PROPERTIES ARE MOBILE HOME PARKS IN RELATION TO THE SCHEMATIC BACKBONE DESIGN AND WHAT'S REALLY INTERESTING IS THE VAST MAJORITY OF THEM ARE ON THE BACKBONE OR VERY CLOSE TO THE BACKBONE SO WE SEE THIS ACTUALLY IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO POTENTIALLY PARTNER WITH SAY BST IN BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS ON TO POTENTIALLY BE ABLE TO HAVE THEM LEAST PART OF THE BACKBONE TO HELP PROVIDE INTERNET SERVICE ON TO THESE LOCATIONS AND THAT WOULD COULD ALSO HELP FILL THE GAP FOR THOSE AREAS WHERE CURRENTLY ON THAT SERVICE PROVISION IS NOT VERY HIGH FOR THOSE PROVIDERS SUI SUI SEE THERE'S POTENTIALLY AN OPPORTUNITY HERE FOR SOME PARTNERING THE CURRENT COST ESTIMATE DOESN'T INCLUDE THE CITY BEING THAT INTERNET PROVIDER SO THIS WOULD BE A PARTNERSHIP WITH ON THOSE EXISTING COMMUNITY PARTNERS THAT WE ALREADY HAVE BUT FOR THEM TO BE ABLE TO UTILIZE THIS NEW CITY INFRASTRUCTURE

[142:02] SUN SO IT'S STILL MORE TO INVESTIGATE HERE FOR SURE BUT IT LOOKS TO BE A PRETTY GOOD OPPORTUNITY BECAUSE QUESTION THAT I HAVE ONE AS WELL AND BOB CHRIS IS THE PACK BACK ON SHOWN HERE IS THAT SOME CURRENT BAR AS WOULD BE BUILT THIS IS AS IT WOULD BE BUILT SO THIS IS THE SCHEMATIC DESIGN THAT ARKANSAS INSTEAD WE WOULD REVISE THIS THROUGH THE DESIGN AND ENGINEERING PROCESS IF WE MOVE FORWARD BUT THIS IS THE SCHEMATIC DESIGN THAT THEY DID WHICH IS THE LINES IN PURPLE ON THE SCREEN AND A FOLLOW UP QUESTIONS WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT IS WHEN THE BACKBONE IS BUILT HOW COULD WE SERVE UNDERSERVED AREAS. CORRECT CORRECT THAT'S THAT WAS THE CONCEPT IN KIND OF THE HYPOTHESIS OR QUESTION THAT WE WE ASKED AS WE WERE LOOKING AT THE DIFFERENT MODELS AND IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT ABOUT SEVEN PERCENT OF CITY RESIDENTS DON'T HAVE INTERNET ACCESS I GUESS THAT IS THAT A

[143:00] LOT OF THAT SEVEN PERCENT WOULD EXIST IN THESE AREAS THAT'S OUR THAT'S OUR ASSUMPTION WHAT WE HEARD IS A STATISTIC OF ABOUT FOUR TO SEVEN PERCENT AND THEN ACTUALLY AS YOU'LL SEE IN THE SURVEY RESULTS THAT'S ONE OF THE QUESTIONS WE ASKED IS WHETHER YOU HAVE INTERNET SERVICE IT WAS A LITTLE LOWER IN THE SURVEY RESULTS ON BUT THAT'S THAT'S ROUGHLY WHAT WE'VE HEARD AND SO WITH THERE'S A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN PROVIDING THE BROADBAND AND JUST PROVIDING INTERNET AND SO WE DIDN'T ASK YOU TO LOOK AT WHAT IT WOULD TAKE TO BE ABLE JUST TO BUY INTERNET ACCESS IS A POST OF BROADBAND ACCESS SO MAYBE WE CAN CONSIDER THAT GOING FORWARD YEAH I THINK THOSE ARE THE THINGS WE COULD CONSIDER AND JULIET CAN CHIME IN HERE TOO BUT DST IS DOING AN INTERESTING PILOT PARTNERSHIP RIGHT NOW WITH TRYING TO THEN USE A WIRELESS IS THE LAST LEG OF GETTING INTERNET SERVICE TO SOME OF THE AREAS THAT ARE NOT SERVED WELL ON TO BE ABLE TO GIVE INTERNET ACCESS FOR STUDENTS SO THERE COULD BE SOME EXPLORATION AND

[144:03] THOSE ARENAS AS WELL. SURE WE ALSO THINK THAT SOME OF THE ADVANCEMENTS IN NETWORK TECHNOLOGY WOULD ALLOW FOR THAT AND SO ONE OF THE THINGS THAT DEVIOUS T IS DOING IS LOOKING AT PARTNERING WITH THE COMPANY THAT DOES OVER THE AIR BROADBAND SO THAT CONNECTS TO YOUR INFRASTRUCTURE AND THEN ALLOWS FOR TRANSMISSION IN THE AIR AND THAT DISTANCE THAT ALLOWS FOR AS A COUPLE OF MILES AND SO ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WERE EXCITED ABOUT IN THIS DESIGN IS THAT THAT COULD ALLOW US TO SERVE S THROUGH A PARTNERSHIP ON MANY OF THE COMMUNITIES THAT WERE INTERESTED AND IN TERMS OF ACCESS. WE'VE ALSO BEEN HAVING CONVERSATIONS WITH COMCAST ABOUT THEIR SERVICE AREAS THEY ARE DOING A LOT TO EXPAND NETWORK INFRASTRUCTURE IN THE METRO REGION AND THEY EXPECT TO COME TO BOULDER TO DO A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF CONSTRUCTION IN THE FUTURE PARTICULARLY IN NINETEEN TWENTY AND SO WE HAVE HAD CONVERSATIONS WITH THEM ABOUT WHAT COMMUNITIES THAT CURRENTLY SERVE IN THE PENETRATION RATES THAN WE DO HAVE A GOOD SENSE THAT

[145:00] ABOUT FIFTY PERCENT OF THE COMMUNITIES REPRESENTED HERE WITH STARS ARE SERVED LESS THAN FIFTY PERCENT OF THE RESIDENTS OF THOSE BUILDINGS OR NEIGHBORHOODS ARE SERVED. CURRENTLY TODAY WITH COMCAST. SO WE DO THINK THAT THERE ARE LEVERS THAT WE COULD POLL EVEN JUST A START TO GET BETTER ACCESS THERE WE ALSO RECOGNIZE THAT AND THAT BECAUSE OF THAT LOW PENETRATION THAT THOSE ARE PROBABLY THE AREAS OF THE CITY THAT HAVE THE LEAST AMOUNT OF ACCESS IN PARTICULAR WE HAVE SOME ADDITIONAL WORK TO DO TO UNDERSTAND THE MANUFACTURED HOME COMMUNITIES IN THE PAST COMCAST HAS HAD A HARD TIME ACCESSING THOSE NEIGHBORHOODS BECAUSE OF DISINTEREST IN HAVING COMCAST ON THEIR LAND AND PROPERTY AND SO THEY ARE COMING BACK TO US WITH MORE INFORMATION ABOUT IF THOSE ARE RECENT OR PAST AND IF ANY CHANGES IN THE CONVERSATIONS WITH THE LANDOWNERS AND THEN YOU KNOW THE CITY COULD POTENTIALLY PARTNER ON THAT SOME LOTS OF OPTIONS THERE

[146:01] ANGUS JUST EXPAND ON THAT QUESTION IS THE TWO FOR THE THESE BJP PARTIES OR THEY'RE GOING TO BE OF A VARIETY OF DIFFERENT TYPES RATING AND HAVE APARTMENT BUILDINGS. YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO PACK SAYS THINGS LIKE THAT AND SO USE IT TO BE FAIR STATEMENT TO SAY WOULD HAVE TO IF WE WANT TO CONNECT THESE COMMUNITIES WOULD HAVE TO HAVE A CERTAIN PER COMMUNITY STRATEGY ABOUT HOW TO ACTUALLY GET INTERNET ACCESS TO FOX REALLY FALLEN FOR MARY'S QUESTION RIGHT YOU CAN GET A FIBER LINE TO THAT PROMISE BUT THAT DOESN'T FINISH THE JOB WRITES THAT EXACTLY. WE NEED SOME ADDITIONAL ANALYSIS AND MAYBE IN SOME PLACE TO GET WIRED EVERY HOUSE MAYBE ANOTHER SHE NEED SOME WIRELESS TO FINISH I THINK ABOUT FOR EXAMPLE THE MOBILE HOME COMMUNITIES WOULD BE TOUGH TO GET A WIRED EVERY HOME. RIGHT SO THEN MAYBE WIRELESS IS THE FAIR STATEMENT SUED WOULD REQUIRE EXPLORATION OF THESE UP BOTH AN OVERARCHING STRATEGY SO WHERE DO WE GO FIRST AND HOW WE PRIORITIZE AND THEN FUNDING STRATEGY AND AN IMPLEMENTATION PLAN SO A LOT OF WORK TO BE DONE THERE THIS IS JUST THE FIRST SENSE OF

[147:00] WE'RE NOT THAT FAR FROM A LOT OF THE COMMUNITIES WITH A GREAT THANK YOU FOR SO I'M HAPPY TO SEE THAT WE DON'T SELL ASSISTS AND THAT THE FIRST COMMUNITIES THAT WE MIGHT SERVE WOULD BE TO BRIDGE THE DIGITAL DEVICES ONE OF THE BIGGEST DRIVERS OF THIS PROJECT IN ADDRESSING THE FORTY SEVEN PERCENT THE MERRIER FOR TWO. THANK YOU FOR DOING ANALYSIS AND I'M HAPPY TO SEE THAT IT WORKED. TURNS OUT THAT WE'RE GOING WE'RE PASSING BY SOME OF THE COMMITTEES THAT WE NEED IS HER FIRST TO THIS BUT THIS A QUESTION. WE TALKED EARLIER ABOUT THE POTENTIAL THIS IS KIND OF A WORST CASE SITUATION OF THE FINANCING DOESN'T ASSUME MUCH OR ANY REVENUE FROM CARRIERS LIKE YOU KNOW EIGHTEEN TEE OR EISNER CENTRAL ANCHOR COMCAST WOULD EVER THINK THAT EVEN THOUGH SOME OF THE SOME COMMUNITIES MAY BE SERVED AT A DISCOUNTED RATE ON THERE STILL IS A SOURCE OF REVENUE HERE PBS THE BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS AND EVEN EVEN IF THAT IS KIND OF RESOURCE REVENUES OF THIS VIA A SECOND POTENTIAL SOURCE OF REVENUE OFFSET THE LOVE MILLION DOLLARS IF WE START GOING

[148:00] DOWN THIS PATH INITIALLY BEFORE WE DO THE FULL TIME CITY WOULD BUILD UP IS THAT CORRECT. THAT'S THAT'S POSSIBLE AND DO REMEMBER THAT BST HAS THEIR OWN BACKBONE AND SAID THE ISSUE HERE IS FIBER TO THE PREMISE VERSES THAT BACK IN TO SEARCH OR SO CERTAINLY AN OPTION IN THE CONVERSATIONS I'VE HAD WITH THEIR CIO YOU KNOW IS UNLIKELY TO BE BIASED IS GOING TO GENERATE REVENUE FOR US SO I WANT TO BE CLEAR ON THAT BUT IT IS A POTENTIAL FOR YOU KNOW IF WE DO ON A CHARGE A SMALL AMOUNT OR YOU KNOW AN INCIDENTAL AMOUNT CERTAINLY GENERATE REVENUE THAT WE THINK OF AS IMPORTANT AS WHAT ABOUT FIFTEEN HUNDRED UNITS OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT SO HE WAS AT SIXTEEN HUNDRED NOW WE'VE LOOKED AT ABOUT THIRTY PROPERTIES INCLUSIVE OF MANUFACTURED HOMES AND THE HP PROPERTIES THAT ARE THE NEIGHBORHOODS ARE SOME NEIGHBORHOODS ACT LIKE GROWNUPS AND IT'S VERY EXPENSIVE THE CONVERSATIONS WITH BB AT BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS IS THAT CURRENTLY

[149:00] IT'S VERY EXPENSIVE FOR THEM TO BE PROVIDING INTERNET AND SO THEY'VE BEEN HAVING CONVERSATIONS WITH COMCAST ABOUT THEIR SUBSIDY PROGRAM THERE ARE THINGS ABOUT THE PROGRAM THAT MAKE IT VERY DIFFICULT FOR RESIDENTS TO GO AND SOURCE REVENUE WHAT WE MAY JUST COUNTED IT STILL IS TO LOOK IN HIS RED NOSE BP IS PAYING THIS MUCH AND IT MIGHT BE DELIGHTED TO PAY THIS MUCH AND THAT MUCH TO STILL MULTIPLY CROSS SIXTEEN HUNDRED HOUSEHOLDS A LOT OF MONEY AND THEN I THINK THE OTHER THING TO THINK ABOUT WITH ANY POTENTIAL REVENUE IS THAT THAT REVENUE COULD ALSO POTENTIALLY BE USED TO HELP SUPPORT THE ONGOING OPERATING COSTS WILL BE ADDITIONAL OPERATING AND MAINTENANCE COSTS THAT WOULD THAT THE CITY WOULD NEED TO PAY PROBABLY STARTING IN TWENTY TWENTY AND SO IT MAY BE THAT THOSE ONGOING LEASE REVENUES COULD HELP SUPPORT THE ONGOING OWEN AM OF THE FIBER BACKBONE MOVE ON OK SO WITH THAT WHAT I'M GOING TO DO IS ACTUALLY TURN THE PRESENTATION OVER TO TOM MILLER FROM THE NATIONAL RESEARCH CENTER. THEY ARE THE CONSULTANT WE HIRED TO CONDUCT A STATISTICALLY VALID

[150:01] SURVEY AND WE WERE SQUEEZING THE SAND BETWEEN THEM A STUDY SESSION AND THIS COUNCIL MEETING SO I THINK THEY ARE LEAST FINISHED MAKING PHONE CALLS LIKE FIVE DAYS AGO AND SO WE HAVE THE PRELIMINARY RESULTS ON THE PRESENTATION FORMAT TODAY. NORMALLY AS YOU FAMILIAR WITH WE GET A VERY DETAILED WRITTEN REPORT OF ALL THE DATA TABLES THAT REPORT IS COMING AND SO WE WILL SEND THAT OUT WHEN THAT COMES OUT BUT WE WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE HAD THE INFORMATION FOR THIS COUNCIL MEETING ON THE SO ON TOM'S GOING TO GO OVER THAT INFO AND THEN WILL SEND A MORE DETAILED REPORTS OUT JUST SO EVERYONE HAS THEM. WE ALSO DINED ON A COPY OF THIS SAME SURVEY ONLINE AND FOR ANYONE TO TAKE AND SO THAT WE HAVE THE RESULTS OF THAT IT'S ACTUALLY REALLY INTERESTING AS OUR ONLINE RESULT ARE VERY SIMILAR TO THE RESULTS FROM THE STATISTICALLY VALID PHONE SURVEY SO I WILL SEND OUT BOTH OF THOSE SO WITH THAT I WILL TURN IT OVER TO TOM THANK YOU CHRIS A PLEASURE TO BE HERE. COUNCIL MEMBERS AND

[151:01] STAFF. I FOUNDED NATIONAL RESEARCH CENTER TWENTY FOUR YEARS AGO IN BOULDER COLORADO AND WE NOW WORK ALL ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND I'M VERY PLEASED TO BE ABLE TO WORK BACK HOME. ALSO AS I GO THROUGH THIS IT AS CHRIS SAID THIS IS REALLY HOT OFF THE PRESS KINDS OF INFORMATION BUT PLEASE FEEL FREE TO ASK QUESTIONS AND INTERRUPTIONS. WE DID THIS SURVEY BY TELEPHONE OVER TWO WEEK PERIOD STARTING IN THE LAST WEEK OF MAY IN THE FIRST WEEK OF JUNE WE DIDN'T GET TO SURVEY DURING THE MEMORIAL DAY WEEKEND BUT WE DID GET FOUR HUNDRED RESIDENTS OUT SPLIT THE WAY YOU SEE IN TERMS OF THOSE WHO ARE REGISTERED VOTERS AND THOSE WHO WE GOT THROUGH OTHER MEANS RANDOM DIGIT DIALING THAT INCLUDED FOLKS FROM THE CELL PHONES AND LANDLINES WHAT WE ASK THEM HAD TO DO WITH THREE MAIN CATEGORIES ONE IS WHAT THEIR CURRENT SERVICES AND

[152:02] THE OTHERS THEIR LIKELIHOOD OF BUYING SERVICE FROM THE CITY SHOULD YOU ACTUALLY GET INTO THIS BUSINESS AND THIRD IS WHETHER OR NOT AT THE EXTENT TO WHICH FOLKS WOULD BE WILLING TO SUPPORT THE BACKBONE BUILD OUT SO THAT'S WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT THIS EVENING. THINK OF JUST SUCCESSFULLY GONE THROUGH A NUMBER OF THESE QUIET. WELL OK SO NOW WE'RE LOOKING AT THE STATUS AND AS YOU'VE ALREADY HEARD THERE'S ONLY IT LEASED FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THESE FOLKS WHO WE TALK TO ABOUT TWO PERCENTAGE OF FOLKS HAVE NO INTERNET AT ALL YOU CAN SEE THAT KIND OF MIDWAY DOWN THAT THAT BAR AND THEN THE OTHERS HAVE THESE VARIETIES OF BROADBAND ALREADY COMING INTO THEIR HOUSE SO NINETY THREE PERCENT OF OLDER RESIDENTS HAVE A BROADBAND SERVICE IN ABOUT TWO THIRDS OF HOUSEHOLDS

[153:01] SUBSCRIBED TO CABLE OR SATELLITE TV AS WELL ABOUT SIX AND TEN. YOU CAN SEE IN THE PIE CHART AT THE BOTTOM ALSO HAVE SATELLITE CABLE WITH THEIR INTERNET AND ABOUT A THIRD JUST HAVE THE INTERNET WITHOUT THE TV BUT HAMMER FOLK SUPPORT BUYING THEIR SERVICE WITH BUNDLING AND THIS IS THE KIND OF BUMBLING THAT FOLKS HAVE IT'S MOSTLY TV AND A LANDLINE PHONE ALONG WITH THEIR INTERNET THERE SOME CELL SERVICE AND HOME SECURITY IS WELL AND THOSE WE DON'T HAVE A SLIDE ON THIS BUT THE COSTS FOR THE BUMPING WAS ABOUT ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY SIX DOLLARS A MONTH FOR THE MEDIAN PAYOUT ACCORDING TO THE FOLKS THAT WE SURVEYED

[154:01] AND WHEN WE ASK THEM HOW MUCH TO THE INTERNET ALONE COST AND WE NEED TO GO BACK AND TALK TO THEM A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT THAT HALF OF THEM DIDN'T REALLY KNOW WHAT JUSTIN ARE NEXT TO US. NOW THE NEXT SET OF QUESTIONS HAS TO DO WITH SUPPORTING OR OPPOSING AND THE CITY BECOMING A PROVIDER AND YOU CAN SEE THAT THERE'S VAST MAJORITY OF FOLKS NINE IN TEN WHO SUPPORT THE CITY BEING INVOLVED IN THE HIGH SPEED INTERNET SERVICE. WE DIDN'T DEFINE HIGH SPEED BUT WE LEFT IT JUST AS YOU CAN SEE THERE SO TWO THIRDS OF RESIDENTS SAID THAT THEY BE VERY LIKELY TO PURCHASE SOMETHING FROM THE CITY IN THE AREA OF HIGH SPEED INTERNET AT THAT VERY LIKELY SOMEWHAT LIKELY IS ONCE AGAIN IT'S NINE AND TEN HOWEVER POINT OUT THAT THERE ARE SOME DIFFERENCES BY INCOME AS YOU CAN IMAGINE SO

[155:00] THE LOWER INCOME FOLKS WERE NOT QUITE IS HIGHER PERCENT SAYING THAT THEY WOULD BE LIKELY TO BUY BUT NEVERTHELESS MAJORITY OF EVERY INCOME GROUP SAID THAT THEY WOULD BE AT LEAST SOMEWHAT LIKELY TO PURCHASE THE HIGH SPEED TURN THIS SO MORE THAN HALF OF THEM SAID THAT THEY WOULD BE WILLING TO PAY SEVEN DOLLARS OR MORE PER MONTH FOR THIS SERVICE YOU CAN ADD UP THOSE THREE BARS AT THE BOTTOM TO ABOUT FIFTY FIVE PERCENT INTO STILLNESS SPECIFY THE SPEED OF THE SERVICE WAS QUICK WE DID NOT EVEN AT HIGH SPEED AND THIS ALSO AS YOU CAN IMAGINE VARIED SOME BY THE INCOME WITH HIGHER INCOME FOLKS BEING WILLING TO PAY MORE WHEN WE ASKED ABOUT THEIR INTEREST AND BUMBLING ABOUT HALF WERE NOT SO INTERESTED

[156:00] IN BOWLING AND THEN ANOTHER TWENTY PERCENT SAID THAT THEY WOULD BE THIRTY PERCENT SAID MAYBE IT DEPENDS. SO THERE'S A LOT MORE INFORMATION THAT FOLKS WOULDN'T WANT TO HAVE OF COURSE THE COST OF BUMBLING WOULD PROBABLY DEPEND ON WHAT COMPETITIVE BUNDLING SERVICES MIGHT BE AND THOSE KINDS OF THINGS HERE ARE THINGS THAT WE HAVE NOT TROUBLE THESE RESPONDENTS WITH AT THIS POINT LET ME ASK YOU FOLKS WOULD BE INTERESTED IN HAVING THE CITY HELP LOWER INCOME IN THE UNDERSERVED FOLKS TO VOTE ONCE AGAIN THE VAST MAJORITY WERE WILLING TO HELP AND WE DID NOT SAY HOW MUCH THAT WOULD COST BUT THE PRINCIPLE IS VERY CLEAR THERE THAT THERE WAS VERY LITTLE OPPOSITION TO THE IDEA NOW TO THE SUPPORT OF THE BACKBONE ITSELF AGAIN WE HAVE A VERY HIGH PERCENTAGE OF FOLKS WHO ARE

[157:01] INTERESTED IN SUPPORTING FUNDS TO BE USED FOR THE BILL THAT WE TOLD HIM ABOUT FIFTEEN MILLION DOLLARS THAT MORE WOULD BE NEEDED FOR THE FINAL CONNECTIONS THERE ARE A NUMBER WHO WERE INSURED SAID IT DEPENDED BUT ONCE AGAIN THE VAST MAJORITY SUPPORTED THIS KIND OF EXPENDITURE. THEN HE ASKED ABOUT WAYS THAT FOLKS MIGHT BE ASKED TO HELP FUND THAT BACKBONE EXPENDITURE AND WE GAVE THEM TWO DIFFERENT TAXING SALES TAX OPTIONS ONE WAS THE THIRTY FOUR CENTS ON HUNDRED DOLLARS OVER A TWO YEAR PERIOD THE OTHER WAS FIFTEEN CENTS PER HUNDRED DOLLARS OVER FIVE YEAR PERIOD AND NEITHER SEEMED TO MAKE MUCH OF A DIFFERENCE THAT IS THAT THE DIFFERENCE IN THE COST WASN'T REALLY REFLECTED MUCH IN DIFFERENT RESPONSES SO FOLKS WERE ONCE AGAIN QUITE WILLING TO HAVE THAT KIND OF EXPENDITURE TIME

[158:04] TO INTERRUPT YOU THERE. WE MOVE OFF THE SIDE OF HIS CAR HEADED TO MIAMI BECAME FROM YOUR COLLEAGUE BOB DRAKE WHO HAS THIS SUGGESTS THAT YOU WANT TO BE IN THE LOW TO MID SIXTIES ON A TAX MEASURE BEFORE YOU LAUNCH IT BUT I DON'T REMEMBER OF WHAT FOR STUDY WITH AND SECONDLY IS AT THE VERY LIKELY IN SOME UNLIKELY WOULD YOU NEED TO BE IN THE SIXTIES ON VERY LIKELY TOBE LAUNCH A TV AND HAVE A GOOD CHANCE THAT THIS IS A GREAT QUESTION AND WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT THAT A LITTLE BIT AND I HAVE A FEW CRAPPY AND SO YOU DIDN'T INTERRUPT THIS IS ACTUALLY THE LESS LIGHT SNOW IN GENERAL WHEN WE ASK ABOUT THE LIKELIHOOD OF A VOTE. IT'S ALWAYS NICE. AND THAT'S THAT WASN'T THE INTENTION HERE SO WE DIDN'T GET QUITE A BIT NICE TO HAVE A VERY UNLIKELY SOMEWHAT UNLIKELY VERY UNLIKELY OR STRONG LEAST SUPPORT OR STRONGLY OPPOSE AND WHEN YOU TAKE A LOOK AT THE POLARITY SIT CAN BE MORE ILLUMINATING THAN JUST

[159:00] LOOKING AT THESE VERY LIKELY ISN'T SOMEONE LIKE THESE BUT ABOUT WHO I RESPECT GREATLY I THINK HE'S RIGHT TO SAY THAT THAT'S NOT A BAD RULE OF THUMB I THINK IN GENERAL WHEN YOU LOOK AT THOSE BAVARIAN SOMEONE LIKE THESE BEING THIS HIGH IT COULD GET FOR ONE VERY STRONG SENSE OF CONFIDENCE ABOUT HOW THIS FOLK AGO SO I JUST WANT TO THROW A LITTLE BIT OF COLD WATER ON THAT AND THAT IS THAT AT THIS MOMENT TO YOU KNOW WE HAVE SEVERAL MONTHS BEFORE AN ELECTION DON'T KNOW WHAT IT'S GOING TO HAPPEN NONE OF US KNOWS WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN TO INFLUENCE ONE WAY OR THE OTHER HAS BEEN NO COMM NO OPPOSITION. THAT'S SHOWN UP THAT COULD MAKE VOTERS THINK TWICE ABOUT WHETHER THEY WOULD SUPPORT THIS A LOT OF PEOPLE WERE TALKING ABOUT IN TERMS OF LIKELIHOOD SWITCHING TO THE CITY HAD TO DO WITH

[160:01] FASTER SPEEDS AND LOWER COST AND WE DON'T KNOWS WHERE COMPETITORS ARE GOING TO OFFER SO THAT KIND OF COMPETITION IN THIS PARTICULAR MARKET I THINK WOULD HAVE AN INFLUENCE ON WHAT PEOPLE THINK I'M MOST PEOPLE WHEN SAYING THEY WANTED TO SWITCH TO THE CITY BECAUSE THEY PREFER THE CITY TO PROVIDE THE SERVICE THAT WAS ABOUT TEN PERCENT OF FOLKS AND TONY PRO TEN PERCENT WERE DISSATISFIED WITH THEIR CURRENT PROVIDER SO YOU HAVE FOR THE MAJORITY OF FOLKS SAYING THAT THEY WANT CHEAPER FASTER SERVICE I THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT FOR US TO REMEMBER AND THAT'S IT FOR MY MICHAEL WATER COULD WELL USE MY FOCUS IS THE BACKBONE OF COURSE DOESN'T GET INTERNET TO MOST PEOPLE'S HOMES RIGHT HOPEFULLY SOME OF THE LOWER INCOME UNDER SURFACE BUT TO

[161:00] MOST PEOPLE'S HOMES. HOW CLEAR WAS THAT MADE WHEN YOU ARE ASKING THE QUESTION ABOUT THE PEOPLE WILLING TO SUPPORT THE VOTE THAT SAY HEY THIS IS STAGE ONE CAN GET INTERNET FROM THIS STAGE STILL UP FOR IT. IT WAS NOT PERFECTLY CLEAR I THINK THOUGH THAT ONE OF THE QUESTION SAID THAT THEY WOULD BE MORE MONEY NEEDED BESIDES THE MONEY FOR JUST THE BACKBONE. WE DIDN'T SAY HOW MUCH WE DIDN'T SEE WHAT THAT MEANS TO YOU PERSONALLY AND I THINK WITH REGARD TO THEIR COUNCIL MEMBER BRACKET THAT IN GENERAL THIS IS A VERY PRELIMINARY KIND OF SURVEY ONE TO JUST GET A SENSE OF ITS ERA LOT OF OPPOSITION TO THIS ITS ARE A LOT OF SUPPORT FOR THIS AT THIS MOMENT UNDER THESE CONDITIONS AND I THINK THE ANSWERS UNEQUIVOCALLY YES. AT THIS MOMENT UNDER THESE CONDITIONS THANK YOU TO MY QUESTIONS ARE MUCH IN THAT VEIN IT MORE I WAS THE MORON WHERE YOU COMMUNICATING THE TIME FRAME AT ALL WITH THEM BUT WOULD

[162:00] YOU SUPPORT A TAX IF YOU KNEW YOU'RE GOING TO GET AND TWENTY TWENTY FIVE OR SOMETHING WELL WE TALKED ABOUT THE LENGTH OF TIME FOR THE PAYOFF AND THE SALES TAX BUT WE DIDN'T TALK ABOUT WHEN WILL THIS ACTUALLY GET INTO YOUR HOUSE. YES AND THEN OF ANY SORT OF ANSWER THIS IF YOU COULD JUST SAY IT ONE MORE TIME WITH SOMEWHAT LIKE LEE'S WHAT PERCENTAGE OF THEM TYPICALLY VOTE IN THE POT IN THE AFFIRMATIVE AT THEM I COULD SAY UNEQUIVOCALLY THAT IT DEPENDS AND SO MUCH OF IT DEPENDS ON HOW CAMPAIGN ROLLS OUT WHAT THE CIRCUMSTANCES ARE IN THE COST IN THE DETAILS IF THERE'S AN OPPOSITION OR NOT BUT I THINK IT WOULD BE MANY MANY FEWER THAN THOSE WHO SAY VERY LIKELY THINK THAT'S IT FOR ME

[163:00] TO PREACH. OK SO MUCH THANK YOU OK CORRAL AT TOM HAD OUT SO MAKING SURE THE LAST QUESTIONS. ANYONE WITH THAT ANYONE WE JUST GOT A COUPLE OF THE LAST CHI NEXT STEP QUESTIONS BEFORE WE FINISH THE PRESENTATION. SO IF COUNCIL GIVES US DIRECTION OF US ON THE BACK BONE. THEN WE WOULD INITIATE AN RFP FOR DESIGN AND ENGINEERING. WE WOULD MOST LIKELY BRING FOR A REIMBURSEMENT RESOLUTION SO THAT ANY UPFRONT EXPENSES FOR DESIGN AND ENGINEERING COULD BE REIMBURSED ONCE ON THE DEBT IS ISSUED OR OR COPD ARE ISSUED ON THAT WOULD REQUIRE AN ADJUSTMENT TO THE BASE FOR US TO BE ABLE TO COMMENCE IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN AND THEN CONSTRUCTION OF A BACKBONE WOULD BE ADDED INTO THE TWENTY NINETEEN ON AND FORWARD CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS PROGRAM RELATED TO THE FUNDING THIS COUNCIL GIVES US DIRECTION TONIGHT TO PROCEED ON WITH FINDING THAT REQUIRES A BALLOT MEASURE WILL GO AND WORK ON PREPARING

[164:01] ORDINANCES FOR COUNCIL CONSIDERATION ON THE JULY AUGUST AND IF WE GET DIRECTION TONIGHT TO PROCEED WITH FUNDING THAT DOES NOT REQUIRE A BALLOT MEASURE WILL THEN WORK TO IDENTIFY THE SOURCES OF FUNDING THROUGH THE TWENTY NINETEEN BUDGET PROCESS AND THEN WORK TO PREPARE THOSE CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION. SO WITH THAT JUST TO FINISH BACK ON THE STAFF RECOMMENDATION IS TO PROCEED WITH A BACKBONE AND THEN WITH THE FINANCING APPROACH TO YOUR RECOMMENDATION. SO WITH OUR HANDS HAPPY TO ANSWER MORE QUESTIONS. SO ONE OF IT CONCERNS HAS BEEN HOW MUCH CAPACITY THERE IS FOR SEO PEAS IN THE CITY AND SO WE HAVE ANY UPDATE ON THAT LIKE WHERE ARE WE NOW ARE REALLY CLOSE TO TAPPED OUT WHAT'S THE STATUS ABOUT THAT. WE DO HAVE CAPACITY RIGHT NOW SO

[165:02] GLAD OF WHAT WE USE IT WAS WITH THE HOSPITAL PURCHASED BACK IN TWENTY FIFTEEN VIEWS WEEK LATTER USED THREE BUILDINGS AS COLLATERAL AND WE ALSO HAVE A PARKING GARAGE OUT THERE RIGHT NOW FOR SOME OF OUR TWENTY TWO WHILE DAD WE ALSO JUST AS A REMINDER I WE DECIDED WE ARE GOING TO USE SEO PEAS IF AND WHEN THE UNIVERSITY HILL HOTEL PARKING PROJECT GOES THROUGH SO FOR THAT PROJECT A LOT OF THE COLLATERAL WOULD BE THE PARKING GARAGE ITSELF BUT NOT ALL OF THE COLLATERAL SO WE WOULD NEED TO ON TO DECIDE ON ANOTHER BUILDING TO USE FOR COLLATERAL SO CERTAINLY WE HAVE A LOT MORE BUILDINGS OUT THERE HOWEVER YOU KNOW SOMETIMES THERE ARE CERTAIN TYPES OF BUILDINGS THAT MAY OR MAY NOT YOU MAY OR MAY NOT WANT TO USE AS COLLATERAL FOR POLITICAL REASONS OR OTHER REASONS SO THAT'S SOMETHING TO CONSIDER BUT RIGHT NOW WE

[166:00] DO HAVE THE CAPACITY BUT IT WOULD LIMIT US IN THE FUTURE HAD A FOLLOW UP AND CINDY ARE JUST GOING TO SAY IF WE TOLD YOU TO GO AHEAD AND DO THIS NO WAY THAT DIDN'T REQUIRE BALLOT MEASURE WOULD YOU THEN COME BACK TO US WITH A LIST OF BUILDINGS THAT YOU'RE GOING TO SEE OR PEES ON OR WOULD IT BE A COMBINATION OF COPD SPARSE RESERVES AND HOW WOULD YOU LOOK AT THAT AT THIS POINT WE WOULD LOOK AT IT THROUGH C O P'S WE POTENTIALLY DEPENDING WHEN THIS PROJECT'S START WE COULD USE CAPITAL FUNDING UP FRONT BUT CERTAINLY THE MAJORITY OF THE MONEY WOULD NEED TO BE DEBT FINANCED SO WE WOULD DEFINITELY BRING THAT TO YOU BEFORE ANY OF THAT HAPPENED WITH OUR RECOMMENDATION FOR COLLATERAL IS A FUNCTION SHOW HE MENTIONED BUILDINGS THAT WE COULD PLEDGE TO SEE A PIECE WITH THE NETWORK ITSELF BE PLEASURABLE. THE ASTOR BOND ATTORNEYS SAID AND THEY

[167:01] HAVE NEVER RAISED A LOOK THROUGH KIND OF THE DEBT DATABASE AND THINGS UNDERNEATH THE GROUND HAVE ACTUALLY NEVER BEEN PLEDGED AS COLLATERAL SO THEY RIGHT NOW THEY'RE NOT SURE LEGALLY IF WE COULD DO IT BUT THEY CERTAINLY THINK THAT THE INVESTORS WOULD BE PRETTY LEERY OF THAT SO THEY WOULD RECOMMEND THAT WE USE OUR BUILDING'S LEDGE FOURTEEN MILLION DOLLARS WITH A FIBER WELL ON THE GROUND BUT BUT BUT MAYBE AND MAYBE SEE A PIECE MAYBE IT'S DIFFERENT BUT I BUT I KNOW THAT THEY HAVE BEEN USED BUT BY CORPORATIONS AS THEY REALLY LIKE THEM BECAUSE THE MONITOR THE REALLY EASY TO MONETIZE AS OPPOSED TO BUILDING TO BUILDING YOUR STUFF WITH A BILL IN THAT MAYBE IS TOO OCCUPIED BY THE BY THE BORROWERS THE FIBER IS RELATIVELY EASY TO MONETIZE BUT THAT SOMETHING IS A DETAIL THAT WON WITH ELISA LEASING THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THAT KIND OF PUTS A LITTLE ON MAKES IT A LITTLE BIT MORE DIFFICULT TO USE AS

[168:00] COLLATERAL AS WELL FOR THE RELEASE OF THEM WE NEED JUST AS IT'S HIS COMPANY OR CRACKED OK GREAT THANKS CINDY AND MARY I WAS JUST CURIOUS ABOUT BUILDINGS THAT WOULD BE POLITICALLY SENSITIVE YOU DID MENTION I'M NOT SURE IF I WOULD BE THE RIGHT PERSON TO MAKE THAT BUT PERHAPS THE HIKE IN RESPONSE TO A C O P ISN'T REALLY A MORTGAGE PURCHASE LEASE BACK AND THERE ARE SOME BUILDINGS THAT LIKE FIRE STATIONS THAT YOU DON'T WANT TO PUT IT TO THAT SITUATION AND SO POLITICAL WAS A SORT OF SHORTHAND WAY OF SAYING THERE ARE WE LIMITED TO BUILDINGS THAT THEORETICALLY WE COULD AFFORD TO LOSE AND SO ALTHOUGH WE NEVER LOSE THEM AND THAT'S NOT REALLY THE ISSUE BUT WE DON'T DO THINGS LIKE THE SAFETY BUILDING ON THE FIRE STATIONS STORYTELLING AND THEN BOB WOULD KNOW THIS BETTER THAN I BUT IS THERE ANY WAY TO FOLLOW UP ON BOB'S

[169:00] LAST QUESTION ABOUT COLLATERAL. I MEAN I CAN CERTAINLY GO BACK TO OUR BOND ATTORNEYS AND ASK THEM TO RESEARCH IT MORE BUT THEIR INITIAL RESPONSE WAS DON'T DO THAT SO JUST TO BE CLEAR I DON'T WANT TO GET TO LEGAL HERE BUT THESE AREN'T MORTGAGES OR DEBTS BECAUSE THOSE WITH THAT WOULD BE SUBJECT TO TABOR THE REASON THE C O P'S ARE NOT SUBJECT TO TABOR IS IT'S REALLY A SALE LEASE BACK SO WE'RE NOT PAYING A DEBT WITH PAYING A LEASE WHICH IS NOT SUBJECT TO TAPER AND SO I JUST THE BOND ATTORNEYS LACK OF COMFORT IS BECAUSE WE'RE ALREADY IN A STRUCTURE THAT IS KIND OF DIFFERENT THAN NORMAL DEBT STRUCTURE TO DO IT ON A LEASE TO PURCHASE LEASE BACK ON SOMETHING UNDERGROUND JUST I THINK WOULD BE REALLY COPPER USING CUTE ACTRESS. YES YES OK SO I'M NOT GOING TO FEEL BUT IT'S JUST ANOTHER BY CONSULATE WORKER IN THIS POINT IF I CAN FALL FROM

[170:00] THE GREATER CREATIVE BOND COUNSEL SCARE ME. YES WELL I MEAN THE HOUSE SO THAT IS TELECOM WORK I GUESS IS WHAT I'M SAYING JUST UNDERSTAND THAT A LITTLE BETTER SO THAT THE SILLY SPEC ARRANGEMENT IN TWENTY YEARS IS THE BUILDING REVERT TO THE CITY WAS AS TO SELL YOU EXPECT TO GET BACK AS WE WHEN WE SELL IT TO A ENTITY THAT WE CONTROL ITS NOT LIKE TO SOMEBODY ELSE AND THAT ACTUALLY FINANCES AND THAT'S THE POLL OF ITS PROPERTIES UP FOR THE PUMP AGAIN THANK YOU MARY. HOW MUCH OF THE C O P CAPACITY IS CURRENTLY SET ASIDE FOR THE HOTEL AND WE'RE THINKING AROUND. IF THE ESTIMATE OF ABOUT TWENTY MILLION COMES TO FOR A SHOW AND FRUITION WE WOULD NEED ABOUT FIVE MILLION OF BUILDING TYPE COLLATERAL WE THINK THE PARKING GARAGE WOULD GIVE US ABOUT FIFTEEN MILLION OF COLLATERAL ANY

[171:00] OTHER QUESTIONS FOR WE MOVE TO THE AIRING SEEING NONE OF THAT OPEN THE HEARING HEIDI HAVING FOLKS WHO HAVE SAT HERE WE HAVE SEVEN PEOPLE SEVEN PEOPLE ARE AND WE HAVE A LIST ON THE SCREEN HERE AND SOO SHOW US YOU MAY BE TO GIVE UP YOUR CEDAR WE GO HERE KNOW THERE'S A SIGN HEARING SPEAKERS SO I WILL DO SO CALL YOUR NAME PLEASE COME ON DOWN YOU CAN HAVE YOUR SEAT THE TABLE YOU GET THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK PLEASE GIVE US YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS FIRST AND WE'RE GOING TO START GOING TO MANGLE PEOPLE'S NAMES PLEASE FORGIVE ME. ALICE CANCER AND YES YOU CAN WATCH FOR YOUR NAME UP ON THE SCREENING GET READY TO COME AT ONCE CAN THE GOOD EVENING MY NAME IS ALICE GET THERE AND I'VE LIVED IN BOULDER MEADOWS TRAILER PARK SINCE TWO THOUSAND TO. I'M EXCITED ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY OF BETTER INTERNET SERVICE IN BOULDER AND SPECIFICALLY IN

[172:01] NORTH BOULDER LIVING IN BOULDER MEADOWS I HAD TWO OPTIONS FOR INTERNET AND CENTURYLINK OR COMCAST. I STAY WAS SENT REELING FOR THE SLIGHTLY LOWER MONTHLY BILL AND I'M WHICH IS CURRENTLY A HUNDRED AND EIGHT DOLLARS A MONTH THAT IS FOR MY INTERNET AND MY LANDLINE DAY AS BOULDER HAS UNRELIABLE CELL SERVICE DESPITE VERIZON'S OF SCI QUIZ AD CAMPAIGNS IT CAN YOU HEAR ME OUT. NO MY FRIENDS THAT CAN'T HEAR ME SO I HAVE A LANDLINE I NEEDED THE INTERNET TO TAKE COLLEGE CLASSES SINCE TWO THOUSAND EIGHT AND UP UNTIL JUST RECENTLY MY DOWNLOAD SPEED HAS BEEN TWELVE MEGABYTES OR LAST RECENTLY I HAD MY INTERNET SPEED BOOSTED TO FORTY BUT THE UPGRADE AND THE NEW WIFI MODEM COST ME A COUPLE THREE HUNDRED DOLLARS IF I DROP THE LAND LINE AND GET A SMARTPHONE MY BILL WILL PRETTY MUCH STAYED THE SAME TODAY INTERNET HAS BECOME

[173:01] ITS NECESSITY RATHER THAN A LUXURY THEY NEED FOR EDUCATION PURPOSES ALONG MAKE IT A MUST HAVE BUT WHAT ABOUT MY LOW INCOME NEIGHBORS THEY USE THE INTERNET ON THEIR CELL PHONES WHICH CAN ALSO BE VERY EXPENSIVE ONLY A FEW OF MY NEIGHBORS HAVE THE INTERNET BECAUSE THEY CAN'T AFFORD IT AND THEY DON'T HAVE A MORE CHOICES THAN I DO SO I GUESS MY QUESTION HERE TONIGHT IS WITH THIS NEW PLAN HELP MY NEIGHBORS WILL IT LOWER MY BILL AND WILL IT HELP ALL THE SCHOOLS STUDENTS THAT THEY NOW LIVE IN BOULDER MEADOWS BECAUSE THEY REALLY HELP IT DOES AND ONE KNOW IN LISTENING THE HEARING COMCAST'S HAS OR HAD LINES THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE PARK WHEN I MOVED IN THERE IN TWO THOUSAND AND TWO WE WERE COMPLETELY WIRED FOR CABLE TV SHOW THERE'S AN EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE IN BOULDER MEADOWS THAT'S PROBABLY DECAYING OR SEMI USED SO

[174:04] SOMETHING TO THINK ABOUT THANK YOU SO MUCH US AND THIS IS PATRICK L MEYER AND FOR YOUR THREE MINUTES YOUR INDICATION THAT YOU'RE RUNNING AT A TIME AS ALL THE WAY UP THERE ON THE RED IT'S THE RED SUIT WITH THAT HERE WHEN THAT GOES HEAL YOUR THIRTY SECOND SLICE YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE UPPER CHAIN SPEAK AND I WANT TO THANK THE STAFF ARE WORKING WAS A WONDERFUL PRESENTATION AND THE OTHER END FOR THE EARLIER SESSION THAT THEY HAD WORKED AT A SESSION WAS ABLE TO CONTRIBUTE AS WELL I'M UP AT WHERE I LIVE IN THE GUN BARREL AND WE HAD THAT MAP UP EARLIER THAT UPPER NORTHWEST AREA SO I CAN SEE IT MENTIONED IN THE PRESENTATION BUT I'D SEEN IN OTHER PARTS. IF THERE'S ANY OPPORTUNITY TO WORK WITH THE COUNTY TO CUT THROUGH AND GET A GUN BARREL FASTER HIGHLY ENCOURAGE THAT. ALSO WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO BRING UP IS A NIGHT IF I WAS UP TO SELL THIS TO ME AS AN UNINFORMED VOTER TO BE TALKING ABOUT THIS WHAT I WOULD TALK ABOUT IS AFFECTED

[175:03] YES THIS ISN'T REALLY FOR THE MOST PART OR ANY REVENUE GENERATION PIECE TO IT BUT THIS IS THE CORE INFRASTRUCTURE REQUIREMENT FOR NO MATTER WHAT OPTION WE GO WITH DOWN THE ROAD HAS BEEN PRESENTED IN OTHER VENUES. THAT'S THE I THINK THAT'S WITH THE WAY WE WOULD PRESENT IT THAT THIS ISN'T GOING TO GET YOU THE INTERNET YOUR HOUSE BUT NO MATTER WHAT OPTION WE GO WITH. YOU'VE GOT TO HAVE THIS BEFORE YOU CAN HAVE THAT THAT'S ALL I WANTED IS MY POINT OF VIEW OF HOLLYWOOD. THIS BECAME A BALLOT MEASURE HOW I WOULD GO OUT AND GET PEOPLE TO VOTE FOR PAT CONNER MAY THINK YOU CAN SEW LIKE TO FIRST OF ALL WHOLEHEARTEDLY AGREE WITH POINTS MADE BY BOTH THE PRIOR SPEAKERS AND MR. HILL MEYER AND JUST ECHO THEY THE INADEQUACY OF THE RATES RELIABILITY IN CUSTOMER SERVICE OFFERED BY THE CURRENT NICE PIECE IN BOULDER IS A COMMON THEME AMONGST ME MAKE FRIENDS AND

[176:01] NEIGHBORS. IT'S BEEN WIDELY CONSIDERED THAT WE DON'T HAVE GREAT INTERNET OPTIONS AND THAT SEEMS STRANGE GIVEN THAT OVERALL CONNECTEDNESS OF OUR SOCIETY TODAY I'D LIKE YOU LITTLE MORE HIGH MINDED PHILOSOPHICAL AND POINT OUT THAT I THINK THAT PROMOTING FREE EQUAL AND UNFETTERED ACCESS TO INFORMATION HAS THROUGHOUT HISTORY AND THE SUREST THING THE GOVERNMENTS CAN DO TO PROMOTE THE FUTURE ECONOMIC PROSPERITY AND DEMOCRATIC CHARACTER OF THEIR COMMUNITIES AND I THINK THAT A FEW POINTS I'D LIKE TO MAKE A CROWN THIS JUST IN OUR CURRENT SITUATION IN THE RAID WHICH THIS TECHNOLOGY IS CHANGING IN THE IMPLICATIONS THAT IT HAS FOR OUR SOCIETY I THINK OVER JUST THE LAST FEW YEARS WE'VE SEEN CANNOT BE UNDERESTIMATED AND THE SECOND OF ALL THAT I THINK AS YOU KNOW THAT THE STRUGGLE AROUND OUR ENERGY SITUATION AND ARE OCCURRING IN OUR CLIMATE COMMITMENTS HAS SHOWN REGARDLESS OF HOW YOU FEEL ABOUT THE COSTS VERSUS BENEFITS OF MOVING FORWARD WITH THE DISPLAYS ASIAN SHOWN

[177:00] THAT LITTLE BIT OF PROACTIVE WORK NOW CAN SAVE US FROM HUGE HEADACHES AND DISAGREEMENTS THAT OUR COMMUNITY MIGHT FACE IN THE FUTURE WITH THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CHANGING TECHNOLOGIES AND INFRASTRUCTURES AND THE FINAL THING IT SAYS THAT THE LAST COUPLE DECISIONS THAT COME OUT OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT IN THE LAST COUPLE DAYS FIRST WITH THE OFFICIAL ROLL BACK OF NET NEUTRALITY PROTECTIONS OF THE FEDERAL LEVEL THAT HAPPEN ON MONDAY WAS FINALLY IMPLEMENTED AND SECOND OF ALL WITH TODAY'S ALLOWING OF THE MOVING FORWARD OF THE EIGHTEEN TEE TIME WARNER MERGER LARGELY UNFETTERED BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SHOW THAT WE CAN'T NECESSARILY TRUST THEM TO YOU TAKE LEADERSHIP IN BEING PROACTIVE AND FORWARD THINKING AND HOW THESE TECHNOLOGIES ARE IMPLEMENTED DOWN THE ROAD AND FOR LOCAL COMMUNITY SHOULD STEP UP AND USE A HEARING THANK YOU COMING ON RABBITS WOULD HAVE UNRAVELED

[178:00] THE TABLE MESA. I'VE ALREADY I'VE ALWAYS SAID THE CITY SHOULD DEVELOP A BACKBONE. SO I DO HOPE WE GO THROUGH WITH IT AND THE FINAL BUILD OUT AND PARTLY BECAUSE I'D REALLY LIKE TO AVOID SEEING FIVE G COME INTO OUR TOWN WITH OURS PRACTICALLY EVERY BUILDING AND ALL THE INCREDIBLE INCREASE IN RADIATION THAT'LL BRING TO THIS TOWN I EDITED A BOOK CALLED THE HEALTH. SOS THE DARK SIDE OF THE WIRELESS REVOLUTION ABOUT TEN YEARS AGO AND I ALWAYS KEEP MY CELL PHONE HAD THE GREATEST DISTANCE THAT I CAN FOR ME AND PEOPLE SHOULD READ THE SHACK LEE IS A NEW PAPER CALLED RE AND REINVENTING WIRES AND TAKE IT EASY TO

[179:02] FIND OUT I MADE A TINY URLS FOR TINY EARL DOT COM SLASH REINVENTING WIRES AND I LEARNED A WHOLE I DON'T I'M JUST BEGINNING AT HOME. WE'RE WASTING A HUGE AMOUNT OF ENERGY BLASTING RADIATION IN ALL DIRECTIONS WHEN ITS THOUSANDS OF TIMES MORE EFFICIENT TO SEND IT DOWN A WIRE ARM AND SO I WAS WONDERING IF THE CITY COULD MAYBE JUST BAN. FIVE G FROM THE CITY LIMITS TO HOLD OFF THIS ONSLAUGHT THAT'S COMING FROM THE WIRELESS COMPANIES TRYING TO GET THERE BEFORE WE BUILD OUR INFRASTRUCTURE WERE TALKING ABOUT. THANKS THANK YOU THANK YOU UNLESS YOU GO

[180:01] BY TECHNO IS HERE AND ACTUALLY BACKS. OK NEXT GREAT TO LEFT OFF ON A SEC SKU NINE FORTY NORTH ST BOULDER. AND I JUST WANNA HIGHLIGHT NET NEUTRALITY IN THIS CONVERSATION THAT NEUTRALITY IS NOT A THEORY FOR ME IS TO LIVE IN SAUDI ARABIA AND THAT IS NOT A NEUTRAL ENVIRONMENT THE EXAMPLE OF THIS IS MY MOM'S SISTER CAME DOWN WITH CANCER THE WAY SHE COPES IS TO TRY AND FIND AS MUCH RESEARCH AS POSSIBLE INFORMATION MAKES HER FEEL SAFE WHEN SHE CAN'T CONTROL SOMETHING SHE CAN SEARCH BREAST CANCER BECAUSE THE WORD BRASS HAD BANNED OR RESTRICTED LIST BY THE GOVERNMENT AND SO THE SIDE EFFECTS LIKE THESE LIKE YOU PUT INTO ME PUT RESTRICTIONS UP YOU JUST NEVER KNOW HOW IT MIGHT AFFECT PEOPLE IN THEIR DAILY LIVES BUT I WANT TO CONNECT THAT TO THE US WHICH IS I THINK OF AN ORGANIZATION LIKE COLOR OF CHANGE AND IF YOU'RE NOT FAMILIAR WITH THEM THEY'RE ONE OF THE LARGEST

[181:03] SOCIAL JUSTICE ONLINE ORGANIZATION THEY FORMED AFTER HURRICANE KATRINA AND THEY WERE BIG BROWN FERGUSON AND THE VIEWS LIKE THE ONLINE WORLD TO DO THE ORGANIZING AND THEY THEIR STANCE AS NET NEUTRALITY IS CRUCIAL TO CIVIL RIGHTS AND EQUALITY AND THEY SAY ARE FREE AND OPEN INTERNET IS CRITICAL TO OUR ABILITY TO HAVE OUR VOICES HEARD AND SO I JUST WANT YOU TO THINK ABOUT THAT IF WE BUILD A BACKBONE AND I PERSONALLY WOULD HOPE THAT IT DIDN'T HAVE TO BE A BALLOT ITEM BUT I DO NOT UNDERSTAND THE FINANCES OF IT SO WHATEVER YA'LL CAN WORKOUT IS GREAT BUT THAT YOU KNOW THAT WILL GIVE US SOME LEVERAGE TO TRY AND MAINTAIN NET NEUTRALITY HERE IN BOULDER EVEN THOUGH ON THE NATIONAL STAGE WE'VE LOST THAT MAKES ME THINK EFFECTS. LINDSAY LIBERTY IS THE LAST PERSON CURRENTLY SIGNED UP SO IF ANYONE ELSE'S AND NO NO WE

[182:00] HAVE ONE MORE SO THAN TO SAY THANKS. SO I'M I'M HERE IN THE LOW BERG AT NINE FORTY FOURTH STREET. I'M ALSO HERE TO ENCOURAGE ME ALL TO MOVE FORWARD AS EFFICIENTLY AS YOU CAN WITH CITY OWNED BROADBAND SERVICES ENCOURAGED TO HEAR YOU ALL OF SUPPORT THE EQUITY ISSUE FOR PEOPLE WHO HAVE LIMITED ACCESS TO BROADBAND I'M CURRENTLY IN AND HEARD ALICE TALKING ABOUT THIS AND HOPING I CAN KIND OF CHARACTERIZE BECAME NEGOTIATIONS AA HEAR PEOPLE MAKING AROUND TWO BASIC NEEDS AND HOW INFORMATION IS ACCESSED AT INFORMATION LACK OF ACCESS TO INFORMATION CAN BE AN ADDED BARRIER FOR PEOPLE WHO HAVE BARRIERS FOR ACCESSING BASIC NEEDS LIKE HOUSING FOOD AND MEDICAL EXPENSES SO WE WE UM WELL YOU

[183:00] ALL MENTIONED THAT CONCENTRATIONS OF PEOPLE WITH LOWER INCOMES HAS FEWER LOWER QUALITY OPPORTUNITIES TO ACCESS BROADBAND AFFORDABILITY IS ANOTHER ACTION ACCESS ISSUES SO YOU KNOW I TALK WITH MY WORK A LOT OF PEOPLE IN THE CITY WHERE MAKING NEGOTIATIONS AND CONCESSIONS TO PAY FOR FOOD HOUSING HEALTHCARE SEVENTY DOLLARS A MONTH ISN'T GOING TO BE AFFORDABLE TO THEM AN AUNT AN EXISTING ISP ISN'T GOING TO BE ABLE TO HELP MAKE IT MORE AFFORDABLE FOR THEM BUT MAYBE THE CITY CAN AND I THINK THAT THAT IS REALLY EXCITING BECAUSE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT INCREASED ACCESS FOR INFORMATION HELP IN HELPING MAKE IT EASIER FOR PEOPLE TO ACCESS THINGS LIKE FOOD AND HOUSING MEDICAID MEDICAL CARE AND UM THE LEGAL ADVICE SO THANK YOU ALL FOR LISTENING AND SUPPORTING THAT ISSUE THANK YOU NC SO WE HAVE

[184:01] ANDREA MIGUEL AND THEN THIS IS THE LAST PERSON TO REALLY SEND UPS IF YOU'RE INTERESTED IN SPEAKING PLEASE DO SIGN UP NOW ARE ABOUT TO CLOSE THE HEARING UNDER MN AGO. HERE ARE A PRESENTABLE THE CHAMBER AT TWENTY FOUR FORTY PEARL ST AND LOVABLE THE CHAMBER HAS TAKEN NO POSITION ON THE SPOT SO THE QUESTIONS SAY YOU'RE BE ANNOUNCED AN EYE WE WERE LOOKING AT THIS INFORMATION WILL BE DISCUSSING IT FURTHER AMONGST OUR MEMBERSHIP AND PRIVATE SECTOR PROVIDERS TO LOOK AT HOW TO ADDRESS THIS ISSUE AND GET TO A SOLUTION THAT DELIVERS IS EFFECTIVELY AND EFFICIENTLY. SO FIRST OF ALL WERE EXCITED THAT THE COUNCIL'S HAVING THIS CONVERSATION TONIGHT AND REALLY WANT TO COMMEND THE STAFF OR THE ADVANCEMENTS THEY'VE MADE AND EXPLORE AND WE'VE COME PRETTY FAR LAST SEVERAL MONTHS AND LOOKING AT INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS AND HOW TO GET HERE WAS SOMETHING THAT CAN BE DELIVERED TO THE COMMUNITY OF THE EDITION IN ADDITION TO THE OBVIOUS BENEFITS IN EXCESS FOR SMALL

[185:00] BUSINESSES AND OUR LOCAL ECONOMY AND WE ALL BENEFIT FROM PUBLICLY AVAILABLE FIBER OPTIC INFRASTRUCTURE. IT'S ESSENTIAL FOR ADVANCING MOBILITY TECHNOLOGIES THAT WERE EXPLORING AND PLANNING OUR COMMUNITIES THAT GIVE PEOPLE ACCESS TO ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY. IT'S GOING TO BE ESSENTIAL IN THE WAY THAT PEOPLE HAVE ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE AND PHYSICIANS AND THE WAY THAT THOSE VISITS ARE EVOLVING AND PEOPLE CAN GET ADVICE AND ALSO FOR ADDRESSING THE DIGITAL DIVIDE WHICH HAVE STEVE TONIGHT STILL EXISTS WITHIN OUR SCHOOLS IN OUR COMMUNITY. SO WITH THAT BEING SAID WILL CONTINUE TO DISCUSS THE OPTIONS MONKS ARE MEMBERS AND EXPLORE THEIR PERSPECTIVES ON HOW TO DELIVER THIS INFRASTRUCTURE EFFECTIVELY AND EFFICIENTLY BUT WE REALLY THANK YOU FOR TAKING THIS ON FOR LOOKING AT HOW TO MOVE THE SUPPORT TONIGHT AND JUST REALLY BEEN A COMMUNITY PARTNER IN ALL OF THIS SO THANK YOU THINKING TRAM WE HAVE A COUPLE MORE

[186:00] PEOPLE. LYNNE SEGAL AND CHRISTOPHER WARREN WHEN SIEGEL MOUNTAIN HEIGHTS AND MY INTERNET COST IS ABOUT THIRTY NINE BACKS WITH CENTURYLINK NYE HAVE TO EVERY SIX MONTHS GO BACK AND FORTH BETWEEN COMCAST AND CENTURYLINK TO THREATEN ONE OR THE OTHER TO KEEP MY RATES AND MY INCOME JUST DROPPED BECAUSE I HAD IT AND GET RID OF MY FORTY PERCENT DISCOUNT FOR MY LONG TERM GUESTS ON AIR BE IN THE AND AND I'M SIXTY FIVE SO I'M NOW GOING TO HAVE TO PAY EIGHT HUNDRED AND THIRTY FOUR DOLLARS A MONTH HEALTH CARE STARTING IN OCTOBER AND I'VE NEVER PAID FOR HEALTH CARE. SOME IN THE HEALTHCARE INDUSTRY AND GOT IT YOU KNOW PAID FOR THROUGH MY WORK AND SO I HAVE MORE DEMANDS ON MY OWN COSTS

[187:07] AND I DON'T THINK THE UNIVERSITY HILL HOTEL SHOULD BE A GOOD SOURCE OF COLLATERAL WITH TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLAR PARKING SPACES. I THINK THAT IT IS ACTUALLY A LIABILITY TO US IF THE CITY AND THERE'S A HOTEL GOING IN ACROSS THE STREET. THE REAL UNIVERSITY IS PUTTING IN THAT WE HAVE NO CONTROL OVER AND I'D LIKE TO GO FOR THE CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION BUT IF IT REQUIRES THAT KIND OF COLLATERAL. UM I DON'T THINK THAT'S COLLATERAL. IT'S A LIABILITY WERE FORTY FOUR MILLION DOLLARS AND YOU KNOW IN DEFICIT NOW AND I DON'T PRESUME THAT THAT IS GOING TO CHANGE. I THINK THAT'S GOING GET WORSE AND IF WE DOUBT KIND OF DEAL WITH A JOBS HOUSING IMBALANCE AND SEE I

[188:03] REALLY SUPPORT AS HAVING HIGH SPEED BROADBAND FOR ACTIVE ENERGY FOR MICRO GRIDS FOR B T G AND I THINK THAT THAT'S SAVINGS THAT WE'RE GOING TO INCUR FROM THIS SHOULD SOMEHOW PAY FOR IT IN THE LONG RUN ANYWAY AND I GUESS PEOPLE ARE PAYING A LOT MORE THAN ME. CHRIS THEY'RE BUNDLING EVERYTHING BUT I WONDER FACT BE INVESTIGATED BECAUSE THE LONG TERM SAVINGS ARE GOING TO BE GREAT BUT MORE PRODUCTIVITY WOULD HAVE THIS HIGH SPEED INTERNET THANK YOU AND CHRISTOPHER WARREN AND HER SON ALONG GO SHORN OF IT TO SIXTY THREE SHERWOOD CIRCLE UM TALK ALOT ABOUT TECHNICAL DETAILS. I JUST WANT TO GIVE A QUICK

[189:02] ANECDOTE BROADBAND INTERNET HIGH SPEED FIBER INTERNET WOULD BRING SO MANY ADDED BENEFITS THAT COME UPS NIGHT JUST A QUICK FEW THINGS IN MY PERSONAL LIFE I'M A FILMMAKER AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT UM FIBER INTERNET OFFERS IS UPLOAD SPEEDS EQUAL TO DOWNLOAD SPEEDS CURRENTLY UPLOAD SPEEDS ARE HORRENDOUSLY SLOW AND IF IT RAINS AND A FILM PROJECT SOMEONE TAKES A LONG TIME SO THAT'S JUST ONE TINY PART OF A MYRIAD OF ADDED BENEFITS THAT ARE NECESSARILY OBVIOUS RIGHT NOW IN THIS MOMENT. UM IT'S FUNNY THAT MY TWO CENTS ON THAT AND THEN ALSO THAN THE YOUNGER HOUSEHOLDS PURCHASING INTERNET MOST OF US GET ALL OF OUR ENTERTAINMENT THROUGH THE INTERNET NOW ANYWAYS. AND THAT RATIO OF INTERNET ONLY USERS VERSUS BUNDLING I PERSONALLY FEEL THAT THE RATIO OF PEOPLE USING JUSTIN AND NOT TV SERVICES AND FOUND ARE GOING TO GO UP

[190:06] IN UPWARDS OF TWO SUSPECTS CHRISTOPHER SON ALONG TO FINISHING THIS UP. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR LETTING ME TALK I AM ONE OF THOSE LUCKY THAT THE US THAT HAVE ACCESS TO INTERNET BUT I AM HERE BECAUSE I REALLY TRY TO BRING WITH ME TO PEOPLE THAT I KNOW THAT THEY DON'T HALF AND HE WAS NOT EASY FOR THEM TO COME TONIGHT. YOU KNOW THEY THEY DON'T WANT TO SHOW SHOW UP IN TWO PLACES ANYMORE. A TWO BASE IS EVEN MORE. YOU KNOW THEY DON'T WANT TO COME FOR THE LAST FOUR YEARS I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO CREATE THESE SPANISH UM YOU KNOW RADIO BROADCASTING. IT IS REALLY REALLY INTO READING SERVICES FOR SPANISH SPEAKING PEOPLE AND AGAIN AND AGAIN WHEN I GO

[191:01] TO TRY TO REGISTER THEM ESPECIALLY THE ADULTS THEY DON'T HAVE INTERNET AT HOME I AM WHEN THEY EXPLAIN EXPLAIN TO THEM WHAT IS IT THAT WE ARE PROVIDING FOR FREE. THEY THEY WANT THEY GIVE ME THEIR NAMES THEY USE THEIR PHONE NUMBERS AND THEY GIVE ME THEIR ADDRESS AND WEBSITE CALLED HIM AND TRY TO PROVIDE THE SERVICE IS IMPOSSIBLE THEY DON'T HAVE INTERNET AT HOME AND EVEN IF YOU TRY TO EXPLAIN TO THEM THAT YOU KNOW BARRY OF SERVICES THAT ARE CHEAP BUT YOU CAN APPLY FOR THEM THEY ARE REALLY THEY DON'T WANT TO DO IT YOU KNOW THEY THEY SAY ALWAYS GOING TO COST ME FACE THE GLACIER ON IT'S GOING TO COST ME LIKE EVEN TEN DOLLARS BECAUSE TEN DOLLARS IS WHAT YOU NEED TO PAY IN BOULDER VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT THEY'RE LIKE NO I'M GOING TO PAY THAT I DON'T HAVE IT SO I KNEW THAT IT WAS DIFFICULT FOR THE PIRATES IN BOULDER

[192:01] RIGHT A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO ACCESS COMPUTERS AND TO GO INTO THEIR INTO VAIN TO NET TO CHECK THE GREATS OF THE KITS AND ALSO TO YOU KNOW TO SEND THE LETTERS OF COMPLAINT ABOUT THESE AND DIED OR WHATEVER COMMUNICATION WITH THE PARENTS WITH IT WITH THE TEACHERS I KNEW THAT I I WAS AWARE THAT THEY WERE NOT GOING TO BE YOU SAYING THAT BUT IT WAS NOT UNTIL I STARTED WE WHAT I HAVE BEEN DOING THIS FOR YEARS THAT I HAVE REALIZED HOW DEEP THAT THE BITE IS IS NOT ONLY THAT THEY DON'T HAVE COMPUTERS IS NOT ONLY THAT THEY DON'T KNOW YOU KNOW WHAT MY PEOPLE DON'T KNOW HOW TO USE IS NOT THAT THEY'RE SHY. IT IS ALSO THE LOCATION THAT HE SET UP FOR THEM NOT TO HAVE ACCESS TO INTERNET. I EVEN WENT TO HOUSE THE DAY I INSTALL A RADIO AND I REALIZE THAT THIS PERSON HAS BEING A PAIN MY

[193:00] KNEE FOR THREE MONTHS AND THEY DIDN'T INSTALL THE SERVICE SO THE LITTLE GIRL WAS USING PAINT OR NAY FROM THE FRIEND OF LEAVING THE OTHER HOUSE AND NOT TELLING THE MOM JUST SO YOU KNOW THE ONE TO GET HER WARD THESE ARE PERSONAL STORIES THINK YOU'RE SO RIGHT SO THAT'S ALL OF THE HEARING SPEAKERS US TO WALK AHEAD AND CLOSE THE HEARING THE QUESTION QUESTIONS FOR STAFF CHERYL AND I'M SITTING HERE LOOKING AT THE REVENUE REPORT THAT WE RECEIVED MOST RECENTLY AND IS IT FAIR TO SAY THAT SOME OF THE EXPECTED FOUR MILLION DOLLARS SHORTFALL IS BEING MADE UP NOW BY HIGHER COLLECTION RATES BECAUSE IT LOOKS TO ME LIKE WE'RE ONE POINT TWO MILLION ABOVE WHERE WE WERE IN SEVENTEEN AT THIS TIME IS CORRECT. CHERYL YEAR MIKE THE WORLD LOOKING AT THE RETAIL SALES TAX WHICH MAKES UP THE MAJORITY OF A WE

[194:01] ARE PRETTY FLAT STILL WERE WERE A LITTLE UNDER ONE PERCENT. THERE IS SOME CONSTRUCTION USE REVENUE IN THAT NUMBER BUT WE CAN RESEARCH MORE AND AND COME BACK SHE WERE NOT AT THE POINT YET WHERE WE WANT TO REVISE OUR NUMBERS WERE HOPING IN THE NEXT COUPLE MONTHS WE'LL HAVE MORE DATA THAT WE WOULD IF IN FACT THERE IS A DIFFERENT TREND OUT THERE THAT WE WOULD REFLECT THAT IN TWENTY NINETEEN BUDGET NUMBERS. OK AND SO THIS IS THROUGH MARCH RATE AND SO ANY KIND OF PRELIMINARY DID IT GO UP OR DOWN IN APRIL OR MAY. WE DON'T HAVE THOSE NUMBERS AT ANY OTHER FELLOW QUESTION STILL SHOULD HAVE ASKED WHEN YOU HAD YOUR SITE UP WITH ALL THE STARS AND THE MOMENT IN TIME A BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS IN MOBILE HOME COMMUNITIES. IMAGINE YOU

[195:00] DOCTOR BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS IN THERE. THEY WON HIM A PARTNER IN DOING THAT LAST WAY WITH A MOBILE HOME COMMUNITIES HE TALKED WITH SOME OF THE PRIVATE OWNERS YOU KNOW PROP IN OTHERS IT WOULD THEY. BECAUSE THAT'S PRIVATELY ENEMY SEE THE OUTFITS ALICE RADIO HOUSES CUMMINS BECAUSE IT'S PRIVATELY IN THE STATE SEEMED TO TAKE EVERY OPPORTUNITY PRAY SCOUT TO THEIR RESIDENCE THAT THEY CAN AS THERE IS THERE A WAY OF E YOU ARE ENSURING THAT THAT THAT LAST LEG FROM OUR BACKBONE TO TO THEM WE WOULDN'T BE IN FURTHER PRICE COUCH FOR THE RESIDENTS SO WE HAVEN'T HAD ANY CONVERSATIONS WITH THE LANDOWNERS FOR THOSE MANUFACTURED HOME COMMUNITIES CERTAINLY IF WE RUN THE FIBER INTO THE PARKS WE WILL OWN THAT FIBER AS WELL AS THE PRICE SHOULD NOT BE CONTROLLED BY THE LANDOWNER OK THAT SAID YOU KNOW WE DON'T KNOW WE HAVEN'T HAD THOSE CONVERSATIONS ABOUT WHAT IT WOULD TAKE TO GET FIBER INTO THOSE PROPERTIES OK AND THE PLAN IS THAT WE WOULD BE THE ONES TO RUN INTO

[196:01] THOSE PROPERTIES CRACKED WE WOULD HAVE TO DEVISE A PLAN FOR HOW TO GET THERE OK AND THERE ARE OTHER TECHNICAL OPPORTUNITIES OUT THERE TECHNOLOGIES OUT THERE ON THERE'S WIRELESS MESH NETWORKS TO AND I MET WITH SOME FOLKS THAT ARE EXPLORING SOME OF THAT RENO WHERE ESSENTIALLY THAT LAST LEG OF INTERNET SERVICES DONE WIRELESSLY AND AND THAT WOULD BE SOMETHING THAT'S SPECIFIC TO THE HOME SO IT WOULDN'T BE INFRASTRUCTURE IN THE GROUND ON THERE'S PROS AND CONS TO THOSE SORTS OF MODELS. SO THOSE ARE ALL THINGS THAT COULD BE EXPLORED AS WE GO FORWARD WITH A MEETING WITH THE B H P PST PILOT THAT THEY'RE RUNNING IS OVER THE YEAR SO IF THAT PROVES OUT IN A BROADER SENSE WE COULD POTENTIALLY NOT HAVE TO GO INTO THE COMMUNITY AT ALL BECAUSE WE PROVIDE AT A DISTANCE TO BCC IS THERE BUT THEY'RE CHARGING TEN DOLLARS A MONTH FOR THAT IF I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY WHAT THEY'RE CHARGING. I THINK IT'S FREE

[197:01] FOR THE RESIDENTS THERE'S A COUPLE THINGS BEING PLATED SO COMCAST OFFERS INTERNET ESSENTIALS AND THAT'S A PROGRAM FOR LOW INCOME INDIVIDUALS IN CERTAIN STIPULATIONS AROUND THAT SO I DO BELIEVE THAT THEY HAVE TO PAY SOME AMOUNT BUT I THINK IT'S IT'S TEN DOLLARS IN OUR CONVERSATIONS WITH BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS IS ACTUALLY VERY COMPLICATED FOR RESIDENTS TO BECOME QUALIFIED FOR THAT PROGRAM AND THERE SOME KIND OF STRANGE COMPONENTS WE HAVE TO GET RID OF YOUR EXISTING THAT WITH COMCAST FOR NINETY DAYS IN ORDER TO SIGN UP FOR INTERNET ESSENTIALS SEE HERE CREATING A GAP IN INTERNET COVERAGE WHICH IS SORT OF STRANGE BUT PART OF THE PROGRAM IS JUST OR STRUCTURE THAT WAY. OTHER THINGS LIKE IF YOU KNOW COMCAST MONEY TO PAY THAT ON THE PRE QUALIFYING THINGS LIKE THAT SO THERE'S SOME SIGNIFICANT BARRIERS TO THAT PROGRAM THAT BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS HAS SEEN BELOW UPTICK FOR THE TREES AND

[198:00] THE LAST REASON IS THAT SOMETHING WAS NOT MENTIONED IS THAT PEOPLE ARE NOT INTERESTED IN BEING REGISTERED AND SO THEY SEE THAT OFTEN IN THE ACCESS QUESTION. OK SOUNDS LIKE A DIRTY DOING THIS BUT AS WE MOVE FORWARD TO JUST AGREE TO CONTINUE TO PRIORITIZE THESE COMMUNITIES AND MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE GETTING FREE FOR YEARS CASA FREEZE POSSIBLE INTERNET TO THEM UNDERSTAND THE DREAM I THINK WE WERE READY FOR COMMENTS TO KICK SO SURE THAT'S COMING IS WHY WE SHOULD DO THE BACKBONE AND WHICH FINANCES HOPELESS BECOME PRETTY OBVIOUS TO US IN OUR LAST FEW SESSIONS OF THIS IS A REALLY IMPORTANT THING FOR US TO DO I'M GLAD THE READING DOWN THE PATH BACK ON IT JUST EMBARRASSING TO ME THAT BOULDER COLORADO SUMMER TEEN FOR SOME PERCENT OF OUR COMMUNITY DOES NOT HAVE ACCESS TO ANY INTERNET IMAGINE IF WE SAID FOUR TO SEVEN PERCENT OF OUR TO NEED A NAP ELECTRICITY FOR DECEMBER SOME OF OUR COMMUNITY DIDN'T HAVE WATER IN I THINK HE DID THE INTERNET HAS BECOME A FUNDAMENTAL NEED ON JUST HOW

[199:00] WATER WAS IN THE LAST ENTRY WE'VE HEARD A LOT OF REASONS FOR GREECE BECAUSE TODAY ABOUT WHY THIS IS SO IMPORTANT WHY FRANCE IS BECOMING MORE IMPORTANT UM NET NEUTRALITY WAS WIPED OUT THIS WEEK IT WAS A FORMER JUSTICE FROM THE DETERMINATION THAT CAN FURTHER CONSOLIDATED THE CONTENT PROVIDERS INSURERS AND SO THAT THE TEMPTATION TO THROTTLE OR SLOW SPEED OR PROVIDE TWO DIFFERENT LANES OF SPEED AND HAS JUST INCREASED AS OF TODAY AS WE HEARD FROM OUR CONSERVATIVE OR RESIDENTS ARM SPEED IS IMPORTANT AND OF COURSE SOME WERE BEING PASSED BY QUITE FRANKLY BY OUR NEIGHBORING COMMUNITIES WHO ARE PROVIDING FAST INTERNET THEIR RESIDENCE AND WERE NOT IN COSTS IS IMPORTANT FOR THE DIGITAL DIVIDE THE COMMITTEE THAT CAN AFFORD IT ALL BUT ALSO FOR OUR RESIDENTS WHO ARE RECEIVING EFFECTIVELY SLOW SPEED AT A HIGH COST. I THINK THIS HAS BECOME AN ESSENTIAL SERVICE I'M GLAD THEY WERE TAKING THE FIRST STEP. WHAT WILL PROBABLY BE A TWO STEP PROCESS TO PROVIDE INTERNET ACCESS. I'M GOING TO SUPPORT

[200:00] OR ENCOURAGE MY COLLEAGUES TO SUPPORT FINANCING THIS FIRST OF THE C O P PROCESS AND I'M GOING TO THE BELL AND EXPLAIN WHY FOR SO I THINK THE STAFF HAS BEEN APPROPRIATELY CONSERVATIVE IN IGNORING MOST POTENTIAL REVENUE BUT I THINK THERE IS ACTUALLY SOME POTENTIAL REVENUE IN TWO REGARDS ONE IS HAVING BEEN IN THIS BUSINESS BEFORE I KNOW THAT CARRIERS WHO UM DO BUSINESS IN TOWN BOTH PROVIDE SERVICE TO BUSINESSES LIKE CENTURYLINK AND IN SEO AND EIGHTEEN T AND VERIZON WILL LOOK AT THIS FIBER AS A SOMETHING THEY'RE GOING TO WANT TO BUY WHETHER IT'S FOR REDUNDANT NETWORK OR TO GET TO PLACES WHERE THEY NEED TO BE SO I DON'T DOUBT THAT UNTIL WE MOVE FROM PHASE ONE WHICH HAS BEEN THE BACKBONE AND PHASE TWO WHICH IS UP FOR AN INTERNET THAT STRANDS REMEMBERING TO PUT IN A PRETTY HIGH FIBER CONTENT WE'RE TALKING ONE FORTY FOUR TO AN EIGHTY EIGHT THOSE EACH ONE OF THOSE FIBERS IS CAN BE SOLD OR LEASED TO THOSE NUMBERS COMPANIES AND THEY WILL PAY A LOT BECAUSE ONCE THE GROUND THE VALUE OF THAT

[201:00] FIBER IS KHAIRY SIGNIFICANTLY SO I THINK THERE'S A THERE'S A GREAT REVENUE POTENTIAL WHETHER THAT CAN COMPLETELY OFFSET OUR ANNUAL INCURRING COST. I DON'T KNOW I DON'T THINK ANY OF US KNOW YET THERE'S A SECOND REVENUE POTENTIAL WHICH IS AS WE PROVIDE SERVICES WITH US TO THE STEW SCHOOL DISTRICT OR TO THE MOBILE HOME PARKS OR TO BE HP I THINK THERE'S A REVENUE POTENTIAL THERE AS WELL AS USING PHP IS AN EXAMPLE TO MAKE THESE NUMBERS UP JUST ILLUSTRATE LET'S SAY THAT BECAUSE OF ALL THE REASONS THAT JULIA JUST MENTIONED THE B H P RESIDENT SO WE CAN CONNECT THEM TO SAY THE PAGE. THE CHP WILL PAY US TWENTY DOLLARS MONTH WHICH IS A PRETTY LOW RATE TWENTY DOLLARS A MONTH TIMES PH PIECE NUMBER OF HOUSEHOLDS GENERATE A QUARTER MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR REVENUE THAT'S THAT'S ONE QUARTER OF THE MILLION DOLLAR TRADING WAS TALKING ABOUT RIGHT THERE AND THAT'S JUST THE HP AND SO I THINK THE POTENTIAL TO OFFSET SOME OF THIS EXPENSE IS THERE YOU THROUGH CARRIERS OR THROUGH OUR VERY OWN INITIAL CUSTOMERS. I DON'T THINK THIS DEBT HAS TO BE LONG TERM WHILE I UNDERSTAND THAT WE HAVE TO TEE IT UP AS

[202:00] LONG TERM THAT I WOULD SUGGEST THAT WE WERE REALLY AFFECTED WILL BE RECOUNTED HERE AND A FINE TIME RIGHT BECAUSE OF ENTER INTO RELATIONSHIP WITH THE MUNI WERE NOT TOO SURE EXACTLY WHERE WE WILL BE ANOTHER COUPLE TO THREE YEARS NOT SO I THINK I THOUGHT WAS AT THE LAST MEETING. LET'S GO AHEAD AND BUILD THIS NO REGRETS FIRST PHASE AND KNOW THAT THAT THAT NETWORK CAN EITHER BE USED BY US TO BUILD A NETWORK OR COULD BE USED BY US IN PARTNERSHIP WE DON'T KNOW WHICH ONE OF THOSE TWO THINGS TO DO YET BUT IT COULD BE BUILT ANYWAY AND I THINK WE CAN HAVE A PRETTY GOOD VIEW IN TWO OR THREE YEARS WHERE WE WERE GOING TO BE ON THE MUNI WE'RE GOING TO BE IN WITH RESPECT TO POTENTIAL PARTNERS AND SO WHILE THIS DEBT WILL BE NOMINALLY TWENTY YEARS MY GUESS IS IN TWO OR THREE YEARS WE HAVE A PRETTY GOOD IDEA AND THIS IS SIMPLY ROLLED OVER INTO THE BREACH TO THE BIGGER PICTURE. I'M A LITTLE RELUCTANT TO GO TO THE VOTERS WITH THIS BECAUSE AS ONE GENTLEMAN SAID WE'RE NOT WE CAN'T PROMISE THAT THIS PHASE WILL DELIVER SERVICE MYTHIC THIS PHASE WE PROBABLY WON'T DELIVER SERVICE TO MOST OF OUR

[203:02] RESIDENTS AND THAT'S CAN BE A TOUGH THING TO EXPLAIN TO VOTERS THIS A RELATIVELY SMALL AMOUNT OF MONEY AND I THINK IT'S AN INVESTMENT THAT WE SHOULD MAKE ME THINK QUITE FRANKLY WE AS COUNCIL HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO MAKE WE MAKE WE MAKE THESE TYPES OF DECISIONS ALL THE TIME WHETHER IT BE FOR TRANSPORTATION OR PARKS OR OPEN SPACE. I THINK THIS IS A DECISION THAT WE HAVE THE PRAGUE HAVE TO MAKE OBVIOUSLY IF WE GO OUT THERE AND BUILD UP ONE HUNDRED AND FORTY MILLION DOLLAR NETWORK THAT'S A DECISION YOU TAKE THE VOTERS I WOULD BYPASS THE VOTERS BY THAT BUT I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE A VERY DIFFICULT THING TO EXPLAIN THAT WE'RE RESTING UP FOR MONEY TO BUILD A NETWORK THAT ACTUALLY WAN GO IN TO PROVIDE THEM SERVICE QUITE YET AND I'D LIKE TO RESERVE THAT QUESTION WHEN WE CAN PROVIDE SERVICE SO I THINK WE HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO MAKE THIS THIS SMALL INVESTMENT NOW ADVANTAGE OF GOING FORWARD NOW AS OPPOSED TO WOOD INTO NOVEMBER. ZACH IS A SIX MONTH HEAD START THIS IS GOING TO TAKE ANOTHER EIGHTEEN TO TWENTY FOUR MONTHS TO BUILD OUT ANYWAY AND WE HAVE TO WAIT UNTIL THE END OF YEAR TO FIND OUT EVEN IF VOTERS APPROVE THIS. WE JUST LOST ANOTHER SIX MONTHS MEMBER LAST YEAR WE WERE HAVING THIS VERY SAME DISCUSSION FOR THOSE OF YOUR COUNCIL LAST YEAR WE KICK THE CAN DOWN

[204:00] ROAD BUT TWELVE MONTHS SINCE WE LAST TWELVE MONTHS AND IF WE LOSE ANOTHER SIX MONTHS BECAUSE WE TRULY NEED THE VOTERS FOR THIS RELATIVELY SMALL A DECISION THAT WOULD BE NOT HAPPY ABOUT THAT SO I HEAT AND SOMEONE TO SUPPORT US. AUTHORIZING CHERYL TO GO OUT THERE IN LIES WITH SEAWEED SOUP PEAS WE CAN CAN CAN DRAW DOWN SHOULD HAVE COME BACK TO US IN THE MONTH OR TWO ANYWAY TO CUT A WOE TO HIM TO TALK ABOUT THAT IN THE MEANTIME CHRIS AND JULIE SEEM TO BE STARTING THE ENGINE AND WORKER I THINK WE'RE GOING TO BUILD THIS NO MATTER WHAT AND I THINK THE ONLY OPEN QUESTION IS HOW WE CAN PAY FOR SOLACE GET THAT WORK STARTED THIS TO THE RESOLUTION WE NEED SO THAT THE MONEY WE SPEND CAN BE ROLLED INTO THE BONDS ARM LET'S GET TO GO ON THE STREET THE SPEAKING CLOCK RUNNING TOWARDS BUILDING THIS NETWORK AND HAVE SURE COME TO US AND LATER IN THE SUMMER AND TELL US HOW WE MIGHT BE FOR THIS WHICH I THINK IS GOING TO BE A RELATIVELY SHORT TERM FINANCING THIS IS AS IT WILL ULTIMATELY TURN OUT GREAT. THINK ABOUT THIS VERY PRETTY THOROUGH ANALYSIS AGREEMENT OR DIFFERENT

[205:02] THOUGHTS AND I JUST WANT TO AGREE AM EITHER YOU SUPPORT WHAT BOB SAID A HUNDRED PERCENT THING MOVING QUICKER ON THIS IS GOING TO BE A COMMUNITY WANTS AND I THINK YOU KNOW NOT WASTING THE SIX MONTHS BECAUSE WE HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO THESE CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION I THINK IT'S THE RIGHT WAY TO GO AND I THINK OUR COMMUNITY IS EAGER TO SEE PROGRESS ON MASTS ARE HAPPY TO SUPPORT BOB SUGGESTIONS OR THOUGHTS MARRY THE WOULD AGREE WITH BOB AS WELL AND ESPECIALLY FROM THE STANDPOINT OF IT WOULD BE A DIFFICULT THING TO EXPLAIN TO VOTERS THAT AFTER THIS VOTE THEY WOULDN'T HAVE BROADBAND SO UM SO I THINK SEO PEACE OR GOOD WAY TO GO ONE THING I WANTED TO JUST AGREE WITH WHAT ANGELS DIRECTION ABOUT FOCUSING ON SOME LOW INCOME AND COMMUNITIES SAID THAT FOUR TO SEVEN PERCENT THAT DOESN'T HAVE ACCESS AND TO DO THAT IN A MANNER THAT IS NOT NECESSARILY BROADBAND JUST

[206:01] BUT JUST FOCUSES ON JUST INTERNET ACCESS IN SOME WAY AND I LIKE THE IDEA THE MESH NETWORKS. HOWEVER IT CAN BE ACCOMPLISHED I THINK IT WOULD BE I THINK A GOOD FIRST STEP TO JUST START TO EQUALIZE THE ACCESS PEOPLE IN AGREEMENT OR OTHER THOUGHTS SEE I'M I'M IN AGREEMENT IN WRITING BUT JUST ABOUT SAYS IT ALL WITH THEM. MARY'S AND INDIVIDUALS A DENIM I THINK IS IS IMPORTANT AS WELL BUT I THINK IT'S A GOOD WAY TO GO GREAT AND I'M SEEING A LOT OF NODS HERE JUST ADD MY SUPPORT IS ALL VERY VERY WELL PUT BOB IN JUST TWO OF THE SURVEY WAS INCREDIBLY HELPFUL AND AT HOW MANY THINGS PULL IT OVER NINETY PERCENT YOU KNOW I MEAN NOT MUCH ELSE I THINK THAT'S AN INCREDIBLY STRONG STATEMENT FROM OUR COMMUNITY THAT THEY'RE READY FOR US TO MOVE FORWARD. SO SOUNDS LIKE WE'RE IN AGREEMENT I'M HAPPY PROMOTION ON THE TABLE SO I MOVE THAT WE DIRECT STAFF TO PROCEED WITH THE DEVELOPMENT

[207:00] OF A FIBER BACKBONE IN SUPPORT OF THE CITY'S BROADBAND EFFORTS WITH A FAMILY INDEPENDENT APPROACH THAT DOES NOT REQUIRE A BALLOT ITEM THAT USES CERTIFICATES OF PARTICIPATION FROM THE SECOND FOR THE THOUGHTS THAT CALL FOR A VOTE THEM ALL IN FAVOR OF SWEETS UNANIMOUS YES. THANK YOU EVERY STEP OF UH THE UH THE STAFF HAS DONE PHENOMENAL WORK ON THE SIDE MADE IT VERY EASY FOR US SO NOT JUST PHENOMENAL BUT VERY RAPID AND EFFICIENT AS WES VERY QUICKLY DOWN THE PATHWAY SO THANK YOU THANK YOU. THAT'S YES THAT'S AN EXCITING MOMENT THE MAYOR NEXT ITEM ON THE AGENDA AS A SECOND READING TO ADOPT AKA SPIKE SHARE THE GREAT THING COULD JUST GIVE THIRTY SECONDS FOR PEOPLE TO SHIP THEIR SEATS BUT WERE NOT TO BELIEVE OTHER THAN THAT OF

[208:00] THE PEOPLE ARE HERE FOR HERE OKAY SO WE'RE HAVING A HEARING ON THE CLASS BICYCLE SHARE LICENSING PROGRAM STAFFERS CAN GET THE START FOR US THE COUNCIL THE DAVE CAMP A SENIOR TRANSPORTATION PLANNER FOR GO BOULDER WITH THE TIDE IS CATHLEEN BLACK E COBLE THE MANAGER WAS JUMP IN TO DOCK A SPY SHOW LICENSING PROGRAM IN TWENTY SEVENTEEN THE CITY OF BOULDER WAS APPROACHED BY NUMEROUS OPERATORS LOOKING TO BEGIN OPERATIONS. THESE NEW FOR PROFIT STARTUP TACO SPECIAL

[209:02] COMPANIES OFFER AN OPPORTUNITY TO ENHANCE MOBILITY OPTIONS WITHIN THE CITY ESPECIALLY AS PERTAINS THE FIRST AND FINAL MILE CONNECTIONS TO TRANSIT IN SHORT TRIPS IN ORDER TO BE PROACTIVE AND MANAGE POTENTIAL NEGATIVE IMPACTS EXPERIENCED BY THE COMMUNITY STAFF HAS DEVELOPED A SET OF REGULATIONS TO A PROPOSED ORDINANCE FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION THIS EVENING SO WHAT IS THE COAST BIKE SHARE IT'S A BIKE SHOW MODEL THAT DOES NOT REQUIRE DOCKING STATION SUCH AS BOULDER B CYCLE THUS TODAY AND STAFF BELIEVES THAT BOTH TYPES OF BIKE SHARE SYSTEMS DOCKING IN THE COURSE ARE NOT MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE AND COULD OPERATE A COMPLIMENTARY FASHION IN BOULDER. THERE ARE TWO DISTINCT TYPES OR OUR MODELS OF THE CROSS BIKE SHARE BIKES DESCRIBED AS SELF LOCKING UNLOCKING TO SELF LOCKING OR FREE FLOATING BY EXTERNALLY LOCK TO ITSELF AND TO BE PICKED UP AND DROPPED OFF ANYWHERE. THE ADVANTAGE AT THE POINT TO POINT CHIPS ARE EASIER TO MAKE AND THE DISADVANTAGE IS THAT THE BIKES CAN BE LEFT

[210:02] ANYWHERE. THE LAST TWO BIKES OFFER INTEGRATED LOCKING MECHANISM CAN BE SECURED TO BUY CRACK. THE BADGES AT THE BIKES CAN BE PARKED OR EARLY AND OFTEN DO NOT POSE OBSTRUCTIONS WITHIN THE RIGHT OF WAY. THE DISADVANTAGE IS THAT THESE THAT IT LIMITS THE EASE OF POINT TO POINT TRIPS TO SAFETY CONCERNS REGARDING BIKES FREE FLOATING IN THE RIGHT OF WAY WHICH CAN CAUSE OBSTRUCTIONS PARTICULARLY ON SIDEWALKS AND THIS CONCERN ESPECIALLY APPLIES TO PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES INCLUDING WHEELCHAIR USERS AND PEOPLE WITH LOW VISION AS THEY ARE THE MOST SUSCEPTIBLE TO POTENTIAL SAFETY IMPACTS AGAIN THE DISADVANTAGE OF STUFF LACKING A FREE FORTY BIKES IS THAT THEY CAN EASILY FALL OVER AND OR BE RELOCATED BY A THIRD PARTY WHICH CAN USE OLD BIKES BEING PLACED IN WELL UNDESIRABLE LOCATIONS IN SOME CASES TOO MANY BIKES HAVE BEEN DEPLOYED AND WHICH HAS BEEN OVERWHELMING FOR SOME COMMUNITIES AS THE BIKES APPEAR ON USE AND CREATES A

[211:00] SENSE OF I CUT CLUTTER. IF YOU FOUND WE WANT TO BE SURE THE BIKES THAT ARE BEING USED BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS ARE OF GOOD QUALITY IN A REGULARLY MAINTAIN THE ORDINANCE BEFORE YOU TONIGHT STAFF RECOMMENDS LIMITING THE INITIAL DEPLOYMENT OF ONE HUNDRED BIKES PROPER EATER. IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THE OPERATORS WILL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO INCREASE THE FLEET SIZE BASED UPON ACHIEVING KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS ON A QUARTERLY BASIS AND A DEMAND BASED KAPPA BE DETERMINED FOR EACH OPERATOR'S MAX FLEET SIZE AND DEMAND BASE CAP REQUIRES THAT EACH BIKE HE USES CERTAIN NUMBER OF TIMES EACH DAY BEFORE AN OPERATOR MAY EXPAND ITS FLEET AND SO IN THIS CASE TASKS RECOMMENDING TWO RIDES PER BIKE PER DAY. STAFF ALSO RECOMMENDS ADOPTING THE LOCK TO MODEL VERSUS THE SELF LOCKING THEIR FREE FLOATING

[212:01] MODEL THIS ONE SURE THE BIKES ARE PARKED IN A FIXED STRUCTURE SUCH AS A BIKE RACK THAT WILL MITIGATE OBSTRUCTIONS IN THE RIGHT OF WAY IN ORDER TO OFFSET THE NUMBER OF STOCK LISTS BIKES PARKED UNLOCKED TO BIKE RACKS THE CITY PROPOSED A FEE FOR OPERATORS TO PROVIDE ONE PARKING SPACE PER PIKE DEPLOYED OPERATORS WOULD BE REQUIRED TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT A SAFETY EDUCATION PLAN AND AN ASSISTANCE PROGRAM TO ENHANCE EQUITABLE ACCESS TO POTENTIAL CUSTOMERS WHO DON'T HAVE ACCESS TO SMARTPHONES OR CREDIT CARDS OPERATORS ARE EXPECTED TO ADHERE TO THE CITY'S DATA SHARING REQUIREMENT PRIMARILY FOR PLANNING PURPOSES WE HAVE AN UNDERSTANDING OF USER DEMOGRAPHICS AND ORIGINS TRIP ORIGINS AND DESTINATIONS THE OPERATORS WOULD BE REQUIRED TO PAY AN INITIAL AN ANNUAL FEE TO OPERATE WITHIN THE BOULDER AND THE CESAR DOS A CITY STAFF TIME TO REVIEW THE APPLICATION AND ONGOING MONITORING OF THE KEY

[213:01] PERFORMANCE INDICATORS THROUGHOUT THE YEAR AND FINALLY IS THIS ORDINANCE CONTAINS A CITY MANAGER RULES COMPONENT THAT ALLOWS STAFF TO PROVIDE SPECIFIC DETAILS REGARDING THE GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR OPERATING A POLL THERE SUCH AS PARKING REBALANCING THE INVENTORY REPORTING THE INFORMATION SUCH AS TRIP DATA MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES AND COLLISIONS WITH THE RE RESEARCHING THIS TOPIC FOR SEVERAL MONTHS NOW AND HAS DEVELOPED THESE PROPOSED REGULATIONS BASED UPON NATIONAL BEST PRACTICES THIS INCLUDES COORDINATION WITH NUMEROUS MR. POUTY THROUGHOUT THE US AND THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR CITY TRANSPORTATION OFFICIALS AND SENT STAFF INITIALLY PROPOSED A LOT TO REQUIREMENT ADDITIONAL CITIES HAVE FOLLOWED SUIT INCLUDING CHICAGO AUSTIN AND SAN FRANCISCO STAFF HAS BEEN COLLECTING FEEDBACK FROM KEY ORGANIZATIONS AND OPERATORS WHICH IS REPRESENTED AND

[214:00] APPENDIX B OF YOUR AGENDA PACKET THE COMMITTEE AND SOME OPERATORS SUPPORT THE LOCK TO MODEL INITIALLY SIZED PARKING REQUIREMENTS THE NEED FOR DIFFERENT TYPES OF BIKES INCLUDING E BIKES AND ADAPTIVE BIKES NOW ADAPTIVE BIKES ARE BIKES THAT ARE SPECIFICALLY DESIGNED FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES ON APRIL NINTH TRANSPORTATION ADVISORY BOARD HELD A HEARING IN RESPONSE THE PROPOSED ORDINANCE TAB RECOMMENDED STAFF PROVIDE MAXIMUM FLEXIBILITY FOR THE TYPE OF INTEGRATED LOCKING EXPRESSED CONCERN THAT THE HUNDRED MAX ONE HUNDRED BIKE MAXIMUM OF BIKES DEPLOYED IS TOO LOW AND THAT THE FIFTY PERCENT RATIO OF REQUIRED THE BASE IS TOO HIGH SO IN RESPONSE WE ARE FLEXIBLE REGARDING THE TYPE OF LOCK WHETHER VIA CABLE OR CLOCK HOWEVER IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WHEN THE BIKE SHARE CUSTOMER BE ABLE TO UNLOCK OR LOCK THE BIKE BEFORE AND AFTER EACH USE. OPERATORS

[215:00] WILL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY IS AS MENTIONED BEFORE TO EXPAND THEIR FLEET ON A QUARTERLY BASIS AND IF THEY ARE ABLE TO ACHIEVE KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS AND STAFF HAS REMOVED THE BIKE. SORRY IF THEY'RE ABLE TO ACHIEVE KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATOR INDICATORS AND ALSO STAFF HAS REMOVED THE BIKE REQUIREMENT AS REQUESTED BY TIME STAFF WILL WORK WITH EACH OPERATOR DETERMINE THE APPROPRIATE RATIO OF THE TYPES OF BIKES TO PUT IN BOLD OR WHETHER THEY BE REGULAR BIKES ADAPTIVE BIKES OR E BIKES AND SO AT THIS TIME WE ALSO WENT TO ADJUST BRIEFLY TOUCH ON THE RECENT REDUCTION OF ELECTRIC SCOOTER SHARE MANY OF THE DHAKA SPIKE SHOE COMPANIES HAVE EXPRESSED INTEREST IN BOULDER HAVE ALSO INTRODUCED ELECTRIC SCOOTERS THAT THIS TIME ACTING SCOOTERS ARE ILLEGAL TO OPERATE IN BOULDER PER THE REVISED CODE AND COLDER AND COLORADO REVISED STATUTE AND THEREFORE WOULD NOT BE LICENSED. IT IS IMPORTANT MAKE THE DISTINCTION HOWEVER THAT HUMAN POWERED SCOOTERS

[216:00] CAN LEGALLY OPERATE ON SIDEWALKS A MULTI USE PATHS BUT NOT WITHIN THE ROADWAY SO IMPORTANT TO KNOW BEFORE YOU TONIGHT IS CRAFTED AS AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE TO MINOR CHANGES THAT WERE MADE FROM THE FIRST READING STAFF DOES BELIEVE THAT THIS IS IMPORTANT TO GET THE ORDINANCE IN PLACE NOW RATHER THAN WAIT FOR THIRD READING. IF APPROVED BY CITY COUNCIL TONIGHT THE CITY THIS CITY COULD BEGIN ACCEPTING APPLICATIONS IN JULY AND OPERATIONS COULD BEGIN AS EARLY AS AUGUST. THE PROGRAM GOES WELL THE NEXT TWO YEARS THE SUNSET PROVISION COULD BE LIFTED. OTHERWISE THIS AND MAY CHOOSE TO MAKE AMENDMENTS TO THE ORDINANCE IN ORDER TO ACHIEVE CITY EXPECTATIONS THANK YOU AND I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THE QUESTIONS FOR STAFF THE QUESTION ABOUT THE SCOOTERS BECAUSE HE'S BEEN SO SUCCESSFUL IN OTHER CITIES AND FOR A LOT A WHIM

[217:01] IN ITS MORE ACCESSIBLE THAN BIKES OF YOUR WEARING A SKIRT IT'S EASIER TO GOSS CUTER THAN A BICYCLE FOR EXAMPLE DIDN'T CAB DISCUSS IT AT THEIR MEETING AT ALL IF YOU DO YOU KNOW YOU MENTIONED IT'S PROHIBITIVE. IT IS THERE AT YOUR MONITOR IS THE WEEK I PLAN OR TIMELINE TO BRING THIS UP SO WE BRIEFLY DISCUSSED AND DEFINED TAB IS AWARE OF THE SUBJECT. WE HAVEN'T DISCUSSED IT AS AN OPPORTUNITY YET BUT WE CAN LOOK INTO THAT BUT IT JUST AS THERE ARE BENEFITS BUT ELECTRIC SCOOTERS ALSO SOME SERIOUS IMPLICATIONS WHEN IT COMES TO THE QUALITY OF THE SCOOTER AND ALSO HOW THE SCHOOLS ARE PLACED WITHIN THE RIGHT OF I CARRY THE WHOLE BUNCH OF QUESTIONS AND I DON'T WANNA GET TO FIND THE WEEDS BUT I MIGHT COME IN THE ORDINANCE AND A SPELLING QUESTION FOR TOM THE IT REFERS TO ANY PERSON IN

[218:00] ADDITION TO FEES ESTABLISHED INCEPTION BUT THE LAW ANY PERSON ISSUED A DOCK LISTS BICYCLE SHARE LICENSE IS THAT IS THOSE THAT INCLUDE AND TEASING COMPANY'S FIRST PERSON WHO SENT IT IS OKAY THAT WAS AND ONE QUESTION AND THEN ALSO IN THE ORDINANCE REFERS TO A MAINTENANCE PLAN FOR SHARED BICYCLES AND I WAS JUST WONDERING IF THAT'S A PAIN IF THAT REFERENCE MAY NOT UNINTENTIONALLY IMPLY THAT THERE'S OTHER SHARED BICYCLES THAT ARE NOT PART OF THAT PARTICULAR COMPANY SIMPLY BE TO DOUBLE CHECK THE PERSON SO I AM HAVING HARD TIME ARTICULATING THIS QUESTION SO THE QUESTION I HAVE IS ON PAGE TWENTY OF OUR

[219:01] MEMO AND ITS ON LINE NINETEEN ITEM NUMBER FIVE WHICH IS A MAINTENANCE PLAN FOR SHARED BICYCLES AND SHARED BICYCLES COULD REFER TO PA SO BICYCLES FROM B CYCLE FOR EXAMPLE AND WITH THAT IMPLY THEN THAT THEY MAY HAVE TO MAINTAIN OTHER BICYCLES OUTSIDE OF THEIR OWN FULLY SUIT IS THE DEFINITION OF SHARED BISON TONGUE CAN SPEAK MORE INTO THE CHART IS THE DEFINITION OF SHARED BICYCLE IN THE ORDINANCE OKAY THAT I DON'T THINK WE COVERED THE CYCLE. OK GREAT I THINK IT SPECIFICALLY SAYS WITHOUT THE USE OF FIXED DOCKING FACILITIES THE MEN ALSO WOULD KIND OF RIGHT AFTER IT AS WELL WHERE IT REFERS TO A PLAN FOR PROPER BICYCLE PARKING AND LIGHTING THEM AND I WAS JUST WONDERING IF THAT WERE TELLING PEOPLE HOW TO RIDE A BIKE IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF ANY

[220:00] BIKE SHARING SOME COMPANY. I MEAN WRITING LEARNING HOW TO WRITE IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE PERSON WRITING SO I WAS JUST WONDERING WHY AND WRITING ISN'T THERE I ASSUME IT'S IN THERE TO ENCOURAGE THEM TO HAVE THE RIGHT IS COMPLY WITH THE LAW. O K RACE AND THE GENERAL QUESTION THERE WERE A LOT OF OF OPERATOR RESPONSIBILITIES THAT WERE PLACED ON THE STOCK THIS BIKE OPERATORS THAT I'M WONDERING ARE ALSO PLACED IT THERE ALSO PLACED ON B CYCLE SO FOR EXAMPLE UM THAT WAS ABOUT YIELDING TO PEDESTRIANS ON SIDEWALKS AND WEARING

[221:00] HELMETS AND B CYCLE IS ALSO HELP TO THESE RULES EIGHT SO THE CITY THE CITY ALSO HAS A CONTRACT WITH BOULDER B CYCLE OPERATING INCLUDES PERFORMANCE STANDARDS AND IT'S KIND OF A DIFFERENT RELATIONSHIP BECAUSE IT'S ACTUALLY CONTRACTING WITH BOULDER B CYCLE TO OFFER THAT SERVICE IN THE COMMUNITY SO IT'S A DIFFERENT TYPE OF ARRANGEMENT BUT THEY DO HAVE THE SAME RESPONSIBILITIES IN TERMS OF CONVEYING SAFETY INFORMATION MAINTAINING THE BIKES DOING IT AND IN A SAFEWAY AND AGAIN MEETING THOSE PERFORMANCE MEASURES THANK YOU AND I THINK THAT'S A BUMMER THE NEARBY SIXTY EIGHT JUST TO QUESTION SOMEONE MENTION THE SUNSET IN AUGUST THE TWENTY TWENTY WHERE TO SET UP SO WHAT WOULD HAPPEN THE SUNSET HAPPENS WOOD WITH WOOD WE HAVE TAKEN ACTION WITH THE AUTOMATICALLY

[222:00] BECOME ILLEGAL OR WITH THE WORD BECAUSE OF THE WILD WILD WEST WE NEED TO MAKE SURE TO NOT MISS THAT DAY TO EXTEND OUR RULES PROBABLY HAVE ASKED ALMS FOR CLEAR CLARIFICATION ON HOW THAT WORKS BUT I BELIEVE THAT IF IT'S NOT A JUST BEFORE THE SUNSET THEN TECHNICALLY THEN THE BIKES ON THE STREET WOULD BE LEGAL NOT BE LIFTED THE SUNSET PROVISION WOULD BE LEGAL OR ILLEGAL ILLEGAL ILLEGAL. OK SO SO WE'RE LETTING THE GOING THERE FOR TWO YEARS AND THEN WE DON'T DO ANYTHING THEN PROHIBITED CORRECT THAT THE DEFAULT OR THEY HAVE TO THINK ABOUT THAT SO THE WAY IT'S WRITTEN IS THAT THE ORDINANCE GOES AWAY THE CHAPTER GOES AWAY. SO IF THE UNDERLYING RULE THAT SHE CAN'T LEAVE THINGS IN THE RIGHT AWAY YES THAT BE PROHIBITED BUT WE MIGHT WANT TO DO SOMETHING CLEARER THAN THAT. OK WEDDING WILL TAKE CARE OF IT BEFORE THAT I JUST WONDERED WHICH WE DEFAULTED TO TODAY'S SITUATION FOR WHICH IS KIND OF LIKE ANYTHING GOES AND IF ALL THE USHERS SO MUCH FOR EVERYTHING ANYTHING GOES

[223:00] TODAY. YOU CAN'T JUST LEAVE THINK YOU'RE PROBABLY RIGHT AWAY. I THINK THAT'S THE CURRENT STATE OF AFFAIRS WE'RE DOING IS AUTHORIZING IT WOULD PROBABLY GUESS THE QUESTION SAYING IT NOW BUT JUST LIKE TO KNOW AND THE SECOND QUESTION I THINK THEY'RE ALREADY ACTUALLY ARE SOME PICS OF THIS TREE RIGHT SUMMED UP THE SPIKES ON THE STREET I SEE THEM. YES THERE IS ONE COMPANY RIGHT NOW IT'S A LOCAL START UP THE CALL YOUR BIKE IS ACTUALLY TWO THAT I'VE SEEN BUT WHEN YOU ARE SO SO WITH A HOW'S THIS FOR TWO FREE PASSES TONIGHT TO THEY HAVE TO GET LICENSED BY CERTAIN THEY WOULD AND RIGHT NOW YOUR BIKE IS NOT CURRENTLY OPERATING FINANCIALLY WITHIN THE CITY. THEY'RE TESTING A PRODUCT OUT WITH FRIENDS AND FAMILY NAPS OR TEN BIKES. OK THAT'S THE ONLY ONE I KNOW OF HOWEVER I HEARD THAT THERE HAS BEEN ONE LINE BIKE HAS BEEN SPOTTED BY BUILDING THIS THERE'S THE ORANGE ONES IN THE GREEN ONES. INTERESTING TO KNOW SO YEAH. SO YES IN ANY COMPANY THAT WOULD BE HOPING TO DO BUSINESS WITHIN THE CITY WOULD BE REQUIRED TO APPLY FOR LICENSE. THANKS

[224:04] AMIR VIOLENCE HIM. OK WELL ADDRESSED THE SUN SETTING BUT I'M JUST SO TYPICAL DAFFODILS COMING FROM A FEMALE PERSPECTIVE OF SOMEONE WHO REALLY DOESN'T USE BIKES TO WORK FEASIBILITY AND WHERE I LIVE BUT I HAD AN INTERESTING TALK WITH ANDREA FROM THE CHAMBER ABOUT THIS WHEN THEIR CONDITION DURING A MEETING GREAT AND HE CAN EXPRESS SAME THING AS WELL SO I KNOW THAT IT'S REALLY KIND OF SPREAD OUT AMONGST ACCOUNT BUT THE SCOOTER OPTION. WE BOTH AGREED THAT IT WAS SOMETHING THAT WAS THAT BICYCLES IN THE SUMMERTIME IF YOU'RE REALLY THE FEASIBILITY OF WRITING FROM MEETING TO ANOTHER MEETING HIM THIS SUMMER YOU'RE HOT YOU'RE SWEATING YOUR DRESS CLOTHES NOT A GREAT OPTION SO I'M GOING TO DRIVE MY CAR THERE'S NO WAY AROUND THAT FOR ME THE IDEA OF SCOOTERS BECAUSE NO BODY EXERCISE HERE'S IT'S NICE NOT TO GET SWEATY AND NOT USING MY FORCED TO MOVE THEM

[225:02] BECAUSE I MEAN I DON'T I KNOW IT'S GOING TO TAKE SOME THINKING TIME OF THE SEAT AND COME BACK WITH SOME OPTIONS CLICKING ESPECIALLY JENNIFER DRESSED FEMALES AND YOU'RE WEARING HEELS AND I HAVE TO WEAR A BACKPACK TO CARRY ANOTHER PAIR OF SHOES YOU KNOW X Y AND Z OF SO MANY OPTIONS HERE AND SO THIS COULD BE REALLY GREAT OPTION THAT I PROBABLY WOULD USE THINGS JUST TO FINISH UP THE QUESTION IS NO LONGER THE AIRING SO TOM PAGE TWENTY ONE MEMBER OF THE PDF LINE TWENTY FIVE IN IT MENTIONS THE NUMBER OF ELECTRIC ASSISTED BICYCLES ARE REQUIRED BY THE LICENSE AND I WE HAVE ELIMINATED THAT REQUIREMENT ARE TABBED PAGE TWENTY ONE VERY LAST LINE ON THE PAGE IS ONE OF YOUR AUTO TONE THAT'S CORRECT I THINK IT'S IN THE AIR AT THE TIME MINE WAS REMOVED BY LOOKS. SO I SAW ONE ON PAGE TWENTY TWO

[226:00] HE REMEMBERS BAYONET PROVIDE CONSIDERATION. WE MISS OUR MOVE I SEE HER MOVE WHICH SHOW INCLUDE A NUMBER OF ELECTRIC ASSISTED BICYCLES REQUIRED BY THE LICENSE. OK SO YOU'VE GOT THAT BOOM OF THE TENT AND COULD YOU JUST GIVE IT A LITTLE BACKGROUND ON WHAT THE DISCUSSION WAS WITH THE ELECTRIC BIKE SUBJECT BECAUSE IT GETS TO SOME OF THE SAME THINGS THAT NEARBY WAS TALKING ABOUT KNOWLEDGE TO SOME OF THEM AS FAR AS THE ADVANTAGES OF AN ELECTRIC BIKE OVER JUST A REGULAR BIKE RIGHT SO SOME OF THE OPERATORS MAJORITY OPERATORS DO HAVE AN ELECTRIC ASSESSED VERSION WHICH MAKES IT REALLY EASY THE LAPELS AND YET THEY GET HOT AND SWEATY WHEN MOVING ABOUT SO IT MAKES FOR A NICE ALTERNATIVE IF YOU'RE NOT READY TO GO OUT AND USED HIM IN POWER THE ELECTRIC ASSESSMENT WHICH ARE LEGAL IN THE CITY OF BOULDER ON A MULTI USE PATHS AND ALSO OUR BIKE LANES AND

[227:02] STREETS AND SO WE WANTED TO ENSURE THAT IF THESE COMPANIES DID HAVE THIS OPTION THAT WE PROVIDED FOR COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND SO SOME COMPANIES HAVE THEM AND SOME ARE STILL IN PRODUCTION AND TRYING TO FIGURE OUT IF THEY WILL OR NOT BUT IT WOULD PRECLUDE ANY COMPANIES THAT DIDN'T MAKE THEM BUT STILL COULD ADHERE TO THE OTHER ASPECTS THAT THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE ORDINANCE. WHAT'S BENEATH. I JUST HAVE SOME COMMENTS WHICH I'LL SAVE THAT UNTIL AFTER THE HEARING HIM ASK QUESTIONS HERSELF SEEN NINA AND HER AIRING HEIDI WHO HAVE SIGNED UP THIS POINT WE HAVE TWO MEMBERS SAME TIME OK SO THIS IS YOUR SPOT FOR SPEAKING AND COME ON DOWN TO THREE MINUTES PLEASE GIVE US YOUR NAME ADDRESS AND WE'LL START WITH NICK BARBER THE GLOBE. NICK BARBER AND I'M ACTUALLY HERE REPRESENTING LIME FORMERLY KNOWN AS LYME BIKE. UM THANK

[228:03] YOU FOR YOU DON'T HAVE HIS HEARING AND DISCUSSING THIS AND I REALLY APPRECIATE A LOT OF THE WORK AND NO PREPARATION. YOU GUYS YOUR TEAM IS PUT IN ARM. I WILL SAY THAT BEFORE I SOMEWHAT DISAGREE WITH THAT WITH THE FINDINGS OUT ASLEEP BUT UM IT'S KIND OF DISCUSS OUR OVERALL CALM CONCERNS WITH SOME OF THE RULES REGULATIONS AS PROPOSED ALL YOU WANT TO EMPHASIZE THAT WE ARE NOT ANTI RULES REGULATIONS WE JUST BELIEVE THAT THIS CASE WE'D LIKE THE KIND OF MODIFY THEM INTO A MORE COMPREHENSIVE PILOT THAT WOULD SET UP THE DOCK INSPECTIONS SYSTEM BETTER FOR SUCCESS ON THE THREE PRIMARY CONCERNS THE FIRST BEING THE FLEET SIZE. I DO UNDERSTAND THAT THERE'S THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THEM TO GROW ON A QUARTERLY BASIS I WOULD ENCOURAGE THAT TO BE MORE FREQUENT AND OTHER CITIES THAT HAPPENS ON A MONTHLY BASIS AND ONE HUNDRED BIKES TO START I WOULD SAY IS SIMPLY TOO LOW FOR OUR TWO

[229:00] FROM EFFECTIVELY ADDRESSING USE OR TRANSPORTATION CONCERNS IN THE COMMUNITY OF THE CITY OF HUNDRED THOUSAND PEOPLE WITH A LARGE UNIVERSITY ON BUT JUST NOT GOING TO BE ENOUGH. ALL OF YOU KNOW IN SOUTH BEND INDIANA WHERE WE OPERATE SIMILAR SIZE WITH AN EVEN SMALLER UNIVERSITY WE HAVE TWELVE HUNDRED OF OUR OWN BIKES AND THAT IT'S ACTUALLY ONE OF OUR MORE SUCCESSFUL MARKETS IN TERMS OF EFFICIENCY AND WRITES FOR VEHICLE ON THINGS LIKE THAT UM THAT ALSO FROM THE FT SAY STANDPOINT AFFECT THE EQUITY COMPONENT OF THIS PSALM BEING ABLE TO SUPPLY NOT JUST TOURIST PARTS OF TOWN OR DOWNTOWN AREAS IS A STALWART OF OUR COMPANY ALL BE LIKE TO ADDRESS THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY INCLUDING LOWER INCOME NEIGHBORHOODS AND IF YOU HAVE A HUNDRED BIKES TO START EVEN IF YOU GO UP ON A QUARTERLY BASIS ARM. THOSE ARE GOING TO END UP DOWNTOWN THE UNDER SERVED NEIGHBORHOODS ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO BE UNDER SERVED IN THIS REALM ON THE SECOND BOMB PART THAT WE WOULD CONTEND WITH WOULD BE THE LOCKING MECHANISM ARM THE LOCKING MECHANISM. WE BELIEVE THAT HAVING THE SELF

[230:03] LOCKING VEHICLES SUCH AS WE HAVE IT LIME BALM PROMOTES GREATER TRANSPORTATION MOBILITY OPTIONS AGAIN IN PARTICULAR UNLIKE OUTER LYING YOU KNOW UNDER SERVED COMMUNITIES ON THE FLEXIBILITY OF POINT TO POINT TRANSPORTATION IN FALL LAST MILE TRANSPORTATION IS FACILITATED WITH THE SELF LOCKING TECHNOLOGY AND WE ALSO LIKE TO EMPHASIZE THAT THE LOCK TO TECHNOLOGY ISN'T ALWAYS THE MIDDLE FOR ALL FIX THAT IT'S PROPOSED TO BE UM WE DO HAVE YOU KNOW YES STOCK SPIKES END UP IN WANT OF LOCATIONS BUT AS DO SO TO LOCK TO GET LOCKE TO EIGHTY EIGHT RAMS THINGS LIKE THAT HOME AND FINALLY THE LAST THING I WOULD CONTEND WITH IS THE PROPOSED FEES AS PROPOSED HUNDRED AND THIRTY THREE DOLLARS PER BIKE IS SIGNIFICANTLY LARGER THAN THE NATIONAL NORM. WE'VE SEEN IN DIFFERENT MARKETS ACROSS THE COUNTRY WHICH IS NORMALLY TEN TO FIFTEEN DOLLARS PER BIKE. UM SO JUST KIND OF IN CONCLUSION I JUST WANNA EMPHASIZE THAT WE ARE VERY OPEN TALKING WITH YOU AND US

[231:01] WOULD LIKE TO WORK ON A MORE ROBUST PILOT PROGRAM THAT IS BETTER SETUP FOR US SUCCESS IN THE LONG TERM. THANKS VERY MUCH THANK YOU QUESTION A QUESTION FOR HIM. OF COURSE FOR THOSE WITH THOSE THAT PHOTO WE SAW OF THAT ALL THAT MY CLUTTER ON THE WAY THOSE LIME BIKES YOURS. THAT WAS A MIX OF LIME AND OVER. I BELIEVE IN THAT PICTURE AND I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THE LINE BIKES THAT HAVE WOUND UP HERE THOUGH THERE HAS BECOME THE SERVER OR SO THOSE ARE NOT ACTIVELY DEPLOYED BY US AND OUR TEAM I KNOW WHAT THE MORNING WILL RETRIEVE SO AND SO FO IS THE YELLOW ONE IN THE THANK YOU THANK YOU EVAN RABBITS NEXT HE HAD JUST TO CLEAR UP ABOUT BIKES VERSUS SCOOTERS THERE ARE E BIKES DON'T HAVE TO PEDAL AT ALL THE TROUBLE I DON'T CHOOSE THAT MINE HAS BOTH A LITTLE ASSIST HAND OF

[232:01] THE BOTTLE I CHOOSE TO USE IT ON PEDAL ASSIST BUT TONIGHT WHEN I LEFT ONLY SEVENTY EIGHT DEGREES AND I CAME THREE MILES HERE FULLY TRUST DIDN'T BREAK A SWEAT SO AND MY BIKE SETUP TO CARRY MUCH SAY THE VOLUME OF THREE BAGS OF GROCERIES BUT I COULD EASILY ADD TWO MORE BASKETS AND CARRY SEVEN OR ANOTHER PERSON. EASLEY PRETTY MUCH COMPARABLE TO US OF AN OLD YOU KNOW WE JUST CALL A SCOOTER KNOW FORTY NINE CC MOTORCYCLE. SO CARRY ANOTHER PERSON WILL CARRY TWO THREE KIDS SEVEN BAGS OF GROCERIES RATHER THINK YOU HAVEN'T HEARD RIGHT WE HAVE THAT PATRICK CAN TANA AND THEN

[233:00] MARCUS PATCH OR THE EVENING MY NAME IS PATRICK WENT ON AND I'M WITH SO FAR ON THE GENERAL MANAGER FOR THE ROCKY MOUNTAINS TIME BASED AND UNDER THIS COUPLE THINGS WE LIKE TO HIGHLIGHT AND I THINK THAT THEY WOULD BE VERY SIMILAR TO WHAT MIKE HAS HIGHLIGHTED UM AND THAT IS THAT WE WOULD REALLY LIKE THIS TO BE A TRUE PILOT PROGRAM SO I THINK ABOUT THE DIFFERENT VARIETY OF OPTION TO BUY SHARE FROM BLOCK TO THE DOCKS MODEL ALL THE WAY TO THE FREE FREE FLOATING DOCK ELLIS LIKE LINE AND SO WHEN WE THINK ABOUT BUT THE BOULDER MARKET WE THINK IS A HUGE OPPORTUNITY FOR BIKES ARE AND WHERE THINGS GET SO EXCITED ABOUT IS THE NUMBER OF RIDES THAT WE CAN POTENTIALLY DO HERE AND ACTUALLY GETTING CARS OFF THE ROAD WHEN WE LOOK AT THE EXISTING PROPOSED PERMIT HUNDRED BIKES. IT'S REALLY REALLY DIFFICULT EVEN WITH A FEW OPERATORS REALLY ACHIEVE

[234:00] THOSE GOALS AND WHEN WE LOOK AT THE SPECIFIC MODEL OF LOCKE TO THAT IS HAS PROPOSED IT AS FICTION TO THE CONSUMER EXPERIENCE THAT THE PROCESS OF ACTUALLY RENTING THAT BIKE AND WE NEED TO ACTUALLY TIE IT TO A BIKE RACK SPECIFICALLY IT'S REALLY DIFFICULT TO SOLVE THAT LAST MILE PROBLEM. THE SMILE YOU ARE OFTEN TRYING TO GO HOME FROM THE SUMMER THERE IS NO BIKE RACK SO IT'S REALLY REALLY DIFFICULT IT IS REALLY THAT DIFFICULT TO ACHIEVE THOSE GOALS. SUCH A LOW NUMBER OF BISON SUCH AS FRICTION FILLED PROCESS. NONE OF THE LOCK TWO MODELS HAVE BEEN ABLE TO REALLY SCALE EFFICIENTLY THE WAY THE TOFU HAS A WAY THAT LINE HAS AS WELL HERE IN US OVER AZTEC ONLY BIKES ACROSS WORLD YOU MAY HAVE SEEN SOME OF THOSE STORIES IN CHINA ABOUT A TON OF BIKES BEING ALL OVER THE CITY WERE MUCH MORE RESEARCH COMPANY NOW WE DON'T HAVE THE US IS VERY VERY DIFFERENT FROM FROM CHINA'S

[235:02] HAPPY TO CHAT ABOUT THAT YOU HAVE QUESTIONS BUT THIS CAPABILITY IS REALLY REALLY KEY IN ACTUALLY ACHIEVING SOME OF THE SUSTAINABILITY GOALS GETTING CARS OFF ROAD AND HAVING A TRULY UBIQUITOUS OPTION ACROSS ALL MARKETS IN BOULDER SO I THINK THAT THE REST OF WHAT I WANTED TO COVER WAS DISCOVERED WHEN I HEARD FROM FROM XL PANTS QUESTIONS ESPECIALLY WHEN WE QUESTION FOR YOU MENTION THAT THAT WILL BE A CHALLENGE WE HAD A LOT TO SYSTEM BECAUSE PEOPLE WOULD HAVE TO LOCK THE BIKE TO A BIKE RACK TO BEGIN AN ANALYSIS OF OF OF THE DISPERSION IN THE NUMBER OF BIKE RACKS THAT WE HAVE IN BOULDER. I'M NOT A SPECIFIC ANALYSIS BUT I CAN SAY THAT WHEN WHEN WE DO DEPLOY THE TRULY AQUA SYSTEMS A LOT OF THE BIKES THAT WE DO HAVE WHETHER IT'S IN AURORA OR DO YOU. IN OTHER PARTS CROSSED US. THEY END UP IN PLACES WERE BIKE RACKS NOT MORE NECESSARILY CONCEDES THE RACE

[236:03] SITE WHERE PEOPLE WANT TO GO THEY END UP USING OUR FIGHTS AND A LOT OF THOSE PLACES ARE ACTUALLY A BIKE RACK SO HAVEN'T ANALYSIS HERE SPECIFICALLY IN BOULDER HAPPY TO PARTNER ON SOMETHING LIKE THAT BUT WHAT I CAN SAY IS THAT WHEN YOU TRY AND TAKE THIS HOME I THINK IT'S REALLY DIFFICULT TO FIND A BIKE RACK IF YOU HAVE TO LOCK INTO SOMETHING IN. ADDITIONALLY THERE'S NO TECHNOLOGY THAT SAYS YOU HAVE A LOCK TO MECHANISM BUT ARE THEY ARE THEY GUARANTEE IS ACTUALLY LOCKED SOMETHING. IN OTHER MARKETS THAT IS OFTEN LOST ITSELF FLUX TEARS I CAN ACTUALLY WALK SOMETHING SO KIND OF DEFEATS THE PURPOSE OF THAT REQUIREMENT. THANKS THANK YOU MARCUS PICTURE AND THAT'S CORRUPT THE HEARING UNLESS ANYONE ELSE WANTS TO COME SENATE SPEAK GREAT. GOOD EVENING MAYOR COUNCIL MEMBERS MARCUS PARTNER. I'M A CONSULTANT TO GO FO ACTUALLY STATEWIDE WORKING ON A NUMBER OF TACOS BIKE SHARE PROGRAMS ACROSS THE STATE AND I JUST WANT TO REITERATE SOMETHING PROBABLY THAT'S BEEN SPOKEN

[237:01] BY A NUMBER OF SPEAKERS TONIGHT IS WE WANT TO BE IN BOULDER WE WERE AT THE TAP COMMITTEE. WE'VE SPOKEN TO STAFF ON NUMEROUS OCCASIONS THERE IS NOTHING MORE THAN THE LARGEST OPERATORS IN THE DARKNESS BIKE SHARE PROGRAM IN THIS COUNTRY AND ACROSS THE WORLD WANT THEM TO BE IN BOULDER BUT WHAT YOU HAVE IN FRONT OF YOU IZZY A PILOT PROGRAM WHICH WE COULDN'T SUPPORT MORE ALL OF YOUR VERY FAMILIAR WITH THE PILOT PROGRAM AND IN THOSE PILOT PROGRAM TO DO SOMETHING THAT CITIES TO ALL THE TIME THEY SET KEY PERFORMANCE MECHANISMS. IF YOU DON'T MEET THE STANDARDS YOU CANNOT OPERATE HERE AND THAT IS ALMOST IN EVERY PILOT PROGRAM THAT YOU THINK OF THAT'S THE BAR TO ENTRY RIGHT IF YOU DON'T MEET OUR PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS STAFF IS DETAIL HOW THEY'RE GOING TO GO THROUGH THAT QUARTERLY THEN YOU WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO OPERATE HERE BUT THE DIFFICULTY IS THAT WHAT YOU'VE HEARD FROM A FEW OF THE SPEAKERS HERE IN THIS SITUATION THERE IS SOMETHING ELSE THAT HAPPENS ON TOP OF THAT THAT'S NOT THE BAR TO ENTRY. RATHER IT'S A

[238:00] COMPONENT OF THE ACTUAL BICYCLES THAT DECIDES WHETHER OR NOT YOU CAN THEN ENTER THE PILOT PROGRAM AND THEN DETERMINE WHETHER OR NOT YOU MEET THE KEY PERFORMANCE MECHANISMS. IT'S THAT INTEGRATED LOCKING SYSTEM WHEN WE TESTIFIED AT THE TAB COMMITTEE JUST TO BE VERY CLEAR ABOUT THAT. TAP A GREAT DEAL OF CONSTERNATION ABOUT THIS INTEGRATED LOCKING SYSTEM THEY REALIZED THIS WAS KEEPING A NUMBER OF COMPANIES SO FULL I'M THE LARGEST OPERATORS OUT OF THIS MARKET AND THE MOTION THE ORIGINAL MOTION ACTUALLY WAS WE WOULDN'T THEY RECOMMENDED NOTING CONCERNED THAT THEIR MAXIMUM FLEXIBILITY ALLOWED FOR THE INTEGRATED LOCKING SYSTEM INCLUDING NOT REQUIRING IT. THAT WAS THE ORIGINAL MOTION ON THAT MECHANISM SO WE WENT BACK THEY MODIFIED THAT THAT WAS THE ORIGINAL MOTION THEY CAME BACK AND SAID JUST HAVE MAXIMUM FLEXIBILITY IN THAT DEFINITION. ALL WE ARE SAYING AND I THINK THE THING WE'RE TRYING TO OFFER IS WE COULD NOT AGREE MORE WITH ALL OF YOU ESTABLISHING GOOD REGULATIONS PUTTING A NUMBER OF BIKES AND PUTTING YOUR

[239:00] OPERATING PROCEDURES ST WHERE IT CAN BE PARKED AND CANNOT BE PART AND IF IT'S PARKED ILLEGALLY THAN IT HAS TO BE MOVED IN A SET AMOUNT OF TIME ALL OF THOSE THINGS ARE TERRIFIC BUT THE INTEGRATED LOCKING SYSTEM DOES NOTHING TO MAKE THAT HAPPEN. THERE IS A PROPENSITY SOME WOULD ARGUE THAT SOME OF THOSE THINGS ARE MORE LIKELY TO HAPPEN WE WOULD ACTUALLY DISAGREE WITH THAT VERY PHENOMENON OF THIS INDUSTRY THE REASON IT IS CHANGED ACROSS THE WORLD AND COUNTRY IS THE CLASS OR CALLING THE DOC. IT'S NOT STATION TO STATION. WE'RE CREATING HERE A PILOT PROGRAM THAT IS IN WITHIN YOUR FOOTPRINT OF THE BIKE CULTURE TODAY. IT'S BY CRACKED A BIKE RACK RATE. WHAT WE DO WHAT DOC LIST OTHERS THAT ACTUALLY GOES TO AREAS YOU DON'T HAVE THOSE BIKE RACKS STILL FOLLOWS ALL OF YOUR LOSS FOLLOWS ALL OF YOU FOREIGN TEACHER PERFORMANCE. SO WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT THERE BE SOME MODIFICATIONS THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR IT I THINK YOU HAVE A QUESTION FOR YOU. SO WHERE DO YOU EXPECT THESE TO PARK EXCEPT FOR THE

[240:00] RIGHT OF WAY. JUST IMAGINE SOMEBODY AND BIKING TO A RESTAURANT AND THEY DON'T HAVE TO WALK THE BIKE NOW BECAUSE IT'S NOT THERE I CONFRONTED HIM. SO WHY WOULDN'T THEY JUST LEAVE IT ON THE SIDEWALK. I MEAN BECAUSE WE PROVIDE OUR BIKE LOCK IN INFRASTRUCTURE SPECIFICALLY SO THAT PEOPLE DON'T BUY SOME SOAP BOX SO CAN YOU TELL ME WHAT THE COMPANY PERSPECTIVE ON THAT IS SURE IF IT'S OKAY I MAY DEFER TO PATRICK AS HE DOES THE OPERATIONS AND GENERAL MANAGER. ONE THING I'LL COMMENT ON THAT I THINK WE'VE MENTIONED A FEW OF THEM TODAY. PEOPLE TAKE THEM HOME A LOT OF THE EQUITY THE MOST EQUITABLE THE PEOPLE WHO NEED THESE SPIKES THE MOST ARE ACTUALLY IN LIVING CONDITIONS THAT DON'T OFTEN HAVE BIKE RACKS RIGHT SO THEY'RE LIMITED SO WE TAKE THEM HOME THEY GO TO PLACES I WAS REMINDED IN THE TAB COMMITTEE THAT ON YOUR BOOKS TODAY. YOU CANNOT PARK IN THE RIGHT AWAY RIGHTS AND WE ALL AGREE WITH THAT FROM WHEN I WENT TO COLLEGE HERE IN BIKED EVERYDAY SENSE THERE WE CAN PARK TODAY AND THE BOULDER RIGHT AWAY. RIGHT SO YOU CAN ENFORCE THAT TODAY JUST AS

[241:00] THE SAME ISSUE WOULD BE UNDER THE PILOT PROGRAM. I'M NOT AT ALL TAKING UMBRAGE WITH THAT REQUIREMENT. ALL WE'RE SAYING IS THAT WALK TO MECHANISM DOESN'T MAKE THAT HAPPEN RIGHT. THEY LOST TO THEMSELVES ALL THE TIME THAT'S JUST A LOCK THAT LOCKS SO I'M NOT TRYING TO ARGUE WITH YOU I THINK THERE'S A LOT OF PLACES AND PATRICK AND GO THROUGH HOW WE DO THAT TODAY IN THE DATA WE COLLECT BUT WE FOLLOW WHATEVER THE REQUIREMENTS ARE THE CITY WINDS UP WHERE YOU WANT TO IMPART. THERE'S CERTAINLY NOTHING THAT PROHIBITS US A LOT OF OUR BIKES ARE IN BIKE RACKS ARE VERY SOPHISTICATED BIKE CULTURE HERE RIGHT WE THINK OUR USERS ARE GOING TO PUT THEM IN BIKE RACKS WHERE THERE ARE BIKE RACKS. IT'S ABOUT EXPANDING THE PROGRAM WHEN IT'S NOT THERE. SO HOW TO REINFORCE THE LAST THING WE WANT IS ANOTHER ENFORCEMENT HEADACHE WHAT WE HAVE TO GO THE BIKES OUT OF THE RIGHT AWAY OR SO HOW ARE YOU GOING TO PROACTIVELY MAKE IT SUCH THAT YOUR BIKES AND KNOCK AND THE RIGHT AWAY SO THE EXACT SAME WAY ANYBODY WITH AN INTEGRATED LOCKING SYSTEM WILL DO THE SAME THE CITY HAS SET KEY

[242:00] PERFORMANCE MECHANISMS THAT SAY IF YOU PARK IN CORRECTLY IF SOMEONE DOES ONE OF YOUR USERS AND THE RIGHT AWAY THERE'S A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME IT HAS TO LEAVE. SO AGAIN WE WILL FOLLOW ALL OF THAT WE HAVE A TEAM THAT COMES IN WE REPOSITION THOSE ON A DAILY BASIS GO THROUGH THAT WORK WITH THE CITY WHATEVER THOSE REQUIREMENTS ARE SO WE ACTIVELY POLICE OUR OWN PROGRAM WE KNOW WE'RE OUR BIKES ARE RIGHT THAT'S THE OPERATING SYSTEM OF THAT SO WE WILL DO ADJUST THE SAME WAY SOMEONE WITH AN INTEGRATED LOCKING SYSTEM IS AGAIN THAT WALK DOESN'T MEAN THEY'RE GOING TO FOLLOW THAT PROGRAM ANY DIFFERENTLY THAN WE ARE THAT THE USERS ARE GOING TO WE THINK AND THE REASON WE THINK WERE THE BIGGEST YOU KNOW DOING THIS BECAUSE WE'VE PERFECTED THAT OPERATING SYSTEM AND HOW TO ENFORCE AND RESPECT THE RULES THAT EACH RESPECTIVE MUNICIPALITY IS ESTABLISHED IT'S NO WONDER QUESTION PRAY IN THE I WONDERED IF YOU HAD ANY TEST OF CONEY ARE TESTIFYING FROM OTHER CITIES BIG CITIES WHERE YOU OPERATE TO THAT EFFECT THAT YOU REALLY BEEN STELLAR

[243:00] THERE HAVE MANY PROBLEMS HERE THEY'RE SPOT ON TO GET WHATEVER'S LEFT IN THE RIGHT OF WAY SHORTER THAN I HAVE IS THAT OKAY TO ANSWER THE QUESTION ANSWER THAT QUESTION FOR FREE HERE FIRST MARKET TO REALLY DEPLOY A LARGE SKILLED OXLEY IS SEATTLE EVERY OWNER'S REQUIREMENTS OF THE OPERATORS TO ACTUALLY RESPOND TO ILLEGAL PARKING PARKING IS HIS BROKEN BIKE AND A DOZEN STUDIES AND THEIR RESIDENTS ARE THE VAST MAJORITY OR SEVENTY FOUR PERCENT ARE IN FAVOR OF THE BIKE SHARE PROGRAM WHICH FOR THIS KIND OF THING IS VERY VERY HIGH AND IN CITIES AROUND THE PIPES ARE IN THE RIGHT OF WAY. RESPONSE TIMES ACTS UP AND THEY'RE CONTINUING TO PUSH THIS PER PROGRAM FORWARD FOR THE BIKES HERE BECAUSE IT HAS BEEN A SUCCESS TODAY NATE AND I DON'T KNOW IF THEY'VE NECESSARILY COLD. MR. POWELL IS IN THE AREA HERE FOR US

[244:01] BUT I THINK THEY ARE CERTAINLY AN ADVOCATE FOR THIS TYPE OF PROGRAM HERE LOCALLY I CAN POINT A COUPLE OF EXAMPLES IN PARADISE AND CITY OF AURORA HAS BEEN ON THE PIONEERS FOR THE SNOWS IN THE DENVER METRO AREA. I WAS THINKING MY QUESTION WAS WHETHER OR NOT ANY OF THE CITIES SUCH AS THE TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT FOR THE ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS OR WHOMEVER IT MAY BE REMOVING THESE THINGS FROM THE RIGHT OF WAY WHETHER OR NOT YOU HAD A TESTIMONY TO THE EFFECT OF HOW EFFECTIVE YOU'VE BEEN IN PERFECTING THAT BEFORE YOU BRING IT AND SORT OF DUMP IT ON BOULDER RACE SO THE RIGHT OF WAY SO TO SPEAK FOR I AM NOT AWARE OF ANY DEPARTMENT TRANSPORTATION HAS COME FORTH AND SAID SOMETHING LIKE THAT UM I THINK THAT IT'S ALWAYS BEEN A PARTNERSHIP WITH THE CITY TO UNDERSTAND WHERE THIS BY SIGNING UP. THERE IS AN ISSUE WHO CONTACTS YOU CAN RESOLVE IT QUICKLY BUT

[245:00] SPECIFICALLY WHAT YOU'RE ASKING FOR I'M NOT AWARE OF ANYTHING I CAN CERTAINLY FOLLOW UP AND SEE IF THERE IS SOMETHING THAT MOST THINK YOU CAN CHILL ONE ONE MORE QUESTION FOR YOU QUESTION THE WE GET THESE CRAZY WIND STORMS HERE AND THE BITES FALLING OVER YOU KNOW SEEMS TO BE ONE OF THE BIGGER COMPLAINTS IN OTHER CITIES THAT WOULD HAPPEN. MANY DAYS A YEAR HERE DUKE HAS HAVE LIKE A CAKE STAND THAT IS BETTER AT PREVENTING THAT AND SO DO WE DO HAVE A KICK STAND THE THING IS PRETTY ROBUST. I DON'T THINK THAT IT'S NECESSARILY NINE A TORNADO GOING TO KEEP THE BIKE FROM THE GROUND BUT WE CONTINUE MAKING PRODUCT ENHANCEMENTS IN RELEASING THE NEXT GENERATION BIKES MAKE SURE THAT THEY'RE CONTINUING TO BE MORE STURDY FOR SITUATIONS LIKE THIS EVERY EVERY MARKET IS DIFFRENT BOULDER COULD BE DONE FROM OTHER MARKETS WHICH IS WHY NO RESPECT THE REGULATIONS PUT IN PLACE SO THAT'S SOMETHING THAT ARE DEFINITELY AWARE OF AND WE WE

[246:03] WE STRIVE TO HAVE A PRODUCT THAT DOESN'T FALL VICTIM TO THOSE KINDS OF SITUATIONS SO WE THINK IS ROBUST AND IS IT IS STURDY RIGHT NOW AND WE CONTINUE TO MAKE THOSE PRODUCTS HANSEN'S GOING FOR IF YOU'RE CALLED UP FROM THE HERE COME ON COME ON UP AND SPEAK TO THEM. PLACE THE STATE. UM YEAH I DISAGREE FOR MUCH LIKE TECHNICAL KICK STAND POINT FROM EVERY DIRECTION THE BIKE IT'S BETTER AND BETTER BUT WE ALSO HAVE RECENTLY INTRODUCED TOM IN OUR TECH LIKE OUR BIKES WHEN THEY TIP OVER WHEN THEY ARE ON THEIR SIDE OR FALL OVER. WE CHOSE THAT IN OUR BACK END TECHNOLOGY OR TEAM PATROLLING THE CITY CONSTANTLY IS AWARE WHICH BIKES ARE UPRIGHT WHICH BIKES ARE NOT RIGHT THAT THE HELP I'VE FALLEN INTO KINK IT UP

[247:03] THE TOWER EQUIPMENT TO THE RIGHT ANY OTHER QUESTIONS RIGHT SING THEM THAT WILL WILL CLOSE THE HEARING. COME BACK TO THE COUNCIL TO HAVE A FOLLOW UP QUESTION FOR STAFF TO TOM THIS AS I READ THE ORDINANCE TO POINTS MADE ABOUT ME RIDES HOME AND THERE MAY NOT BE A BIKE RACK BUT IT IS A CORRECTED IF YOU PARK THE BIKE ON PRIVATE PROPERTY THAT THE VIOLATION OF ORDINANCES IS TO LOOK ABOUT THEM BUT I DON'T THINK IT IS THAT'S THAT'S HOW I READ IT THAT YOU COULD GO HOME THERE'S NO BIKE RACK AND YOU COULD PROBABLY FIGHT AGAINST HIS LAWYER WHO WORKED ON THE PERMISSION OF THE PROPERTY OWNER YOU CAN PARK ON PRIVATE PROPERTY OKAY GREAT THANK YOU ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR STAFF WHO WOULD LIKE TO START OFF OUR DELIBERATIONS AND COMMENTS ON THE MATTER. I'M JUST GOING AND JUST START BY READING A

[248:02] NEWS ARTICLE. THE THIS IS NEITHER THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WAS DONE BUT CHANNEL SEVEN IN A FEW WEEKS AGO ONE OF THE ONE OF THE SPEAKERS REFERRED TO THE WORST CITY PLANNER BRANDON CURTIS AND BRENDA BYRD AS IN EVERYTHING GOOD THINGS ABOUT LYME LATERAL ACTUALLY HE HAS HE'S APPLYING DIRECT RECEIVER OR A BIKE SHARE PROGRAM HE SAYS HE RECEIVES A FIVE TO TEN COMPLAINTS A WEEK OR AS A THOUSAND OF THESE BIKES ON THE STREETS IN THESE THIS IS QUOTE IT'S NOT SO MUCH WITH THEIR BLOCKING SIDEWALKS IT'S THAT THEY'RE EVERYWHERE THEY'RE TIPPED OVER THE USE OF THE MESSAGES WE HEAR ABOUT GOES ON TO SAY THAT THEY HAVE SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS WITH NO PHONE LIMELIGHT CAN GET RESPONSES. HE'S ENCOURAGING HOMEOWNERS REACH OUT TO COMPANIES DIRECTLY ONE ON ONE WAS QUOTED THE REACH OF THE COMPANY COULDN'T GET A RESPONSE TO ARTICLES ON THIS IS A FEW WEEKS AGO IN A ROW SO I FIGURE IS HELD UP AS THE MODEL OF PERFECTION. I'M NOT SURE WE WANT TO BE THAT

[249:00] THE SALMON THEN NEARBY. YEAH I MEAN I'M FOREGOING HAD A LIMITED PILOT INDUCING WHAT WE GET AT IT I'M PRETTY COMFORTABLE STARTING WITH THE HUNDREDS I MEAN WE'RE NOT A HUGE PLACE AND THERE WILL BE MULTIPLE DIFFERENT THE PROVIDERS HERE PROBABLY I'M WILLING ALSO TO TRY NOT HAVING THEM LOCKED UP THIS EARLY TO BIKE FACILITIES BUT IF WE HAVE A PROBLEM WITH IT THEN WE CAN PUT THAT REQUIREMENT IN PLACE. I MEAN I'M CURIOUS TO TRY AND SEE HOW PEOPLE USE THEM HERE IN BOULDER. I THINK LIMITING TO A HUNDRED YEARS IS THE RIGHT WAY TO START I MEAN THERE'S PICTURES ALL OVER THE INTERNET OF THE MESSES THAT OTHER TOWNS HAVE HAD AS A RESULT OF BLUES AND DALLAS BEEN ONE SEATTLE BEING ANOTHER I MEAN WHEN YOU LOOK OVER IN CHINA AND IT'S JUST INSANE SO I MEASURED START TO THIS IS THE WAY TO GO SO THAT WE DON'T END UP WITH A BIG PROBLEM AND WE CAN SEE TO THE COMPANY'S DO IS TO CLAIM

[250:01] AND COME GET THEIR BIKES AT THE RIGHT WAY OR DOES IT BECOME AN ONGOING PROBLEM SO YOU KNOW I DON'T THINK IT'S THE WORST PROBLEM IN THE WORLD BUT CERTAINLY IT HAS CLUTTERED OTHER CITY'S SIDEWALKS AND SPACES NEARBY AND THEN I'LL CALL MYSELF IN THIS AND I DON'T DISAGREE WITH AND I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE GIVING THEM ENOUGH LEEWAY TO BE SUCCESSFUL OR NOT HINDERING THEM ENOUGH. IT'S ONE ONE TIE AND BOB'S ARTICLE MEAN THAT THE THOUSAND BIKES AND HE'S GETTING FIVE TO TEN COMPLAINTS AND YOUR ONE PERCENT SO I MEAN THERE ARE THOSE PEOPLE WHO WORK IN A COLONY I FEEL LIKE ONE PERCENT IS RELATIVELY LOW BUT THAT'S JUST ME A MEAN OR EVEN FIVE OR LESS THAN ONE PERCENT IT'S GOING TO HAPPEN YOU'RE GOING TO GET THOSE PEOPLE WHO ARE GOING TO CON COMPLAIN BUT I FORGOT TO DO THIS I FEEL LIKE WE SHOULD AT LEAST DO ENOUGH TO SEE IF IT'S TRULY SUCCESSFUL I THINK IT HAS SOME REALLY COOL POTENTIAL

[251:02] AGREE I KNOW I THINK I'D LIKE TO SEE IS TO SOME KIND OF A PILOT HUNDRED BIKES DOES SEEM LOW TO ME BUT IF WE WERE GOING TO SAY ALOUD TO THE UNLOCKED ONCE THE ONE TO FIX LOOKING LIKE THIS AND THEN I WOULD REALLY WANT TO GO ON THE LOWER SIDE IF WE DO STICK WITH THE REQUIREMENT TO LOCK TWO I'D BE OPEN TO ALLOWING MORE TO START OUT TO THE PEOPLE GET BECAUSE I FEEL A POTENTIAL IMPACTS FROM THOSE OR ARE LOWER. WHAT ONE THOUGHT I DO HAVE IS I THINK THE IDEA OF HAVING SOME SEMI BIKES IN THE FLEET IS ATTRACTIVE BECAUSE IT IS AN ALTERNATIVE FOR ME. I RODE MY BIKE DOWN HERE IN RELATIVELY HIGH HEAT AND NO MORE DISHEVELED THAN USUAL. I THINK UH IT'S IT'S IT'S A GOOD TRANSPORTATION MECHANISM WHEN YOU DO HAVE MEETINGS AND SUCH SO I MAYBE WE COULD OFFER AN ADDITIONAL ALLOTMENT FREE BIKES OR FOR ADAPTIVE BIKES WHICH WILL ALSO BE CRATES WE COULD SET A CAP OF A CERTAIN NUMBER THEN SAY OR YOU GO FIFTY PERCENT ABOVE IT FOR THE BIKES ARE ADAPTIVE BIKES AN IDEA. CINDY AND

[252:03] NIGEL. SO I HAD THE PLEASURE OF VISITING LOS ANGELES AND VENICE BEACH OVER MEMORIAL DAY SO I GOT TO SEE THESE THINGS IN ACTION ALL OVER THE PLACE INCLUDING PLACES WHERE THEY WERE ALLOWED. LIKE ON SIDEWALKS AND BIKE PATHS ET-CETERA THEY WERE DUMPED ALL OVER THE PLACE I HAVE CHILDREN OF THE GENERATION OF THE YOUNG WOMEN ON EITHER SIDE OF ME AND THEY WERE SAYING THIS IS NOT REALLY PRETTY SCENE AND SO THIS IS WHERE THEY LIVE AND THEY'RE ALL BIKE RIDERS THEY RACE YOU KNOW ET-CETERA SO I'M REALLY HAPPY TO SEE THIS STARTING OFF SLOW. THEY WANT TO BE IN BOULDER FOR A REASON AND I REALIZED THERE MAY BE ALTRUISTIC REASONS IN THERE BUT I'M THINKING IT MAY BE THE BOTTOM LINE FIRST AND PART OF THE PROBLEM IS ONCE THEY'RE IN IS GETTING RID OF THEM BECAUSE IT SEEMS THAT THEY'RE MORE DISPOSABLE THAN NOT IN TERMS OF THE COMPANY'S

[253:01] INVESTMENT SO I THINK STARTING LOW IS REALLY DOING A PILOT SCENE WHERE IT GOES AND ENDING GOING FROM THERE IF THERE'S NO HARM IF THERE'S GREATER DEMAND THEIR FINE SUPPOSED TO BE REALLY GREAT FUN BUT I REALLY LIKE IT. I REALLY HEARD WHICH STAFF SAID ABOUT WHO IS WHO'S GOING TO BE PICKING UP IN FORCING ADDITIONAL BURDENS ON THEM AS WELL. CHELAN OF THE YET THAT'S A GOOD POINT CINDY AND I THINK BE GIVEN THAT THE PILOT PROJECT HOPEFULLY WE COULD SCALE BACK IF IT DID BECOME TOO BURDENSOME A THING BECAUSE IT'S A PILOT A MORE SUPPORTIVE OF SOMETHING A LITTLE BIT MORE LENIENT THE TO IT AND SEE HOW IT GOES AND SEE YOU KNOW SEE WHAT PEOPLE'S REACTIONS TO IT ARE AND THEN AND THEN ADJUST FROM THERE TO REALLY LIKE ERIN

[254:02] YOUR IDEA AND I THINK THE SUPPORT THAT FUR IS STARTING OFF WITH A HUNDRED BUT THEN GIVING IT AN EXTRA ALLOWANCE IF IT'S IF THEY'RE IF THEY ARE E BIKES. I'M THRILLED WE DO SOMETHING WHERE THE BIKES THAT BLOCK TWO BIKE RACKS CAN GET A HIGHER AND THEN DA CLASS GO LOWER. WE GET SPARSE AS I THINK IT'S A PERSON THING IN THAT VEIN AS WELL I THINK THERE'S A LOT OF GREAT POTENTIAL FOR THIS PROGRAM COLOR I WAS GOING I THINK I AGREE WITH WITH WITH WAS IN THE COMMENTS WERE MADE. I THINK AS BETWEEN THE TWO PROBLEMS THE NUMBER AND AND AND WHETHER THEY ARE UM AND BIKE RACKS I THINK THAT THE BIGGER PROBLEM IS NOT HAVING THE BIKE RACKS I MUCH RATHER HAVE MORE BIKES THAT ARE REQUIRED TO BE RACKED AS OPPOSED TO FEWER BIKES THAT CAN GO ANYWHERE. THIS IS A CITY THAT HAS A LOT OF BIKE RACKS KATHY MAY EVEN KNOW WHAT WE HAVE A LOT OF BIKE RACKS IS NOT ONE FROM MY HOUSE BUT THERE'S THERE'S ONE PRETTY CLOSE TO JUST ABOUT ANYWHERE YOU WANT TO GO IN THIS TIME QUITE FRANKLY THESE

[255:00] COMPANIES CAN MAKE SO MUCH MONEY REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY WANT TO BE IN BOULDER THEY CAN HELP US BUILD BIKE RACKS I SUSPECT A THING THAT YOU WOULD DUMP THE PLACES WHERE THEY COULD GO BACK REST OF THE EXPENSES THAT LIKE TO TRY TO NOT ACTUALLY AS PART OF THE PROPOSED ORDINANCES SAY WOULD HELP CONTRIBUTE TO THE BIKE SO I THINK I WOULD I WOULD GO ALONG THE LINES OF THINKING A HIGHER NUMBER IF THEY WERE LOCKED TO RACKS BUT IF THAT IS NOT THE LECTURE OF DOCTOR X I'M NOT ACTUALLY INTERESTED IN THIS ALL GO WITH THE STEPS ORDINANCE AND SAY A HUNDRED AND THAT HE AND REX BUT IF PEOPLE ARE GOING TO COMMIT TO A ROCKIN' THEIR BIKES. I COULD GO WITH A BIGGER NUMBER AND BY WRECKING THE BIKE STEALING THE LOCK TO MAKE A SPOT JUST TO UNLOCK THE COMMITMENT AND THAT IS WHAT MARY DID YOU ENTER YOU NOW FACE CHARGES FOR HIM TO SAY THAT I THOUGHT STAFF'S PROPOSAL OF INCREASING THE NUMBER ALLOWED EACH QUARTER WAS JUST A FINAL IMPRESSION BECAUSE IT DOES ALLOW PEOPLE TO DO BIGGER AND BIGGER BUSINESS HERE BUT AT THE SAME TIME WE CAN MONITOR THE IMPACTS AS WE INCREASE

[256:03] THE NUMBER SO I MEAN I GUESS HOW MANY KATHLEEN HAVE ANY BLOCK TWO COMPANIES ARE INTERESTED IN BEING IN BOULDER AND HOW MANY OF THE COMPANIES ARE NOT LOCKED OR SO THERE'S THREE COMPANIES RIGHT NOW THEY ARE INTERESTED IT'S ON TO HAVE A LOCK TO MECHANISM INTEGRATED WITHIN THEIR BICYCLE. THE NEXT JUMP WHO MAKES THE BIKES THE COMPANY CALLS ACTS THAT SCHISM IS AXED OR WHICH HAS A BUY CALL PACE AND THEY HAVE A LOCK TO MECHANISM IT'S A CABLE AND THEN B CYCLE MADE BY TRACK IS ALSO COMING OUT WITH A LOCKING THE LOCK TO MECHANISM THEN THERE IS SO THERE ARE SOME COMPANIES RIGHT NOW BACK AND MEET OUR REQUIREMENTS THERE ARE SOME THAT CAN OVER HOPING IS THAT THE COMPANIES THAT CAN CONFORM THEIR PRODUCT MODIFY THEIR PRODUCT TO MEET OUR STANDARDS INSTEAD OF US HAVING TO CONFORM OUR REQUIREMENTS TO MEET THEIR

[257:00] BIKE GUY JUST PAYBACK ON THAT I THINK THAT'S AN IMPORTANT POINT IN THE DELTA BUT WERE SEEN FROM OTHER CITIES AROUND THE COUNTRY THAT THE INDUSTRY STANDARDS ARE CHANGING TO HAVE MORE AND MORE OF THE LOCK TO MECHANISM BECAUSE I THINK WHAT WE TRIED TO POINT OUT IN THE STAFF REPORT IS IT'S NOT JUST A CUSTOMER WHO LEAVES THE BIKE. IT'S WHAT HAPPENS TO THE BIKE AFTER THE CUSTOMER WALKS AWAY AND WHEN THE BIKES ARE NOT LOCKED TO SOMETHING THAT'S WHEN THEY END UP IN THE TREE IN THE CREEK AND ALL OF THE IMAGES THAT WE'VE ALL SEEN ON THE INTERNET SO IT'S NOT JUST THE CUSTOMER COMPONENT IT'S WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THAT AND SO THAT'S WHY THE LOCK TO IS SO IMPORTANT FROM A STAFF MORE STUDIES ARE MOVING IN THAT DIRECTION RIGHT NOW MANY LONG RUN HAS THE SAX TERRY BELIEVED THEY HAVE THE PACE MILE NOT YET FORT COLLINS JUST RECEIVED THE PACE MODEL TO HAVE ARE THERE TOO SO THEY DON'T HAVE ANY DATA ON WHAT HAS THAT HAS

[258:00] WORKED FOR THEM YET. I THINK IN THE ONE OF THE LETTERS THEY HAD WRITTEN. THEY REFERRED US TO THE DATA WITH RESPECT TO THE NUMBER OF BIKES NUMBER OF COMPLAINTS OF BIKES THAT HAVE A SELF LOCKING VERSUS BIKES THAT HAVE A LOCK TO MECHANISM AND THE BIKES THAT HAVE A LOCK TO MECHANISMS RECEIVE FAR LESS COMPLAINTS WAY LESS ISSUES THAN THE BIKES WITH THE SELF LOCKING AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT YOU KNOW ONCE THAT HAPPENS THE DAMAGE IS DONE IT ONCE THE ONCE THE OBSTRUCTION AND THE SIDEWALK CURBS AND SOMEONE IS INJURED AND OR AFFECT SOMEONE WITH MOBILITY ISSUE THEN THE DAMAGE IS DONE THIS OVER CHINA DO IS BE PROACTIVE WITH THIS ORDINANCE AND REALLY AVOID ANY TYPE OF NEGATIVE CONSEQUENCES CAME TO GET WILLA SO WHAT I'M HEARING SO FAR I THINK THERE'S INTEREST IN THIS PILOT THEIR SUPPORT FOR AND THAT IS FOR THE OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS OF WHERE OR WHETHER WE REQUIRE LUCK TO FROM DAY ONE OR NOT

[259:00] AND THE NUMBER OF BIKES THAT WE MIGHT ALLOW ON DAY ONE SO DOES ANYONE PUT A PROPOSAL ON THE TABLE TO MOVE THIS FORWARD HERE WHILE I TOOK HER HEAD BEFORE IT STARTED A HUNDRED BLOCK TWO AND IF PEOPLE WANT TO GO UP ABOVE WITH ELECTRIC BIKES ARE LOCKED TO THAT WE ALLOW A CERTAIN MODEL OF THAT AND HAVE STAFF REVIEW IT EVERY QUARTER SO I'D BE WILLING TO SAY A HUNDRED PLUS UP TO FIFTY BIKES AS A PROJECT STARTED TO ROLL OUT THE PILOT AND AIR AND I ROOT FOR TO STAFF ITS FIRST GROCERY TOTE I'M FINE WITH THAT I MADE IT LOOK TOO I MIGHT START WITH TWO HUNDRED PERSONALLY BUT I'M OPEN TO WHATEVER NUMBER THE THING THAT I WOULD GO WITH A SMALLER NUMBER AGAIN ITS PILOT AND IF THEY'RE PERFORMING TO STANDARDS TO GOING TO BE ABLE TO ADD ON SO IT'S RATHER THAN OPENING PANDORA'S BOX. BOB AND MARY I

[260:00] WOULD AGREE WITH WITH SOME SALMON AND CINDY. I THINK I'D RATHER STILL THE SMALL NUMBER LISTEN THIS IS HAVE A SUCCESSFUL ONES LOVE TO HAVE A GREAT AND WE CAN BRING THIS BACK IN THREE MONTHS FOUR MONTHS FIVE MONTHS AND THIS IS JUST AN ORDINANCE WE CAN CHANGE IT YOU KNOW ANY TUESDAY NIGHT AND SO LET'S GO WITH THE SMALLER NUMBER I LIKE SAM'S IDEA OF PUTTING SOME UPSIDE FOR ELECTRIC BIKES MY DEALS SONGS LOOK TOO HAPPY TO HAVE A DISCUSSION BUT IT WOULD STOP THE SMALLER NUMBER WE CAN ALWAYS TURN IT UP LATER SO I WOULD CONCUR AND I LIKE THE IDEA OF GOING WITH A LOT TOO ESPECIALLY SINCE AS KATHLEEN SAYS THAT'S THE DIRECTION THAT THE INDUSTRY STANDARD IS MOVING SO WE SHOULD FOR THAT DIRECTION I THINK IN TERMS OF SAFETY AS WELL. WE WILL SEE HIM DOING TO MAKE A MOTION SENSOR GRID OR DIRECTION OR SUGGEST SOMEONE WHICH THE PLACE. SO IN ADDITION TO THE CHANGES THAT ARE IN THE RASHID I WOULD RECOMMEND THE CHANGE SECTION FOR DASH

[261:00] THREE ONE DASH SEVEN SUBSECTION J WHICH NOW READS NO OPERATOR SHOW INITIALLY DEPLOY MORE THAN HUNDRED SHARED BICYCLES RECOMMEND THAT THAT BE CHANGED TO ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY SHARED BICYCLES AT LEAST FIFTY OF WHICH SHALL BE ELECTRIC ASSISTED BICYCLES. I LIKE THE ELECTRIC OR ADAPTIVE BECAUSE OF HIM BEING A SISTER A DOCTOR OR YOUR KID ABSOLUTELY JUST A DRAFTING COMMENT ON THE WAY WE READ ADMITTED SOME MIGHT THEY HAVE TO HAVE FIFTY WERE SOME THAT COME WITH A HUNDRED NOT DO ELECTRICAL THEY WANTED TO WRITE. YES IT'S THE IDEA CAN READ ABSOLUTELY CREEPY YET JUST A SECOND SET AND MAKE A PERIOD OF HELP. NO OPERATIONAL FOR MORE THAN A HUNDRED BICYCLES AND OPERATIVE MAY DEPICT TO PLAY UP TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTY ONE SHARED BICYCLES FIFTY OF THOSE BICYCLES OR SHATTER ADAPT WHAT THE DISTANCE JUST SOMETHING WE JUST SAY NO MORE THAN A HUNDRED NON ELECTRIC

[262:00] BICYCLES AND MORE THAN FIFTY ELECTRIC BICYCLES OR ADAPTIVE OR WHATEVER OTHER WORDS I WOULD COMP TICKETS IF THEY COME IN THE MACOMB WAS SEVENTY AND TWENTY OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. I DON'T THINK YOU DON'T SEE NO MORE THAN FIFTY BIKES BECAUSE THEY COULD DO HUNDRED AND FIFTY BIKES OR WRITE ME WE DON'T WANT TO LIMIT THE NUMBER OF E BIKES IS THAT YOU GET A BONUS IF YOU'RE FOR THE BIKE THAT WAS MY IDEA WAS LIMITED TO JUST SIT WITH US OR MAYBE IT'S THE MAYOR TO PLAY NO MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED SHARED AND NINE HE ORDERED BIKE RIDE I DON'T KNOW IS THAT NO ONE TO SHARE BICYCLES THAT ARE NOT ELECTRIC OR ADAPT AS THEY MAY DEPLOY UP TO FIFTY ADDITIONAL BICYCLES THAT ARE ELECTRIC OR DEPT OF RAW BUT NO MORE THAN A HUNDRED FIFTY BICYCLES OF WHICH NO MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED BEING NOT ENOUGH TO PASS THE WORD SYMPHONY LIKE THEY'LL THINK NOW IT SOUNDS AWKWARD BUT WE

[263:01] TOOK TIME TO TIME DRAFTING IT BUT I'M READY TO MOVE TO ADOPT ORDINANCE EIGHTY TWO FORTY SIX TREATING AT THE CLOSE BY BICYCLE SHOOTER LICENSING PROGRAM BY AMENDING TITLE FOR LICENSES AND PERMITS APPEARS IN NINETEEN EIGHTY ONE AND SETTING FORTH RELATED DETAILS AS AMENDED BY TOM TOM'S LATEST TO NEED SECOND WHICH FOR THE EMERGENCY YOU KNOW THAT IT'S ALREADY IN THIS VERSION OF YOUR FINE CAME IN FOR THE DISCUSSION THEN LET'S HAVE A BOSE THE SERVER WILL CALL THE TROY IS THOM TIME TO HAVE FOREIGN LANGUAGE. SO HOW ABOUT NO OPERATIONAL AND DEPLOY MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED SHARED FRIES. PROVIDED HOWEVER OPERATOR MAY DEPLOY AN ADDITIONAL FIFTY BICYCLES UP TO AN ADDITIONAL FIFTY BICYCLES IF AT LEAST FIFTY OF THE POLICE WITH THE BICYCLES ARE ELECTED FOR ADAPTIVE THAT ALLOW YOU TO GO OVER THE FIFTY FRILLY BUT YOU GET UP TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTY

[264:11] LOCAL FOLKS KNOW I JONES TERRY AND MYSELF ABSENT IN A COMA BY THE GATES OF THE KNOWN YES THE KID. I THINK I AM I THE US. CHILL FOR THE COMING OF THE SAME ONE TO SPEAK TO DIE JUST WHEN WE AS THE GET REALLY REALLY GOOD FEEDBACK AND SURVEYS FROM THE COMMUNITY BECAUSE YOU'RE I READ AN ARTICLE JUST WHERE WE ARE HERE THAT IN SEATTLE WITH THE DARKNESS AND WE DIDN'T GET TO BEFORE WITH ONLY FOUR PERCENT ARE PARKED ILLEGALLY NOW THEY HAVE A TEN THOUSAND DEPLOYED SO THAT'S ACTUALLY BIG NUMBER BUT I

[265:01] JUST WANT A REALLY GOOD FEEDBACK BECAUSE HER FACE AND SUCCESSFUL. I THINK WE'RE STARTING REALLY SMALL AND BROADENING IT COULD BE GOOD YES CHILL SO THE ONGOING QUARTERLY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS INCLUDE HAVING THE COMPANY'S CONDUCT A SURVEY TO THEIR CUSTOMERS TO DETERMINE HOW IT'S GOING SO THAT'S PART OF THE REVIEW PROCESS AND I THINK IT WILL BE GOOD FOR US AS WELL. WE'LL CONTINUE TO MONITOR AND EVALUATE THE DOC LESS THE SAW FLOCKING OVER THE COURSE THE NEXT TWO YEARS TO SEE HOW IT PERFORMS AND WE COULD REVISIT LATER AND THIS IS ONE OF THE FALL COMING TO US JUST ON THE ELECTRIC SCOOTERS IT IF WE CAN KEEP AN EYE ON THAT AND CONSIDER HAVING TAB LOOK AT THE QUESTION OF ELECTRIC SCOOTERS SOMETIME NEXT YEAR OR SO I THINK YOU KNOW THERE'S SOME GOOD COMMENTS ON HOW THAT COULD POTENTIALLY BE TOLD YES WE WOULD BE GLAD TO DO THAT AND THEN OBVIOUSLY THEY'VE BEEN DEPLOYED IN DENVER SO THERE'S A

[266:00] RELATIVELY LOCAL INFORMATION ON THAT AS WELL SO WE'RE CONTINUING TO MONITOR AND JUST PLAIN CHAOS. ARE YOU GUYS PLAN TO ISSUE QUARTERLY REPORTER SOMETHING LIKE THAT TO US SO THAT WE KNOW AT ANY GIVEN POINT I'M NUMBER OF COMPLAINTS THAT KEEP THE EYES ALL THAT STUFF SURE WE CAN DO THAT AND ALSO UPDATE TAB ALONG THE WAY TO ENSURE THAT INFORMATION IS ALL YOU THINKING RIGHT THING STAFF AND FOR THAT WORK ON THE ORDINANCE AND I THINK WE ARE ADJOURNED FIVE MINUTES EARLY THE BODY