Transcript

Captions from City of Boulder YouTube recording.

[0:35] THE IN THE UH

[1:18] . THE ARE THE SHAME THE KNOW THE GAUGE WE'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND START OUR SCIENCE TUESDAY PRESENTATION TONIGHT BEFORE COUNCIL MEETING WITH A HALF AN HOUR AND WE VERY MUCH LOOKING FORWARD TO THEM A TURN OF THE LISA TO DO A

[2:04] QUICK INTRO OPEN SO I'M IN EVERYBODY HEAR ME. SO TONIGHT WE HAVE A VERY SPECIAL GUEST AND I AT THE THIRTEENTH OR I ARE ASKING THE COUNTY IF WE COULD INVITE DOCTOR LISA MCKENZIE TO COME AND SHARE HER LAB RESULTS FROM A RECENT STUDY THAT SHE IS CONDUCTED WITH OTHERS ON THE HEALTH RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH FRACKING. JUST AS THE INTRODUCTION TO DOCTOR MCKENZIE DOCTOR MCKENZIE HAS A MASTER'S OF HEALTH IN EPIDEMIOLOGY. SHE RECEIVED THAT FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO. SHE WENT ON TO GET HER DOCTORATE IN ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMISTRY AND SHE CURRENTLY SERVES AS AN ASSOCIATE RESEARCH PROFESSOR

[3:00] FOR THE COLORADO SCHOOL OF HEALTH. HER RESEARCH INTERESTS ARE EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT NATURAL GAS DEVELOPMENT AND AIR POLLUTION SO I SHEET IN THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL AND OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH AND THIS STUDY WAS FUNDED BY THE NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION AND WITH THAT AND NO FURTHER ADO I WELCOME DOCTOR MCKENZIE TO COME AND PRESENT THE COUNCIL AND OUR RESIDENTS THAT SOME OF THE RESULT OF HER STUDY SAID THANK YOU FOR SPENDING THIS EVENING WITH US TONIGHT THANK YOU FOR THAT INTRODUCTION AND ITS BASIS ON CAM SHOULD BE OKAY. SOUNDS LIKE IT IS SO WHAT I MAY BE PRESENTING TO YOU TODAY IS OUR MOST RECENT STUDY WE'VE DONE ON SOME OF THE HEALTH IMPLICATIONS AROUND DEVELOPING OIL AND GAS IN RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOODS AND THE FUNDING FOR THIS WORK ALL THE DIFFERENT FUNDERS ARE

[4:01] LISTED THERE AT THE BOTTOM I MEAN THE RISK ANALYSIS PART OF THAT WAS FUNDED BY THE NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION BUT THE SAMPLES WERE COLLECTED BY FUNDING FROM FROM THE DISCOVERER AND TRAP A STUDIES IN THE SUMMER OF TWENTY FOURTEEN SO THAT WAS NASA NOAA IN IN CAR AND I'M A LITTLE BIT OF FUNDING ALSO FROM THE COLORADO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT HE THERE AGO ANNA SO THIS JUST TO SHOW A NEW AA COPY OF THE PUBLICATION THIS WAS PUBLISHED IN CAME OUT IN MARCH OF THIS YEAR AND THIS THIS ISN'T SOMETHING I DID BUY MYSELF A LOT OF COLLABORATORS AND YOU CAN SEE MY CO AUTHORS LISTED UP THERE AND IT INCLUDED PEOPLE FROM BOULDER COUNTY HEALTH IN STAR THAT LOVE HELMET HE MAY BE PRESENTED TO YOU BEFORE YOU MAY BE AWARE OF HIS WORK AND THEN I WANT TO CALL OUT SOME OF THE PEOPLE THAT WERE

[5:01] REALLY HELPFUL IN GETTING ALL THOSE AIR SAMPLES COLLECTED IN THE SUMMER OF TWENTY FOURTEEN THERE INDICATED THAT BOX WITH THE STAR SELL HIM WHAT MOTIVATED US TO DO THIS STUDY WELL IN THE SUMMER TWENTY FOUR TEAM THAT THERE WAS A VERY LARGE AIR SAMPLING CAMPAIGN THAT HAPPENED HERE ALONG THE FRONT RANGE COLORADO. IT INVOLVED A LOT OF RESEARCHERS FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO BOULDER IN CAR IN NASA AND OTHER PARTS OF THE COUNTRY WHAT THEY DID IS THEY BROUGHT SEVERAL PLANES IN HAIR AND A LOT OF GROUND EQUIPMENT TO DO A VERY COMPREHENSIVE AIR SAMPLING OVER THAT ENTIRE SUMMER AND WHAT THEY FOUND THE HEAD ONE STATION THAT WAS IN PLATTEVILLE WHICH IS RIGHT IN THE CENTER OF OUR OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT HERE IN COLORADO AND THAT IS SHOWN BY THE YELLOW DOT THERE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ORANGE BLOB

[6:00] ON THE MAP THAT WAS WHERE THE PLATTEVILLE LOCATION WAS THAT LOCATION THEY CONTINUOUSLY SAMPLE THE AIR FOR BEEN SEEN IN SOME OTHER HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS FOR A MONTH AT THE SAME TIME THEY HAD PEOPLE DRIVING AROUND ON THE GROUND COLLECTING AIR SAMPLES ALL OVER AND WHAT WAS INTERESTING ABOUT THE STUDY IS THEY DID IT WITH IN THE AREA OF OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT WHICH IS WHERE THAT BIG ORANGE BLOB IS THOSE ARE ALL OIL AND GAS WELLS AND OUTSIDE THE AREA OF OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT SO WE COULD START TO MAKE SOME COMPARISON SO THAT WAS AN INTERESTING SET OF DATA AND THAT'S PART OF WHAT MOTIVATED US TO DO THIS STUDY IN AND WHAT THEY ARE FOUND IN THAT STUDY IS THAT THE MEDIAN CONCENTRATIONS OF BENZENE IN THAT AREA WITH THE MOST DEVELOPMENT WERE TWICE AS HIGH AS IN THE AREAS WITH NO DEVELOPMENT. THEY ALSO FOUND AS SHOWN ON THIS GRAPH IF YOU LOOK AT THE VERTICAL AXIS TOUTS CONCENTRATIONS OF

[7:01] BENZENE IN IF YOU LOOK AT THE HORIZONTAL AXIS THAT IS TIME GOING OVER TIME AND YOU CAN SEE THE BINS IN CONCENTRATIONS ARE FLUCTUATING THERE AND WHAT THEY FOUND WAS A BENZENE CONCENTRATIONS WERE PEAKING IN THE PREDAWN HOURS PRE DAWN HOURS OR WHEN WE WOULD MOST LIKELY EXPECT PEOPLE TO BE IN THEIR HOMES SO THIS ALSO WAS A CAUSE A LITTLE BIT OF CONCERN THINKING ABOUT THIS POTENTIAL FOR EXPOSURE TO BEEN SEEN IN THESE PRE DAWN HOURS. I'D ALSO POINT OUT ON THE SLIDE IS THE AGENCY FOR TOXIC SUBSTANCES DISEASE REGISTRY THEIR MINIMUM RISK LEVEL FOR BENZENE IS NINE PARTS PER BILLION ON THIS SLIDE YOU CAN SEE THAT SEVERAL OF THOSE PEAKS ARE EXCEEDING NINE PARTS PER BILLION THE HIGHEST ONE IS AT TWENTY NINE PARTS PER BILLION IS ABOUT THREE TIMES HIGHER THAN THAT MINIMUM RISK LEVEL THAN SORRY AND THAT'S THAT'S

[8:00] THE AIR AGENCY FOR TOXIC SUBSTANCES DISEASE REGISTRY THEY'RE PART OF THE CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL SO THAT WILL ALSO DURING THE SUMMER OF TWENTY FOURTEEN OTHER PEOPLE WERE COLLECTING AIR SAMPLES BOULDER COUNTY FUNDED STUDY THAT SUMMER IN WHICH IN STAR GET LOVE HELMET IN STARK LIKE A CANISTER SEE SAMPLES AROUND THE COUNTY COLLECTED SEVERAL WRITE IN THE CITY BOULDER WHERE BOULDER COUNTY HEALTH IS ON IRIS STREET AND THEN HE COLLECTED SEVERAL MORE MORE ALONG THE COUNTY OF ALONG THE BORDER OF WELD COUNTY IN BOULDER COUNTY IN ERIE LAFAYETTE AND LONGMONT IS WHERE HE HAD A SAMPLING STATIONS IN ALL HIS STATIONS WERE IN RESIDENTIAL AREAS SO AREAS WHERE YOU WOULD BE EXPECTING PEOPLE COULD LIVE IN THIS MAP IS SHOWING YOU WHERE THOSE ALL THE SAMPLING LOCATIONS WERE THAT WE USED IN THE RISK ASSESSMENT AND THE DENSITY OF OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT THE DARKEST BLUES WHERE THAT MOST OIL AND GAS

[9:02] DEVELOPMENT WAS OCCURRING GREEN LAST AND THEN WHEN YOU GETTING OUT TO THE YELLOW AND WHITE AREAS ALMOST NO OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT THE SUMMER OF TWENTY FOUR TEAM AND WHAT WE DID IS THIS IS A BUSY SLIDE I THINK YOU HAVE THIS FOR YOUR REFERENCE I DON'T KNOW IF I WANT TO GO ALL THE WAY THROUGH IT BUT WE DID IS WE TOOK ALL THOSE AIR SAMPLES AND WE DIVIDED THEM INTO CATEGORIES BASED ON HOW FAR THEY WERE FROM THE NEAREST OIL GAS FACILITY AND ALSO ON THE LINKS. HOW LONG THE SAMPLES COLLECTED FOUR SO SOME OF THOSE SAMPLES WERE COLLECTED FOR ONE MINUTE WHAT WE CALL A GRAB SAMPLE AND WE USE THOSE TO ESTIMATE VERY SHORT TERM RISKS SO THE RISK FROM A SHORT TERM HIGH EXPOSURE PUT IT THAT WAY WE ALSO HAD SAMPLES THAT WERE COLLECTED OVER WHAT WE WOULD CALL A THREE TO SEVENTY TO NINETY SIX. OUR INTEGRATED SAMPLE AND THOSE GIVE US A BETTER IDEA OF WHAT SOME OF

[10:00] THE CHRONIC CHRIS MIGHT BE SO MORE RISKS IF YOU ARE TO BE EXPOSED TO A LOWER LEVEL OVER A LONG PERIOD OF TIME YES THE END ONE OF THE PREVIOUS CRAFTS YOU HAD THE PEAK BENZENE HANDS THAT THEY WERE PEAKING EARLY IN THE MORNING WAS THAT A GRAB SAMPLE OR A LONGER TERM THAT WAS FROM THE CONTINUOUS MONITORING SO THAT WAS LIKE A SECOND AND WHAT WE DID WITH THOSE SAMPLES. I DON'T GET TOO FAR IN THE WEEDS BUT WHAT WE DID WITH THOSE CONTINUOUS IS WE AVERAGED A MERE TWO HOURS SO WE WE TOOK EVERY ALL THE SECOND HSE WITHIN ONE HOUR ON AVERAGE THOSE TOGETHER SO IT WOULD BE A LITTLE MORE REPRESENTATIVE OF AN ACTUAL EXPOSURE AND TWA IN THE SLIDE STANDS FOR TIME WEIGHTED AVERAGE AND THE REASON WHY WE DID TIME WEIGHTED AVERAGES ON THE THREE HOUR SAMPLES IN THE ONE MINUTE SAMPLES OSOS WERE ALL COLLECTED DURING THE DAYTIME AND AS I MENTIONED TO YOU WE HAVE SAW THOSE HIGHER CONCENTRATIONS AT NIGHT SO WE WANTED TO INCREASE THAT ESTIMATE A

[11:00] LITTLE BIT TO ACCOUNT FOR THE NIGHTTIME EXPOSURES THAT WERE EXPECTING TO BE HIGHER SO THE METHODS WE USED TO DO OUR HUMAN HEALTH AND HUMAN HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENT WORK FORM CALIFORNIA'S OFFICE OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH HAZARD ASSESSMENT AND THE REASON WHY WE CHOSE TO CALIFORNIA METHODS OVER THE FEDERAL EPA METHODS IS THAT THOSE GUIDELINES ARE MORE CURRENT AND THEY HAVE INCORPORATED MORE CURRENT INFORMATION THAT IS NOW AVAILABLE FOR BENZENE WHICH IS ONE OF OUR PRIMARY CHEMICALS OF CONCERN WITH OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT AND THEY ALSO IN THEIR METHODS HAVE NOW IN CORPORATE AWAYS FOR US TO CONSIDER LIFETIME A LIFETIME CONSEQUENCES OF EXPOSURE TO THINGS IN EARLY LIFE AS EARLY AS THE GESTATION WHICH WE DON'T HAVE AND THE EPA METHOD SO WE THOUGHT THAT WOULD BE MORE APPROPRIATE FOR THIS TYPE OF EXPOSURE. WE ALSO ACCOUNTED LIKE I SAID FOR THE HIGHER NIGHTTIME LEVELS OF HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS BY USING THIS TIME WEIGHTED AVERAGE JANE

[12:02] AND WE WE ONLY ASSESS THE HEALTH EFFECTS FROM HYDROCARBONS THAT HAVE BEEN MEASURED IN THOSE THINGS THAT HAD BEEN ASSOCIATE WITH OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT. WE DID NOT ASSESS EXPOSURES TO OZONE PARTICULATES MATTER OR CARBON EELS WHICH ISN'T ANOTHER COMPOUND THAT MIGHT BE ASSOCIATE WITH OIL GAS DEVELOPMENT. WE DIDN'T HAVE THOSE MEASURES. AND THEN AS SO FOR THAT THOUGH SHORT TERM ACUTE EXPOSURES SO THIS IS IF YOU WERE TO BE EXPOSED TO A HIGH CONCENTRATION FOR A VERY SHORT TERM WE WILL USE MAXIMUM CONCENTRATIONS MAXIM DETECTED CONCENTRATIONS FOR THE CHRONIC EXPOSURE SO LONG LONG TIME EXPOSURE TO LOWER CONCENTRATIONS WE USED A TIME WEIGHTED AVERAGES OR MEDIAN CONCENTRATIONS FOR THE NON CANCER HEALTH EFFECTS SO IN RISK ASSESSMENT WE DIVIDE THE HEALTH EFFECTS INTO

[13:01] CANCER IN NON CANCER THAT'S WHAT IS TYPICALLY DONE SO FOR THE NON CANCER HEALTH EFFECTS WE ASSUMED SOMEONE WAS EXPOSED TO THIS CHEMICAL FOR FOR THE CHRONIC EXPOSURES TWENTY FOUR HOURS A DAY THREE HUNDRED AND FIFTY TO THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTY FIVE DAYS A YEAR FOR MORE THAN SEVEN YEARS SO THAT'S THOSE ARE PRETTY VERY PROTECTIVE EXPOSURE MEASURES WHAT DISEASES ARE UNDER THE NON CANCER MEDICAL NON CANCER IT CATEGORY IS A WHOLE HOST OF DISEASES SO WHEN WE GO FURTHER AND THE RISK ASSESSMENT THEN WE START TO DIVIDE AMOUNT TO RESPIRATORY EFFECTS AND NEUROLOGICAL EFFECTS AND THINGS LIKE THAT THAT WE DON'T LOOK AT SPECIFIC DISEASES WITH THE SOCKS PLAIN THAT A LITTLE BIT AS WE GET A LITTLE FURTHER AND ON FOR THE CANCER AFFECTS WE ASSUME THAT PEOPLE WERE IN THEIR HOMES SEVENTY TWO TO EIGHTY FIVE PERCENT OF THEIR TIME AND THAT WAS THOSE

[14:00] PERCENTAGES VARY ON THE AGE OF THE PERSON AND WE CAN ACCOUNT FOR THAT IN THE EQUATIONS THAT WE USE IN THAT THEY'RE THERE FOR A THIRTY YEAR PERIOD SO ONCE AGAIN THIS IS A THIS IS WHAT WE CALL REASONABLE MAXIMUM EXPOSURE. HE'LL LIKELY MOST PEOPLE ARE IN THE SAME HOME FOR THIRTY YEARS BUT THEY MAY BE LIVING IN THE SAME AREA FOR THAT AMOUNT OF TIME SELL WHAT WE FOUND THE FIRST THING I WANT TO WALK YOU THROUGH IS JUST THE CONCENTRATIONS THAT WE OBSERVED IN THE SAMPLE SO THESE ARE THE ONE MINUTE SAMPLES THAT WERE BEING COLLECTED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF IRVINE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE THEY WERE DRIVING AROUND COLLECTING GRAB SAMPLES AT VARIOUS DISTANCES FROM OIL GAS FACILITIES ROADS OTHER INDUSTRIAL FACILITIES IN JUST WHAT THEY THOUGHT WERE GOOD BACKGROUND LOCATIONS AND WHAT WE HAVE TO HAVE FIVE DIFFERENT CHEMICALS THERE BEEN SEEN TELL YOU WHEN ETHEL BINS IN TOTAL SILENCE AND

[15:00] THEN UP IN THE UPPER RIGHT HAND CORNER IS ALL THE AL CANE SCREWED TOGETHER THEIR TOXICITY FACTORS ARE VERY SIMILAR TO EACH OTHER FOR THIS TYPE OF ASSESSMENT AND ALONG THE HORDES. SO THE CONCENTRATIONS ONCE AGAIN EARNED THE VERTICAL AXIS IN THOSE OR LOG SCALES AND THE DISTANCE CATEGORIES THAT WE LOOK AT ARE ON THE HORIZONTAL AXIS AND THE DISTANCES WE LOOKED AT WERE GREATER THAN SIXTEEN HUNDRED METERS OR ONE MILE FROM AN OIL AND GAS WELL THEN THE CLOSEST WE LOOKED AT WAS WITHIN FIVE HUNDRED FEET OR HUNDRED AND FIFTY TWO METERS AND WHAT YOU CAN SEE THERE IS FOR ALL OF THOSE HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS BINS IN TOTAL OUR CANES TIGHT TUSSLE BEEN SEEN AND THE SILENCE THERE ARE SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER AND WITHIN THAT FIVE HUNDRED FOOT RANGE AND SO THAT'S KIND OF THE TAKEAWAY POINT FROM

[16:00] THE SLIDE WE DID THE SAME KIND OF COMPARISON FOR THE CANISTER SAMPLES THAT HAD BEEN COLLECTED BY IN STAR AND ALSO BY THE COLORADO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AT THEIR PLATTEVILLE LOCATION AND WHEN WE LOOK AT THOSE SO BOLD OR THE CITY OF BOULDER THAT'S FROM THAT STATION AT IRIS NOT MUCH OIL AND GAS AROUND THERE BUT A LOT OF OTHER AIR POLLUTION IS THERE MAINLY FROM TRAFFIC EAST THE SAMPLES WERE COLLECTED ALONG THE BORDER OF WELD AND BOULDER COUNTY AND THE PLATTEVILLE LOCATION AND YOU CAN SEE THERE THAT THE CONCENTRATIONS OF THESE HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS REALLY AREN'T THAT MUCH DIFFERENT THAN BOULDER ALTHOUGH WE DID SEE SLIGHTLY HIGHER CONCENTRATIONS OF ALL OF THEM IN PLATTEVILLE IN ERIE. COMPARED TO BOULDER WE'RE GOING TO TELL US WHY WELL THEY DON'T BECAUSE OF

[17:00] WELL BECAUSE OUR BOULDER LOCATION WAS ACTUALLY AT THAT BUSY INTERSECTION SO HAD A LOT OF TRAFFIC INFLUENCE THERE. WHY THEY WEREN'T SIGNIFICANT. UM WHY WE DIDN'T SEE ANY STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE IS WE DIN YOU'LL SEE THIS IN ANOTHER SLIDE WE DID SEE THAT THE HIGHEST BENZENE CONCENTRATIONS WERE ALWAYS BEING OBSERVED IN THE AREAS OF OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT THOSE ARE HIGHER THAN THAT INTERSECTION AT BOULDER THE CANES TENDED TO BE HIGHER IN BOULDER THAN THEY WERE SOME OF THE ARCADES NOT ALL OF THEM SOUL WHAT WE DO WITH THIS KIND OF DATA IS WERE WE TAKE THESE CONCENTRATIONS THAT WE'VE OBSERVED IN THE AIR SAMPLES AND WE COMPARE THEM TO WHAT WE CONSIDER TO BE A SAFE DOSE OR DOSE AT WHICH WE TALK SISSY STUDIES HAVEN'T OBSERVED ANY EFFECTS AND SO I PUT THIS TOXICITY CURVE HERE JUST TO REMIND US OF WHAT THAT IS SO WHAT THEY TYPICALLY DO TO COME UP WITH THESE VALUES AS THEY DO AN ANIMAL STUDY WITH BENZENE THEY'VE BEEN ABLE TO

[18:00] USE SOME OCCUPATIONAL HUMAN STUDIES BUT TYPICALLY THIS IS DONE WITH AN ANIMAL STUDY AND WHAT THEY DO IS THEY INCREASE THE DOSE OF A CHEMICAL THAT THEY EXPOSE AN ANIMAL TOO AND THEY WATCH THE ANIMALS TO WHEN THEY HAVE A HEALTH EFFECT AND THEY GROW THEY MAKE A GRAPH OF THAT AND THEY DETERMINE THE LEVEL AT WHICH THEY EITHER DON'T SEE ANY EFFECT IN THE ANIMALS OR THEY SEE THE LEAST HEALTH EFFECT IN THE ANIMALS SO I KIND OF HAVE A ANOTHER ONE SO THEN THEY TAKE THAT LEVEL AT WHICH THEY SAW AT LEAST MAYBE ONE ANIMAL HAD AN EFFECT AND THEN THEY DIVIDE THAT BY SOME UNCERTAINTY FACTORS BECAUSE THEY'RE GOING FROM ANIMAL TO HUMANS SO THAT OUR SUMMONS UNCERTAINTY THEY WANT TO CONSIDER AND UNCERTAINTY FOR SENSITIVE POPULATIONS IN THAT TYPE OF THING AND THAT'S HOW THEY COME UP WHAT WE CALL A REFERENCE STOSUR OF THE SAFE DOSE AND THEN THE NEXT THING YOU DO IN THE RISK ASSESSMENT

[19:00] IS YOU TAKE THE CONCENTRATION THAT YOU SAW IN THE AIR AND YOU DIVIDE IT BY THE SAFE DOSE SO SIMPLE RATIO IN OF THE SAFE DOSE IN THE CONCENTRATION THE AIR THE SAME THEN YOU ASSUME IT'S NOT LIKELY THE HEALTH EFFECTS ARE GOING TO OCCUR. HOWEVER IF THE CONCENTRATION THAT YOU OBSERVED IS GREATER THAN THAT SAFE DOSE THAT RATIOS GOING TO BE OVER ONE IN THEN YOU WOULD CONCLUDE THAT THERE MIGHT BE THERE IS A POTENTIAL FOR A HEALTH EFFECT OF SOMEONE TO WORK TO BE EXPOSED TO THAT. SO THAT'S CALLED HAZARD QUESTION IT'S A SIMPLE RATIO YOU DO THAT FOR EACH CHEMICAL THEN YOU ADD ALL THOSE HAZARD CUSHIONS TOGETHER TO COME UP WITH SOMETHING CALLED HAZARD INDEX AND IT WORKS THE SAME WAY IF IT'S OVER ONE YOU ASSUME THAT HEALTH EFFECTS MAY OCCUR. SO THESE ARE THE HAZARD INDICES THAT WE CALCULATED FOR THE DIFFERENT DISTANCES AND IN ALL OF THESE WE HAVE THE CHRONIC HAZARD INDEX. SO FOR A LONG TERM EXPOSURE AND THEN RIGHT BENEATH IT WILL BE

[20:00] THE ACUTE FOR THE SHORT SHORTER EXPOSURE AND I'VE INDICATED THERE WITH A RED ARROW WHERE ONE IS SO IF IT'S A BOD THAT ON THE HORIZONTAL AXIS. THEN WE MIGHT THINK THAT HEALTH HEALTH EFFECTS COULD OCCUR DOESN'T MEAN THAT THEY WILL OCCUR. THIS IS THIS IS THE ESTIMATE SO WHAT WE FOUND WAS THAT FOR THOSE THAT WERE LIVING WITHIN FIVE HUNDRED FEET OR HUNDRED AND FIFTY TWO METERS AT THE WELL THAT THOSE HAZARD INDICES WERE GREATER THAN ONE FOR BOTH CHRONIC AND ACUTE EXPOSURE SCENARIO WE FOUND FOR THE OTHER SCENARIOS THAT THERE WERE ALL LESS THAN ONE SO THE TAKEAWAY FROM THIS IS THAT FOR THOSE THAT WERE LIVING NEAREST TO THE WELLS MAY HAVE AT RISK FOR HEALTH AFFECTS THOSE LIVING FURTHER AWAY DON'T SEEM TO BE AT THAT RISK AND THESE ARE NON CANCER WE DID THE SAME THING WITH THE BOULDER COUNTY RESULTS

[21:00] AND REALLY OVERALL WHAT WE FOUND WAS THAT THE WE DID HAVE ONE OF THE MONTH FROM THE ONES COLLECTED ALONG THE BORDER THAT WAS SLIGHTLY OVER ONE NOT MUCH OVER ONE WE DIDN'T REALLY SEE ANY UM ALARMING INDICATION OF HEALTH EFFECTS NON CANCER HEALTH EFFECTS HERE. ALTHOUGH ALL POINT OUT TO YOU AGAIN THE BLUE BAR IS THE BINS IN CONTRIBUTION TO THAT AND YOU CAN SEE IT THAT THE HIGHEST BENZENE CONCENTRATIONS ARE HIGHER IN THE OIL GAS FIELDS RISKS ARE HIGHER THAN OIL GAS FIELDS AND THEY ARE IN BOULDER COUNTY SO THAT'S HOW WE DID THE NON CANCER WE GET TO THE CANCER WHICH I'M IN A KIND OF EXPLAIN WHAT WE ARE LOOKING OUT FIRST BEFORE I TELL YOU WHAT THE RESULTS WERE WHAT WE WERE CALCULATING WAS AND LIFETIME EXCESS

[22:01] CANCER RISK AND TO PUT THIS INTO PERSPECTIVE. WE IN THE UNITED STATES HAVE A THIRTY TO FORTY PERCENT CHANCE OF GETTING CANCER IN OUR LIFETIME THAT'S OUR TOTAL CANCER RISK FOR A LOT OF DIFFERENT REASONS AND SO THAT IS INDICATED BY THE YELLOW SHADED AREA OF THESE MILLION PEOPLE ON THIS GRAPH IF YOU LOOK DOWN THERE IN THE LOWER RIGHT HAND CORNER. WHAT I HAVE SHADED THERE AND KIND OF A MAGENTA PINK COLOR THAT WOULD BE LIFETIME EXCESS CANCER RISK THAT YOU WOULD GET FROM EXPOSURE TO THE SITE OK SO THAT IS IN ADDITION TO THIS THIRTY TO FORTY PERCENT CHANCE YOU ALREADY HAVE OF GETTING CANCER IN YOUR LIFETIME SO I WANT TO PUT THIS INTO PERSPECTIVE FOR YOU WHAT THIS REALLY MEANS IN THE NUMBERS AND EPA HAS THRESHOLDS FOR THIS SO THEIR TEAM IN AMOS RISK IS ONE IN A

[23:01] MILLION SO THAT'S ONE MORE CANCER IN A MILLION PEOPLE BASED ON EXPOSURE TO THAT TO WHATEVER YOU'RE LOOKING AT AND THEIR UPPER THRESHOLD IS A HUNDRED IN A MILLION OR TEN OUT OF TEN THOUSAND BC SKIS ME ONE OUT OF TEN THOUSAND SO WHAT WE FOUND WAS THE FIRST OF ALL ALL THE SITES WILL HIT CITY OF BOULDER INCLUDED NOT TERRIBLY SURPRISING EXCEEDED EPA ZZ DE MINA MOST RISK FOR EXCESS LIFETIME CANCER IS AND THAT'S BECAUSE BENZENE CONSTANT BENZENE IS UBIQUITOUS IN THE ENVIRONMENT IT'S A LOT OF OTHER SOURCES OF BENZENE IN OIL GAS COMES FROM TRAFFIC CAN COME FROM GAS STATIONS THERE OTHER PLACES AND ALSO BOULDERS AIR MAYBE BEING INFLUENCED BY THE OIL AND GAS FIELDS TO THE EAST UP BUT AS WE MOVE CLOSER TO THE OIL AND GAS WELLS YOU CAN SEE WHAT'S HAPPENING THERE IS THAT THAT

[24:03] EXCESS LIFE LIFETIME EXCESS CANCER RISK IS INCREASING AND BY THE TIME WE GET TO THOSE LIVING WITH AND ABOUT A THOUSAND FEET. WE'RE REACHING THE A'S UPPER THRESHOLD OF ONE IN TEN THOUSAND WHICH IS INDICATED WITH A RED ARROW THERE TO THE RIGHT AND WHEN WE GET WITHIN FIVE HUNDRED FEET WE ARE EIGHT TIMES HIGHER THAN EPA HSE UPPER THRESHOLD AND BENZENE IS DRIVING THAT EXPOSURE TO BENZENE AND HOW MANY WOULD THAT BE PER MILLION SO THAT WOULD BE PER MILLION AND THAT WOULD BE EIGHT HUNDRED PER MILLION ALMOST ON A THOUSAND SO THE STRENGTHS OF THIS STUDY WERE THAT WE USED RESIDENTIAL EXPOSURE

[25:00] SCENARIOS AND WE WERE ABLE TO BECAUSE OF ALL THE WORK THAT HAD BEEN DURING DONE DURING THE SUMMER TWENTY FOURTEEN WE'RE REALLY ABLE TO INCORPORATE A LOT OF SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL REZ VARIABILITY THAT HAD NOT BEEN CONSIDERED BEFORE WE ARE ABLE TO CONSIDER THOSE SHORT TERM EXPOSURES TO HIGH LEVELS OF AIR POLLUTANTS WHICH WE HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO ADDRESS BEFORE IN WHICH WE THINK ARE IMPORTANT. WE ALSO HAD SOME GOOD REFERENCE SITE SO THAT HAVING THAT TRAFFIC IMPACTED SITE IN BOULDER I THINK WAS A REALLY POWERFUL PART OF THE STUDY BECAUSE WE'RE ABLE TO SHOW IT EVEN WITH TRAFFIC BEING CONSIDERED THESE BINS IN CONCENTRATIONS ARE HIGHER IN THE OIL AND GAS AREAS AND FINALLY OURS. OUR FINDINGS WERE CONSISTENT WITH SOME OF THE HEALTH EFFECTS AS WE'VE BEEN SEEN IN THE EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES AND OTHER RISK ASSESSMENTS THE POWER WE DID HAVE A LOT OF LIMITATIONS TO ONE THING I JUST REALLY WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR WITH WITH RISK

[26:04] ASSESSMENT SAYS THEY'RE NOT EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES THEY ARE SANE. IF SOMEONE WERE TO BE EXPOSED TO THIS CONCENTRATION THAT WE'VE OBSERVED IN THE AIR HERE IS WHAT THE HEALTH RISK MIGHT BE WE DON'T KNOW THAT ANYONE'S BEEN EXPOSED TO THAT CONCENTRATION AT THIS POINT OF TIME AND TIME AND THAT'S ACTUALLY IN MY FUTURE STEPS WE'D LIKE TO KNOW WHAT THE WHAT PEOPLE REALLY HAVE BEEN EXPOSED TO ARE BEING EXPOSED TO HIM. THERE'S LESS LIMITED INFORMATION ON THE TOXICITY AT THE LEAD AT THE LEVELS WERE OBSERVING MOST OF THE TESTS ARE DONE A VERY HIGH LEVELS OF THESE CONCENTRATIONS OF THESE POLLUTANTS LIKE I SAID WE DIDN'T HAVE INFORMATION ON ALL THE AIRPLANES THAT ARE SO SOAKED WITH OIL GAS DEVELOPMENT. MOST SAMPLES WERE COLLECTED IN THE DAYTIME SO WE REALLY DON'T THINK WE HAVE A GOOD HANDLE ON WHAT THOSE NIGHTTIME EXPOSURES MIGHT BE AND WE JUST LOOKED AT ONE SEASON. SUMMER SUMMER OF TWENTY FOURTEEN WE THINK THE REASON WHY WE SEE HIGHER CONCENTRATIONS AT NIGHT TIME IS BECAUSE OF THE IN VERSIONS

[27:00] THAT OCCUR AT NIGHT TIME THINGS GET TRAPPED NEAR THE SURFACE THAN THE SUN COMES UP IN COLUMN BREAKS UP AND THEY DISPERSE THE WINTER THERE ARE MORE THOSE IN VERSIONS AND THEY LAST LONGER WITH THE WITH THE COLD TEMPERATURES SO WE MIGHT EXPECT THAT CONCENTRATIONS MIGHT BE HIGHER SO THOSE ARE FEW THE LIMITATIONS I JUST BRIEFLY WANT TO GO OVER WHAT THE POLICY IMPLICATIONS ARE CUZ WE HAD SOME OF THIS IN OUR PAPER ALSO IT'S IMPORTANT TO KNOW THAT TENS OF THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE IN COLORADO BY LIVING WITHIN FIVE HUNDRED FEET OF AN OIL GAS WELL EVEN THOUGH OUR SETBACK DISTANCES NOW FIVE HUNDRED FEET. STATE LAW IN THE STATE LAWS. SO IF WE LOOK AT THE CANCER BURDEN MANY MORE CANCERS WE WOULD EXPECT JUST IN THAT POPULATION LIVING WITHIN FIVE HUNDRED FEET WE WOULD EXPECT FOURTEEN ADDITIONAL CANCERS WHICH DOESN'T SOUND LIKE A BIG NUMBER BUT IF YOU ARE ONE OF THOSE FOURTEEN PEOPLE THAT IS THAT'S A HORRIBLE NUMBER RATE SO THEY DON'T WANT TO MAKE LIGHT OF THAT NUMBER IN AWE

[28:03] AND WE'VE ALSO IN I STAY THAT WE DID ON THE POPULATION ACTUALLY BEEN AROUND THE SITES IS THIS POPULATION WITHIN FIVE HUNDRED FEET IS GROWING FASTER THAN THE GENERAL POPULATION HERE IN WELD QUAY IN NORTHEASTERN COLORADO. SO TAKING INTO WHY THAT MIGHT BE IS WHY WE DO HAVE A SETBACK DISTANCES FROM THE C O G C C THAT'S A WELL HOUSE TO BE FIVE HUNDRED WHEN THEY DRILL WELL HAS TO BE FIVE HUNDRED FEET FROM THE RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURE HISTORICALLY THAT DISTANCE WAS ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY OR THREE HUNDRED FEET DEPENDING ON HOW DENSE THE POPULATION WAS AND THOSE WELLS DIDN'T GO AWAY THOSE WELLS ARE STILL THERE. THERE'S NOT A REVERSE SETBACK THAT CONSISTENTLY ACROSS THE STATE SO THERE'S NO THERE'S NOT CONSISTENTLY ANY REGULATIONS OR ZONING ABOUT WHERE YOU CAN BUILD A HOME IN RELATION TO AN OIL AND GAS WELL AND WE'VE SEEN HERE ALONG THE FRONT RANGE

[29:00] THAT HOMES ARE BEING BUILT CLOSER THAN FIVE HUNDRED FEET TO OIL GAS WELLS AND FINALLY THESE SETBACKS ARE REALLY ONLY ADDRESSING THE WELLS THEY'RE NOT ADDRESSING ALL THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF OIL AND GAS FACILITIES THAT ARE REQUIRED TO DEVELOP OIL AND GAS IN A REGION LIKE THE COMPRESSOR STATIONS GATHERING LINES AND ALL THAT TYPE OF STUFF TANKS ALL JUST THROW THAT WENT IN AND WITH THE EXISTING WELLS BOULDER COUNTY DID A STUDY RECENTLY WHERE THEY FOUND THAT MANY OF THE OLDER AND SMALLER SITES HAD SOME MALFUNCTIONS THAT WERE CAUSING LEAKS THEY FOUND SIXTY FIVE PERCENT OF ONE HUNDRED AND FORTY FIVE OIL AND GAS SITES WERE HAD GAS LEAKS. SO IF THEY'RE LEAKING METHANE. I THINK IT'S PRETTY SAFE TO ASSUME THEY MAY BE LEAKING SOME OF THESE OTHER HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS AND I'VE LISTED WHERE THOSE ARE COMING FROM AND WHAT THEY TYPICALLY HAVE DONE TO DO THE INN SINCE FACTIONS IS

[30:00] WHAT THEY CALL A VO EXPECIALLY INSPECTIONS AUDIO VISUAL OLFACTORY INSPECTIONS THOSE MISS MOST OF THE LEAKS THE BOULDER COUNTY WENT OUT AND USED AN INFRARED CAMERA WHICH WAS MUCH MORE EFFECTIVE IN FINDING LEAKS SO THOSE ARE THINGS FOR POLICYMAKERS TO BE THINKING ABOUT AND WHERE POLICY CAN HAVE AN EFFECT HERE SO JUST TO CONCLUDE THESE ARE CONCLUSIONS I DON'T KNOW IF I NEED TO READ THEM TO YOU THEY'RE UP HERE BUT WE WE REALLY ARE EMPHASIZING THAT THOSE PEOPLE ARE LIVING NEAREST TO THESE WELLS REALLY ARE BURYING THE GREATEST RISK OF THE DEVELOPMENT COMPARING TWO PEOPLE ARE ARE FURTHER AWAY AND I DON'T. THEREFORE YOU KNOW THE POLICIES NEED TO BE CONSIDERING THAT AND THERE COULD BE SOME REALLY SOME SERIOUS ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE ISSUES HERE BOTH IN

[31:00] PROCEDURAL JUSTICE AND WE HAVEN'T YET HAD A CHANCE TO LOOK AT HOW THIS IS SHAKING OUT WITH SOME OF THE OTHER DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION ABOUT PEOPLE LIKE SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS AND RACE AROUND THE SITES. SO THESE ARE THE WANTED TO GET TO THIS IST THESE ARE WHAT WE WOULD LIKE OUR NEXT STEPS TO BE WOULD REALLY LIKE TO MEASURE SOME EXPOSURES AT PEOPLE'S HOMES REALLY SEE WHAT THE CONCENTRATIONS ARE IN THEIR HOUSES OVER VARYING DISTANCES FROM THE SITES COLLECT URINE AND BLOOD SAMPLE SO WE CAN LOOK AT SOME BIO MARKERS OF EXPOSURES TO SEE WHAT THEIR INTERNAL DOSES AND ALSO IN THE SAME BIO MARKERS WE CAN START LOOKING FOR SOME SOME COULDN'T SUB CLINICAL HEALTH EFFECTS AND SOME OF THEM ARE JUST AS SIMPLE AS LOOKING AT BLOOD PRESSURES WHICH ISN'T TOO COMPLICATED SO WITH THAT I THINK I THINK I REALLY THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE TO PRESENT OUR RESULTS TO YOU AND TAKE ANY QUESTIONS

[32:02] THAT YOU WILL OR MAYBE THE FIRST TO THANK YOU. THIS IS VERY INFORMATIVE AND RELEVANT VERY TIMELY TO DISCUSSION WILL BE HAVING LATER TONIGHT WE'RE SUPPOSED TO START OUR OFFICIAL MEETING HERE SHORTLY SO WE PLAY AT ONE TIME FOR ONE QUESTION AND SAM PUT UP HIS HAND FIRST JUST A QUICK QUESTION. THIS APPLIES TO ALL PARTS OF THE HYDROCARBON CHAIN RIGHT WHICH INCLUDES OIL AND GAS WHICH IS OUT IN THE FIELDS HAVE THERE BEEN STUDIES LIKE THIS TOWN THAT REFINERIES AND OTHER PARTS OF THE OIL AND GAS TRANSPORTATION CHAIN THERE HAVE BEEN STUDIES EH THERE HAVE BEEN SOME LIMITED STUDIES AT REFINERIES AND NOSE HAVE BEEN MOSTLY DONE EITHER IN SCANDINAVIAN COUNTRIES WITH SOME WORKERS AND THE SO IT'S IT'S HARD TO COMPARE THE WORKER RESULTS TO RESIDENTIAL ROUTE RESULTS BECAUSE THE EXPOSURES ARE VERY DIFFERENT UM THEY HAVE DONE SOME WORK IN TEXAS CITY WHERE THEY'VE SEEN AFTER

[33:00] THE LARGE RELEASES FROM SOME OF THE REFINERIES THERE THEY'VE OBSERVED HIGHER LEVELS OF SOME BLOOD EFFECTS IN CHILDREN BUT THAT THE STUDIES IT REALLY BEEN LIMITED IN THE ABILITY TO MEASURE THE CONCENTRATIONS OF THESE THINGS IN THE AIR AND THE HEALTH EFFECTS IN THE PEOPLE SO TO HAVE THOSE CONCURRENTLY HAPPENING THAT'S BEEN THE LIMITATION IN THE RESIDENTIAL SETTINGS OCCUPATIONAL SETTINGS FOR BEEN SEEN ITS SPY MEAN BEEN SEEN AS A WELL ESTABLISH A HUMAN CARCINOGEN AND AND THERE'S A LOT AND ALSO A PLASTIC ANEMIA AND OTHER BLOOD DISEASES THERE'S A LOT OF DATA OUT THERE FOR HIGH CONCENTRATIONS TO HIGH LEVELS OF BENZENE IN OCCUPATIONAL SETTINGS. THANK YOU OK ONE MORE QUESTION ON WHERE TO STAY IN THEIR OWN AFFAIRS TO STUDY GETS THIS IS THAT PREVAILING WINDS BRINGS WHATEVER'S HAPPENING IN WELD COUNTY TO US. GENERALLY SPEAKING YES. OTHER STUDIES THAT LOOK AT WHAT HAPPENS

[34:02] WHEN WHAT THAT THESE EMISSIONS FROM WELLS PILE UP AGAINST SAY THE FLAT IRONS WELL SO THERE ARE OTHER MORE OF ATMOSPHERIC SCIENTISTS THAT ARE DOING THAT KIND OF WORK AND A HELMET HAS DONE A LOT OF THAT WORK AND HE IS HE HAS A SAMPLING STATION AT THE RESERVOIR OUT HERE AND HE HAS BEEN SHOWING THE INFLUENCE OF THE OIL AND GAS OPERATIONS AS THE WIND TURNS AND TURNS BACK TOWARDS THE WEST AND BLOWS THAT IN GETTING THAT ROAN HAS ALSO DONE. AND JESSICA NIGHT. I'M SORRY. GILMAN SORRY IF THEY'VE ALSO DONE QUITE A BIT OF WORK ON THAT AND SHOWING HOW MUCH THE OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT IS CONTRIBUTING TO BENZENE LEVELS AND LEVELS OF METHANE AND OTHER HYDROCARBONS HERE AND I CAN'T I'M NOT GOING TO GIVE YOUR NUMBER BECAUSE I'M NOT THE RIGHT NUMBER THAT THIS IS A SIZABLE CONTRIBUTION FOR US TO GO RIGHT THIS IS JUST ONE

[35:01] HAND WE COULD TALK FOR LONG LONG TIME AND FORTUNE ALLOWED TO GET THE FINAL WORD TO LISA HERE WE REALLY APPRECIATE YOU COMING TONIGHT AND THIS WAS AN INCREDIBLE PRESENTATION AND I KNOW I HAVE SEVERAL QUESTIONS WE DON'T HAVE TIME BUT WOULD IT BE OK YOU SHOWED YOUR E MAIL AT THE FRONT. IF WE THE MALE GUESTS QUESTIONS TO MY EMAILS THERE AND I'M ALWAYS HAPPY TO ANSWER QUESTIONS OR OR TALK TO SOMEONE ON THE PHONE AND IF THEY'D LIKE TO DO THAT IN THE TREE IN THEN I WAS WONDERING IF WE COULD POST YOUR THIS PRESENTATION ON OUR CITY SIGNED TUESDAY WEBSITE YES YOU MAY WHAT I WHAT I'LL DO IS ALL SEND YOU A PDF OF IT BECAUSE I PREFER NOT HAVE THE POWER POINT. NO THAT'S OKAY. EXCELLENT THANK YOU SO MUCH AND THANKS FOR TAKING TIME MANY OF HIS THANK YOU CHILL UH THE UH OKAY THAT

[36:00] WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A MINUTE TO GET ASSEMBLED BEFORE WE STARTED THE ER IN ER THE ER UH IN THE SHOWER AT SHIP IN

[37:15] THE AT THE CHEYENNE THE IN

[38:03] TO THE TWO THUS THE GOOD EVENING EVERYBODY OF PEOPLE COULD TAKE THEIR SEATS THAT WOULD BE GREAT THE RIGHT CALL TO EXCUSE ME THE COURT TO ORDER BOULDER CITY COUNCIL MEETING IN MAY FIFTEEN TWENTY EIGHTEEN LE NET WILL YOU CALL THE ROLL. COUNCILMEMBER BROCK A NEAR CARLISLE YOU'RE GONNA HEAR JONES HEAR YOURSELF A GOAL YOU'RE EVER NEAR YATES WE'RE YOUNG WE HAVE A QUORUM THANK YOU ANNETTE FOR A FIRST UP GOING TO HAVE OUR QUARTERLY BRIEFING FROM OUR MUNICIPAL JUDGE ME TURN IT

[39:04] OVER TO YOU FOR THAT DAY AND WE COULD USE HELP GET IT. OK ON TO MAKE SURE I HAD THE MICROPHONE ON THE EVENING THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF CITY COUNCIL I GOING TO DISCUSS A FEW TOPICS JUST IN THE SHORT FIFTEEN MINUTES THAT I HAVE ONE THINK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT IS THE COURTS OPPORTUNITIES WITH SOME NATIONAL INITIATIVES. I'M ALSO GOING TO I'M TOO AND UNDERAGE SUBSTANCE USE UPDATE BECAUSE I THINK THERE'S SOME INTERESTING TRENDS IN THERE AND THEN ALSO AN UPDATE ON THE WHOLENESS NAVIGATOR AND THE KIND OF THE WORK THAT SHE'S DOING. I'M JUST SO YOU KNOW AHEAD OF TIME WE DO ANTICIPATE BEING VERY INVOLVED WITH THE HOMELESS MEETING THAT WILL OCCUR IN AUGUST SO WE CAN GO INTO A LOT MORE DEPTH AT THAT TIME THE RIGHT OPPORTUNITIES WITH NATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS. SO THE EYE NATIONAL LEAGUE OF

[40:00] CITIES IN THE MACARTHUR FOUNDATION HOSTED A GROUP OF TWELVE JUDGES IN SOME COURT ADMINISTRATORS FROM AROUND THE COUNTRY IN WASHINGTON DC IN MARCH TO TWENTY SEVENTEEN WITH A VIEW TOWARDS FORMING A NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR MUNICIPAL COURTS THERE IS NOT SUCH SUCH AN ENTITY. WE HAD A FOLLOW UP MEETING IN ATLANTA THIS MARCH AND WE ARE NOW IN THE PROCESS OF EXPLORING OPTIONS FOR FORMING UNDER THE NATIONAL LEAGUE OF CITIES UMBRELLA WE SPENT THE LAST YEAR TRYING TO FIGURE OUT A WAY TO FORM AS A NON PROFIT AND WHAT WE ARE FINDING WAS THERE WERE SOME PRETTY SIGNIFICANT BARRIERS FROM A FINANCIAL STANDPOINT TO DOING THAT BOTH MYSELF AND JAMES CHO ARE A SENSIBLY OFFICERS IN THIS ORGANIZATION ALTHOUGH SINCE WE'RE NOT REALLY FORMED THAT'S A LITTLE BIT HARD TO SAY THAT WE'RE OFFICIALLY OFFICERS BUT IF WE WERE TO BE THAT ORGANIZATION IN THE NEXT SHORT LITTLE WHILE I WOULD BE THE PRESIDENT AND JAMES WOULD

[41:00] BE THE TREASURE ARE ONE OF OUR NEXT STEPS S WERE EXPLORING WORKING UNDER THE NATIONAL LEAGUE OF CITIES UMBRELLA IS THEY DID SUGGEST THAT WE SOME OF THE COURT SUBMIT PROPOSALS FOR THEIR CITY SUMMIT WHICH OCCURS ANNUALLY IN NOVEMBER AND SO WE HAVE SUBMITTED A PROPOSAL FOR THAT SUMMIT WILL FIND OUT LATER ON IN THE SUMMER IF WE WILL BE PARTICIPATING OR NOT BUT ANOTHER VERY ANXIOUS TO SORT OF START HAVING THAT EDUCATION OCCUR TO THE REST OF THEIR MEMBERSHIP ABOUT THE ROLE OF THE MUNICIPAL COURTS BECAUSE THAT'S BEEN A VOID IN THE NATIONAL LEAGUE OF CITIES ORGANIZATION ANOTHER OPPORTUNITY IS THE PRETRIAL JUSTICE INSTITUTE. THEIR MISSION IS BOND RE FORM AND THEY ARE ESPECIALLY LOOKING AT MOVING FROM A MONEY BASED TO A RISK BASED PRE TRIAL DETENTION MECHANISM. I PARTICIPATED IN THEIR LEED PROGRAM WHICH HAS BEEN RUNNING SINCE DECEMBER

[42:01] AND WE FINISHED UP IN JUNE AND YOU CAN SEE I HAVE MY CAPSTONE PROJECT IS TO TRY TO FIND SOME WAYS TO INCREASE COURT ATTENDANTS FROM OUR HOMELESS POPULATION BECAUSE FOR INSTANCE THE DATA SHOWS THAT TELEPHONE REMINDERS TOO ARE A LOT TOWARDS INCREASING ATTENDANCE IN COURT. THAT'S NOT NECESSARILY A VIABLE OPTION FOR MANY OF OUR HOMELESS DEFENDANTS SO I'M TRYING TO FIND SOME CREATIVE WAYS THAT WE CAN MAYBE WORK ON THAT AND THEN FINALLY TOM CARR AND I'VE BEEN TALKING WE'RE VERY INTERESTED IN TRYING TO BRING BEST PRACTICES TO WORKING WITH THE HOMELESS TO OTHER MUNICIPAL COURTS IN THE COUNTRY AND THERE'S A BIG ROLE FOR THE PROSECUTORS IN THAT SO I'M EXPLORING TRAINING OPTIONS IN THAT REGARD ON THE NEXT THING I WANNA DO IS TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT UNDERAGE SUBSTANCE USE AND THE REASON I TALK ABOUT THAT IS THAT IS SORT OF A PROXY FOR SUBSTANCE USE AND QUALITY OF LIFE ISSUES BY THE EIGHTEEN TO TWENTY FIVE

[43:00] YEAR OLD POPULATION HERE IN BOULDER WHICH IS A BIG PERCENTAGE OF THE COURT CASES AND FOR THESE KINDS OF CASES SITE ISSUED CITATIONS ARE ISSUED NOT JUST BY THE BOULDER POLICE DEPARTMENT BY ALSO BY THE CU POLICE DEPARTMENT AND THE VAST MAJORITY OF THE CU TICKETS ARE ISSUED IN THE DORMS TO ISSUE WE MEANING THE POLICE ISSUE ABOUT HALF OF THE CITATIONS FOR THIS CHARGE FOR THE ENTIRE YEAR IN THE FIRST MONTH OF THE ACADEMIC CALENDAR AND THE REASON THEY DO THAT IS THEY WANT TO SET THE TONE IN THE COMMUNITY EXPECTATIONS SO THAT PEOPLE THE YOUNG ADULTS WHO ARE USING ALCOHOL ESPECIALLY THOSE WHO ARE USING UNDER AGE NO WAY THAT THIS IS NOT NEW ORLEANS AND MARDI GRAS AND YOU CAN JUST WALK AROUND THE HILL WITH AN OPEN CAN OF BEER AND BECAUSE IF YOU DO YOU'RE GOING TO GET A TICKET. YES SIR THINGS I'VE BEEN HEARING OUT THERE IS

[44:00] THAT THERE'S A USE OF SOMETHING CALLED THE JEWEL THAT LOOKS LIKE A USB UP AND DOWN BY CHILDREN YOUNGER THAN EIGHTEEN OUT THERE IN THE SCHOOLS AND I WAS CURIOUS TO KNOW IF THERE IS ANY CITATIONS THAT CAN BE ISSUED OR IS THAT PERFECTLY LEGAL TO BE DOING THAT AND SCHOOLS ARE THE SO WHAT A JEWEL IS IS IT IS ESSENTIALLY A FORM OF A PING DEVICE LIKE AN E CIGARETTE OR SOME OF THE DEVICES THAT ARE COMMONLY USED TO ALSO CONSUME MARIJUANA PRODUCTS AND THIS ONE BECAUSE IT LOOKS LIKE A USB DEVICE IS A LITTLE BIT MORE DISCREET AND SO NOT UNCOMMON FOR STUDENTS TO BE CARRYING AROUND SOMETHING THAT LOOKS LIKE A LITTLE FLASH DRIVE THAT THEY MIGHT HAVE NO PRESENTATIONS FOR SCHOOL OR WHATEVER ON AND THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE USING IT'S HARD TO KNOW ALL THE TIME WHETHER OR NOT THEY'RE USING TOBACCO WHICH FOR PEOPLE UNDER EIGHTEEN IS ALSO ILLEGAL OR WHETHER THEY'RE USING SOME OTHER KIND

[45:00] OF SUBSTANCE IN THERE WE SINCE WE DON'T HANDLE CASES FOR PEOPLE UNDER EIGHTEEN I CAN'T REALLY SPEAK TO THE TRENDS IN OUR SCHOOLS BUT I KNOW I'M FROM THE LISTSERV THAT I PARTICIPATE IN OF ALL THE MUNICIPAL JUDGES AROUND THE STATE CERTAINLY SOMETHING THAT IS BEGINNING TO BE SEEN MORE COMMONLY I UM I DID TALK TO BST ABOUT THIS FOR MY SON HAS BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION AND THEY SAID THAT THEY HAVE SEEN AN UPTICK IN OR WORKING ON IT THEY'VE DONE TEACHER TRAINING AROUND DEAD AND IMPLEMENT ITS MOTHER NOBODY'S RULES SO I KNOW THAT IT'S VERY MUCH ON THEIR AWARENESS AND THAT THEY'RE WORKING ACTIVELY ON IT THE SO IN TERMS OF UNDERAGE SUBSTANCE ABUSE AT THE MAIN POINT OF THESE TWO GRAPHS IS TO SHOW YOU THE EXTENT TO WHICH UNDER AGE USE OF MARIJUANA CASES HAVE INCREASED AS A PERCENTAGE OF THE OVERALL UNDERAGE SUBSTANCE USE CASES OR EIGHTEEN TO TWENTY YEAR OLDS IN OUR COURT AND WE WENT BACK

[46:00] AS TWO AS FAR AS TWENTY FOURTEEN WHEN THOSE CASES WERE LEGALIZED OR SUBSTANCE WAS LEGALIZED ON A RECREATIONAL BASIS FOR PEOPLE TWENTY ONE AND OVER AND I'M AS YOU CAN SEE FROM THE GRAPH ON THE RIGHT. IT'S NOT A FIFTY PERCENT YET BUT IT'S BECOMING AN INCREASINGLY HIGH PERCENTAGE OF THE CASES THAT WERE SEEING AND AGAIN MOST OF THESE TICKETS PARTICULARLY FOR THE MARIJUANA CASES ARE ISSUED BY CU POLICE TO STUDENTS IN THE DORMS. IT'S NOT AS COMMON FOR THE BOULDER POLICE TO BE ISSUING THOSE TICKETS SO THIS IS AN INTERESTING GRAPH SO DO YOU SEE ALCOHOL USE GOING DOWN ORDERS ALCOHOL USE INCREASING WITH USE OF MARIJUANA AT THE SAME TIME SO IT'S A REALLY HARD TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION AND THE REASON IS I THINK IN OUR COMMUNITY WE ONLY HAVE SO MUCH ENFORCEMENT CAPACITY. SO WHAT YOU'RE

[47:00] SEEING IS IF YOU LOOK AT NOTE THE AND NUMBER ON THE GRAPHS ON THE LEFT. SO FOR THAT FALL SEMESTER. YES WE HAVE HAD AN OVERALL INCREASE OF CASES. SO SIX HUNDRED ONE CASES IN TWENTY FOURTEEN EIGHT HUNDRED THIRTY NINE CASES IN TWENTY SEVENTEEN DEFINITELY AN INCREASE IN NUMBER OF CASES THE NUMBER OF ALCOHOL CASES HAS GONE DOWN WELL IT WENT UP AND THEN IT WENT DOWN SO PRETTY SOME ARE TO WHERE IT WAS ON TWENTY FOURTEEN WHILE THE MARIJUANA CASES ARE ON THE RICE BUT AGAIN SUCH TO SOME DEGREE I THINK THE NUMBER OF OFFICERS THAT YOU HAVE AVAILABLE TO INVESTIGATE AND ISSUE CITATIONS CAN BE A LIMITING FACTOR. HE JUST BE INTERESTING TO SEE PEOPLE ARE ARE ARE UM INSTEAD OF DRINKING SMOKING POT OR TAKING THE ENTIRE RIGHT OR ARE THEY CONTINUING TO DRINK I AN HOUR TAKING POT AT THE SAME TIME I'M SURE SOME

[48:00] OF BOTH WE DO SOMETIMES SEE CITATIONS WHERE THEY'RE CITED FOR BOTH UNDERAGE MARIJUANA USE AND UNDER AGE ALCOHOL USE THE SAME CITATION ANECDOTALLY I WILL SAY THAT THE MARIJUANA KIDS AND ALCOHOL KIDS TEND TO PRESENT A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT THOUGH I THINK BY AND LARGE THEY'RE SORT OF YOU KNOW IN DIFFERENT KIND OF SUBCULTURES ITS BANKS ARE EIGHT ONTO UPDATE ABOUT THE HOMELESS NAVIGATION THAT WE'RE DOING AND PART OF THE RESULT SOME OF THE SLIDES AND HERE ARE SLIDES I PRESENTED TO THE THREE NEW CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS AT A FRIDAY FOCUS MUCH WILL NOT GOING TO SPEND REALLY ANY TIME ON THOSE BUT I DID WANT TO SHARE THOSE WITH THE REST OF COUNCIL BUT THESE ARE THE TOPICS THAT I'M GOING TO DISCUSS UNDER THIS SECTION I WAS ASKED TO PROVIDE THIS CAMPING INFORMATION YOU CAN SEE THE REAL TREND IS THAT THEY'RE STILL HIGHER IN THE SUMMER. NO SURPRISE I WOULD BE CAUTIOUS. I WOULD BE CAUTION YOU AGAINST READING TOO MUCH INFORMATION INTO

[49:01] THIS AS A PROXY FOR HOMELESS ACTIVITY FOR INSTANCE YOU'LL SEE THAT THERE WERE FEWER CITATIONS IN TWENTY SIXTEEN THAT WAS LIKELY A FUNCTION OF A DIFFERENT APPROACH TO ENFORCEMENT THAN NECESSARILY A DIFFERENCE IN THE NUMBER OF HOMELESS PEOPLE WHO WERE IN BOULDER BUT I PROVIDED TO YOU BECAUSE I WAS ASKED AND IT'S ALWAYS INTERESTING TO SEE WHAT TRENDS LOOK LIKE WHEN YOU BREAK THEM OUT GRAPHICALLY NEXT SLIDE STREET MEDICINE. SO THIS IS THAT THIS IS A REALLY COOL THING THAT HAPPENED DOCTOR BETH CONTACTED ME I DON'T KNOW HOW SHE GOT MY NAME INITIALLY BUT DOCTOR BETH IS ASSOCIATED WITH CLINICAL AND SHE HAD BEEN TO THE STREET MEDICINE CONFERENCE IN PITTSBURGH LAST YEAR AND WAS ALL EXCITED ABOUT THE PROSPECT OF DOING STREET MEDICINE HERE IN BOULDER SO SHE AND I MET ALONG WITH OUR WHOLENESS NAVIGATOR IN OUR HOMELESS OUTREACH TEAM OFFICERS AND WE SAID LET'S DO IT AND SO SHE HAD SOME THINGS THAT SHE HAD TO WORK OUT YOU KNOW FROM AN

[50:00] INSURANCE STANDPOINT AND SO FORTH BUT YOU CAN SEE FROM THE SLIGHT THIS IS A NATIONALLY KNOWN PROGRAM FIFTEEN COUNTRIES ACROSS FIVE CONTINENTS THEIR CONFERENCE THIS FALL IS IN ROTTERDAM ANYBODY WANTS TO GO THAT WOULD BE A GREAT PLACE TO VISIT BUT WE'RE REALLY PLEASED WITH WHAT WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO DO SO FAR. RIGHT NOW SHE IS WORKING OR SHE'S VISITING WEEKLY SOME OF THE SERVICE PROVIDER LOCATIONS SUCH AS THE SHELTER AND OTHER PLACES WHERE THE HOMELESS PEOPLE TEND TO GATHER AND SHE ALSO WORKS ON THE STREET WHEN SAFETY IS NOT AN ISSUE THERE IS ALSO A WONDERFUL NURSE THAT ACCOMPANIES HER IN THAT ALLOWS HER TO GET IT WORKED AND SHE'S TRYING REALLY HARD TO ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO COME IN FOR FOLLOW UP APPOINTMENT AT CLINIC AH SO FAR SHE HASN'T HAD A LOT OF SUCCESS IN GETTING PEOPLE TO FOLLOW THROUGH SO IT JUST SHOWS THE NEED TO BE ABLE TO MEET PEOPLE WHERE THEY ARE AND PROVIDE THIS SERVICE IS THIS THAT MAY BE RELATED TO THE LACK OF ACCESS TO

[51:02] TELEPHONES AND GETTING REMINDED THAT THEY NEED TO GO FOR A FOLLOWER. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT'S A FUNCTION OF THERE A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE WORKING ON FULFILLING THEIR BASIC NEEDS AND YOU KNOW FOOD MAYBE A HIGHER NEED ON A PARTICULAR DAY THEN KEEPING THAT APPOINTMENT. THEY'RE ALSO PEOPLE WHO ARE KIND OF SUSPICIOUS OF INSTITUTIONS IN GENERAL THERE CAN BE A LOT OF REASONS TO HAVE A SENSE OF HOW MANY PEOPLE BEING TREATED YET NOT AT THIS POINT IT'S STILL RELATIVELY NEW THAT SHE STARTED AND THIS IS SUCCESSFUL SOMETHING WE'D LIKE TO GROW A PROGRAM THAT WITH THAT INCREASE HIM FOR MORE THAN ONE. CERTAINLY IF THE CAPACITY IS THERE. I MEAN I THINK THE HARDEST PART TO WORKOUT WAS SORT OF WHAT WAS THE MALPRACTICE COVERAGE FOR HER AND I THINK SHE WAS ABLE TO EVENTUALLY WORK THAT OUT THROUGH CLINIC A SO I WOULD SAY THAT THAT WOULD BE A GREAT QUESTION FOR CLINIC A IN TERMS OF THEIR ABILITY I'M

[52:02] NOT SURE THAT SHE'S ACTUALLY BEING PAID FOR THIS I KNOW SHE IS A PAID EMPLOYEE OF CLINIC UP BUT SHE MAY BE DOING THIS ON HER NON CLINICAL DAYS SO IT'S NOT A CITY CLINIC A PARTNERSHIP OR WERE PROVIDING ANY FUNDING NO ICING. THANK YOU ALL RIGHT SO THIS IS ONE OF THOSE SLIDES WHERE MOVES THAT I SHARED WITH THE THREE NEWER CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS BACK IN JANUARY. JUST SOME OF THE AT OUTCOMES OF OUR NAVIGATOR IN TERMS OF DOCUMENTATION THE NEXT SLIDE IS SIMILAR IN TERMS OF HOUSING AND OF COURSE SINCE THIS WAS ALL COUNTED AS OF THE END OF DECEMBER SO THERE BEEN SOME PROGRESS SINCE THAT TIME AGAIN I'M NOT GOING TO SPEND ANYTIME ON THIS BUT YOU WANT TO ASK QUESTIONS LATER TIME I'M HAPPY TO DO THAT ON THE LAST THING UH ABOUT IS THE COORDINATED ENTRY AND THE CORE HIGH UTILIZE THE EXPERIENCE OF THAT

[53:00] THE WAY THIS WORKED IS THAT WE WERE ASKED TO IDENTIFY HIGH UTILIZED HERS TO WHEN WE STARTED THE PROCESS SIXTY FIVE OF THEM WERE IDENTIFIED THE CRITERIA WERE BASED ON HAVING TEN CITATIONS AT MINIMUM DURING THE PREVIOUS EIGHTEEN MONTHS TWO OF THEM ARE NOW DECEASED SAID THE DATA THAT FOLLOWS THIS FOR THE REMAINING SIXTY THREE WHETHER OR NOT THEY'VE BEEN THROUGH COORDINATED ENTRY AND HAD AN ASSESSMENT WAS SOMETHING THAT WE'RE INTERESTED IN LOOKING AT SO YOU CAN SEE SO FAR TWENTY OF THOSE THAT OF THOSE SIXTY THREE OR SIXTY FIVE ACTUALLY HAVE BEEN THROUGH COORDINATED ENTRY THAT CONSTITUTES THIRTY ONE PERCENT BUT IF YOU LOOK AT JUST THE TOP TWO ROWS SO ELIMINATE THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE NOT HAD RECENT CONTACTS IN BOULDER OR HER NOW DECEASED THAT MEAN THAT NUMBER GOES UP TO THIRTY NINE PERCENT OF CONSECRATED ENTRY STILL NOT AS MANY AS WE WOULD LIKE OBVIOUSLY BUT A PREVIOUS ANALYSIS OF HIGH UTILIZE OR TENANTS AT THE SHELTER SHOWED A RATE OF USE OF ABOUT

[54:00] SIXTEEN PERCENT SO IT DOES SEEM THAT WE ARE INCREASING THE DEGREE TO WHICH PEOPLE ARE WILLING TO ENGAGE WITH SYSTEMS OF IT TO COOK THAT I THOUGHT THAT UNDER A NEW STRATEGY THAT ALL PEOPLE PRESENT FOR SERVICES HAVE TO GO TO COURT INTRIGUE THEY HAVE TO GO TO THE COORDINATED ENTRY ASSESSMENTS SITE TO BE ASSESSED AND SO FOR INSTANCE IF THEY CHOOSE NOT TO SHELTER THEY'RE NOT GOING TO GO THROUGH COORDINATED ENTRY THEY DON'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH COORDINATED ENTRY TO USE THE SEVERE WEATHER SHELTER THEY ARE ENCOURAGED TO THEY DON'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH TO COURT MADE AN ENTRY TO ACCESS FOOD A COMMUNITY TABLE AGAIN. THAT'S ONE OF THE OUTREACH SITES WHERE IT'S ENCOURAGED BUT IT'S NOT REQUIRED BUT YOU JUST COOK IT NOT A QUESTION OF THOSE TWENTY TO HAVE GONE THROUGH QUITE AN ENTRY DO WE HAVE A SENSE OF HOW MANY OF THOSE WHAT THEIR EVENTUAL COME SPEND WITH HER STATE OF SHOCK OR LIED SO I LOVE THAT OF THE TWENTY THAT WENT THROUGH ONE OF THEM IS NOW DECEASED. THIS IS

[55:00] THE ANALYSIS OF WHETHER OR NOT THEY'RE USING THE SHELTER AND THEY ARE IF THEY ARE REFERRED TO THE SHELTER WHICH THEY ALL ARE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO USE RESERVE BAD THE FOUR OF THEM HAVE HAD A RESERVE BED AT SOME POINT AND ELEVEN OF THEM HAVE BEEN AT A STANDBY BAD THOSE INCLUDE FOR THE FOUR THAT HAD RESEARCHED THAT'S SO NOT HIGH UTILIZATION OF THE SHELTER RESEARCH THAT SYSTEM WE ALSO LOOKED AT THEIR USE OF PAST HOME THE SEVERE WEATHER SHELTER AGAIN MOST OF THE HIGH UTILIZE HERS WERE NOT USING THE SET IS SEVERE WEATHER SHELTER VERY OFTEN DURING THE SEASON WE'RE NOT SURE WHAT THE REASONS ARE FOR THAT ARE YOU KNOW WHETHER OR NOT THEY GOT THE IMPRESSION THAT NOW PASS TO RICH HAS BECAME PASSED A HOME YOU CAN ACCESS IT IF YOU WEREN'T A PATH TO HOME CLIENT OR WEATHER WAS JUST THAT THEY PREFER TO BE OUTSIDE BUT THAT'S WHAT THE UTILIZATION. THIS IS A SMALL COHORT GROUP REMEMBER THIS IS THE SIXTY SIXTY FIVE

[56:01] PEOPLE HOUSING OUTCOMES ARE ALWAYS OF INTEREST AND OF COURSE THIS IS THE LONG TERM SOLUTION THIS IS NOT SOMETHING THAT HAPPENS VERY IMMEDIATELY BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF HOUSING RESOURCE IN OUR COMMUNITY WHAT'S INTERESTING IS THAT IN A LOT OF RESPECTS THE NUMBERS AREN'T THAT DIFFERENT FOR THOSE WHO GOT RECORDED A COORDINATED ENTRY COMPARED TO THOSE WHO HAVE NOT SAY YOU DON'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH COORDINATED ENTRY TO BECOME HOUSE WE HAVE PEOPLE THAT EVEN BEFORE COORDINATE COORDINATED ENTRY HAD STARTED WE HAD DONE THE VULNERABILITY INDEX WE HAD PUT THEM INTO THE HOUSING SYSTEM THERE THEIR NAME CAME UP FOR HOUSING RESOURCE IN OUR HOUSE HOMELESS NAVIGATOR WORKED WITH THOSE PEOPLE TO GET THEM INTO THAT RESOURCE SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH COORDINATED ENTRY TO BE ABLE TO MAKE THAT TRANSITION AND THERE IS A DIFFERENCE IN TERMS OF THE NUMBER OF IN PRE MATCH. I'M NOT SURE WHAT THAT IS ABOUT WITHOUT KNOWING ACTUALLY WHO THOSE FOLKS ARE

[57:00] BUT THE GOOD THING IS THAT WE DO HAVE THE HUMMUS NAVIGATOR BECAUSE SOME OF THESE PEOPLE THESE PEOPLE WHO ARE IN THE OTHER'S GROUP THEY WOULD NOT BECOME HOUSE WITHOUT THE ASSISTANCE OF AN INDIVIDUAL LIKE THAT TO HELP THEM GET THROUGH THE PROCESS IT THERE'S JUST NO WAY THAT THEY COULD DO THAT AND SHE'S ALSO HELPS THE ONES WHO HAVE BOUCHER SAID. SO FAR HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO LEASE UP AND HELPING THE ONES WHO ARE IN PRE MATCH HOPING THE ONES WHO ARE IN FOR LYON SHE'S INVOLVED WITH ALL OF THEM AND I'M JUST SEARCH SORT OF SOME SUMMARIES OF THE HIGH UTILIZE HER EXPERIENCE WITH COORDINATED ENTRY I'VE SUMMARIZED THUS HERE ARE NOT GOING TO STATE THOSE VERBAL YOU CAN READ THEM AGAIN WITH RESPECT TO THE FOURTH BAR DOWN THERE ON THE WHOLENESS NAVIGATOR IS OUR RESOURCES PROVIDING THE CASE MANAGEMENT WHEN PEOPLE ARE CHOOSING NOT TO FOR INSTANCE STAY AT THE SHELTER ENGAGE WITH THEIR CASE MANAGERS. I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE WITH A GREAT DEAL OF GRATITUDE WENDY SCHWARTZ

[58:00] SHE'S BEEN VERY HELPFUL AT TRYING TO OPEN DOORS AND PROBLEM SOLVE INDIVIDUAL CASES AS WELL AS SYSTEMIC ISSUES AND THE FEEDBACK LOOP THAT WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO ESTABLISH WITH THE NAVIGATOR TO HUMAN SERVICES BECAUSE OUR NAVIGATORS REALLY ON THE GROUND LEVEL AND WENDY'S MORE THE SYSTEMS LEVEL HAS BEEN A REALLY GREAT MECHANISM FOR PROVIDING PRETTY IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK ON HOW DATED ENTRY IS WORKING FOR THE SIXTY FIVE HIGH UTILIZES AND FOR OTHER PEOPLE LIKE THEM AND IT SO IT'S HELPING THEM TO IDENTIFY AND DEVELOP RESPONSES TO SERVICE GAPS. SO FOR INSTANCE ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S NOW BEING HAPPENING IS THEY'RE STARTING A VULNERABLE ADULTS GROUP AND THEY'RE LOOKING AT SORT OF SUB POPULATIONS OF PEOPLE THAT ARE VULNERABLE IN ONE WAY OR ANOTHER SOME OF THEM ARE PEOPLE WITH INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES. SOME OF THEM ARE RETIREES WHO HAVE LOST THEIR APARTMENTS BECAUSE THEY GOT PRICED OUT OF THEIR

[59:01] APARTMENTS AND THEN SUDDENLY BECAME HOMELESS AND OF COURSE THERE'S THESE ALSO THESE CHRONIC OR HIGH UTILIZE OR SET TEND TO HAVE MENTAL HEALTH AND OTHER KINDS OF ISSUES BUT I DON'T THINK WE WOULD HAVE THOSE SERVICE CAPS WOULD HAVE EMERGED AS QUICKLY AND WOULD HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED IN AS TIMELY A FASHION WITHOUT THAT KIND OF THAT'S IT GOOD. I THINK WE'VE BEEN ASKING OUR QUESTIONS AS WE HEAL. I THINK YOU JUST WANNA SAY HOPE FOR THIS HEAVY COME HEAR THE RHYTHM OF HAVING YOU COME QUARTERLY SHARE KIND OF WHAT YOUR BRANCH OF THE GOVERNMENT'S WORKING ON ACTUALLY HELPFUL TO APPRECIATE THE GOOD WORK HAPPENING. SAM SO I JUST HAVE A COMMENT OR REQUEST THANK YOU FOR THAT I JUST WANNA REMIND US THAT THIS WAS ABOUT HOW YOU LASER STRAIGHT OF THE COURT SYSTEM AND IT WOULD ALSO BE INTERESTING AND JANE YOU MAY KNOW THIS OFF THE TOP YOUR HEAD FOR US TO LOOK AT HOW COORDINATED ENTRY AND THE NEW SYSTEM HAS BEEN GOING OVER ALL BECAUSE I ALWAYS

[60:01] FIND THESE NUMERICAL PRESENTATIONS VERY HELPFUL ARE WE GOING TO BE HEARING SOMETHING ABOUT THAT NOPE NOW IS YES WE HAVE A STUDY SESSION SCHEDULED FOR AUGUST WHICH WE'RE GOING TO GIVE YOU A HOMELESSNESS UPDATE. WE ALSO HAVE THE DASHBOARD ON THE CITY WEBSITE THAT TALKS ABOUT THE UTILIZATION OF THE HOMELESS SHELTER AND PATH TO HOME AND WE HAVE BEEN NOT EXPERIENCING SITUATIONS AND WE IN WHICH PEOPLE WHO WANT A BED CAN'T FIND ONE BEDS ARE AVAILABLE UNDER THE NEW CORNING ENTRY SYSTEM TRAY AND THE OTHER THING THAT WOULD BE GREAT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE IS EXITS FROM HOMELESSNESS SO WHETHER THAT'S ON THERE AS WELL THANK YOU. YES THEY MAY BE GOOD. I THINK THE JUDGE. SO IN THE UK SO WITH THAT WE ARE TURNING TO OPEN COMMENT BEFORE YOU STARTED A COUPLE ANNOUNCEMENTS ONE IS JUST A

[61:00] REMINDER THAT OUR INFORMATION PACKET WHICH WERE ON OUR WEBSITE UNDER CITY COUNCIL HAS TWO TOPICS BEING COVERED THERE THIS MONTH OR THIS WEEK AND THAT'S AN UPDATE ON OUR ACCESS MANAGEMENT AND PARKING STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION AND THEN ALSO AN UPDATE ON THE OPEN SPACE MOUNTAIN PARKS MASTER PLAN PROCESS AND THEN FINALLY JUST A REMINDER THAT YOU HAVE SIGNED UP FOR OPEN COMMENT YOU ARE FREE TO SPEAK TO US ABOUT ANY TOPIC EXCEPT FOR THE THREE TOPICS THAT ARE SCHEDULED FOR HEARINGS LATER AND THOSE TOPICS ARE THE CONCEPT PLAN REVIEW FOR THE FOUR CUPS AND CITE OIL AND GAS REGULATIONS AND THE FIRST ADJUSTMENT TO THE TWENTY EIGHTEEN BUDGET SO YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT THOSE SIGN UP SEPARATELY FOR THOSE HEARINGS THAT WE'RE GOING TO START OPEN COMMENT PLEASE BEGIN WITH YOUR NAME AND YOUR ADDRESS IF YOU NOT WANT TO GIVE US YOUR I JUST GIVE US THE NEIGHBORHOOD WHERE YOU LIVE IN AND WHETHER YOUR CITY RESIDENT. THANK YOU HI MY NAME IS LEONARD SIEGEL TIME RESIDENT AT SEVEN TWENTY SIX

[62:02] PINE ST. AND I'M HERE TONIGHT AS A BOARD MEMBER THE MUSEUM OF BOULDER. I'M REALLY EXCITED TO EXTEND AN INVITATION TO EVERYONE TO COME TO THE GRAND OPENING OF THE MUSEUM OF BOULDER THIS COMING SATURDAY FROM ONE DEFY THE MUSEUM HAS BEEN COMPLETELY RE IMAGINE TO NOW BE THE SHOWCASE WHAT MAKES BOLDER BOULDER. IT PROVIDES EXHIBITS CONVERSATIONS AND EVENTS THAT FOCUS ON TRENDING IDEAS THAT SHAPE THE PAST THE PRESENT AND WILL INFORM THE FUTURE. IT'S A HANDS ON PERSONAL AND DIGITAL EXPERIENCE THAT WILL ENERGIZE AND ENLIGHTEN YOU WHETHER YOU'VE LIVED HERE A LONG TIME OR JUST VISITING AT THE GRAND OPENING ON SATURDAY THE NINETEENTH WILL BE A BLOCK PARTY WHICH IS GOING TO BE A MUSEUM LOCATED AT THE CORNER OF BROADWAY AND PINE STREET. THERE'LL BE MUSIC AND DANCE PERFORMANCES KIDS' ACTIVITIES AND A ROCKY MOUNTAIN JO PHOTO BOOTH AND YOU MIGHT NEED TO COME THERE TO FIND A ROCKING ON JOE WAS

[63:00] AT TWO O'CLOCK THERE WILL BE A SHORT RIBBON CUTTING PROGRAM AFTER WHICH THE MUSEUM WILL BE OPEN TO THE FOR FREE VISITORS WILL HAVE A CHANCE TO VIEW OUR FIRST THREE EXHIBITS THAT RELATE TO STRONG THEMES IN BOULDER'S HISTORY ATHLETICS SCIENCE AND INVENTION. SPORTS ARE A G IS A HANDS ON EXHIBIT ABOUT INDIVIDUAL ATHLETIC POTENTIAL ESPECIALLY GEARED FOR KIDS DISCOVER NASA IS AN INTERACTIVE EXHIBIT THAT EXPLAINS WHAT NASA DOES AND ITS PLANS FOR THE FUTURE AND EVENTUALLY MEANS MACHINES IT'S A DISPLAY OF OVER SEVENTY FIVE INVENTIONS FROM THE GENIUS OF LEONARDO OPENING THIS NEW KIND OF MUSEUM IT'S BEEN A DREAM THAT ORIGINATED MANY YEARS AGO WE COULD HAVE DONE IT WITHOUT THE FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF THE CITIZENS OF BOULDER AND THE BACKING OF THE CITY COUNCIL AND CITY STAFF. I'D ALSO LIKE TO ACKNOWLEDGE A TERRIFIC LEADERSHIP OF NANCY GUY OR WHO HAS SERVED AS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR ALL THESE YEARS TO REALIZE

[64:01] THE MUSEUM LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU AT THE GRAND OPENING. OK THANKS DOWN ECONOMY AND AFTER DARYN IF KIMBERLY GIBBS COULD BE READY BY TARA CONNER TWENTY ONE ARE COMING AVENUE TONIGHT TO TALK ABOUT THE INCREASE IN MAXIMUM RENTAL RATES FOR PEOPLE ON AFFORDABLE RENTAL UNITS WITHIN BOULDER HANDING THIS OUT YOU GOT A SLIGHT UP THEIR TIME WITH THEIR SHARES WITH US FROM THE RENTAL TO RENTAL COMPLIANCE MANUALS THAT THE CITY MAINTAINS THE DISCRETION TO AMANDA MAXIMUM RENTS IT'S CALCULATED BASED ON SIXTY PERCENT OF AREA NEW INCOME OR AREA MEDIAN INCOME. THIS GRAPH APPEAR IN THE MIDDLE WAS REALLY THE MOST INTERESTING ONE TO ME IT SHOWS THE CHANGE SINCE TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN TO TWO THOUSAND AND SIXTEEN IN THE NUMBERS OF PEOPLE MAKING A PARTICULAR INCOME RANGE TO SEE THAT THE NUMBERS GO DOWN DOWN DOWN THE PEOPLE MAKING THOSE

[65:03] AMOUNTS DOESN'T COME BACK TO ZERO WHEN YOU SUM UP UNTIL YOU HIT A HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS WHERE MOST OF OUR GAMES TURNER IS IN THE HUNDRED THOUSAND ABOVE AND SO THIS IS AFFECTING RANT YOU HAVE THE ABILITY TO CHANGE WHAT THESE NUMBERS ARE OUT IT WENT UP OVER TEN PERCENT THE SHARE AND TALK TO WE WENT TO BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS AND I HAVE SOME MESSAGE THAT CAME BACK FROM MY GYM COULD TELL I HAVE BEEN SAYING HIS NAME RIGHT WHICH IS A LITTLE DISTURBING LUCKILY BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS THEY LIMIT THEY TOLD US THEY WILL LIMIT THE INCREASE TO ABOUT THREE PERCENT RATHER THAN LETTING THIS TEN PERCENT NUMBER HAPPEN BUT JIM WRITES THAT TYPICALLY WHEN AM I GOES DOWN WHICH YOU DID LAST YEAR AND THEY WERE SHOCKED WHEN IT GOES DOWN RENTS TO NOT FOLLOW BECAUSE THE PREVIOUS HIGHER RENT IS GRANDFATHERED IN THIS IS NECESSARY BECAUSE THE OWNER MAY HAVE RECEIVED A RUN BASED ON THE RATS BLAH

[66:01] BLAH BLAH. SO RENT PRICES ON THE LAP THIS YEAR THEY GOING UP TEN PERCENT AND YOU COULD YOU COULD CHANGE THAT YOU COULD COME UP WITH A CLEVER CLEVER AND APPLICABLE MEANS OF CALCULATING THE QUESTION TREE GEARING COULD DO WEREN'T ENOUGH OF THESE COULD USE YOU JUST E MAIL IT TO SHARE. GOT ONE RIGHT ON HAND WITH BUT TELL YOU I WILL ATTEND IS EIGHT AND ITS DISCRETE INFORMATION TO THE SIDE AND I JUST HAVE A QUICK COMMENT COME FROM HOWEVER READ A PSALM FROM OUR HOUSING DEPARTMENT TODAY ON THIS VERY SUBJECT HAS ANOTHER CITIZEN HAS INQUIRED AND I JUST WANTED TO POINT OUT THAT THEY'VE BEEN COMMUNICATING WITH THE PARTNERS THAT OWN AND MANAGE AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE CITY AND NONE OF THEM HOME WE'VE COMMUNICATED WITH OR CONSIDERING RAISING RATES TO THIS LEVEL SO THAT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE WE MYSELF AND SOME MEMBERS OF BOULDER D A S A CALL TO A NUMBER OF THESE OR NOT WITHIN BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS BUT HAD THESE AFFORDABLE UNITS AND

[67:02] THEY WOULDN'T TELL US YES OR NO BUT SOME OF THEM CERTAINLY SOUNDED LIKE THEY WOULD BE RAISING THEM ONE OF THEM SAID BASICALLY YOU'RE IN ONE OF THE MOST GENTLE FIGHT EXPENSIVE AREAS OF THE COUNTRY AND THE FACT THAT YOU'RE WORRYING ABOUT A HUNDRED DOLLARS SEEMS MISPLACED SO RIGHT SO I AM JUST REPORTING WHAT WOULD THEY TOLD US THEY RENT WILL GO UP BEHIND AT THE LEVEL OF CHAPTERS STEP AND I'M I'M HERE IS SOMEONE WHO'S IN ONE OF THESE UNITS THAT IN AN AFFORDABLE UNIT NOT THE BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS AND THOSE WENT UP BY THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT. OK SO WHAT YOU HAVE THEM CONTACT US THROUGH E MAIL OK BECAUSE ONE OF THE PEOPLE HAS ALREADY COMMUNICATED WITH THIS WE LIKE THEM OR MAKE A NEW VISION AND IF I'M SAYING THAT CORRECTLY. THAT'S TRUE. OK ALL RIGHT TAKING THE STAND IN THE ONE THING YOU DIDN'T BRING UP THAT IS PROBABLY ANOTHER FACTOR IS THANH HOA

[68:00] FEES GO UP SO WE'LL CONTINUE THIS CONVERSATION. I THINK HOA FEES ARE PART OF THIS NUMBER CHAIR KIMBERLY GIBBS AFTER KIMBERLY RACHEL BAILEY IF YOU COULD BE READY TO GET EVENING MY NAME IS KIMBERLY GIBBS I LOVE IT SEVEN FOUR SIX EIGHT MOUNT SHERMAN ROAD IN GUN BARREL OF A COUNTY RESIDENT. I'M HERE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE FIREARMS ORDINANCE ON MARCH NINETEENTH I VISITED THE STATE CAPITOL TO TESTIFY AT A SENATE HEARING ON TWO GUN BILLS SENATE BILL FIFTY ONE WOULD HAVE BANNED FROM STOCKS THE BASKET IN FIVE YEARS FIVE HOURS OF TESTIMONY THE VAST MAJORITY OF SPEAKERS SUPPORTED THIS COMMONSENSE BILL. THEY INCLUDED EDUCATORS PARENTS LAWN FOR SMIRNOFF OFFICIALS AND PEOPLE WHO HAD BEEN DIRECTLY AFFECTED BY GUN VIOLENCE BEFORE THE VOTE REPUBLICAN SENATOR OWEN HILL EXPLAIN THAT GUN SET HIS SAFETY LAWS DON'T WORK AND HE WAS GOING TO SUPPORT FREEDOM

[69:01] OVER BURDENSOME AND UNNECESSARY REGULATIONS REPUBLICAN SENATORS VICKI MARBLE AND GARY SANDBERG OFFERED SIMILARLY ABSURD COMMENTARIES. THE BILL DIED IN THE SENATE COMMITTEE ALONG PARTY LINE VOTE A SECOND BILL PROPOSE TO REPEAL THE BAN ON HIGH CAPACITY MAGAZINES. THIS COMING JUST A SHORT TIME AFTER THE LATEST MASS SHOOTING AT A FLORIDA HIGH SCHOOL. THE COMMITTEE PASSED THIS BILL. INCIDENTALLY THE MAGAZINE LIMIT IS PART OF THE GUN SAFETY PACKAGE ADOPTED IN TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN WHEN DEMOCRATS CONTROLLED BOTH THE STATE HOUSE AND THE SENATE SELF LIKE TO MAKE A COUPLE OF POINTS. THE REPUBLICAN CONTROLLED STATE SENATE WILL CONTINUE TO OPPOSE SENSIBLE GUN SAFETY LAWS AND UNTIL SANITY IS RESTORED AT THE STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WILL BE ASKED TO DO MORE AND I WANT TO THANK YOU CITIZENS WILL ALSO HAVE TO DO MORE AND EXPAND OUR INFLUENCE WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT LAWS PASSED AT THE STATE LEVEL

[70:01] AFFECT THE DAILY LIVES OF ALL COLORADANS WE CAN FIX THE STATE LEGISLATURE AND I HOPE I INVITE YOU TO JOIN ME IN STRONGLY SUPPORTING TWO CANDIDATES FOR STATE SENATE CAME THE STORY IN DISTRICT SIXTEEN AND FEET WINTER IN DISTRICT TWENTY FOUR THANK YOU THANK YOU RACHEL. AFTER RACHEL WE HAVE AUDREY ADDITION I HAVE MY NAME IS RACHEL DALEY ELEVEN AND PQ ROAD AND BOULDER HERE AND I HAVE TWO YOUNG DAUGHTERS THAT GO TO BOULDER SCHOOLS. I JUST WANNA REMIND YOU OF SERIOUSNESS OF THE WEAPONS THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE LAS VEGAS SHOOTING THERE WERE THE ONE SINGLE MAN WHO JUST THEY STILL DON'T EVEN KNOW WHY LOST HIS MIND OR WHATEVER. HE FIRED MORE THAN ELEVEN HUNDRED ROUNDS INTO A CROWD OF PEOPLE IN TEN

[71:00] MINUTES KILLED FIFTY EIGHT PEOPLE AND SHOT FOUR HUNDRED AND TWENTY TWO PEOPLE TOTAL EIGHT HUNDRED AND FIFTY ONE PEOPLE WERE INJURED FROM JUST THE MADNESS THAT HAPPENED AFTERWARDS. UM I JUST WANT TO THANK YOU FOR PASSING THIS COMMON SENSE GUN LAWS IN OUR COMMUNITY IT MAKES ME REALLY PROUD OF BOULDER FOR STEPPING UP TO DO THIS I REALLY HOPE THE OTHER COMMUNITIES WILL DO THAT IS WHILE I SAW THAT YOU GUYS ARE THINKING ABOUT ALLOWING GUN STORES TO ISSUE CERTIFICATIONS AND I THINK THAT THAT MIGHT BE A POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST. I JUST TRY TO THINK TOO ABOUT OTHER LEGAL DOCUMENTS HE CAN GET LIKE A PRIVATE STORE AND JUST THINK IT MAYBE IT'S FOR SOME POLICE LET THE POLICE THE BOY'S HAND THAT'S A THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU AUBREY AND AFTER AUBREY WE HAVE ANDREW O'CONNOR MY NAME IS AUBREY AT IT AND I LIVE AT SEVEN FORTY

[72:00] SIX ELEVEN ST. THIS IS MY THIS IS OUR CATERER LIVE IN NEW LENS AND THIS PROPOSED GUN BAN HAS ZERO EFFECT ON SAFETY WILL COST THE CITY MILLIONS OF DOLLARS FIGHTING THE LEGAL CHALLENGES TO THE STATE'S ALREADY PREEMPTIVE LAWS IN THE FACE OF BOULDER'S GROWING BUDGET DEFICIT THE RESPONSIBLE CITY COUNCIL GIVE UP ON THIS PROPOSAL GRACEFULLY TOM CARR'S LEGAL COUNSEL CANNOT BE TRUSTED AS HIS TRACK RECORD OF OVERSTEPPING CONSTITUTIONAL AUTHORITY IN SEATTLE HAS COST THAT CITY MILLIONS OF DOLLARS. MY BIGGEST HEAD SCRATCHER HERE TRYING TO JUSTIFY THE RELEVANCE OF YOUR PROPOSED BAN ANY CRIMINAL WOULD STILL BE ABLE TO DRIVE TEN MINUTES OUTSIDE OF BOULDER AND PURCHASE AN AIR FIFTEEN MONTH DR AN HOUR TO WYOMING BY HIGH CAPACITY MAGAZINES OR BUM STOCKS MAKES NO SENSE BUT YOU WANT TO TAKE AWAY THESE PRIVILEGES FROM BOULDER RESIDENTS THAT MAKE SENSE TO YOU KNOW YOU KNOW THAT ANY FIREARM CAN BE CONVERTED TO A RAPID FIRE

[73:01] LIKE A BOMB STUCK WITH A SIMPLE RUBBER BAND WHO BUNKS STOCK RUBBER BAND TRICK YOU'LL SEE THAT BANNING BUMP STOCKS A FEW TILE AND DISINGENUOUS AT BEST. GUN OWNERS LAUGH HARD AT UNWITTING POLITICIANS WHO THINK BANNING BOMB STOCKS HAS ANY SORT OF MERIT WHATSOEVER IT DOESN'T STICK AND RUBBER BANDS AS WELL. BOULDER CITY COUNCIL'S ALL LEFT APPROACH HAS TURNED ME A BOULDER DEMOCRAT INTO A NEW SCHOOL REPUBLICAN. I JUST CHANGE MY PARTY AFFILIATION BECAUSE OF YOUR WALLET LEFT ATTITUDE HAVE HEARD OF MANY BOULDER RESIDENTS DOING THE SAME YOU'RE LOSING A LOT OF SUPPORT IN THE CITY AND THE DISCORD IS GROWING LOUDER AND LOUDER. DON'T SHOOT YOURSELF IN THE FOOT CITY COUNCIL. CONGRATULATIONS BOULDER CITY COUNCIL. YOUR ONCE AGAIN GOVERNING EXTREMIST LEFT VALUES YOURSELF OR CLAIM LAWS OF THE CONSTITUTION OF THE PEOPLE'S SOCIALIST

[74:00] REPUBLIC OF BOULDER NO FREEDOM NO RESPONSE THE EASY AND NO REGARD FOR FEDERAL BANK. THANK YOU VERY MUCH TO THE AUDIENCE PLEASE NO OUTBURST OF ANY KIND AND GOOD EVENING MY NAMES AND OR J O'CONNOR. I'VE LIVED IN BOULDER SINCE NINETEEN NINETY FOUR I MARRIED AND HAVE A NINE YEAR OLD DAUGHTER WHO ATTENDS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL IN BOULDER. I'M HERE TONIGHT TO STAND UP FOR WOMEN AND CHILDREN AND THERE DUE TO PASS THIS COMMON SENSE REASONABLE ORDINANCE ON THIRD READING IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO. WE CAN NO LONGER LET THE NRA OR THE ROCKY MOUNTAIN OWNERS CONTROL THE DISCOURSE IN THIS DEBATE WHO'S CRAZIER NICHOLAS CRUZ OR THE AMERICAN SOCIETY LED BY NE AR FIFTEEN THERE ARE THREE MILLION AND SEVEN TO THREE MILLION TO SEVEN MILLION MUSLIMS IN THIS COUNTRY ONLY FIVE MILLION NRA MEMBERS SO MASS MEMBERSHIP DRIVE BY MUSLIM AMERICANS COULD EFFECTIVELY GIVE THEM CONTROL THE ORGANIZATION

[75:00] MORE IMPORTANTLY THE PROSPECT OF MORE MUSLIMS ARE WITH THEY ARE FIFTEEN OTHER WEAPONS OF WAR BUT PETRIFIED CONSERVATIVE WHITE SUPREMACISTS JUST A BIT COS E PHOTOS OF PJ CLAD WOMEN WIELDING A AR FIFTEEN ASSAULT RIFLES AT THE LOCAL GUN RANGE BILLBOARD IS CLAIMING THAT THE ONLY WAY TO STOP A BAD GUY WITH A GUN IS A GOOD GUY WITH A MUSLIM IS A GOOD MUSLIM WITH A GUN REPUBLICANS IT'S ONLY SEE THE WISDOM OF UNIVERSAL BACKGROUND CHECKS LONGER WAITING TIMES FOR PURCHASES AND OTHER RESTRICTIONS YOU MIGHT EVEN SEE SOME RIGHT WINGERS AND MY SUPREME START QUESTIONING THE SECOND AMENDMENT ITSELF THE NRA ONLY CARES ABOUT ARMING WHITE AMERICANS AGAINST THEIR FEAR OF DARK SKINNED CRIMINALS AND TERRORISTS. AGAIN THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU'RE DOING. THANK YOU LOUISE BRADLEY AND LOUISE AND AFTER LOUISE WE HAVE KATHY JOIN LOUISE BRADLEY ON YOUR VOTER ROLLS ALICE L BRANTLEY BEEN HERE SINCE NINETEEN FIFTY SEVEN AND I THANK YOU FOR LISTED ALL

[76:00] THESE URGENT MATTERS THAT YOU TAKE YOUR TIME TO LISTEN TO AND I WOULD SAY AMONG THE MOST URGENT IS THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF YOUR CITIZENS SO TO MAKE IT SHORT I CAME TO SKI AND T SCHOOL AND I FOUND THIS INCREDIBLY CUTE GEOLOGY PROFESSOR AND I'VE STAYED EVER SINCE YOU SLEEP SO WE RETIRED AND TO FRAZIER FIVE YEARS AGO JUST IN TIME FOR THE FLOOD. WELL WE ARE THERE FEW MONTHS AND WE ESCAPED WITH ONLY MINOR FINANCIAL COUPLE CARS A BICYCLE OF SOME FURNITURE SOME PHOTO ALBUMS BUT NOTHING SERIOUS BUT AS WE AGE WE ARE LESS ABLE TO SCRAMBLE UP STAIRS MY POST POLIO HUSBAND DOW HAS TEN WHEELCHAIR AND SO I URGE YOU TO REALLY THINK ABOUT OUR SAFETY AND ALL THOSE WONDERFUL PEOPLE THAT I LIVE WITH LIKE THIS LAST WEEK A WEEK OF RAIN AND WILL USE

[77:01] ALL THINK THIS WILL BE THE NEXT ONE SO I URGE YOU THERE'S URGENCY OF DECISION FOR YOU TO MAKE IT WE TRUST ENGINEERS TO MAKE A GOOD DECISION. WE QUESTION THE MOTIVES OF THOUGH THIS SAYS SAY IT SHOULD BE SAFE FOR A THOUSAND OR FIVE OR FIVE HUNDRED YEAR FLOOD. WE SUSPECT THEY MAY BE AT A UNIVERSITY OR ANTI ANY GROWTH SO YOU MUST START THEIR MOTIVES FROM THE SAFETY OF YOUR SODA SINCE I THINK SO WE KNEW IT WAS BUDGETED FOR TWENTY EIGHTEEN. THE MEETING SAID THE COMMENTS I'VE SKIED THE PROPERTY I HIKE THE PREPPY AND IT'S REALLY TIME TO ACT SO THAT ALL HAVE TO SAY REALLY. RIGHT WELL THANK YOU VERY MUCH KATHY AFTER CAT THE DAVID MCCOY

[78:08] GOOD EVENING MY NAME IS KATHY JOIN OUR LIVE IN KUALA DRIVE IN BOULDER AND I IMAGINE THAT YOU GUYS ALL RECEIVED IN YOUR UTILITY BILL THIS LITTLE FLYER ABOUT FLOOD SAFETY. WELL I DIDN'T I READ IT CAREFULLY AND I NOTICED THAT ONE OF THE ITEMS ON THE EARS TO MOVE TO HIGHER GROUND. I JUST WANT TO REMIND COUNCIL THAT IN TWENTY THIRTEEN MY NEIGHBORHOOD HAD NO OPPORTUNITY TO MOVE TO HIGHER GROUND. THERE WAS NO WAY FOR EMERGENCY RESPONDERS TOOK TO ACCESS OUR NEIGHBORHOOD. MORE WILL WE ABLE TO LEAVE IN AN EMERGENCY SO THE CITY HAS BEEN STUDYING THE SOUTH BOULDER CREEK FLOOD MITIGATION FOR OVER TWO DECADES TO DATE SEVEN YEARS OF ANALYSIS HAS BEEN SPENT ON THIS LATEST EFFORT PLEASE KNOW THAT WE ARE VERY APPRECIATIVE OF ALL YOUR PAST SUPPORT. STILL THERE SEVERAL YEARS LEFT TO PROJECT COMPLETION WITH NO INTERIM SOLUTION WOULD LIKE TO ENCOURAGE COUNCIL TO FIND

[79:01] WAYS TO MOVES AT MOVE AS QUICKLY AS HUMANLY POSSIBLE ON ADVANCING THIS PROJECT IN THE COMING WEEKS. STAFF WILL BE PRESENTING RESULTS OF OPTIONS ANALYZE TO CITY BOARDS AND COUNSEL FOR THE SELECTION OF A FLOOD MITIGATION ALTERNATIVES TO BE ADVANCED FROM THE CURRENT CONCEPT FACED A PRELIMINARY DESIGN ALL OF THE OPTIONS TO BE PRESENTED TO BOARD AND COUNCIL WILL HAVE TO MEET THESE BASELINE CRITERIA THEY MUST PREVENT OVER TOPPING OF U S THIRTY SIX DURING THE HUNDRED YEAR FLOOD DESIGN AT A MINIMUM THEY MUST BE PERMISSIBLE BY REGULATORY AGENCIES INCLUDING FEMALE EPA CORPS OF ENGINEERS AND FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE. THEY MUST BE ACCEPTABLE TO STATE ENGINEERS ARE ENGINEERS OFFICE THE LANDOWNERS MUST BE WILLING TO HAVE THE CONSTRUCTION TAKE PLACE ON THEIR SITE IMPACTS TO GROUNDWATER MUST BE MITIGATED AS ALL OF THESE OPTIONS WILL BE PRESENTED HERE IN THE COMING WEEKS WILL HAVE MET THESE THESE BASELINE CRITERIA WE WOULD URGE YOU TO SELECT THE ONE THAT CAN BE IMPLEMENTED AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. NO ONE CAN TAKE

[80:01] THE PLACE OF OUR GOOD FRIEND OWL WILL CLAIM HE WAS ONE IN A MILLION AND THE GOLD YOU MANY MESSAGES IN THE PAST TO HURRY UP AND DO SOMETHING BUT I DO MY BEST TO CHANNEL HIM IN HIS TYPICAL COURTEOUS MANNER WHEN HE ASKED WHAT IS TAKING SO LONG. THANK YOU THANK YOU CATHY DAVID MCGUIRE AND THEN LYNNE SEGAL AND IN THE WIRE AND WOODEN FRASIER MEADOWS NEIGHBORHOOD BOULDER COLORADO AND IT'S BEEN NEARLY FIVE YEARS SINCE THE TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN FLOOD DEVASTATED MANY OF OUR NEIGHBORHOODS IN THE FLOODWATERS WERE COMING OVER U S THIRTY SIX. I ASKED RESPONSIBILITY AND MORAL OBLIGATION OF ELECTED OFFICIALS IS TO PROTECT THE HEALTH SAFETY AND WELFARE OF ITS CITIZENS WE'VE SEEN OUR COUNCIL RECENTLY TAKE ON LETHAL WEAPONS AS A KNOWN THREAT TO THIS COMMUNITY IN ORDER TO SAVE LIVES THERE ARE OVER THREE THOUSAND OF US STARING DOWN THE BARREL OF A KNOWN LETHAL THREAT THAT IS

[81:02] POINTED AT US FROM ACROSS U S THIRTY SIX AND WE'RE FORTUNATE THAT HAS NOT GONE OFF IN THE LAST FOUR AND A HALF YEARS. PLEASE APPLY THE SAME COURAGE YOU HAVE DISPLAYED IN YOUR OTHER BATTLES TO SAVE LIVES IN OUR COMMUNITY WHEN GUIDING THE SOME PORT AND FLOOD MITIGATION PROGRAM FORWARD OUR LIVES DEPEND ON IT AND THANK YOU FOR MOVING THIS THROUGH THE COMP PLAN PROCESS THIS PAST YEAR AND NOW THROUGH THE PLANNING AND IMPLEMENTATION PHASES OF THE SOUTH BOULDER CREEK MITIGATION PROJECT. THANK YOU THANK YOU TO RUN AFTER LAN WE HAVE PATRICK MURPHY IMAN SINGLE MOUNTAIN HEIGHTS BOULDER AND I WANTED TO BRING UP THIS AND YOU KNOW HAWAII IN AND KILL AWAY AND AND AND AND KAI INTERESTING THING AND THERE'S A GEOTHERMAL POWER PLANT RIGHT NEAR WHERE ONE OF

[82:02] THAT AND YOU KNOW LAVA FORMATIONS ARE FISSURES ARE COMING OUT AND SELL IT JUST KIND OF IRONIC. THERE'S A WAY OF GETTING GEOTHERMAL HEAT AND YET THAT NATURAL FORCES THAT THE GEOTHERMAL HEAT ARE OVERCOME IN THAT VERY THAT ABILITY. I THINK THAT AND AN ANALOGY CAN BE MADE WITH THE HOUSING SITUATION IN THE UNITED STATES AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND AND BOULDERS APPROACH TO IT PARTICULARLY WITH REGARDS TO AIR B AND B AND THE SHORT TERM RENTAL SITUATION THAT THAT HAS BEEN ADDRESSED THROUGH THE HOUSING AND WORKS WITH THE HOUSING ADVISORY BOARD AND MOE'S AND EIGHTY USE AND IT'S JUST IT'S QUITE REMARKABLE THAT THAT

[83:00] THE RESIDENTS THAT HAVE BEEN HERE FOR A LONG TIME MOM AND DAD MEANT HIKING CLUB YOU KNOW AND WE ARE ALL INDEPENDENTLY WEALTHY AND I COMMUTED TO DENVER FOR TWENTY FIVE YEARS NOW I'M COMPETING OUT OF MY HOUSE AND I'D LIKE TO SEE SOME BENEFITS NOT ATTRACTIONS NOT THE CITY TAKING TWELVE PERCENT FROM MY GUESTS ON THEIR B AND B IT'S A GREAT WAY OF MAXIMIZING LAND USE AND KEEPING BEDROOMS FULL AND I DON'T THINK YOU COULD ASK FOR MORE. IT'S A PLATFORM AND IT IS REACTING TO MARKET RATES THAT I AM DOING. IN FACT EVERY NBA HAS SMART PRICING AND AND THANKS FOR AN INSTANT BOOK AND LOTS OF FEATURES THAT THE CITY OF BOULDER IS NOT PROVIDING ME WITH THEIR TWELVE PERCENT FOR JAMIE PATRICK MURPHY AND THEN MARTY COMBS MY NAME IS PATRICK MURPHY HALL IN

[84:01] BOULDER DEMOCRACIA TIES DECENTRALIZED CARBON EYES AND DEMONIZE THE WORLD INTO THE POCKET EYES FIXED ARISE HYPERBOLE LIES. LET ME PROVIDE SOME EXAMPLES. LAST NIGHT CLEAN ENERGY ACTION INTRODUCED TWO SPEAKERS ONE WONDERFUL LADY SPOKE ON SOCIAL EQUITY AND UNFORTUNATELY HAD TO STRUGGLE WITH A FAILED COMPUTER CONNECTOR THE SECOND LADY DID A PRESENTATION OF THE HORRORS OF THE NEVADA POWER COMPANY EXTRAPOLATED ALL THOSE HORRORS TO EXCEL WITH NO EVIDENCE AT ALL. SHE ADMITTED THAT FACT AFTER I QUESTIONED OR THIS LADY IS A LAWYER WHEN I ASKED HER WHAT WAS BETTER HIGHLY REGULATED MONOPOLY LIKE EXCEL OR NON REGULATED MONOPOLY LIKE BOULDER. SHE STATED THAT BOULDER WOULD BE A MONOPOLY BECAUSE ITS RESIDENTS WOULD HAVE SOME SORT OF CHOICE OF WORLDWIDE ELECTRICITY IN A BOULDER MUNI SHOW ALSO BACKTRACKED ON THIS AND STATED THAT EVEN WITH A MONOPOLY. WE WOULD HAVE ALL KINDS OF OPPORTUNITY TO

[85:00] CONTROL OUR POWER. IN FACT THERE WOULD BE NO MORE OR LESS CHOICE THAN WE ALREADY HAVE WITH EXCEL. THE ONLY REAL CHOICE FOR REAL DEMOCRATIZATION AND DECENTRALIZATION WOULD OCCUR IF WE COULD PICK ANYONE YOU WANTED IS OUR SUPPLIER BOWL OR EXCEL OR ANYONE BUT WE WON'T HAVE THAT CHOICE. NOT THAT BOULDER COULDN'T GIVE US THE CHOICE SINCE THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT WE'RE GOING TO DO WITH A GUN BARREL REACH RESIDENTS THEY WOULD BE XL CUSTOMERS BUT BOULDER WOULD BE THE DISTRIBUTION SUPPLIER OF BOULDER TO DO THAT FOR THEM. BOULDER COULD DO THAT FOR ANYONE BUT WE WON'T BECAUSE WE'D BE A MONOPOLY THAT DEMONSTRATES MUNI HYPOCRISY. LAST WEEK MISS GUEST ROOM SPONSORED A TALK ABOUT COAL ASH THE VELMA PLANT SHUTDOWN SHE PRESENTED BAR GRAPH SHOWING GROUNDWATER POLLUTION IMPLYING THAT THE DATA WERE ASSOCIATED WITH BELMONT WHEN I ASKED HER WHERE SHE GOT HER DATA. SHE DIDN'T KNOW THAT SUCKS

[86:03] TOURISM RIGHT THANK YOU PATRICK. MARTY AN F AFTER MARTY WE HAVE LANCE CAGLE. HI MARTY COMBS LIVE OFF OF LINDEN IN BOULDER COLORADO NET LIKE TO SEE MY TIME TO CODY WISNIEWSKI THANK YOU MAYOR COUNCIL MEMBERS NAME IS CODY WAS NEW SKI ON A STAFF ATTORNEY AT MOUNTAIN STATES LEGAL FOUNDATION. I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF MY CLIENTS IN REGARD TO THE FIREARMS ORDINANCE. I FIND IT UNFORTUNATE THAT WE'RE STILL CONSIDERING THIS ORDINANCE WHICH DIRECTLY DISCRIMINATES AGAINST A POLITICAL MINORITY IN THIS COMMUNITY. THIS IS TRAGICALLY IRONIC GIVEN THE OPEN NESS AND WELCOME IS THAT BOULDER CAN VASE AND IT'S NORMAL MESSAGING AS A RESULT EVEN THOUGH THERE IS SOME QUESTION WHETHER THIS COUNCIL WILL PASS THIS ON THIRD READING. SHOULD THE COUNCIL PASSED THE ORDINANCE ON THIRD READING. WE ARE READY AND PRESENTLY GOING TO FILE A

[87:01] LAWSUIT AGAINST CITY OF BOULDER ALLEGING VIOLATIONS OF THE SECOND AMENDMENT THE FIFTH AMENDMENT THE FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT THE COLORADO CONSTITUTION CURRENT STATUTORY PROVISIONS AND WE WILL BE NAMING AS A DEFENDANT AMONG OTHERS. EACH COUNCIL MEMBER THAT VOTES IN FAVOR OF PASSING THE ORDINANCE. THANK YOU THANK YOU EXCUSE ME AUDIENCE NEXT STEP WE HAVE LANCE AND THEN ROBERT AND EVEN COUNCIL LANCE LIKE A BOULDER COUNTY I'M HERE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF THE GUN ORDINANCE BANNED AS A FATHER OF FOUR WITH EACH CHILD IN A SCHOOL I AM NOT IMMUNE TO THE SHOCKING HEADLINES PUT FORTH BY THE MEDIA EVERY DAY SINCE THE PARK AND SHOOTING I HAVE BEEN ON EDGE WORRYING ABOUT MY CHILDREN AND IF THEY WILL MAKE IT HOME SAFELY OR BE THE VICTIMS OF ANOTHER MASS SHOOTING. I SHARE THIS UNEASY HELPLESS AND FRIGHTENED FEELING WITH GROUPS LIKE MOTHERS TO MAN

[88:00] ACTION BUT I WILL NOT ALLOW MYSELF AND MY FAMILY TO BE LED DOWN A PATH THAT DOES NOT LEAD TO REAL SOLUTION TONIGHT THEY ARE TO CITY COUNCIL BOULDER TO OPEN A DIALOGUE TO THE FACTS ACCORDING TO BULLOCK OF BULLOCK ALREADY BACK OF THE URBAN ZERO MURDERS BY JUVENILES SINCE TWENTY THIRTEEN SIX BY ADULTS AND NO INSTANCE OF A MASS MURDER BY GUN AS DEFINED BY THE FBI THE FBI DEFINES MASS MURDER AS MURDERING FOUR MORE PERSONS DURING AN EVENT WITH NO COOLING OFF PERIOD BETWEEN THE MURDERS WITH A POPULATION OF ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHT THOUSAND AN AVERAGE MURDER RATE OF ONE POINT TWO MURDERS PER CAPITA SINCE TWENTY THIRTEEN. YOU HAVE A ONE POINT TWO IN ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHT THOUSAND CHANCE OF BEING MURDERED BY AN ADULT IN BOULDER BUT EVER SINCE IT IS SIX REPORT MURDERS BUT WHO KNOWS YOU HAVE A ZERO PERCENT CHANCE OF BEING MURDERED BY DUBAI NOW THEREFORE I ASK CITY COUNCIL AND THE ADVOCATES FOR THIS ORDINANCE TO ASK THEMSELVES WHAT PROBLEM IN BOULDER ARE YOU SOLVING THOSE WHO OPPOSE THIS ORDINANCE SEE THIS AS SIMPLY A WHOLE SOLUTION SO THAT WE CAN ALL FEEL BETTER

[89:00] BECAUSE WE DID SOMETHING BUT WHAT DOES THIS ORDINANCE TO BE SAID CRIMINALIZE LAW BIDING CITIZENS IN WHY THE GAP BETWEEN AN ALREADY POLITICALLY POLARIZED POPULATION IN TWENTY TWELVE WE DECIDED IT WAS HIGH TIME THAT THE CITY SINCE IT SHOULD BE TAUGHT IN JAIL FOR POSSESSING A PLANT AND THUS WE CRIMINALIZE CANNABIS THE POET HAS THE SAME PROHIBITION DOESN'T WORK BANS DO NOT WORK. THE ONLY INCREASE CRIME BECAUSE CRIMINALS NOT FOLLOW THE LAW IF YOU WANT A SOLUTION HERE IT IS IN FULL RECORD AS A LIBERTARIAN I'M ONE HUNDRED PERCENT AGAINST ANY TAX WHATSOEVER BUT I UNDERSTAND A COMPROMISE IN ORDER. CRUMP ALSO SHOWS THAT WHEN YOU TAX SOMETHING YOU HAVE LESS OF IT WHEN YOU SUBSIDIZE SOMETHING YOU HAVE MORE BUT THE PLASTIC BAG TAX CAMPBELL IS PROOF OF CONCEPT THEREFORE IF YOU WANT LESS OF CERTAIN GUNS IN BOULDER. TAX THEM AND THERE WILL BE LESS OF THEM THEN MAKE A TAX THAT NEED TO SOME KIDS ARE THE HEALTH PROGRAM'S SAFETY CHECKPOINT AT SCHOOLS AND YES EVEN ON SATURDAY AND SHE WROTE IN AND MICHAEL BLOCH ROBERT ANDREW SULLIVAN

[90:00] FOLSOM ST. IF YOU STUDY THE FRENCH THE RUSSIANS AND THE CHINESE COMMUNIST REVOLUTIONS IN THE FASCIST TAKEOVER IN GERMANY. YOU LEARN THAT MILLIONS OF AVERAGE CITIZENS MUCH LIKE US IN THIS ROOM ARE KILLED BY THEIR OWN GOVERNMENTS BY FAMINE FORCED LABOR GAS CHAMBERS IN ASSASSINATION BY GUN THEY WERE KILLED FOR IDEOLOGY IF YOU HAD THE RIGHT IDEOLOGY YOU MIGHT LIVE AND PROSPER IF YOU HAD THE WRONG IDEOLOGY OR FEWER A FREE THINKER YOU ARE BRANDED AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE AN ENEMY OF THE STATE AND YOU LOST YOUR LIFE. WHY DIDN'T THESE PEOPLE DEFEND THEMSELVES IN GERMANY HITLER HITLER HAD ACCESS TO EXTENSIVE GUN REGISTRATION. CREATED BY THE Y MY REPUBLIC HE CONFISCATED THE GUNS OF GYPSIES AND OTHER ENEMIES OF THE STATE MAKING IT MUCH EASIER TO EXTERMINATE THEM AND COMMUNIST RUSSIA AND CHINA MOST PEOPLE WERE POURING COULD NOT AFFORD GUNS TO GUN CONFISCATION WAS NOT AN ISSUE IN THE UNITED STATES WE HAVE THE SECOND AMENDMENT

[91:01] WE HAVE THIS HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE AND THUS MY PLACE WE HAVE THIS HISTORIC PERSPECTIVE UNITED STATES AND WE HAVE THE DISCRETIONARY INCOME TO BUY MILLIONS OF GUNS AND WE HAD SO WE HAVE DONE SO AND WE CONTINUE TO STOKE MOST AMERICAN GUN OWNERS UNDERSTAND THAT THE PRIMARY PURPOSE OF GUNS IS DEFENSE TO DEFEND OURSELVES AGAINST WHAT HAPPENED TO MILLIONS OF GERMANS RUSSIANS AND CHINESE CITIZENS IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY AND THESE MURDERS CONTINUE INTO THE TWENTY FIRST CENTURY PARTICULARLY IN THE MIDDLE EAST AND RIGHT AT THE END TODAY. MASSIVE DESTRUCTION MASSIVELY DESTRUCTIVE WEAPONS PURCHASED REGULARLY BY AMERICANS WITH AMERICAN TAX DOLLARS AND SOLD BY BOTH THE DEMOCRATS THE REPUBLICAN ADMINISTRATION TO ALL TAKERS PARTICULARLY IN THE MIDDLE EAST ON BOTH SIDES OF EVERY CONFLICT RESULTING IN THE DESTRUCTION OF ENTIRE COUNTRIES THE DISPLACEMENT OF MILLION FROM THEIR HOMES

[92:00] THE MURDER OF THOUSANDS THANK YOU SOLDIER AND THESE TWO GUN ISSUES ARE RELATED AND DON'T GO FORWARD UNTIL YOU MAKE THAT LINK. THANK YOU MICHAEL AND THEN WE HAVE RACHEL FRIEND HEIL MICHAEL GORE PONDEROSA MOBILE HOME PARK I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT GUNS I WOULD LIKE TO PROTEST THE CITY'S PLAN TO BUILD HOUSES ON THE WEST END OF PONDEROSA MOBILE HOME PARK FIRSTLY I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THAT STRIP OF LAND BECOMING A GREEN BEAR TO ALWAYS DEVELOP MINORITY BUILT ON LAND ORIGINALLY DESIGNATED BY THE BENEFACTOR TO THE CITY FOR OPEN SPACE. SECONDLY JUST BECAUSE WE ARE LOW INCOME DOES MEAN WE ARE DESERVING OF SOME BEAUTIFYING NATURAL ADDITIONS TO OUR EXISTENCE LIKE TREES AND PLANTS FOR THE MORE HOUSES MEAN MORE TRAFFIC NOISE AND PEOPLE POLLUTION IMPACTING OUR LIVES EVEN AFTER THE TWO YEARS OF

[93:03] CONSTRUCTION WE PUT UP WITH FOR THE BUILDING OF STRUCTURES ALREADY TO THE WEST OF THE PARK AND I WOULD LIKE TO PROTEST ALL OF THE PARKING OF VEHICLES ON THAT STRIPPER OF AIR NOW HOME A BUNCH OF TRUCKS AND KIND OF THINGS THAT SHOULDN'T EVEN BE THERE. IT'S AN EYESORE AND IT'S ABOUT A THANK YOU FOR COMING TO SHOW THAT NIGHT WE HAVE A QUESTION FOR YOU SIR WELL IT MIGHT BE A STAFF QUESTION IT IS THE LAND ADJACENT CITY LAND THAT WE HAVE A PLAN TO BUILD ON THE I DON'T KNOW AND I DON'T KNOW KURT FOR NUMBERS IN THE AUDIENCE YET YOU PUT YOUR PLAN IS TO BUILD TEN HOUSES UNFAIR TO THE WEST OF THE TRAILER PARK. THERE'S A LITTLE STRIP OF LAND THIS POST TO BE OPEN SPACE. NOW IT'S FILLED WITH TRUCKS AND

[94:00] TRAILERS. OH AND HERE AS CURRENT AND SHOULD SHOULD BE REMOVED IT SHOULD BE ON STRIP OF GREEN BEANIES SHOULDN'T BE ATTRACTED BY THE WAY WE SHOULDN'T BE IMPACTED ABOUT ANOTHER MORE HOUSES BEING BUILT. THANK YOU SO HOPE HIS SOUL AND WAS BEEN FACTORED IN AND THE CITY DECIDE TO TRADE SOMEHOW MICHAEL R YET JUST WANTED TO CONFIRM THAT WAS CITY AND NOT PRIVATE LAND AND JUST HEAR A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE PLANS ARE TO BE OKAY GREAT. MAYBE WE CAN DO ABOUT IT AS SOON AS WE ARE DONE IN A FEW MORE PEOPLE HEAR FROM HIM EXCEPT RACHEL FRIEND AND MAN LANCE TO BETTY. YES I AM RACHEL FRIEND BOULDER CITY RESIDENT ELEVEN THE FRASIER MEADOWS NEIGHBORHOOD. BEAR WITH ME A SECOND THIS INTRO I ONCE HAD A JOB HAD TO DO STRATEGIC PLANNING FOR A COMPANY WHERE WE MAPPED OUT LIKE THE COURSE OF THE COMING DECADE FOR THE NON PROFIT AT

[95:01] THE END OF THE FIRST SESSION THE FACILITATOR GAVE US AN OVERVIEW OF WHERE WE WERE AND SAID SOMETHING THAT FOR ME WAS MAGICAL TO HEAR YOU ONLY HAVE TO TRY FOR GOOD ENOUGH AND FOR MY PART AS SOMEBODY WHO IS LIKE A STRAIGHT A STUDENT AND ALWAYS STRIVES FOR PERFECTION THAT WAS REALLY A REVELATION FOR ME AND IT HAS APPLIED ALL OVER MY LIFE AND IT APPLIES TO BOTH OF THE THINGS THAT I WANT TO SPEAK TO YOU ALL AND TONIGHT THE FIRST IS A LOT OF MY NEIGHBORS SOUTH BOULDER CREEK FLOOD MITIGATION EFFORTS ARE NEVER GOING TO FIND A PERFECT SOLUTION BUT YOU'VE ALREADY GOT ONE THAT'S GOOD ENOUGH ACCORDING TO SOME VERY SMART AND QUALIFIED ENGINEERS AND GOOD ENOUGH IS WHAT WE WILL NEED TO DO TO SAVE LIVES. SO WE'VE BEEN ON NOTICE OF WHAT THE CREEK CAN DO IN FRASIER MEADOWS NEIGHBORHOOD FOR ALMOST FIVE YEARS AND IT'S BEEN RAINING FOR ABOUT THE LAST FIVE DAYS AND A LOT OF MY NEIGHBORS WHEN IT RAINS FOR DAYS ON END GET ACTUALLY PTSD LIKE THEY THEY'RE THEY CAN'T SLEEP SO I THINK YOU GET ENOUGH AND IT'S TIME TO ACT THE SECOND THING

[96:03] IS FOR THE ASSAULT WEAPONS BAN. WE ONLY NEED TO GET TWO GOOD ENOUGH AND THAT I THINK AT THIS POINT AND AT SOME POINT YOU'LL HAVE TO HAVE HEARD ENOUGH OF THIS TOXIC TOPIC FROM ALL OF US AND THERE'S ALL THESE PASSIONATE PEOPLE ON BOTH SIDES THAT COME OUT AND TUESDAY NIGHTS AND AT SOME POINT AND I'M HOPING IT'S TONIGHT'S HOPE YOU ALL A PASS. THE ASSAULT WEAPONS BAN AND OTHER THINGS A GO WITH IT AND SAY IT'S GOOD ENOUGH AND THEN IF POSSIBLE TWEAK IT THROUGH AMENDMENTS. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE OPTIONS ARE FOR FOR CHANGING THINGS AFTER YOU PASS THEM BUT I HOPE THAT IT CAN GET PAST TONIGHT AND THEN IF THERE ARE DISAGREEMENTS AND CAN AMEND IT GOING FORWARD BECAUSE THIS ROOM FEELS VERY TOXIC TO ME AND I THINK THAT IT WOULD BE GOOD IF YOU GUYS COULDN'T GET THROUGH IT. THANK YOU THANK YOU RACHEL LANTZ AFTER LANCE WE HAVE JONATHAN WITH ME

[97:00] THANK YOU FOR LET ME TALK I'M A NAME IS LANCE TO BE I LIVED IN BOULDER FOR ABOUT FIFTEEN YEARS I LIVE IN LONGMONT NOW I JUST WANTED TO SPEAK ABOUT THE GUN PROPOSED GUN LAW THE PROPOSED INFRINGEMENT ON INNOCENT CITIZENS RIGHTS IS A DETESTABLE ACTION WITH NO CLEAR HISTORY OF SUCCESS ASIDE FROM BEING IN DIRECT OPPOSITION TO THE SECOND AMENDMENT IS QUITE PROBABLY UNENFORCEABLE. THE BIGGEST RESULT WILL BE TURNING LAW BIDING CITIZENS INTO INSTANT CRIMINALS SIMPLY BY CONTINUING THE HERETOFORE LEGAL OWNERSHIP OF SELF DEFENSE FIREARMS WHICH ARE NOW GIVEN THE NEBULOUS AND HOT BUT NAME OF ASSAULT WEAPONS A DEFINITION WHICH VARIES DEPENDING ON THE DESIRED EFFECT SIMPLY MAKING LOSS TO FEEL GOOD OR TO SHOW EFFORT IS RIDICULOUS AND SHORT SIGHTED IN FACT THE RESULTS. THESE LAWS AND FOUR ARE ALREADY LAWS ASSAULT IS A CRIME MURDER IS A CRIME PUTTING MORE POINTLESS LOSS ON THE BOOKS MERELY FEEDS AN EGO OR ATTEMPTS TO JUSTIFY SOME SORT OF WORK. WHY ARE SOME DEMONIZING THE NRA NO MASS MURDER MASS MURDERS OR SHOOTERS HAVE EVER BEEN NRA MEMBERS THOUGH SOME ARE ONE

[98:00] MASS KILLER WAS STOPPED BY OWNER NRA MEMBER. SOME SEE THESE ISSUES AND DEMAND ACTION. MANY OF US SEE THESE ISSUES AND DEMAND ENFORCEMENT OF EXISTING LAWS. PLEASE LEAVE A LAW ABIDING CITIZEN'S ABILITY TO DEFEND THEMSELVES OUT OF THIS QUEST FOR POLITICAL CORRECTNESS. THANK YOU THANK YOU JONATHAN AND THEN WINCED OUTER EVENING COUNCIL PLANS ON THE WAY I'M BOULDER CITY RESIDENT IN THE NOBLE PARK NEIGHBORHOOD COLORADO NATIVE AND I LIKE TO SEE MY TIME TO JASON VARGAS COUNCIL. SO I LIVED IN A BOULDER FOR TWENTY SEVEN YEARS AND AS A MEMBER OF THE BORDER COMMUNITY FOR THE LAST TWENTY SEVEN YEARS I MUST EXPRESS THEM VERY DISAPPOINTED IN THE COUNCIL DECISION TO CONTINUE TO PURSUE THESE PURSUE THIS BAND COUNCILWOMAN MARY YOUNG AND NEARBY TABLE TO PUT FORTH A STRONG EFFORT TO BRING ALL PARTIES THE TABLE FOR

[99:00] RATIONAL CONVERSATION WITH A COUNTER PROPOSAL ONLY TO HAVE OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS REJECT THE IDEA UNDER PRESSURE INFLUENCE FROM NATIONAL INTEREST GROUP MOMS DEMAND ACTION. THIS WILL BE FORGOTTEN. IT'S SAD THAT THE COUNCIL'S PURSUIT A SOLUTION FOR A NONEXISTENT PROBLEM IN OUR COMMUNITY A SOLUTION IS SO DIVISION IN OUR COMMUNITY WELL BEING UNENFORCEABLE. IT WILL LIKELY BE STRUCK DOWN UNDER STATE PREEMPTION LAW ALL WHILE DOING LITTLE TO NOTHING TO ADDRESS ACTUAL HEALTH AND SAFETY ISSUES MAY ACTUALLY INCREASE CRIME. LIKE ALL OF THESE BANDS DO AS I STATED AT FIRST READING THE COUNCIL'S BEEN ILL ADVISED ON THIS FROM THE GET GO. THE PROPOSED ORDINANCE WILL COST THE CITY DEARLY IN THE ENSUING LAWSUITS. WHY DID THE COUNCIL LISTS THE FISCAL IMPACT OF THIS ORDINANCE ZERO DOLLARS IT MUST BE FOR THE SAME REASON THAT THE CITY IS RUNNING A FOUR MILLION DOLLARS BUDGET DEFICIT BECAUSE THE COUNCIL SEEMS TO WASTE TAXPAYER MONEY ON FRIVOLOUS THINGS. TOM CORPS

[100:00] HAS A HISTORY OF BEING CONSTITUTIONALLY GRAY IN THROUGH THOSE ACTIONS COST THE CITY OF SEATTLE MILLIONS AND MILLIONS OF DOLLARS HERE NOW IS WHERE WE SAT DOWN TO START DOWN THE SAME ROAD FOR BOULDER. I ENCOURAGE ANYONE TO GOOGLE BOULDER WEEKLY TOM CARPER IN READ ARTICLE THAT THEY WROTE ABOUT TOM. IT DETAILS WHAT IS ABOUT TO HAPPEN TO OUR CITY WITH HIS IN JOE BROWN KNOWS OVERREACH THE COUNCIL CAN STILL AVOID ALL OF THIS STOP IN VOTE NO CONTINUED PROTESTS DON'T NEED TO HAPPEN. THE LAWSUITS CAN BE AVOIDED. NO THANK YOU WHEN STONER AND THEN LAST OF JULIAN WATERS TEEMING BOULDER CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS THE SECOND AMENDMENT READS A WELL REGULATED MILITIA BEING NECESSARY TO THE SECURITY OF A FREE STATE THE RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE TO KEEP AND BEAR ARMS SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED UPON. IT IS OUR GOD GIVEN RIGHT TO PROTECT OUR FAMILIES HOW WE SEE FIT. THE SECOND AMENDMENT WAS CREATED TO PROTECT THAT RIGHT NOT GIVE

[101:00] US THAT RITE AID YOU ARE INFRINGING ON THAT RIGHT WITH YOUR PROPOSED A W MANN THOMAS JEFFERSON SAID LAWS THAT FORBID THE CARRYING OF ARMS DISARM ONLY THOSE WHO ARE NEITHER INCLINED NOR DETERMINED TO COMMIT CRIMES IS A W BAND GOES AGAINST OUR SECOND AMENDMENT RIGHT MAKING THIS POTENTIAL RULING UNLAWFUL AS YOU CERTAINLY INFRINGING ON MY RIGHTS. THIS IS NOTHING MORE THAN A PURE GUN GRAB AS MOSSAD THEIR GRANDMA MENTION SHE'S ALL FOR TAKING THE GUNS JUST LIKE THEY'VE DONE IN CHICAGO WHICH MIGHT I ADD HAVE THE HIGHEST CRIME RATES AND THE STRICTEST GUN LAWS. MR. WEAVER WROTE IN A TEXT MESSAGE IF THE UW BAND THAT COUNCIL MAY PASS GOES THROUGH AND IS CHALLENGED BY THE STATE COURT SYSTEM WE MIGHT LOSE ON THE GROUNDS OF PREEMPTION BUT WE'RE CLEARLY ON SOLID GROUND REGARDING THE SECOND AMENDMENT MR. WEAVER THE HE. WHY NOT ON GROUNDS THE SECOND AMENDMENT YOU'RE INFRINGING ON THOSE WE DO NOT HAVE A GUN PROBLEM WE

[102:00] HAVE A MENTAL HEALTH AND HUMAN PROBLEM AND NOBODY IS ASKING THAT QUESTION. NOBODY IS ADDRESSING THAT ISSUE THEY JUST WANNA GO AFTER THE GUNS SO DRUNK DRIVERS KILL FAMILIES BLAME TONGUE TRIBE OR NOT THE CAR BOMBERS BOOK BUILDINGS AND KILL HUNDREDS BLAME THE BOMB OR NOT THE BOMB BUT THIS COUNCIL IS DOING IS NOTHING MORE THAN INSTILLING FEAR IN CITIZENS OF BOULDER WHO ARE IGNORANT ABOUT GUNS RIFLES ARE WHAT THE MAGAZINE IS AND WHAT IS ALREADY LEGAL OR ILLEGAL REGARDING THEM. PEOPLE FEAR WHAT THE DO NOT UNDERSTAND TRYING TO ENFORCE YOUR WILL UPON PEOPLE AND BLATANTLY VIOLATING AMERICANS' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS WILL GET YOU SUED. SO I PRAY THAT YOU RECONSIDER YOUR POSITION ON THIS MATTER BECAUSE I CAN PROMISE YOU THIS PEOPLE ARE WAKING A CAREFREE DAY TEASING TO THE AUDIENCE AND THE AUDIENCE NEEDS TO BE QUIET WITH EITHER SUPPORTIVE OR AGAINST WHAT'S BEING SAID

[103:00] AND PEOPLE THAT FAIL TO DO THAT GOING FORWARD WILL NEED TO LEAVE. K LETS ALL BE RESPECTFUL WHATEVER POSITIONS PEOPLE ESPOUSING JILLIAN JILLIAN WATERS AND I'M A RESIDENT OF THE CITY OF BOULDER RESIDING IN THE GUN BARREL NEIGHBORHOOD AND A MEMBER OF MOM SOME AND ACTION I'M HONORED TO SPEAK LAST BECAUSE I WILL NOT BE HAVING SOMEBODY ELSE SPEAK FOR ME AND I WILL NOT BE THREATENING ANYBODY. MY HUSBAND I BOTH GREW UP IMPACT IN FLORIDA AND HAVE NEVER BEEN MORE PROUD TO SAY WERE ALUMNI OF MARJORIE STONE DOUGLAS HIGH SCHOOL. HE CURRENTLY WORKS AS A PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO BOULDER. MY SON ATTENDS PRESCHOOL BOULDER AND MY DAUGHTER WAS BORN HERE IN BOULDER. DESPITE BEING FROM SOUTH FLORIDA AND RAISED THERE. WHEN ASKED WHERE WE'RE FROM OUR FAMILY IS PROUD TO SAY BOULDER COLORADO. I PRAY THAT AN EVENT LIKE THE ONE THAT SHOOK MY HOMETOWN NEVER HAPPENS HERE IN THE PLACE FOR MY CHILDREN WILL GROW UP TO BE CALLED HOME. I'M LUCKY THAT THE STUDENT I KNOW WHO ATTEND SOMA DOUGLAS WAS ABLE TO WALK OUT OF HIS HISTORY OF THE HOLOCAUST CLASS ON FEBRUARY FOURTEENTH I SAY LUCKY BECAUSE HIDING UNDER YOUR DESK AT SIXTEEN YEARS

[104:00] OLD AS UCONN WON AND WATCH TWO OF YOUR CLASSMATES DIE IN FRONT OF YOU SEEM TO BE SETTING THE LOCK BAR PRETTY LOW. NOT A SINGLE PIECE OF LEGISLATION WILL REMOVE ALL RISK OF TRAGEDY THAT IS NO REASON TO SIT AROUND AND DO NOTHING. IT'S NOT EASY TO BE PIONEERS IN LEGISLATION ON SUCH A HOT TOPIC ISSUE BUT IN THE ABSENCE OF A PERFECT SOLUTION. OUR ELECTED OFFICIALS HAVE A DUTY TO PERFORM THE DIFFICULT TASK OF MAKING THEIR BEST ATTEMPT AT KEEPING THEIR NEIGHBORS SAFE TO COLORADO'S KNOWN FOR ITS HISTORY BEING LEADERS IN PUTTING ACCEPTANCE SAFETY AND WELLBEING OF ITS CITIZENS FIRST. WITH THAT LEGACY IN MIND I URGE CITY COUNCIL TO PASS THE ORDINANCE THAT BANS ASSAULT WEAPONS AND HIGH CAPACITY MAGAZINES FOR THE GENERAL DON'T LET THE STATISTICS MENTIONED EARLIER ABOUT HOW SAFE BORDER IS TODAY RIGHT NOW FOOL YOU INTO THINKING TRAGEDY CANNOT HAPPEN HERE. ORDINANCES LIKE THE ONE YOU WILL BE DISCUSSING TODAY WILL ALWAYS BE TOO LATE FOR ME AND MY HOMETOWN THE SAFEST CITY IN FLORIDA WHEN SOMEONE FINDS OUT I'M FROM PARKLAND FLORIDA THEY WILL ALWAYS KNOW EXACTLY WHERE THAT IS WE KNOW THERE

[105:00] ARE LOTS OF WONDERFUL REASONS TO KNOW ABOUT THE TOWN OF BOULDER. DON'T LET IT BE DEFINED BY AN EVENT THAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN PREVENTED IF ONLY OUR ELECTED REPRESENTATIVES ACTED PROACTIVELY WHEN THEY HAD THE CHANCE TO THINK AND THANK YOU AND WITH THAT WE'RE GOING TO CLOSE OPEN COMMENT AND I THINK EVERYBODY WHO'S COME TONIGHT TO SHARE THEIR VIEWS AND RETURN TO STAFF TO SEE IF YOU HAVE ANY COMMENT ON ANY MATTERS RAISED. YEAH WE DID HAVE A QUESTION WITH REGARD TO PONDEROSA AND AS YOU KNOW KURT FOR HOPPER OUR HOUSING DIRECTORS HERE AND WE'LL ADDRESS THAT. SO JILL COULD YOU REPEAT THE QUESTION FOR ME THE MUCH ANCHORED I JUST WANTED KNOW IF THAT WAS CITY LAND AND IF THERE WAS A PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT OR IF IT'S PRIVATE LAND OR JUST WITH THE UPDATE IS THERE. ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT THE PONDEROSA LAND ITSELF MORE THE ADJACENT TO THAT THE GENTLEMAN SPOKE ABOUT THIS. THAT'S THE WAY TO THE WEST SO TOM TO US THERE IS A PROPERTY THAT WAS BUILT

[106:01] ON A FEW YEARS AGO BY THISTLE THAT DEVELOPMENT IS ALREADY COMPLETE FURTHER TO THE WEST SO THAT IS ALSO A PROPERTY OWNED BY B H P AND I DO NOT KNOW WHAT THEIR INTENTIONS ARE FOR THAT PARTICULAR PROPERTY DESSERT BUT THERE'S THERE'S AN IDEA OF POSSIBLY BUILDING SOME ADDITIONAL UNITS ON THE EXTREME WEST OF THE PONDEROSA PROPERTIES THERE SO THAT'S WHAT THE GENTLEMAN. OK SO ON PONDEROSA PROPERTY THAT THERE IS AN AREA ALONG THE WEST SIDE OF THAT WHERE THE CONCEPT PLAN IS SHOWING SOME UNITS THERE THEY MAY NOT BE ADDITIONAL UNITS BECAUSE AS THE SITE RE DEVELOPS IT WILL BE REQUIRED FOR SOME PEOPLE TO MOVE IN SO WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S A PLACE THAT THEY CAN MOVE TO WITHIN THE SAME PROPERTY IN TWO YEARS AND WHO OWNED THAT PROPERTY IS SET OWNED A PONDEROSA. THAT'S OUR TRIP IS

[107:01] THE HEART OF BOULDER OPEN SPACE THAT STRIP IS PART OF THE PONDEROSA PROPERTY OK CUZ THEY THINK BECAUSE IT HASN'T BEEN DEVELOPED AND REMAINED CLEAN I THINK THAT WAS THE CONCERN YEAH IT'S MOSTLY USED FOR PARKING AND TRAILERS AND THAT SORT OF THING THEY'RE SO CURT THANK YOU FOR THAT UPDATE IN YOUR STATEMENT YOU MENTION THAT THIS WAS A CONCEPT PLAN AND SO THERE ARE STILL THINGS THAT CAN HAPPEN AS IT GOES THROUGH THE PROPER AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF THE PROCESS US THANK YOU AND SO IF PEOPLE DID WANT TO WEIGH IN ON THE CONCEPT PLAN WHERE WOULD YOU DIRECT MEMBERS OF THE TODAY SO IT WILL BE GOING TO CITY COUNCIL AND THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO TO PLANNING WHAT I'M SORRY PLANNING BOARD I MISSPOKE THINK YOU WILL BE GOING TO PLAY MORE THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS WE'VE ALSO HAD SEVERAL COMMUNITY FUNCTIONS OUT AT PONDEROSA WHERE THEY'VE GIVEN THEIR INPUTS. PRIOR TO THE CONCEPT

[108:03] PLAN AND ALSO IN PRESENTATION OF THE CONCEPT PLAN WE'RE ALSO HAVING AN OPEN HOUSE FOR THE NEIGHBORS AROUND PONDEROSA I DON'T HAVE THE DATA OFF THE TOP MY HEAD BUT THAT'S ALSO IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO AT THIS VERY HELPFUL TO ANY OTHER COMMENT FROM SLIM AND NONE FOR ME AND AARON TO CRITICS ADDED A QUESTION FOR YOU THE CARD I HAD A QUESTION FOR A DIFFERENT MATTER IF YOU DON'T MIND POPPING BACK UP AGAIN ABOUT THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE RENTAL FOR AFFORDABLE UNITS CHURCH APPRECIATED YOUR EMAIL TODAY EXPLAINING SOME OF THAT BUT THERE ARE COUPLE FOLLOW UP QUESTIONS THE THIRD B COULD GET ADDRESSED IN THIS FORM WHICH IS DO WE HAVE CONTROL OVER WHAT THAT MAXIM ALLOWABLE RENT IS IN THE CITY AS A COUNCIL WORSE THAT SET EXTERNALLY IT SET EXTERNALLY BY CHAFF US SO WE ALIGNED WITH THE WITH THE CHAFF OR RENTS BEARS WE DO HOWEVER HAVE SOME UNITS THAT ARE

[109:01] SMALLER THAT DON'T FIT INTO THE CHAFF OR END TABLE AND SO THAT'S WHY WE HAVE THAT STATEMENT IN OUR REGULATIONS THAT WE CAN ALSO SET OTHER RANTS. THOSE ARE AND SET FOR THOSE THAT ARE NOT IN THE CHAFF THE TABLE BECAUSE EVERY SORT OF RESTRICTED SIZES IN THE CHAFF A TABLE THAT USED TO IT WE CHOSEN TO LIVE WITH CHAFF ARE WE REQUIRED. WE'VE CHOSEN TO FOCUS THAT IS SOMETHING CAN SEE BLUE WOULD HAVE DISCRETION OVER. THAT'S CORRECT AND THEN I UNDERSTAND YOU'VE REACHED OUT TO AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROVIDERS IN TOWN SINCE THIS SITE AND INCREASE ALLOWABLE IN IT RIGHT. HAVE YOU GOTTEN COMMITMENTS FROM EVERYONE AT THIS POINT THAT THEY WILL NOT BE RAISING THE MAXIMUM RENT OR WE HAVEN'T GOTTEN COMMITMENTS WE'VE BEEN IN COMMUNICATION WITH THEM THEY'RE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT OTHERS ARE DOING AS WELL TO TRY TO STAY SOMEWHAT IN LINE WITH EACH OTHER WE DON'T HAVE ANYTHING IN WRITING THAT SAYS WELL FOR SOME OF THEM WE DO BUT NOT ALL OF THEM OF WHAT THE RENT INCREASES ARE

[110:00] DEPOT SQUARE IS THE ONE THAT WAS IN QUESTION YOU WOULD HAVE RECEIVED AN EMAIL FROM THEM LATER THIS AFTERNOON THEY HAVEN'T SENT OUT ANY RENT INCREASES TO THE RESIDENCE YET SO WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THOSE RENT INCREASES ARE OKAY BUT I JUST I'D LIKE TO FLAG THIS IS SOMETHING THAT MERITS FURTHER DISCUSSION. YES IT A FUTURE MEETING HIM SOME KIND OF FORM AND CAN BECOME IMPORTANT. SO SAM AND LISA CURT JUST FOLLOWING UP MAKE SURE WE'RE CRYSTAL CLEAR TO THE HOUSING DEPARTMENT THE CITY OF BOULDER DOESN'T RUN IN THE RENTAL HOUSING ARE SELF CORRECT AND BOULDER HOUSING PARTNERS IS INCREASING RENT BUT NOT TO THE FULL AMOUNT THAT'S CORRECT OKAY AND SO THAT'S GOOD BECAUSE IT'S A LARGE FRACTION WRITE A RENTAL UNITS IN THE STATES ABOUT HALF OF OUR RENTAL UNITS AND SO IT WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL IF WITH THE REMAINDER YOU COULD GIVE US SOME KIND OF SUMMARY ONCE YOUR DOUBT BECAUSE THAT WOULD BE A WAY FOR US TO THINK ABOUT IT TALK

[111:00] ABOUT IT RIGHT. I THINK THE OTHER IMPORTANT DISTINCTION IS RAISING THE RENTS OF CURRENT RESIDENCE IN THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROGRAM AND ACTUALLY ALL OF OUR PROVIDERS OFTEN RAISE RENTS ONLY AT THE TIME OF NEW TENANTS COMING IN. SO THOSE CAN BE TWO DIFFERENT APPROACHES. YEAH AND IF YOU COULD SUMMARIZE THAT THAT WOULD BE HELPFUL I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT DISTINCTION AND IT'S ALSO HELPFUL FOR US TO BE ABLE TO KNOW BOTH. HERE'S THE RENT INCREASE FOR EXISTING TENANTS AND HERE'S WHAT IT WILL BE FOR NEW TENANTS WRITE EACH PROPERTY YEAH IT'S ALSO WORTH NOTING THAT THE RENTS HAVE BEEN RAISED IN THREE YEARS AS WELL SO I SUPPORT WHAT HERRING AND SALMON SAID BUT I ALSO AM CURIOUS TO FINDING OUT MORE ABOUT THIS DISCREPANCY BETWEEN THREE PERCENT WHICH I UNDERSTOOD PHP TO BE AT VERSUS TEN PERCENT THAT'S A BIG CHUNK TO HANDLE ESPECIALLY AT LOWER INCOMES AND THEN I HAD ASKED

[112:00] THE PERSON WHO CAME UP HERE ABOUT HOA FEES BECAUSE THAT'S A WHOLE NOTHER KIND OF BALL OF WAX THAT PEOPLE HAVE TO ADDRESS AND I DON'T KNOW IF THEY'RE FULLY AWARE OF IT WHEN THAT THEIR HOA IS CAN GO UP MORE THAN PROBABLY TEN PERCENT COMPARED TO THE RENTAL INCREASE SO I THINK MAKING SURE PEOPLE UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY'RE GETTING INTO AND THEN ALSO MAKING SURE THAT WE STILL ARE PROVIDING AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND NOT JUST RELATIVE OF FOUR FULL OF ZING IMPORT CAN ASK A FOLLOW UP QUESTION ARE YOU MENTION IT TO A'S DO OUR RENTAL PROPERTIES HAVE A CHOICE OR ZED NOW THEY DID THEY WOULDN'T HAVE HOA FEES I THINK LISA WAS MAYBE SAYING IT'S A SEPARATE BUT SIMILAR TO THE OCEAN BOTH. I MEAN I THAT RAY AND I JUST HEARD THIS CONCERN FROM PEOPLE WHO

[113:00] LIVE IN THEIR HOMES IN THAT THEIR HOA FEAST GO UP MUCH FARTHER FASTER THAN WHAT THEY EVER ANTICIPATED AND MANY TIMES IT'S NOT IN THEIR BUDGET. SO MARY COULD UM YOU SAID THAT THE TABLES ARE SET BY CHAFEE AND THE COLORADO HOUSING AND FINANCE AUTHORITY AND ARE THOSE TABLES SET THROUGH FEDERAL REGULATIONS OR IS THAT STATE REGULATION IT'S IT'S THROUGH THE STATE BUT THEY USE THE THEY USED TO HIDE DATA TO CREATE THAT ABOUT THE DESCENT. CENSUS DATA TO CREATE A SO I'M GOING WITH THAT IS THAT UM ARE THOSE TABLES THAT ARE SAID BY CAFE IS THAT SOMETHING THAT COULD BE CHANGED TO STATE LEGISLATION IT COULD BE CHANGE LOCALLY AS I MENTIONED TO AARON WE HAVE CHOSEN TO USE CHAFEE AS A BENCHMARK FOR

[114:05] ANTS BECAUSE IT'S A SYSTEM THAT'S IN PLACE THE TRACKS ARE BASED ON DATA SOMETHING THAT WE PROBABLY COULDN'T DO OURSELVES. OK THANK YOU THANK YOU CURTIS CREEK. OK ANY OTHER COMMENTS FROM COUNCIL OKAY OBVIOUSLY WE'RE GOING TO BE TALKING ABOUT SALT LOOKED INTO SHORTLY YOUR CONSENT AGENDA TONIGHT IS ITEMS AND K SO THIS IS THE LOVE NOTES A LOT OF FIRST READINGS AND THEN ALSO THIRD READING ON THE ASSAULT WEAPONS BAN. YES I MEAN MOST OF THE CONSENT AGENDA IS FAIRLY CLEAR TO ME BUT IT DOES SEEM LIKE WE NEED TO GO OVER THE ASSAULT WEAPONS ISSUE AND DECIDE WHETHER WE

[115:00] WANT TO PASS IT ON ANY CHANGES OR CHANGES WITH EMERGENCY OR CONTINUE TO FOR THREE K IN TERMS OF PROCESS THE FOLKS WANT TO PAUSE AND AT RIGHT NOW I CAN THINK OF ANY BETTER TIME TO DO IT. OK SO LET'S DO THAT RIGHT NOW UM DID YOU. WHO WANTS TO START TO GO TOM NOE I USE ON HOTLINE THAT I'D SUGGESTED TO MAKE SURE YOUR YEP SORRY JUST FIVE CHANGES TO THE SECOND REASON READING ORDINANCE AND TOM VERY KINDLY AFTER THOSE UP ON OUR BLUE SHEETS HERE UPON THE DIOCESE UM HAPPY TO EXPLAIN TO ME THE FIVE HITS IN A SUBSEQUENT NOTE TO TOM WITH RESPECT TO ITEM NUMBER UM ONE TOM I THINK IF WE WERE

[116:01] TO GO DOWN THAT PATH ALLOW CERTIFICATION BY SOME STORES GUN STORES. WE ALSO NEED TO CHANGE THAT OTHER PROVISION AND FIVE E TWENTY TWO O FIVE TWENTY FIVE ASCENSION NOTE ON THAT. THIS EVENING IF COUNCIL DOES WANT TO DO THIS NOW BECOMES MOOT DAN WOULD BE BEST TO TAKE HIS ONETIME CIA AND LET'S START WITH THE EASIEST PERSON TO KNOW JUST IN ANOTHER FIRST ONE IS THE HARDEST PART OF IT. I MEAN THEY SAY I'D RATHER JUST PASS THIS SO I THINK IF WE'RE STARTING WITH THE EASIEST AND MORE NODDING ALONG TO THEM I DON'T WANT TO BE CONSTRUED AS I'D LIKE TO MAKE THESE AMENDMENTS SO I'M A STATE THAT FOR THE RECORD THAT I LIKE TO SEE HOW THIS ORDINANCE WORKS AND MAKE AMENDMENTS LATER IF WE FEEL NEED BE. SO I JUST DON'T KNOW HOW TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS ONE A TIME THING WAS SO I

[117:03] GUESS LET'S CLARIFY IF WE WANT WE CAN MAKE AMENDMENTS TONIGHT AND GO AHEAD AND PASS IT ON EMERGENCY AND HAVE IT BE DONE. SO THAT'S AN OPTION OKAY I MEAN IF WE DID THAT WE NEED SAE SIX FOOT SIX VOTES TO DO THAT BY EMERGENCY AND THAT JUST MEANS THAT WE CAN BE DONE WITH IT TONIGHT SO IF WE IF WE DID THAT. DOES THAT CHANGE WHAT YOU DECIDE IF WE CAN DO AN EMERGENCY THAN THAN I AM OPEN TO LOOKING AT SOME OF THESE. OK LISA JUST TALKIN PROCESS YET I GUESS I'M A LITTLE SO I'M NOT SO HOT TO PASS BY A MERCHANT IAN SO THE QUESTION FOR ME CHILL IS THAT HE SAID IF WE ADD ANYTHING THEN. I MEAN RIGHT NOW IF WE TOOK IT AS IT IS WE COULD PASS THAT WOULD NOT BE BY EMERGENCY C SEC RICHT ON CRACK BUT IF WE ADD ANYTHING TO IT TONIGHT

[118:03] THEN UM WE UH AND YOU WANT IT TO PASS IT TONIGHT IT WOULD REQUIRE SIX OF THOSE VOTING WITH YOU ARE VOTING TO PASS IT BY EMERGENCY IS THAT CORRECT. OK SO I JUST WENT THOUGH I GUESS THE ONE THING I'LL DO SO INTO THE MIX HERE IS A COUPLE OF THESE SUGGESTIONS ARE CLEANUP AMENDMENTS AND IT'S I THINK IF IT'S ONE THING WE ARE TEACHING SOME SUBS AND CLEAN UP AMENDMENTS WE SHOULD DO IF IT MEANS WE HAVE TO PACIFY SIX PEOPLE BECAUSE THEY ARE DOING CLEAN OF AMENDMENTS. I HAVE NO HEARTBURN ABOUT THAT IF PEOPLE DON'T WANT TO ADD ANYTHING SUBSTANTIVE ON TONIGHT THAT I TOTALLY RESPECT THAT BUT LET'S CLEAN UP ANY WORD SHE ASKED ONE MORE QUESTION MY UNDERSTANDING WAS THAT THERE WERE REASONS NOT TO PASS SOMETHING ON EMERGENCY THAT MIGHT END UP IN COURT AND SO FORTH FOR MY STANDPOINT ENOUGH I EITHER WANT TO GO WITH IT AS IS PASSES ON THIRD READING OR MAKE THE CHANGES

[119:00] WHICH I PROBABLY WILL SUPPORT WANTING TO DO AND THEN WE HAVE A NON CONSENT AND FORTH READING AT THE NEXT MEETING WHICH BEGAN WITH OK I BELIEVE THAT THOSE ARE THE TWO CHOICES AND UM LET'S TALK ABOUT THE MERITS OF THE CHANGES. FIRST I THANK YOU FOR CLARIFYING THAT I FORGOT ABOUT THAT MEETING DAD WAS JUST A LITTLE BIT JUST THAT I THINK A CRUDE SEMI THINK HER STANDING. WE WANT TO BE ONE AND I WOULD PREFER TO NOT PASS THIS ON EMERGENCY YES I WOULD LOVE TO GET THIS DONE TONIGHT. I'M OPEN TO HEARING THE MERITS OF THESE BUT IT DOES RAISE THE BAR FOR ME ON THE LEFT DOES THAT SUM UP WHERE EVERYBODY IS NOT OK SO WITH THAT LOW IN THE BACK THESE ARE ONES TOWARD THE BACK OF THE PROBABLY THE MOST OPTIONAL ONE IS THE FIRST ONE TO NUMBER FIVE THIS IS MORE A QUESTION I THINK WE TALKED ABOUT THESE THINGS IN THE WAY THE SECOND READING DRAFT CAME OUT IS HAS TWO EXCEPTIONS AND I JUST A GUESS I'M JUST WANT TO DO A SANITY CHECK WITH COUNSEL

[120:01] THAT THEY'RE OK WITH THESE TWO EXCEPTIONS I THOUGHT WE TALKED ABOUT ONE OR BOTH OF THESE AND I WASN'T EXEMPT TAX EXCEPTIONS OR EXEMPTIONS HE THE ONE CALLED THE TULLE RUFFLE REGULATION WOULD NOT APPLY TO THOSE PERMITTED UNDER THE FEDERAL LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS SAFETY ACT. I THINK IS A LITTLE REDUNDANT TO GET A LITTLE RE INTO THE WEEDS HERE SORT OF A FIVE EIGHT TWENTY FIVE A M FIVE A TWENTY FIVE B FIVE EIGHT TWENTY FIVE A AND IF YOU CAN PUT UP THERE TOM CAT NO YOU CAN'T DO THAT. OK HAS A LONG LIST OF EXCEPTIONS FOR ACTIVE DUTY MILITARY AND POLICE OFFICERS AND FIVE THE TWENTY FIVE B WHICH WAS ADDED. HAS FURTHER EXCEPTIONS FOR CONCEALED PERMITS UNDER THE FEDERAL LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER SAFETY EXHALE PAUSE THERE MAYBE EXPLAIN THE DIFFERENCE I THINK WE EXEMPTED CONCEALED CARRY PURSE A REJECTED THESE TWO

[121:00] ACTS THAT SO I CAN EXPLAIN THE FIVE TWENTY FIVE K YOU AMENDED SUIT AFTER FIRST READING I PROPOSED AMENDING IT TO EXEMPT ALL ON FORCE AND OFFICERS REGARDLESS OF WHETHER OR NOT THE GUN WAS INVOLVED WITH SOMETHING THEY NEED TO FOR THEIR COURSE OF EMPLOYMENT COUNCIL REJECTED THAT AMENDMENT AND REINSTATED THE ORIGINAL LANGUAGE WHICH I GOT FROM THE GF ITS FOUNDATION FIVE FIVE THE TWENTY FIVE B WHAT DOES CLARIFY FOR EVERYBODY SAYS TO LET FIVE TWENTY FIVE B EXCEPT PEOPLE WHO ARE ENTITLE TO NATIONWIDE CONCEAL CARRY UNDER THE FEDERAL LAW ENFORCEMENT SAFETY ACT WHICH WAS IN WAS ADDED AFTER THE FIRST FIRST READING AND NEVER DISCUSSED REALLY AT THE SECOND READING YOU TOOK OUT OTHER EXEMPTIONS BUT YOU LEFT THAT ONE AND YOU MAY RECALL THAT IT'S A FEDERAL STATUTE THAT ALLOWS ALL LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS AND SOME RETIRED FOR FOUR LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS ALONG IT

[122:00] AS LONG AS THEY KEEP THEIR QUALIFICATIONS WITH THEIR HOME AGENCY TO CARRY CONCEALED AND SO FOR TWO TO AVOID A FEDERAL PREEMPTION ARGUMENT. I SUGGESTED EXAM THING THAT AFTER THE FIRST READING AND SO IT WASN'T DISCUSSED AT THE SECOND READING SO I LEFT IT IN AND SO AT BOB'S QUESTION AS WE DISCUSSED IT TODAY AND I WANT TO PUT WORDS IN YOUR MOUTH WAS IS THAT'S PURPOSEFUL OF COUNCILS OR JUST SOMETHING THAT GOT OVERLOOKED IN THE LENGTHY DISCUSSION THAT YOU HAD THAT FEAR OF YET SO I RECALL THAT ONE HAS BEEN PURPOSEFUL THE NEXT RUN THAT I THINK IS MORE QUESTION AND SO CAN EXPLAIN THAT ONE BELIEVE IT IS PAS IS EVERYBODY AGREED WITH THE FEDERAL LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS SAFETY ACT WAS SOMETHING THE PURPOSELY EXEMPTED. YES YES WE ARE IN AGREEMENT. CARRY ON. OK SO THE OTHER ONES ARE THERE ARE IN THE FIRST READING ORDINANCE. IT READ LIKE THIS THAT IS IT EXEMPTED

[123:01] THE WEAPON THAT HAD BEEN GRANTED A FEDERAL TAX STAMP OR PERMIT SO I EXPLAINED ITS SECOND READING THAT THERE ARE TWO LEVELS OF FEDERAL FIREARMS CERTIFICATION AS A FEDERAL FIREARMS LICENSE WHICH GOES TO DEALERS AND THAT'S STILL AN EXEMPTION YOU'VE NEVER DISCUSSED TAKING THAT OUT THERE'S A SECOND ONE THAT GOES TO PEOPLE WHO HAVE THE RIGHT TO PURCHASE A PARTICULAR WEAPON AND THEY GET A PERMIT OR A STAMP FOR THAT. AFTER FIRST READING I SUGGESTED THAT YOU EXPAND THAT TO INCLUDE ANY WEAPON THAT THEY ALL SO JUST BASICALLY EXEMPT THE PERSON NOT THE WEAPON COUNCIL REJECTED THAT EXAM THAT EXPANSION AND I WENT BACK TO THE WEIGHT HAD BEEN DRAFTED ORIGINALLY WHICH IS JUST THE WEAPON THAT IS EXEMPTED UNDER FEDERAL LAW AND THE I'M SORRY SIGNIFICANT TREES AND THE REASON FOR THAT IS THAT AGAIN. I'M A LITTLE CONCERNED ABOUT FEDERAL PREEMPTION HERE IF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS SPECIFICALLY SAID YOU CAN OWN THIS SPECIFIC WEAPON IT WOULD BE DIFFICULT FOR BOLD

[124:01] TO SAY THAT YOU CAN'T AND SO THE COUNCIL RATCHET IT BACK TO JUST THAT JUST THE WEAPON THAT IS THAT HAS GOTTEN A TAX STAMP AND THAT REQUIRES AN EXTENSIVE BACKGROUND CHECK BY THE ALCOHOL TOBACCO FIREARMS AND SO THE QUESTION IS DID WE MEAN THAT YES THAT'S THE QUESTION. SO LOTS OF THESE BANAL WEAPONS SOME OF THEM ARE ACCESSORIES YES THAT'S TRUE SILENCE OR SOMETHING LIKE WRITE THINGS LIKE THAT AND SO THEY HAVE A STAMP AND STAMP IS ASSOCIATED WITH THE WEAPON IS NOT WITH A PERSON AND IT WOULD BOTH IN FACT AND SO THE WAY I READ THIS IT'S THOSE POSSESSING A WEAPON WITH THE STAMP SO SAY A SILENCE OR DON'T HAVE ANY RESTRICTION ON OWNING ASSAULT WEAPONS AFTER DECEMBER THIRTY BY YOURSELF. NO NO IT'S THE WAY IT'S DRAFTED NOW AT LEAST AS I READ IT IT'S THEY THEY'RE ENTITLED TO THAT WEAPON. OKAY THE WAY I HAD CHANGED IT WAS THEY COULD BUY

[125:00] ANY ASSAULT WEAPON AND YOU REJECTED THAT'S WHY RETURN TO THE ORIGINAL LANGUAGE. IT'S IT'S JUST FOR THE WEAPON THAT EXEMPT THAT EXEMPTED UNDER THE FEDERAL STAMP WHICH IS WHAT I THINK WE MEAN TO DO TORN MEAN THAT'S WHAT WE NEED TO DO THE QUESTION IS ARE YOU AN ADJUSTMENT TO MAKE SURE WE MET WHAT WE SAID AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE ON THE READING. YES OKAY I THINK WE'RE GOOD ON THAT THEY DISAGREE. OK SO THAT WHEN WE'RE DONE MOVING BACKWARD POINT FOR I THINK OUR INTENTION WAS THAT A LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINES WE HAVE TWO CLASSES ONE IS FROM OR PISTOLS AND ONCE FOR EVERYTHING ELSE AND FOR EVERYTHING ELSE I THINK WE'RE AT TEN TEN ROUNDS WITH RESPECT EPISTLES. I THINK WE SAID AT FIFTEEN AND THAT'S VERY CLEAR FROM THE FIRST FOR THE ORDINANCE BUT THE SECOND CLAUSE AN ORDINANCE THAT EXEMPTS FROM THE STATUTE REALLY EXACT LANGUAGE POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN

[126:01] MAGAZINES ALONG AS A POSSESSION OF A HANDGUN AND MAGAZINE ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH STATE LAW AND I THINK THE RISK OF HAVING THAT CLAUSE IN THERE. NOT SURE WHAT WE NEEDED BUT SECONDLY IS UNDER STATE LAW THE FIFTEEN ROUND MAGAZINE LIMIT HAS A GRANDFATHER PROVISION SO SOMEBODY HAD A MAGAZINE THAT WAS BIGGER THAN FIFTEEN ROUNDS BEFORE THE LAW WENT INTO EFFECT IN TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN FOURTEEN WHATEVER WAS MAKING TEA. THOSE ARE IN TENSION OR LAST MEETING WAS TO ELIMINATE THE GROUND FOLLOWING WITH RESPECT TO LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINES THAT IS THAT DEPEND WHETHER IT'S A RIFLE OR PISTOL EITHER BE TEN OR FIFTEEN PERIOD BUT THERE'LL BE NO GRAND FATHERING THAT WAS TO IN THE STATE LAW GRANDFATHER. I'M AFRAID THAT THIS SECOND CAUSE IT'S IN HERE WOULD INADVERTENTLY ALLOW FOR GRANDFATHER WHICH IS NOT WHAT WE WERE TENDING I HAVE ANOTHER PROCESS QUESTION THAT GETS COUNTED TO THIS AND OR WHETHER WE NEED TO FIX THIS AT THIS MOMENT OR WHETHER WE COULD COME BACK WITH A PACKAGE THAT FIXES IT BECAUSE THAT IS OBVIOUSLY A

[127:00] RISK BUT THAT IS A RISK THAT WILL NOT MATERIALIZE UNTIL NEXT YEAR AT THE EARLIEST RIGHT BECAUSE THE LEGISLATURE'S OUT OF SESSION AND SO VARIED SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT GRANDFATHER AND IF THE STATE LEVEL RIGHTS OVER AT THE STATE LEVEL MAGAZINES LARGER THAN FIFTEEN ROUNDS WERE GRANDFATHERED FOR ANY ANY WEAPON. SO WHAT COULD HAPPEN BETWEEN NOW AND THE NEXT LEGISLATURE TO CHANGE THAT I THINK THOSE TWO ISSUES ONE IS A NEW DRESS WHICH IS I THINK WE WANTED THIS CLAUSE IN HERE FOR TWO REASONS ONE IS IN CASE LEGISLATURE CHANGES ITS MIND AND INCREASES THE NUMBER ABOUT FIFTEEN WE WOULD HAVE A SMALLER NUMBER IN BOULDER. I AGREE COMPLETELY THAT THE RISK OF THAT HAPPENING BETWEEN NOW AND NEXT. THIS TIME NEXT YEAR IS ZERO RECOLLECTION OF THE SESSION BUT I THINK THE SECOND THING WE WERE DOING THIS IS THE POINT I'M TRYING TO MAKE IS IS I THINK WE ARE WITH RESPECT TO THE BOULDER WERE TRYING TO ELIMINATE GRANDFATHER E SO IN COLORADO RIGHT NOW IF YOU HAD WITH LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINE

[128:05] EXCESS OF FIFTEEN AND AS LONG AS YOU BOUGHT IT BEFORE THE CUTOFF DATE WHICH I THINK WAS IN TWO THOUSAND THIRTY TWO THAT YOU CAN KEEP IT OUR INTENTION HERE. IF I UNDERSTOOD CORRECTLY FROM OUR LAST MEETING WAS WE DON'T WANT TO GRANDFATHER IN HERE IN BOULDER WE WANT TEND TO BE THE LIMIT FOR RIFLES FIFTEEN BE THE LIMIT FOR PISTOLS FULL STOP NO GRANDFATHER. SO SOMEBODY HAS A THIRTY CAPACITY THEY CAN'T KEEP IT HERE IN BOULDER AFTER JULY FIFTEEN WHICH IS THE DAY THIS IN THE STATUTE THAT'S OUR INTENTION THAT'S FINE BUT BUT I THOUGHT THAT WAS OUR INTENTION WAS TO GO BACK TO MY PROCESS QUESTION AND SO I AGREE THAT WE SAID TOM IF WE WERE TO PASS THIS TONIGHT MOM CLEAN NON EMERGENCY COULD RE COME BACK IN TO THREE MONTHS WITH A PACKAGE OF FIXES THAT LOOK LIKE THIS AND GET THAT DONE THIS SO I MEAN I MIGHT SUGGEST THAT I FIND ALL THESE TO BE MEANINGFUL SUBSTANTIVE SUGGESTIONS. I DON'T KNOW IF WE WANT TO SLOW DOWN MARIS OR

[129:01] EXPOSE IT TO EMERGENCIES SO PERHAPS WE CAN JUST GO AHEAD NOTE THESE ARE ON THE WORK PLAN AND RETURN TO EYE WITH THE ONE MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE ALL KNOWINGLY PASSING THOUGHT WE WERE GOING I JUST WANTED TO BRING THAT UP IS NOT YET OK SO THIS ONE RATES AND NUMBER FIVE WE DISPENSE WITH AND WE DON'T CARE ABOUT THIS ONE. WE NEED TO FIX SOME POINT I'M EITHER DAVID OR AT PLAY IN ORDER TO MAKE SURE INTENT WHICH I THINK YOU SAID CORRECTLY. OK ARM IS FULLY REALIZED AND CHECK TO MAKE SURE THE REAL GIRL. RIGHT RIGHT SO THAT PART. OK SO SETTING ASIDE WHEN WE PASS OR IF WE PASS THIS TONIGHT OR NOT TO PEE OF PEOPLE IN AGREEMENT WITH WHAT BOB IS PROPOSING WHICH IS TO MAKE SURE THAT THE LANGUAGE ON THIS ONE PROVISION MATCHES WHAT OUR INTENT WAS TWO WEEKS AGO. YES YES YES YES I MEANT

[130:02] SOMETHING TO DO GREAT WITH THE SUBSTANCE OF THIS PROGRAM YES NO GRAND FATHERING OF LARGER MAGAZINES. OK YOUR DATE NEARBY DOES NOT OTHERS WELL JUST PASSED TONIGHT THAN WELL THAT WILL NOT JUST SOME TENTATIVELY DO AGREE WITH THAT INTENT NOT TO COME BACK WITH CHAIN DON'T KNOW JUST NOT GRAND FATHERING IN LARGER MAGAZINES AND FIFTY DEGREES THE SUBSTANCE OF THAT THAT'S WHAT WE WERE INTENDING TO DO TWO WEEKS AGO WE FOUND A PROVISION THAT DOES THAT IT SUCKS UP FROM THE MOVING BACKWARDS TO NUMBER THREE AGAIN THE NUMBER ONE THESE ARE ALL CLEAN UP AND SO WE CAN DECIDE WHETHER TO THESE TONIGHT OR TWO OF THEM LATER BUT I JUST WANTED TO SEGUIN TO BE AWARE IN A DEFENSE OF TOM THE CLAUSES EXCEPTION FOR PEOPLE PASSING THROUGH THE CITY OF BOULDER WITH. SO SOMEBODY LIVES DOESN'T LIVE IN BOULDER HAVE A LEGAL

[131:00] ASSAULT RIFLE PASSING THROUGH BOULDER THEY'RE GOING TO SOME OTHER CITY IN THESE HAPPEN TO BE DRIVING UP THIRTY SIX PM SO WE HAVE AN EXCEPTION FOR THAT WHICH I THINK WE'RE ALL OKAY WITH THE EXCEPTION WHICH WHICH COMPANY THE STATUE COME FROM STATE LAW AND SO TIME WAS STUCK WITH SOME I THINK UNFORTUNATE RAFTING UP IN THE STATE LAW AND SO THE QUESTION IS CAN WE IMPROVE THE DRAFT IN ORDER WE WANT TO JUST LEAVE IT ALONE A COUPLE EXAMPLES OF OF BAD DRAFTING AS THE EXEMPTION FOR EXAMPLE ONLY TOOK ONLY SPEAKS TO PEOPLE WHO ARE TRAVELING THROUGH WITH A WEAPON WITH THE INTENTION TO USE THAT WEAPON FOR HUNTING OR PERSONAL PROTECTION PERIOD THAT'S IT. SO IF YOU'RE DRIVING THROUGH BOULDER ON HER WAY TO A SHOW OF SHOOTING MEAT YOU DON'T GET EXEMPTION WHICH IS KIND OF BIZARRE WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT IT THAT'S PROBABLY THE MOST LIKELY PURPOSE OF THE SO AND SO THIS IS A DRAFTING POINT BADLY DRAFTED STATE LAW TOM PICKED UP FROM STATE LAW BECAUSE HE WANTED TO SHARE WHAT I THINK TO HAVE THE GREATEST LIKELIHOOD OF HIM FOR STABILITY. THE QUESTION IS DO WE WANT TO IF TO IMPROVE

[132:01] THE WRITING OR DO WE WANT TO JUST GO WITH STATE LAW OF A STRONG FEEL AS ONE TO MAKE SURE THE COOLEST PEOPLE THAT ENTER HAS HAD A QUESTION TO MY OF MY MEMORY IS THAT YOU FELT LIKE IT MADE THE OVERALL STATUE MORE DEFENSIBLE TO WHERE DID THE SAME WAY ISN'T THAT CORRECT. YES I THINK ONE OF THE GREATEST RISK PREEMPTION IS PEOPLE TRAVELING THROUGH BECAUSE THEY WHEN THE PREEMPTION THEY LOOK AT EFFECTS ON PEOPLE OUTSIDE OF BOULDER UP SOME TRAVELING THROUGH IS OUTSIDE OF BOULDER IS OUTSIDE OF BOULDER AND IN THE DENVER CASE THAT WAS ONE OF THE THINGS THEY CRITICIZED SO THAT THEY STRUCK DOWN SO I WANTED TO STICK TO WHAT THE STATE HAS SAID SO THAT THEY WOULD BE NO ARGUMENT PREEMPTION ON THE TRAVELING THRU SO THAT'S WHY IT'S THERE IS IT IS SAID I AGREE WITH YOU ON LINKAGE BEEN BETTER DEFENSIVELY THIS AND MAKE DIFFERENT REPORTER IT'S WORTH I THINK THAT THE LANGUAGE BUT WHAT ACTUALLY BROUGHT AN EXCEPTION. SO SOME SOMEONE WOULDN'T STAY LONG AS A REALTOR NEAR EXCEPTION I THINK CLEANUP WOULD ACTUALLY MAKE THE EXCEPTION BROADER BUT TOM'S UP THE RIGHT I MEAN

[133:01] IF WE IF WE WANT TO INCREASE THE LIKELIHOOD OF PREVAILING THEN WE PROBABLY SHOULD STICK TO THE SAME LOGIC I WANT TO CALL PEOPLE'S ATTENTION THAT IT'S KIND OF FUNKY WAY IT'S WRITTEN BUT A FUNKY IT WORKS BEST FOR US NOT TO THE WORLD WE COULD CLEAN IT UP LATER IF WE DECIDED TO MARRY ONE OF THE POINTS OF TONIGHT'S DISCUSSION IS TO IDENTIFY WHAT WE MIGHT WANT TO COME BACK DURING RECESS OR WE WANT TO COME BACK TO NOT FIVE. SO THEN THERE'S THE QUESTION OF THIS ON I FEEL AS STRONGLY ABOUT IT BUT I DO THINK YOU MAKE A POINT TO I GUESS OTHER QUESTION HEAVENS FOR THE MINERS COULD LEAD THE STATE'S LANGUAGE AND JUST ADD ANOTHER EXEMPTION TO IT SO NO JUDGE COULD MISINTERPRET THE GRAPHIC ON THE GRAPHICS ARE JUST AS I DON'T HAVE TO DO THAT TONIGHT YEAH OKAY HE JUST KEEP THE STATE. YES THIS IS NOT ABOUT TONIGHT JUST AS FUTURE THAT WAY IT'S CLEAR FOLLOWING THE STATE'S LAWYER JUST ADDING TO IT NOT SUBTRACTING ON THE ONE GIVEN THAT WE'RE SEEMED TO BE ON THE SAME PAGE

[134:00] WITH COMING BACK TO THESE I WOULD ACTUALLY LIKE TO REVISIT FIVE WHEN WE DO COME BACK TO ITEMS I WAS UNDER AS WE WERE DOING FIVE HOURS UNDER THE IMPRESSION THAT THIS WAS FOR TONIGHT AND SO I'M JUST GOING TO FLY THAT RIGHT NOW AND THEN WE CAN MOVE ON. I ACTUALLY GREW TO JULY WANT TO REVISIT IF I TOOK SO DON'T FULLY UNDERSTAND IT BUT FOR PURPOSES OF GETTING SOMETHING DONE TONIGHT I'M HAPPY TO PARK AND IT LOOKS TO BE THOROUGH BECAUSE I THINK WE HAD AN ON THE SAME DIRECTION THAT TOO IS REALLY JUST LANGUAGE CLEAN UP THE WAY WAS DRAFTED IT MADE THE CONDITIONS TO GETTING THIS THIS EXEMPTION CERTIFICATE AND THERE'S BEHAVIORAL REQUIREMENTS AFTER THE EXEMPTION CERTIFICATE FROM DRAFTING SAM POINT WHICH IS SEPARATE THOSE DON'T FEEL STRONGLY ABOUT THIS DEFINITELY FALLS IN THE CATEGORY OF CLEANUP. SO WE'VE BEEN SPENDING MORE TIME ON I THINK YOU KNOW CHECKING ON WHAT JOE SAID I THINK ALL OF THESE ARE WORTHY OF FURTHER DISCUSSION JUST NOT TONIGHT AND YOU KNOW SO I WOULD SAY TOM YOU'VE ALREADY DONE MOST OF THE WORK HERE

[135:01] CATS WE COULD COME BACK TO ESSENTIALLY THESE AND HAVE A FULLER DISCUSSION YOU WANT TO MENTION THE FIRST ONE OR NOT I DON'T THINK THE SUPPORT I WANTED TO FLOAT IS AN IDEA I HEARD FROM A NUMBER OF GUN OWNERS THAT THE SUGGESTION THAT IF THEY HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO GET A CERTIFICATION FROM A GUN STORE OTHER THAN THE POLICE DEPARTMENT MIGHT MAKE THEM FEEL COMFORTABLE TO FEEL STRONGLY ABOUT AND WANTED TO PUT ON THE TABLE IN CASE THERE WAS SOME SOME ENTHUSIASM FOR MATH IS NOT JUST FLOATING THE IDEA YOU KNOW THE IDEA IS TO GET AT LEAST MY UNDERSTANDINGS OF WHAT WE'RE INTENDING TO GET AS MANY OF THESE WEAPONS WITH CERTIFICATES IS POSSIBLE AND IF PEOPLE FEEL MORE COMFORTABLE GOING TO A WEAPON A GUN STORE THEN I'M ALL IN FAVOR OF THAT FOR ME IT'S A MATTER OF GETTING THESE THINGS RECORDED IN SOME WAY WITHOUT A REGISTRATION SO FOR

[136:00] ME I'D LIKE TO COME BACK IN AND OFFER THERE BUT WE COULD HAVE THAT DISCUSSION LATER. I AM NOT INTERESTED IN CHANGING LIVES TRY TO REMEMBER THEY HAVE UNTIL DECEMBER THIRTY ONE REGISTERS ARE READING THIS BACK IN AUGUST FOR EXAMPLE THERE'S STILL PLENTY OF TIME IN THIS ONE THINGS WE CAN SURVEY THE COMMUNITY WITH THIS IS ENTIRELY ANECDOTAL I JUST HEARD FROM SOME GUN OWNERS IS THAT SHE'S MORE LIKELY TO REGISTER OR CIRCLES OR VACATION IF I CAN GO TO GUN STORE IN SO WE CAN GET THAT IN PLACE. YOU KNOW WELL BEFORE DECEMBER THIRTY ONE HAS THEM THAT OPTION. YOU THINK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT HAVE ICE NODDING AND I JUST WENT FOR A CAUTION ON THE PROCESS QUESTION HERE WHICH IS I WOULD LOVE TO GET THIS DONE TONIGHT AND MOVE FORWARD IN BRINGING THE SOME SMALL EDITS BACK A LATER TIME COULD WORK FOR ME BUT IF IT'S IN JUST A FEW MONTHS THINK WE'RE GOING TO GO BACK THROUGH THE PROCESS THAT WE'VE JUST BEEN GOING BUT THROUGH THE COMMUNITY AT GREAT LENGTH AND THEIR STRONG FEELINGS ON THIS TO GET AROUND TO GET AN UNHAPPY AND

[137:01] SO I WOULD CAUTION US AGAINST COMING BACK TO THIS AND THREE MONTHS. I MEAN I THINK WE'VE BEEN TOLD ARE GOING TO GET STUDENT HOPEFULLY I AND I EXPECT THAT WE'LL BE SUCCESSFUL DEFENSE OF THAT BUT MAYBE WE THINK ABOUT A LONGER TIME PERIOD TO LET THE ORDINANCE STAND AS WRITTEN AND THEN PERHAPS THIS IS SOMETHING NEXT YEAR THAT WE CAN COME BACK TO AND MAKE A FEW CLEAN UP ITEMS RATHER THAN EVERYTHING JUST SEEMS TO EITHER GET IT DONE SNYDER WE ARE WE WAIT A LITTLE WHILE LONGER SET THERE'S ONE EXCEPTION TO THAT THAT I WOULD POINT OUT NUMBER ONE HERE BECAUSE IT'S ABOUT THE CERTIFICATION PROCESS WILL PROBABLY DO NEED TO COME BACK TO SOONER AND I THINK IF WE WERE TO LIMIT IT TO IF YOU WANT. I MEAN THIS IS A SUBJECT OF A BCC CAN THINK ABOUT AS WELL WHO ARE LIMITED TO THAT ONE ISSUE. IT'S REALLY NOT IMPLICATING ANYTHING EXCEPT FOR WHERE CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED ISSUED THIS A GREAT POINT PERSONALLY I'M NOT INTERESTED IN THAT ONE I THINK THAT THE POLICE FOR THE RIGHT ORGANIZATION TO

[138:03] CERTIFY GRANDFATHER IN EXISTING WEAPONS. WE WORKED REALLY HARD TO ASSUAGE CONCERNS OF GUN OWNERS THAT THEY WOULD NOT BE ON THE REGISTRATION I THINK WE DID A GOOD JOB OF DEALING WITH THAT I'M MUCH MORE COMFORTABLE AND PLEASING TO THE MARION SO I WOULD BE IN FAVOR OF THIS WIN AND I WENT TO ONE OF THE BASIC TENANTS OF DOING OUTREACH. ANNE AND BEING SUCCESSFUL IN MEETING WITH PEOPLE AND MEETING THEIR NEEDS IS TO MEET PEOPLE WHERE THEY ARE AND I WOULD AGREE WITH LEE SAID THAT IF THIS IS WHERE FOLKS FEEL MOST COMFORTABLE AND HAVING THIS DONE I WOULD BE IN FAVOR OF IT AND I ALSO THINK THAT UM YOU KNOW GUN A GUN SHOP OWNER SOMEONE WHO'S GOING TO HAVE ONE OF THESE EXEMPTIONS WHO HAS GONE THROUGH SOME SORT OF SOME SERIOUS VETTING SO IT'S NOT LIKE YOU WOULD BE HANDING OFF THIS CERTIFICATION

[139:01] PROCESS TO A AN ENTITY THAT IS IRRESPONSIBLE IN FACT I THINK THEY ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE MORE RESPONSIBLE JUST BECAUSE OF WHAT IS RIDING ON IT. SO LISA AND I HAVE NOT SAID JILL AND THE NEARBY I'M WITH ERIN AND NOT IN FAVOR OF THIS WHAT I I THINK THAT WE NEED OVERSIGHT ON THE REGISTRATION AS A CITY AS OUR POLICE FORCE AND WE DON'T HAVE THAT A GUN SHOP WE DON'T HAVE QUALITY CONTROL AT A GUN SHOP WE DON'T KNOW WHETHER WHAT THEY'RE REGISTERING IS LEGITIMATELY HAD BEEN PURCHASED BEFORE THIS WHEN IS THE PLACE OR NOT OR IS COMING IN FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE. I THINK THAT THIS NEEDS TO BE KEPT IN OUR HANDS WITH OUR POLICE NOT WITH THE GUN SHOPS WHO HAVE OPPOSED THIS EVERY STEP OF THE WAY SO I'M IN FAVOR FOR THIS AS WELL. I SPOKE TO THE SHOPS IN BOULDER

[140:04] THIS WEEKEND AND THEY VOICE THE CONCERNS FOR THEIR PATRONS ON THAT MANY OF THEM STILL WERE NOT ARRESTED AND EVEN DOING THE CERTIFICATION AN IRKED ME A LITTLE WORKED REALLY HARD AND THANKS TO JANE'S WONDERFUL IDEA TO GET THIS WORKED OUT WITH COUNSEL AND SO THEY STILL HAD THE CONCERN THAT SOMEHOW THERE WOULD BE RECORDS KEPT THOUGH I ASSURED THEM THAT THERE WOULD NOT AND SO I THINK THIS WOULD BE A REALLY NICE BALANCE. THEY'VE BEEN ERA COMMUNITY FOR A LONG TIME THEY HAVE CONTRA EXTENSIVE BACKGROUND CHECKS. THEY'RE EXTREMELY RESPONSIBLE MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY AND I THINK THIS WOULD HELP INCREASE THE LEVEL OF COMPLIANCE WHICH FOR ME WAS A GOAL AND I THINK FOR MANY OF YOU SO I THINK THIS IS AN EXCELLENT COME AGAIN ANOTHER STEP TOWARDS THE MIDDLE I'M ASSUMING THE CERTIFICATE WOULD BE ONES THAT WE WOULD DESIGN AND THE CITY IN THEY WOULD BE WHAT YOU CALLED HIM PLAY

[141:02] STORE AND BOUGHT SOLD AND ARE EMBOSSED AND SAID WHOA. AND SO THOSE CERTIFICATES WOULD ALL COME THROUGH SAID THE GUY I SEE IT AS THE GUN STORE OWNER WOULD GO GET TO TEN CERTIFICATE AND HAVE THOSE FROM THE POLICE DEPARTMENT AND HAVE THOSE AVAILABLE FOR GOD AND STORE PATRONS TO COME AND IN TERMS OF TRACKING TO THE WEAPON THEY CAN'T. THIS ONLY GOES TIL DECEMBER THIRTY FIRST TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHTEEN WERE NOT SELLING ASSAULT WEAPON AFTER JANUARY FIRST YES THAT'S ME. I THINK IT'S UM AFTER WE PASS IT RIGHT RIGHT RIGHT RIGHT WING SAIL BUT CERTIFICATION CAN HAPPEN UNTIL THE THIRD HILL RIGHT AT THE IMPORTANT THING TO CLARIFY IS THAT THERE IS A WINDOW IN TIME FOR A SET NUMBER OF GUNS IT TO BE CERTIFIED AFTER WHICH THERE WON'T BE ANY CERTIFICATION SO IT IS FINITE OK SO WHAT I'M HEARING IS THERE'S A LITTLE

[142:00] BIT OF A MIXTURE OF USE BUT SEEMS LIKE THERE'S MORE PEOPLE IN FAVOR OF OF OF CONSIDERING THIS PACKAGE INCLUDING NUMBER ONE ARM. I THINK PERHAPS ONLY NUMBER ONE YOU KNOW WE CAN HAVE A DISCUSSION ABOUT IT. I CONCUR WITH AARON ON THIS THE MORE THAT WE BRING FORWARD TO TWEAK THE MORE PEOPLE WILL WANT TO BE MORE THINGS TO SPEAK TO AND IF IT'S JUST HOW WE'RE ISSUING THE CERTIFICATE AND THEY WERE ADDING GUN STORES TO THE OPTIONS I THINK THAT KEEPS IT VERY NARROW IN FOCUS AND DOESN'T IMPLICATE MOST OF THE LANGUAGE IN THE STATUTE AND SO THE LAWSUITS WILL YOU KNOW EXCEPT FOR THIS ONE CHANGE ABOUT CERTIFICATION EVERYTHING ELSE IS GOING TO BE AS WE PASS IT IF WE PASS IT TONIGHT SO I MEAN I'M WILLING TO WAIT ON THE REST OF THE PACKAGE. BOOKMARK IT AND SCHEDULE IT I GUESS IF IF

[143:01] WE'RE GOING TO TAKE THIS UP AGAIN IN AUGUST TO DO NUMBER ONE I SAY LET'S DO THE CLEAN UP WORMS WITH IT I MEAN IT THE CLEANUP ONES AND WE DON'T CARE ABOUT BECAUSE THEY'RE JUST DOING WHAT WE SAID WE WANT TO DO AND SAY IT BETTER. UM I GUESS I WOULD DO IT ONE OF THE OTHER JUST SUGGEST A STRAW POLL ON ITEM NUMBER ONE TO SCHOOL IF WE BRING IT BACK ONCE AND THEN DECIDE HEY WE DON'T DO IT AFTER ALL IT'S WORTH AND OLD A PROBLEM BEING THAT WE JUST GOT IT A FEW HOURS AGO AND UM I'M A BIT MAKE A BROADER JUST PEOPLE WHO WOULD THINK IT'S WORTH CONSIDERING BRINGING BACK A COUPLE MONTHS NOT NECESSARILY WANT IT'S FINE TO KNOW THAT I THINK IT'S FAIR GAME TO GET RIGHT THING TO DO OR NOT I THINK IT'S FINE I JUST HAVE TO PAUSE AND THINK ABOUT IT BECAUSE OK SO HOW MANY SAID THE IDEA IS TO JUST BRING IT BACK IN AUGUST AND DO WHAT I PRESUME RATHER QUICKLY AND YET SEE

[144:05] THE GUESTS OR JUST FOR TO DECLARE FOR YOU DRILL YOU ON AUGUST FOR YET ANOTHER READING WELL IF YOU HAVE TO SAY WE HAVE TO DO WHETHER YOU NEED OR JUST THESE NEW ORDINANCE GREAT. I UNDERSTAND THE WORDS WE WOULDN'T PASS IT TONIGHT TO PASS IT TONIGHT AND BRING THIS BACK AS A SEPARATE ORDINANCE IN AUGUST THE SMALL SCREEN THAT CHANGES SO I MEAN THAT'S A PROPOSAL I THINK THE QUESTION IS DO WE WANT TO BRING THESE BACK YES OR NO TO PROCESS JUST UM IF IF THERE SEEMS TO BE CONCURRENT SOME CLIP CHANGES INCLUDING THE MAJORITY MAY BE IN CONCURRENCE THE MOST CLEAR CHANGES WHEN I PASSED THE ORDINANCE WITH FINALITY TONIGHT AND THEN PASSING MOMENT IN JUNE. I MEAN YOU LIKE THE ENDING GET IT DONE YET AND THAT YEAH THAT WAY LIKELY BE DONE WITH IT THAT WAY THOSE THOSE WHO ARE NOT COMFORTABLE WITH A GUN SHOP

[145:00] RESTRICTION CAN VOTE AGAINST THAT MAYBE PASSES ON A SEVENTY TWO OR SIX THREE BUT WE WILL ALL HAVE PASSED AND THE PRINCIPAL GUN ORDINANCE AND THIS IS JUST AN AMENDMENT JUNE AMENDMENT AND THOSE WHO DON'T LIKE SOME OF IT CAN VOTE AGAINST THE AMENDMENT OUR SCHEDULE IS PACKED AND A FURTHER HEARING WILL NOT BE SHORT. WE HAVE HAD THE AFTERNOON. OK YES ONCE AGAIN CONSENT VOTE OR NOT THAT'S FINE. OK SO HERE'S A PROPOSAL THAT WE MOVE FORWARD ON CONSENT THE PROPOSAL BEFORE US TONIGHT AND THEN WILL BRING BACK YOUR PACKAGE OF FIVE FOR NOW. OR MAYBE FIVE O FIVE FIVE OKAY WE WILL CLEAN THESE UP AND GET HIM TO US AND WE WILL BRING THEM BACK ON CONSENT AS AMENDMENTS TO THE ORDINANCE WE WILL HAVE PASSED THE NIGHT TO OVERCOME THAT BRING EVERYBODY ALONG

[146:05] THEY DISAGREE WITH ME I KNOW SITE CAN PEOPLE LIVE WITH THAT EVEN THOUGH IT'S NOT YOUR PREFERRED JUST GOING TO BE CLEAR THAT WE WOULD BE UM WHEN THIS SO WE WOULD PASS THIS AS IT IS TONIGHT CORRECT AND THEN WHEN THE AMENDMENTS COME BACK THEY WOULD COME BACK TO SIMPLY AS AMENDMENTS BY THEMSELVES CORRECT AND THEN THE PROPOSAL IS TO BRING THE AMENDMENTS BACK ON CONSENT YET LIKE SOON LIKE NEXT MONTH. OK THAT WAS THAT WE DON'T HAVE TO RETHINK ABOUT IT AN OBVIOUS WE CAN JUST CARRY. OK I JUST WENT BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT'S BEING PROPOSED TO DO THE STRAW POLL AND NUMBER ONE BUT NOW THAT IT'S NOT WE DON'T NEED TO I THINK WE'RE JUST GOING TO BRING IT BACK AND PASS IT OR NOT THEY COULD GET EVERYTHING IN ITS NYE WOULD FOR DIFFERENT APPROACH TO ITS FINAL VOTE ON WHAT WE HAVE IN FRONT OF A STABLE SINCE

[147:01] THE COUNCIL TAKE THAT PROCESS YET SO WITH THAT. CAN I HAVE A MOTION TO PASS THE CONSENT AGENDA AND I'M GOING TO INTERRUPT FOR A MINUTE JUST TO REMIND YOU THAT THE THREE L HAS SOME ADDITIONS TO IT WHERE WE HAD LEFT NUMBERS BLANK BECAUSE WE'VE GOT THE BIZ TODAY SO JUST WHEN YOU PASS IT IS WITH THIS VERSION OF THREE L YOU HAVE YOUR SEATS AND GIVE ANOTHER CENT OR TWO OF EXPLANATION BECAUSE THIS IS HOW WE BOND YES EXACTLY. WE PUT BONDS OUT TO BID A FEW WELL AND ON DIFFERENT LARGE CORPORATIONS DECIDE WHETHER THEY WANT TO PURCHASE THEM OR NOT AND THEY BEEN IN AND WE SAE WE ACCEPT THE ENTITY THAT PROVIDES US WITH THE BEST INTEREST RATE THESE BONDS ARE TO CONSTRUCT THE CARTER LAKE PIPELINE AND SO THERE FOR SAFETY AND WATER QUALITY. THEY'RE GREAT BONDS

[148:00] WE GOT A REALLY GOOD RATE ON HIM WHICH IS GREAT TO HEAR THIS IS THE BEST THIS I SIGN THIS AND HIT YOU. OK SO WORRIED ABT IT LOOKS LIKE I'M GUESSING EVERYONE TO SPEAK TO THE GUN THING BEFORE HE PASSES ME BY ONE TOO. I WAS GOING TO MAKE A MOTION AND CAN RETAKE IT THIS WEEKEND SO I MOVED THE CONSENT AGENDA WE OWE OUR EMOTION WE'RE GOING TO SPEAK AFTERWARD. I HAVE ANOTHER ISSUE. OH YES LET'S HEAR THAT MISSION AND SO THE QUESTION IS ON THE AGENDA ITEM THREE M ABOUT THE CONSIDERATION OF THE LAND USE CODE AND ABOUT SETTING A DATE FOR MAKING IT PERMANENT AND I GUESS I'M WONDERING WHY WE'RE MOVING TO ORDINANCES FORWARD IN THE PLANNING BOARD VOTED IN FAVOR OF LENT SO THAT WE DIDN'T HAVE TO DISCUSS IT TONIGHT SO THAT WE WOULD FULLY DISCUSS IT AMONGST OURSELVES. SO THIS IS ONLY PASSAGE ON FIRST READING

[149:01] I IN JULY HE WILL ASSUME ONLY PASSED ONE OF THE TWO ON SECOND READING WHEN YOU COULD HAVE IF YOU HAD THE BENEFIT OF A HEARING. OK THE HIGHLIGHTED THINK U OK SO THE QUESTION OF THE CONSENT AGENDA. I WAS CERTAIN SHE IS GOING TO SAY J ALL RIGHT WE'RE GOOD ON ALL THINGS AN HOUR JUST GOING TO SPEAK TO IT THAT RATE THE OTHER QUESTION I DO HAVE. WELL ONE OF THE THINGS I WOULD LIKE TO DO IS FOR CONSISTENCY SAKE RECUSED MYSELF FROM SINCE I HAVE A SHOT AS TO OUR CHURCH OR A LICENSE RECUSE MYSELF FROM THAT WHICH IS WHICH NUMBER IT SELDOM CLEAN TWENTY TO THIRTY FOR THE CLEANUP PLANS AND ARE OK UNDER K S ONLY GET TO THE VOTING ARE GOING TO RECUSE YOURSELF FROM THAT NEARBY WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK WITH THE SAME TO CHILE TO MAKE THE MOTION AS AMENDED BY RATES AND ARE YET AS AMENDED BY THIS ITEM. YES AS

[150:01] I DO KNOW IS INTENDED HERE FOLKS AND THAT'S OKAY THE SECOND ARE OKAY. PLEASE SPEAK TO THIS MOVIE OK SO I JUST DON'T WANT TO SHARE MY THOUGHTS ON WHAT THE COMMUNITY BECAUSE THIS HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MOST DIFFICULT THINGS I'VE EVER HAD TO DO I'VE SPENT MANY A NIGHT NOT SLEEPING OVER THIS ISSUE. UM I DON'T AGREE WITH THIS ORDINANCE IN MANY WAYS I THINK THAT IT'S INCREDIBLY DIVISIVE TO OUR COMMUNITY AND THAT BRINGS ME A LOT OF SADNESS BECAUSE I DID NOT CAMPAIGN ON THAT I CAMPAIGNED ON BRINGING ALL VOICES TO THE COMMUNITY WHETHER OR NOT YOU AGREE WITH EACH OTHER OR NOT I PROPOSE SOMETHING THAT I THOUGHT WOULD TRULY BRING OUR COMMUNITY TOGETHER THAT WOULD ALSO CREATE EFFECTIVE ENFORCEMENT HIGH LEVEL OF COMPLIANCE AND TRUE SAFETY IN

[151:01] OUR COMMUNITY. UNFORTUNATELY THAT DIDN'T WORK OUT AND MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY WOULD NOT WORK WITH EACH OTHER AND AGAIN I THINK THAT'S EXTREMELY SAD BECAUSE WE HAD OURSELVES AN INCREASED INCREDIBLY OPEN COMMUNITY THAT WANTS TO WORK FROM ALL SIDES AND SO I THINK THIS HAS BEEN REALLY TRUE YOU UPSETTING ISSUE FOR ME WITH ALL THAT SAID I WAS GOING TO VOTE NO ON THIS ORDINANCE AND COUNCIL DIDN'T NEED MY VOTE BUT THEY WERE GRACIOUS ENOUGH TO AT LEAST WORK WITH ME ON ONE BIG ISSUE FOR THE GUNNERS AND THAT WAS GETTING REGISTRATION OFF THE TABLE THIS WAS ACHIEVED AND I THINK IT WAS INCREDIBLY AMAZING THAT OUR COUNCIL WORKED WITH SOMEONE WHO'S BOTH DID NOT NEED AND JANE THANKFULLY AGAIN CAME UP WITH CERTIFICATION. I KNOW IT'S NOT PERFECT I THINK THAT UM WE'RE GOING TO SEE A LOT OF COURT CASES COMING BEFORE US THINK THAT WE'RE GOING TO SPEND A LOT OF TIME AND MONEY IT'S NOT THAT WAS HURT WORSE

[152:00] THAT BUT I THINK THAT THERE IS A BETTER WAY OF GOING ABOUT THIS AND SO I WILL BE VOTING YES ON THIS TO HONOR THE FACT THE COUNCIL TO WORK WITH ME TO GET REGISTRATION OF THE TABLE SO I WANT PEOPLE TO UNDERSTAND THAT AND THAT I FULLY RESPECT GUN OWNERS' RIGHTS AS MY HUSBAND IS ONE OF YOU AND I MARRIED HIM SO THANK YOU ALL EVERY SINGLE ONE NO MATTER WHAT SIDE YOU'RE ON FOR YOUR INCREDIBLE PASSION. I MEAN IT'S IT'S INCREDIBLE TO SEE WHAT THIS COMMUNITY DOES. SO THANK YOU FOR BEING INSPIRING ON ALL SIDES AND UM HOPE EVERYONE CAN UNDERSTAND THE DIFFICULT POSITION THAT WEREN'T THINKING THAT WE'LL LEAVE IT THERE OR DO OTHERS WILL SPEAK TO ME. SO I WAS SOME KIND IT WOULD MATTER WITH ME BY NOT IN THE SENSE THAT I IN ANY WAY SUPPORT THE NRA OR HAVE BEEN SUPPORTIVE OF ASSAULT

[153:02] WEAPONS ANYWAY ARI EVEN GUNS FOR THAT MATTER BUT WHAT DOES MATTER TO ME IS LISTENING AND I FEARED THAT WE WERE NOT LISTENING VERY WELL AND HIS MARE BY SAID THERE WAS THAT WHEN CONCESSION THAT WAS MADE AND I THOUGHT THAT THAT IT'S REALLY DISHEARTENING TO ME THAT WE AGREE ON SO MUCH. I MEAN AND I I FOUND MYSELF AGREEING WITH A LOT OF THE E MAILS THAT WERE ACTUALLY SENT BY GUN OWNERS SAYING THIS IS WHAT WE NEED TO DO AND IT WAS TO ME IT WAS YES YOU GUYS A RAID AND AND THERE WAS ACTUALLY A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT WERE ANTI ASSAULT WEAPONS THAT WERE SAYING THE SAME THINGS SO WHY COULDN'T WE AGREE ON THAT AND PASS THAT WITHOUT THE LOCATION WITHOUT THE DIVISIVENESS AND WITHOUT THE ANIMOSITY EASY AND YOU KNOW IT'S JUST IT'S VERY

[154:01] DISHEARTENING THAT ARM. WE COULDN'T COME TOGETHER ON THAT HERE. SO WITH ASTHMA BY SAID THEM THERE WAS AT ONE CONCESSION WAS MADE AND I HOPE THAT IN THE AMENDMENTS WHO MAKE THE OTHER ONE REGARDING THE BE ABLE TO CERTIFY THAT THE GUN SHOPS AND I SAID IN NO WAY DOES THIS MEAN THAT I HAVE ANY SUPPORT FOR ANY OF THE TACTICS OF THE NRA BUT I I WAS ALSO VERY DISHEARTENED THAT WHEN THERE WAS AN ATTEMPT TO BRING THE TWO SIDES OF THE ISSUE TOGETHER ONCE I DROPPED OUT AND IT WAS NOT THE GUN OWNERS SO THAT WAS VERY DISHEARTENING. UM AND UM I HOPE THAT IN THE FUTURE WE CAN AT LEAST TALK TO EACH OTHER NOT VILIFY CHAIRS MUCH AS WE HAVE ON THIS ISSUE AND I KNOW IT THAT PASSIONS RUN HIGH. I REALIZED THAT BUT THE LEAST WE CAN DO

[155:02] IS RESPECT EACH OTHER THE SAME SO YOU KNOW BOB AND I HAD AN EDITORIAL IN WHICH WE KIND OF LAID OUT OUR THOUGHTS ON HOW WE GOT TO WHERE WE ARE DOING TO POINT OUT THAT THERE WAS ANOTHER POINT THAT WE STARTED ON EARLY AS FAR AS CONSIDERING THE RIGHTS OF PEOPLE WHO HAD LEGALLY PURCHASED THESE WEAPONS THAT WERE SUBJECT TO THE BAND AND NOT MAKING THOSE WEAPONS OUTRIGHT ILLEGAL MOST OTHER COMMUNITIES COUNTIES AND CITIES WHO HAVE PASSED BANS OF THIS TYPE HAVE NOT HAD A GRANDFATHER IN PROVISIONS IN WHICH PEOPLE HAVE A PATHWAY TO LEGALITY FOR WEAPONS THAT WERE PERFECTLY LEGAL WHEN THEY WHEN THEY ACQUIRED THEM AND SO I FEEL LIKE THAT WAS ANOTHER AREA IN WHICH WE MADE EFFORTS AND WE CAME UP WITH THE SYSTEM THAT WAS I BELIEVE CONSIDERATE OF THE CONCERNS OF FOLKS I DO WANT TO SAY

[156:01] THAT I BELIEVE THAT ALMOST ALL GUN OWNERS ARE RESPONSIBLE NOT ALL BUT MOST AND IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE ACKNOWLEDGE THAT AND RESPECT THAT IN THIS PROCESS AND I TRIED TO DO THAT ALL ALONG AT THE SAME TIME I DO BELIEVE THAT WE ARE ON FIRM SECOND AMENDMENT GROUNDS HERE BECAUSE AUNT AND SCALY IS THE ONE WHO WROTE THE OPINION IN HELLER D C VERSUS HELLER AND THAT HAS BEEN UPHELD BY THE FACT THAT THE SUPREME COURT DID NOT TAKE UP THE CHALLENGE TO THE HIGHLAND PARK ILLINOIS ASSAULT WEAPONS BAN WHICH WAS COMPLETE AND DID NOT HAVE ANY GRAND FATHERING AND THEY DIDN'T TAKE IT UP BECAUSE IT'S SETTLED LAW AND SO FROM THAT STANDPOINT I FEEL LIKE WE'RE BEING RESPONSIBLE AND THE WAY THE SUPREME COURT HAS INTERPRETED THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES WHICH WE ARE SWORN TO UPHOLD AND BASED ON THE RUINS OF THE SUPREME COURT. I THINK WE'RE DOING

[157:01] THAT THERE ARE TWO OTHER CITIES IN COLORADO THAT HAVE THESE KINDS OF PROVISIONS IN THEIR MUNICIPAL CODE DENVER AND VAIL AND SO I THINK WE ALSO STAND A VERY GOOD CHANCE OF SURVIVING A CHALLENGE TO PREEMPTION. I JUST WANT TO PUT OUT THERE THAT THIS IS NOT DIRECTED AT A GROUP OF PEOPLE AT ALL AND IS DIRECTED AT SAFETY AND THE ONE THING I WOULD SAY TO THOSE WHO SAY YOU HAVEN'T HAD ONE OF THESE IN YOUR TOWN IS THESE ARE EXCEPTIONAL BLACK SWAN TYPE OF EVENTS AND I WOULD SAY THAT MANY OF THE TOWNS THAT SAW THESE KINDS OF MASS KILLINGS HAVE NOT SEEN THEM PRIOR TO THAT AND SO THIS IS NOT ABOUT RESPECTIVELY TRYING TO SOLVE A MASS SHOOTING IT'S TRYING TO BE IN FRONT OF THE POSSIBILITY OF ONE HAPPENING HERE IS A COUPLE WORDS I DO FEEL LIKE GENERALLY THE DISCUSSION ON THIS TOPIC HAS BEEN RESPECTFUL IT'S ONE WHERE FEELINGS RUN HIGH BUT I HAVE

[158:00] THE HIGHEST RESPECT FOR PEOPLE WHO'VE ENGAGED WITH US ON THE TOPIC FROM THE DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES NEW NOTIFICATION INTENDED. I THINK FUNDAMENTALLY THE PURPOSE OF THIS ORDINANCE IS TO PREVENT THE POSSESSION OF WEAPONS THAT ALLOW FOR MANY PEOPLE TO BE KILLED IN A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME AND I THINK THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TRYING TRYING TO DO HERE AND I'M VERY GLAD THAT WE'RE DOING HERE IN OUR COMMUNITY AND MY HOPE IS THAT MORE COMMUNITIES WILL JOIN US AND THAT WILL PLAY A POWERFUL ROLE IN THAT SENSE AND THAT WILL ALSO SEE MORE OF THESE PANS. THE STATE LEVEL AND ONE DAY AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL SO THAT THESE WEAPONS WILL NO LONGER BE PRESENT IN OUR SOCIETY TO EXTENT POSSIBLE ON EVERY ISSUE THAT WE TAKE UP THURSDAY. THERE'S VARIOUS SIDES TO THE STORY WHETHER IT'S ENERGY OR HOUSING OR

[159:02] WHATNOT AND I'VE SEEN MANY MANY CASES WHERE WE DON'T OUR SOLUTION ISN'T A COMPROMISE BETWEEN THE VARIOUS SIZED LEADERS ARE ELECTED TO MAKE OUR DECISIONS AND THERE'S A LOT OF EXAMPLES GOING BACK TO HISTORY WHERE THERE ARE TWO SIDES QUOTE UNQUOTE AND WE MADE DECISIONS AND WE LOOK BACK AT THEM NOW AS EITHER OBVIOUSLY RIGHT ARE OBVIOUSLY WRONG AND THAT IN THE WEAPONS INDUSTRY IS EVOLVING SO RAPIDLY. THIS IS NOT AN ATTACK ON THE SECOND AMENDMENT GENERALLY BUT ON THESE EVER EVOLVING WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION THAT ARE BEING USED TO MURDER CHILDREN IN SCHOOLS ALL THROUGHOUT OUR COUNTRY AT RATES HIGHER THAN ANY OTHER COUNTRY AND I BELIEVE THAT IT'S OUR ROLE AS LEADERS TO BE BOLD AND TO MAKE THE RIGHT DECISION AND THE TIME WITH THE INFORMATION

[160:00] THAT WE HAVE AND NOT NECESSARILY ALWAYS JUST A COMPROMISE WILL ASK SOMETHING SO AS WE MOVE THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS AND ONCE THE LOSSES HAVE COME IN I WOULD LIKE TO SEE COMING THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS HAVE HAD THIS ACCOUNT OR THE MONEY THAT WILL BE SPENT ON THAT AS WE GO THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS IS THAT SOMETHING WE CAN DO. YES THIS ABSOLUTELY THINK YOU UP. MY COLLEAGUES ON COUNCIL AS I SAID THIS IS THIS IS ONE OF THE TOUGHEST DECISIONS I THINK OF US HAD HAD TO MAKE AND THIS IS YOU KNOW I MY GUESS IS THAT THIS IS NOT THE ORDINANCE AND ANY OF US WOULD WALK THERE WAS A LOT OF COMPROMISE OR A LAND OF SOME PEOPLE WOULD LIKE TO GO FURTHER. SOME PEOPLE THINK FILLED THIS HAS GONE TOO FAR I'M HAPPY THAT WE'RE GOING TO PASS UNANIMOUSLY. WE TRY TO BE RESPECTFUL OF

[161:00] THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY DONORS AND THERE'S AT LEAST THREE OF US UP HERE AND THOSE WHO WOULD LIKE TO SEE MORE RESTRICTIONS SO WE'RE DOING THE BEST WE CAN. I REALLY WANT TO THANK MY COLLEAGUES FOR COMING TOGETHER THIS IS I THINK THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT WE PASS UNANIMOUSLY AND BY THAT WE ARE HERE BY A SPECIAL THANKS TO YOU I KNOW THIS IS VERY DIFFICULT BUT I REALLY APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT PEOPLE ARE WILLING TO MAKE CONCESSIONS EXCEPTIONS COMPROMISES TO COME UP WITH AN ORDINANCE THAT WE AT LEAST BELIEVE REFLECTS OUR COMMUNITY VALUES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH OK I THINK ARE GOOD I CAN'T REALLY IMPROVE UPON WHAT'S BEEN SAID THIS ISN'T AN ISSUE THAT I THINK ANY OF US WANTED TO DEAL WITH HIM BUT I DO THINK WE'RE CALLED AS LEADERS TO RESPOND TO THE ISSUES OF THE DAY AND THIS HAS BECOME ONE OF THEM AND FORTUNATELY SO WITH THAT WE HAVE A ROLL CALL VOTE THEY START WITH

[162:09] COUNCILMEMBER NAGEL I WEAVER EYE GATES BY YOUNG I BROKE A CARLISLE EXCEPT FOR THE ONE WE CHOOSE THE KIDS FROM THREE K RUN AND I JONES WAS OUR MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY WITH COUNCILMEMBER CARL ERIC IS FROM UH UH UH THE END WE WILL PROMPTLY MOVED TO THE NEXT ITEM AS SOON AS FOLKS WHO CAN TRANSITION A NEW SIGN THE NEXT YOUR CALL UP CHECK AND WORK AND

[163:13] THE AGAIN THANKS TO ALL OF YOU FOR COMING TONIGHT AND REAGAN ASK YOU TO MOVE QUICKLY. THEY HAVE. THANK YOU ALL TO MOVE TO ANNEX THE STAFF READY TO CALL A CHECK AND FIFTEEN EIGHTY CHRIS CORLEY UTILITY EASEMENT VACATION GUIDE CISCO YET YOU HAVE TO DO THAT ROLL CALL CHECK AND THUS TAKING AWAY WE ARE EATING. OH I'M SORRY OTHER AGENDA OKAY. DOES ANYBODY WANT TO CALL UP FROM

[164:03] FIFTEEN EIGHTY CREST COURT UTILITY EASEMENT VACATION THERE IS NO INTEREST FOR K OR FIRST HEARING AS A CONCEPT PLAN REVIEW FOR THE FORMER RETAIL SITE AT SIXTEEN SIXTEEN SIXTY FIVE THIRTY THIRD STREET AND CHARLES FERRO WILL HANDLE THIS MATTER ALONG WITH SLOAN WEBER TO THOSE ON THEIR WAY OUT CAN I ENCOURAGE YOU TO THANK YOU OKAY. GOOD EVENING MEMBERS OF COUNCIL'S LONE WEBER WILL PRESENT STAFF ANALYSIS THIS EVENING. MARIAM GOOD EVENING EVERYONE. SO THE ITEM FOR DISCUSSION TODAY IS THE PROPOSAL TO REDEVELOP THE FORMER FOR HOPS RETELL SAY AT SIXTEEN SIXTY FIVE THIRTY THIRD STREET WITH A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT THAT IN CREW INCLUDES A CONGREGATE CARE FACILITY. ERM THE PROJECT IS REQUIRED TO COMPLETE A CONCEPT PLAN REVIEW BECAUSE IT EXCEEDS THE THRESHOLD FOR REQUIRED

[165:01] CONCEPT PLAN AND SITE REVEAL THEY ARE ALSO ASKING FOR A MODIFICATION TO BUILDING WHICH WOULD REQUIRE SITE REVEALED. SO JUST AS A REMINDER THE PURPOSE OF A CONCEPT PLAN REVIEW IS TO DETERMINE THE GENERAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR PARTICULAR SAY AND TO HELP IDENTIFY KEY ISSUES IN ADVANCE OF A SITE REVIEWS THE MIDDLE AND THIS STEP IS INTENDED TO GIVE APPLICANTS AN OPPORTUNITY TO SOLICIT COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD CITY STAFF TIME IN THE EARLY IN THE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS AND IS INTENDED TO BE A CONVERSATION SO AS PART OF THE PROCESS WRITTEN NOTICE WAS SENT SAND NOTICE WAS POSTED ON THE PROPERTY HIM AND ALL NOTICE REQUIREMENTS HAVE BEEN MET STAFF DID RECEIVE A NUMBER OF WRITTEN RESPONSE AS REGARDING THE PROPOSAL PRIMARILY FROM RESIDENTS OF THE PALETTE ON AND THOSE WERE INCLUDED IN

[166:01] THE PLANNING BOARD PACKET AND THE PLANNING BOARD MINUTES AS WELL. THE SITE IS LOCATED WEST OF AN ADJACENT TWO THIRTY THIRD STREET NORTH OF ARAPAHOE AVENUE AND THE AREA CONTAINS A WIDE RANGE OF RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL OPERATIONS INDUSTRIAL USE AS AND HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL USE AS THE GENERAL CHARACTER OF THE COMMERCIAL AREA TO THE WEST IS A GREAT AUTO ORIENTATED WITH LARGE SCALE RETAILERS INCLUDING THE TWENTY NINTH STREET MALL NORTH ON THIRTY THIRD STREET ARE VARIOUS SERVICE AND LIGHT INDUSTRIAL USES INCLUDING THE RTD ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES AND MAINTENANCE GARAGE. THE BOULDER COUNTY CLERK AND RECORDER BUILDING AND THE CITY OF BOULDER SAFETY FACILITY THE PALATE ON DEVELOPMENT IS LOCATED DIRECTLY ACROSS THIRTY THIRD

[167:00] STREET WHICH IS A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT CONTAINING THREE HUNDRED AND NINETY DWELLING UNITS AND AS WELL AS OFFICE RETAIL AND RESTAURANT USES TO THE SOUTH IS A WELLS FARGO BANK WITH DRIVE UP SERVICE AS AND ALSO A LARGE OFFICE BUILDING THE CENTER A CENTER IS LOCATED DIRECTLY TO THE WEST WHICH CONTAINS A VARIETY OF RETAIL SERVICE AND RESTAURANT USES TO THE SOUTH OF THE SE ACROSS ARAPAHOE IS THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO EAST CAMPUS AND RESEARCH LABS AND BOULDER COMMUNITY HOSPITAL IS LOCATED APPROXIMATELY THREE FOURTHS OF A MILE EAST ON ARAPAHOE AVENUE. I SEWED THE EXISTING PRIMARY STRUCTURE WAS FORMERLY A GREENHOUSE AND GARDEN CENTER BUILT IN NINETEEN SEVENTY EIGHT BUT THE SE IS CURRENTLY MAKE AND THE BUILDING WAS DESIGNED BY

[168:00] BERT WAGGONER HE WAS A PROMINENT ARCHITECT AND BUILDER STARTING IN THE NINETEEN FIFTIES DAILY NEWS DOES A NATION AS GENERAL BUSINESS WHICH ANTICIPATES INTENSIVE COMMERCIAL USE AS AND I'M ALSO RESIDENTIAL USES AND THE CORRESPONDING ZONING IS BUSINESS REGIONAL WINE WHICH IS DEFINED AS BUSINESS CENTERS CONTAINING A WIDE RANGE OF RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL OPERATIONS THE PROJECT SITE IS LOCATED JUST OUTSIDE OF THE BOULDER VALLEY REGIONAL CENTER. I AM WHICH IS ONE OF THE CITY'S THREE REGIONAL ACTIVITY CENTERS AT THE B OR C IS A HIGH INTENSITY REGIONAL COMMERCIAL CENTER PLANNED FOR A VARIETY OF USE AS I AM AND ALTHOUGH THE SITES LOCATED OUTSIDE OF THE BR SEE THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA IS ECLECTIC AND REPRESENTATIVE OF THE REGIONAL BUSINESS CENTER PROPERTY IS LOCATED WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES OF

[169:00] THE CROSSROADS EAST SUNRISE CENTER AREA PLAN WHICH INCLUDES THE EASTERN MOST PORTION OF THE B OR C AREA WAS TARGETED FOR SPECIFIC AREA PLAN BECAUSE IT WAS LOW IDENTIFIED AS A LOCATION WITH SIGNIFICANT OPPORTUNITIES FOR REDEVELOPMENT AND THE OBJECTIVES OF THE PLAN WERE TO ENRICH THE AREA'S IMAGE AND DESIGN QUALITY IMPROVE VEHICULAR CIRCULATION AND PEDESTRIAN NETWORK BICYCLE ACCESS AND OUTLINED DESIRED USES FOR THE AREA WAS SO MOVING ON TO PROPOSE ALL THE PROJECTS INCLUDES A CONGREGATE CARE FACILITY WITH ONE HUNDRED PERCENT PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE RENTAL UNITS FOR SENIORS THE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT WOULD BE MULTIFAMILY STACKED FLATS AND TWO FIVE STORY BUILDINGS ACADEMY SENIOR LIVING WOULD MANAGE TO CONGREGATE CARE FACILITY AND THE FACILITY WOULD INCLUDE COMMUNITY AMENITIES SLY COMMON DINING AND ASSOCIATED

[170:01] ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES I AM AND JUST AS A SIDE NOTE THERE ARE SPECIFIC DENSITY CALCULATIONS FOR CONGREGATE CARE WHEREBY THEY USE A DWELLING UNIT EQUIVALENCY SUBJECT TO CERTAIN STANDARDS IN ADDITION THE DEVELOPMENT WOULD INCLUDE APPROXIMATELY FIFTEEN THOUSAND SQUARE FEET OF RETAIL RESTAURANT AND OFFICE SPACE AND EIGHTY EIGHT TWO STORY BUILDING FRONTING ON THIRTY THIRD STREET AND THE PROPOSAL INCLUDES SEVENTY FOUR ARE ON SITE PARKING SPACES WHICH WOULD BE DESIGNED AS PODIUM PARKING UNDER THE CONGREGATE CARE FACILITY PARKING WOULD SHARE IT BE SHARED BETWEEN RESIDENTS EMPLOYEES AND PATRONS OF THE BUSINESS. ASO IN TERMS OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THE E RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT CONTAINS THREE AFFORDABILITY COMPONENTS THE FIRST WOULD BE AS SATISFYING THE EXCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENTS FOR

[171:00] THE DEVELOPMENT ON SITES WHEREBY THEY WOULD HAVE TO TWENTY FIVE PERCENT OF THE TOTAL DWELLING UNITS HAS PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE THE SECOND WOULD BE PERSONALLY SATISFYING THE INCLUDE A REQUIREMENT FOR THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON SAID A MOMENT THERE HAS EVER CRIME AND OF APPROXIMATELY TWENTY AFFORDABLE UNITS OF VARIOUS SIZES AND VARYING NUMBER OF BEDROOMS AND COULD QUESTION THE BLUE THE PROS BUT OPPOSING EIGHT UNITS ON SITE AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON IS THAT WHAT THEY COME THE GOING TO BRING WELL I'M JUST ASKING BECAUSE IT'S ON THIS SITE YES I WAS GOING TO MENTION THAT THEY HAVE REVISED THEIR PROPOSAL WITHIN THE LAST WEEK OR SO TO HAVE EIGHT UNITS TO BE POTENTIALLY LOCATED ON SITE AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON SO THIS SITE WOULD HOUSE THAT WHATEVER THE REMAINING NUMBER OF UNITS WOULD BE. THANK YOU

[172:02] M AND THE THIRD COMPONENT WOULD BE PROVIDING THE REMAINING UNITS AS PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE POTENTIALLY FINANCED BY CITY FUNDING OR OTHER FUNDING SOURCES BUT YOU KNOW THAT'S SORT OF UNCLEAR AT THIS POINT WE'RE GOING TO HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT THIS PIECE OF IT THE YOU TELL ME HOW MANY MORE SLIDE YOU HAVE IN YOUR OVERALL PROPOSAL WAS AND NO WORLD IN A TALK ABOUT IT IT'S A TEN ISH. OK CAN WE JUST KNOW WHAT WE'LL HOLD A QUESTION ON THIS ONE AND YOU KEEP GOING THROUGH ALL MY SLIDES YET TO SUSPEND THEM FROM OUR TIME ON THIS AND I SAID THE PLAN IS FOR FOUR BUILDINGS OR GRANT ORGANIZED AROUND A CENTRAL COURTYARD THREE OF THE BUILDINGS WOULD BE FOUR STORY STRUCTURES OVER PARTY AND PERK AM LIKE A MANSION WHICH WOULD BE FIVE STORIES TALL. I HAD TWO STORY STRUCTURE FACES THIRTY THIRD STREET AND ITS PROPOSED PROPOSE TO CONTAIN

[173:00] THE COMMERCIAL USE AS AND THAT COMMERCIAL STRUCTURE IS DESIGNED TO ENHANCE THE PEDESTRIAN EXPERIENCE THE PROPOSAL INCLUDES USABLE OPEN SPACE IN THE FORM OF THAT INTERIOR COURTYARD AND ENCLOSE SKY BRIDGE TO ENTRY PLAZA AND PRIVATE BALCONIES AND THAT'S A VIEW OF THE COURTYARD SO THAT CONGREGATE CARE STRUCTURES WOULD BE SOMEWHERE BETWEEN FORTY FIVE AND FIFTY FIVE FEET IN FIGHTS AND AS I MENTIONED A MODIFICATION WOULD BE REQUIRED AS PART OF SITE REVIEW TO EXCEED THIRTY FIVE FEET FOR THE DESIGN IS CONTEMPORARY WITH FLAT ROOFS AND THE PROPOSED BUILDING MATERIALS INCLUDE FIBER CEMENT BOARD SIDING BRICK AND STEEL DETAILING SO THE KEY ISSUES AS IDENTIFIED BY STAFF ARE WHETHER THE CONCEPT PLAN IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN II

[174:01] WHETHER IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THEIR CROSSROADS THE SUN RAYS CENTER AREA PLANNED AND WHETHER THE HEIGHT MASS AND SCALE OF THE PROPOSED BUILDINGS ARE COMPATIBLE WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA AND SO STEPHEN'S THE PROPOSED USES ARE CONSISTENT WITH THAT GENERAL BUSINESS LAND USE DESIGNATION WHICH IS APPLIED TO AREAS WHERE INTENSIVE COMMERCIAL USES EXCESS AND IT'S HARD TO SEE ON THE SCREEN BUT HOUSING IS LISTED AS A USE TO BE ENCOURAGED WITHIN THIS LAND USE DESIGNATION AND I SAW FINDS THAT THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WOULD BE IT APPROPRIATE TRANSITION BETWEEN MANY MORE INTENSIVE COMMERCIAL DISTRICT TO THE WEST AND THE PALATE ON AND OFF A SERVICE USES TO THE EAST AND INITIALLY THE PROPOSAL IS CONSISTENT WITH MANY OF THE GOALS OBJECTIVES AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE CONFERENCE A PLAN PARTICULARLY REGARDING HOUSING AT THE SITE IS IDEAL FOR CONGREGATE CARE BECAUSE

[175:01] THAT IS EASILY ACCESSIBLE TO A VARIETY OF SERVICE AS RETAIL DINING ENTERTAINMENT HE SAYS IT'S ALSO WELL SERVED BY TRAN SAID. AND BY THE LARGER MULTI MODAL NETWORK SO IT'S UNCLEAR AT THIS STAGE WHETHER THE PROPOSAL MEETS POLICIES REGARDING DESIGN AND HISTORIC RESOURCE AS BUT ADDITIONAL ANALYSIS WOULD NEED TO BE DONE AT THE STATE REVIEW STAGE. WHAT ABOUT HISTORIC RESOURCES ARE IMPACTED THERE THE BUILDINGS WERE DESIGNED BY A COVERT WAGONER. I'M SO AT THIS STAGE WE JUST DON'T HAVE ENOUGH INFORMATION TO KNOW WHETHER THAT'S SIGNIFICANT AND THEY'RE OVER FIFTY YEARS OLD DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY LANDMARK BUILDINGS OR STRUCTURES WE HAVE A HUBBY WEGNER IN THE CITY DO NOTS. I KNOW THERE'S AT LEAST A FEW TO BE TRAMPLED. I GUESS I HAVE A PROCESS QUESTION SO IT MAY TURN OUT THAT WE NEED TO

[176:00] PRESERVE THOSE BUILDINGS ARE THAT IT'S POSSIBLE. SHOULD WE FIGURE THAT OUT SOONER RATHER THAN LATER. OKAY IT'S JUST POINTED OUT THERE FACT THIRD LESS THAN FIFTY YEARS OLD. OK SO BUT NONETHELESS BUT YOU'D THINK IN TERMS OF AS PART OF SITE REVIEW THERE IS A CRITERIA THAT TALKS TO PRESERVING HISTORIC RESOURCES I'M SO WE'D BE DOING THAT IN ALL SISTERS THEY REVEAL YOURSELF LIKE THIS BECAUSE I MEAN IF YOU HAVE TO PRESERVE THIS BILLINGS THIS TIRE HAVE TO BE AGAINST CRITERIA THAT HAS TO BE SATISFIED THROUGH SALE OF U S LANDMARKS TEAM AND MY MARKS BOARD FINDS VALUE IN THOSE BUILDINGS AND I THINK THAT'S A DIFFERENT DISCUSSION BUT IT WOULD HAVE TO BE SOMETHING WE'D ADDRESS THROUGH THE SURVEY PROCESS OF BEING THAT THEY'RE NOT FIFTY YEARS OLD. DON'T TRIGGER THAT AUTOMATIC CONSIDERATION. OK JUST WANTED TO PUT OUT THERE SOONER RATHER LATER IN RAY AND MARY HAS THEIR HAND UP BUT IF IT HAD BEEN IF THEY HAD BEEN OLDER AND OLDER THAN

[177:00] FIFTY YEARS IT WOULD HAVE BEEN TRIGGERED PREVIOUSLY WOULD'VE ALREADY TELL THAT THEY WOULD NEED TO GET A DEMO PERMIT BUT NOT NECESSARILY AT THE STAGE BECAUSE THEY'RE ONLY GOT FOUR HUNDRED AND EIGHTY DAYS SO THEY WOULD WHAT A CRAZY PROCESS THAT I DON'T REALLY KNOW WHAT MY QUESTION IS BECAUSE I'M SO CONFUSED BY THIS BUT THE WHAT WHAT WOULD THE PROCESS BEFORE I MEAN IT'S KIND OF A CHICKEN EGG THING HERE WHERE YOU HAVE THESE POTENTIALLY HISTORIC STRUCTURES THAT AREN'T GOING TO TRIGGER TRIGGER THE DEMOLITION OF THE LANDMARKS BOARD REVIEW BUT IF THROUGH SITE REVIEW THEIR DETERMINED THAT THEY ARE THEN DO THEY GO BACK TO THE LANDMARKS WHAT'S THE PROCESS. THIS IS CONCEPT PLAN REVIEW SO IT'S AN EARLY CHANCE FOR COUNCIL TO GIVE COMMENT SO THE APPROPRIATE THING FOR MY RECOMMENDATION TO DO TONIGHT IS HIS EXPRESSION ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE POTENTIAL LOSS OF THOSE BUILDINGS THE WHOLE IDEA OF TONIGHT IS TO GIVE THE DEVELOP AN EARLY IDEA OF THINGS THE COUNCIL WILL

[178:00] CONSIDER IMPORTANT. IF THIS COMES BACK TO YOU ON SITE REVIEW WITH THE CURRENT PLAN INDICATED THAT THE SEC REVIEW CRITERIA FOR PRESERVING HISTORIC STRUCTURES IS SOMETHING THE COUNCIL CONSIDERS IMPORTANT. SO IF THEY DON'T DEAL WITH THAT THEN YOU CAN ADDRESS ITS SITE REVIEW AS PART OF THAT CRITERIA WHEN BALANCING IT AGAINST ALL THE OTHER CRITERIA. SO TONIGHT YOU COULD SEND A STRONG SIGNAL THAT THOSE BUILDINGS ARE IMPORTANT TO YOU IN THE DEVELOPED WHICH CAN CAN CAN OR CANNOT. THIS IS ALL JUST CALM IT CAN CAN OR CANNOT TAKE THOSE INTO ACCOUNT AS THEY DEVELOP THE FINAL PLAN FOR YOUR REVIEW THAT MAKE SENSE BARRY YES I THINK THE STRONG MESSAGE ON A SENTENCE THAT PROCESS SEEMS A LITTLE OUT OF SEQUENCE GOOD YET I CAN IN OUR PACKET FIND ANYTHING ABOUT HOPI WAGNER WAGNER AND SO I FEEL LIKE THERE'S A BIG PIECE OF INFORMATION MISSING AND I DON'T KNOW HOW OLD THIS BUILDING IS HE SAY THAT IT'S NOT FIFTY YEARS. IT IS FOR THE NINETEEN SEVENTY EIGHT FORTY A CAVE SO FORTY YEARS

[179:02] AND I GUESS I'D LIKE TO LIKE MYRIAD LIKE TO UNDERSTAND A LITTLE MORE WHERE LANDMARKS BOARD COMES INTO THIS. OK SO LET US LIKE THIS AS IT JUST TO MEET THE SEQUENCE OF HOW THIS IS BEING CONSIDERED IS JUST ODD BECAUSE IF WE DID HAVE CONCERNS YOU KNOW IT WOULD HAVE BEEN NOT ANY BUT THE POINT MADE WHAT YOU CONTINUE ON. I ASO THE SECOND KEY ISSUE WOULD BE WHETHER THE PROPOSAL MEETS THE CROSSROADS THE SUNRISE CENTER AREA PLAN THE PLAN DOES CONTAIN SPECIFIC URBAN DESIGN GUIDELINES AND PLANNED TRANSPORTATION CONNECTIONS TO GUIDE FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OF THE AREA AND THE GUIDELINES WERE INTENDED TO CRACK STRIP MALL STYLE DEVELOPMENT IN THE AREA WITH LARGE EXPANSES OF SOFT SURFACE PARKING LIKE THE ONE IN THE PHOTO I'M IN

[180:01] WITHOUT GOING INTO DETAIL THE PROPOSAL DOES GENERALLY MEANS THE DESIGN OBJECTIVES BY PROMOTING A HUMAN SCALE DEVELOPMENTS TIME WITH BUILDING FOR DESIGN AND LIMITING SURFACE PARKING IT IS IMPORTANT TO KNOW HOWEVER THE PLAN ANTICIPATES A CONNECTION ACROSS THE PROPERTY TO THE CENTER A CENTER TO THE EAST AND IN INFORMAL CONNECTION CURRENTLY EXISTS WITHIN THE WELLS FARGO DRIVE ACCESS IN THE ADJACENT OFFICE DEVELOPMENT AND STAFF RECOMMENDS PROVIDING A MORE DEFINED PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIONS WITH US ON RACE AND ARE IN THE SHOPPING CENTER THE WEST. SORRY TO THE WEST YES BUT HAS ANYBODY ASKED WELLS FARGO OF PEOPLE CAN USE THEIR DRIVEWAY TO WALKED THROUGH I DOUBT IT SPED SORT OF BECOME AN INFORMAL CONNECTION BUT WHEN IT ALL THE PROPERTY OWNERS WELL THE RECOMMENDATION IS TO DO SOMETHING IN ADDITION

[181:00] TO RE ADD THIS WOULD REPLACE ANY INFORMAL COLLECTION. OKAY I'M SO LASTLY AS I DESCRIBED APPLICANTS REQUESTING A MODIFICATION OF THE PROJECT WOULD BE ELIGIBLE FOR MODIFICATION BECAUSE A HUNDRED PERCENT OF THE FLOOR AREA OF THE BUILDINGS OVER THIRTY FIVE FEET WOULD BE FOR PERMANENT PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND POTENTIALLY THERE ARE SEVERAL LARGE SCALE BUILDINGS IN THE VICINITY. I'M WITHIN THE PELOTON A BOMB AND THERE ARE SEVERAL BUILDINGS THAT ARE MORE STORIES THAN FIFTY FIVE FEET TALL AND DUE TO THE PROXIMITY TO THE PALLET ON THE HEIGHT OF THE DEVELOPMENT WOULD NOT BE AN ANOMALY. I'M IN WOULD ADD TWO OF BRADY OF HEIGHTS IN THE AREA AND IT SHOULD ALSO BE NOTED THAT IN TWO THOUSAND AND FOUR WHEN THE PELOTON WAS APPROVED. IT WAS NOTED THAT PROPERTY IS WEST OF FOOTHILLS HIGHWAY AND SOUTH OF PEARL PARKWAY WERE APPROPRIATELY PLACED TO SUPPORT FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OF TALLER

[182:01] BUILDINGS AND VIEWS FROM THE SITE TOWARDS THE MOUNTAINS WOULD LIKELY BE OBSCURED OR ELIMINATED. I AM BUT NONE OF THESE FEW QUARTERS HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED AS SIGNIFICANT A FEW QUARTERS THE FIVE STORY STRUCTURES ARE PULLED AWAY FROM THE STREETS AND WHEREAS WHEREBY THE TWO STORY STRUCTURE IS ORIENTED ON THIRTY THIRD STREET WHICH CREATES A TRANSITION IN HEIGHT FROM THIRTY THIRD STREET AND BUT AS ALWAYS ENHANCED DESIGN WOULD BE PARAMOUNT IN ANY IN SUPPORTING HEIGHT MODIFICATION REQUEST IT'S A GREAT MEAL AND THEN AND JUST QUICKLY IN TERMS OF PLANNING BOARD FEEDBACK THEY'D THERE WAS A HEARING ON MARCH FIFTEENTH. GENERALLY THE BOARD FROM THE PROPOSAL CONSISTENT WITH A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND THERE WAS SUPPORT FOR THE PROVISION OF MUCH NEEDED SENIOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND THE BOARD STATED THAT THE PROPOSED MIX OF USES AND INCREASED DENSITY WAS SUPPORTED BY THE CROSSROADS EAST CENTER A CENTER PLAN AND

[183:01] THEY DID NOTE THAT CONSIDERATION NEEDS TO BE GIVEN TO USABLE OPEN SPACE AND PRESERVING VIEWS TO THE WEST. THEY ALSO DISCUSS THE COMPATIBILITY OF THE INVOLVEMENT WITH THE CHARACTER OF THE AREA SEVERAL MEMBERS COMPLIMENTED APPLICATION ON THE PROPOSED DESIGN. THERE WAS SOME SUGGESTIONS ABOUT SCALING DOWN THE AND NORTH SOUTH ORIENTED BUILDINGS AND THERE WAS ALSO SOME DISCUSSION ABOUT PERKY IN AND THERE WAS SUPPORT FOR A BAN FOR OR ON PERSONAL CARS FOR THE RESIDENTS OF THE CONGREGATE CARE FACILITY AND LASTLY THERE WAS SOME CONCERN ABOUT THE LIGHTING FOR THAT INTERIOR COURTYARD IN ENSURING THAT THE COURTYARD WAS MEANINGFUL OPEN SPACE AND THAT'S ALL I HAVE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS TO WHAT CAN YOU GO BACK TO THE AFFORDABILITY. I SHOULD POINT OUT THAT KURT FOR

[184:03] PRAYER IS HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU FROM KEEPER. SO THIS GOT US A GENERAL ONES IN WHOEVER WANTS TO ANSWER THEM CAN YOU SORT OF JUST LAY OUT THE CONNECTION BETWEEN THE TWO DEVELOPMENTS AND ALSO I DON'T KNOW IF YOU'RE WELL VERY VERSED IN THE OPTIONS BUT SORT OF THAT HAS BEEN MORE THAN ONE PROPOSAL BEEN PUT OUT THERE ABOUT INTEGRATING MORE UNITS BETWEEN THE TWO SITES IN TERMS OF AFFORDABILITY AND THERE'S OBVIOUSLY SOME TRADE OFFS THERE. I THINK JUST SORT OF LAYING THAT OUT THERE AND KIND OF HOW THE MATH WORKS BETWEEN THE TWO UNITS WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL AND WE ALL WANT TO KNOW THAT SHE CAN OCCUR FOR ANOTHER DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF HOUSING SO AS YOU MENTIONED IS A CONNECTION BETWEEN THIS SITE AND THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON THREE ELEVEN MAPLE TEN AS IT'S CURRENTLY PROPOSED WOULD REQUIRE ROUGHLY NINETEEN AFFORDABLE

[185:01] UNITS TO BE BUILT IF THEY WERE BUILT ON SITE IN A SIMILAR SIZE AND LAYOUT IN CONNECTION FOR OFFICE BECAUSE THERE ARE DIFFERENT SIZE UNITS THEY WOULD BE REQUIRED TO DO THIRTY FOUR UNITS FOR OFFICE IF THEY DID ALL OF THEIR AFFORDABLE HOUSING ON THE FRUIT OFF SITES I JUST LEARNED A FEW DAYS AGO ABOUT THE NEW PROPOSAL OF PUTTING IN EIGHT OF THEIR AFFORDABLE UNITS FOR THREE WITH THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON ON SITE SO I HAVEN'T HAD A CONVERSATION WITH THE APPLICANT ABOUT THAT'S SO THEY REQUIREMENT TO FOR OFFICE YOU KNOW WOULD BE LOWERED TO TWENTY TWO UNITS SOME OF THE IMPACTS ARE TRADE OFFS THAT I THINK YOU'RE YOU'RE ASKING ABOUT THINGS THAT WE HAVEN'T HAD A CHANCE TO DISCUSS WITH THE WITH

[186:02] THE APPLICANT. SO THIS WOULD REQUIRE THAT THESE UNITS BE OWNED AND MANAGED BY HOUSING AUTHORITY OR SIMILAR ORGANIZATION THAT THERE WOULD BE CHALLENGES IN DOING THAT AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON THEY WOULD AFTER EITHER HAVE TO BE DESIGNATED IN SOME WAY AS A HOUSING AUTHORITY ARE SIMILAR OR THEY WOULD HAVE TO GET A HOUSING AUTHORITY ARE SIMILAR TO ON AND ON AND MANAGE THEM IT'S IT WOULD BE A CHALLENGE FOR AB HP OR THISTLE TO MANAGE A PROPERTY AS SMALL AS A UNIT'S NOT SEEN IT CAN BE DONE BUT IT'S TYPICALLY THEY THEY LIKE TO MANAGE A LARGER INVENTORY AT ONE PARTICULAR SITE SO THAT WAS SIMPLY BE SOMETHING THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE WORKED THROUGH THE NIGHT K

[187:01] ASK A QUESTION THAT I'M TO BE DESIGNATED AS AFFORDABLE HOUSING MANAGER OR MANAGING ORGANIZATION WOULDN'T IT BE POSSIBLE THAT THE ORGANIZATIONS CAN OPERATE THE CARTERET CARE FOR SOVIET THREE LEFT AND COULD ALSO MANAGE THOSE UNITS AT THROUGH OFFS. NO I'M SORRY THE UNITS THAT MIGHT BE AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON SOME OTHER WORDS THE SITE OPERATOR AND MAPLETON COULD THEY MANAGE TO AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNIT AT MAPLETON. IF FAITH IF THEY FIT THE DEFINITION OF A HOUSING AUTHORITY OR SIMILAR WHEN YOU SAY OR SIMILAR. DO THEY HAVE TO BE NON PROFIT THAT THEY DON'T HAVE TO BE NON PROFIT. WE'VE DEFINED IT AS HAVING TYPICALLY AT LEAST FIVE YEARS OF EXPERIENCE IN MANAGING SIMILAR TYPES OF PROPERTIES IF IT'S A LIE TECH

[188:01] PROJECT WHICH IT PROBABLY WOULDN'T BE BUT NORMALLY IF IT'S A LIE TECH PROJECT WE WOULD WANT TO SEE EXPERIENCE IN MANAGING LIGHT UP PROJECTS AND SORT OF THE REGULATORY REGULATION OR REQUIREMENTS THAT COME WITH THAT GET IT AND JUST EXPLORING THIS CONCEPT A LITTLE FURTHER THIS ORGANIZATION IS WE KNOW THE APPLICANT ORGANIZATION MANAGES ACADEMY BRAVERY CARE FOR SODIUM. THIS WOULD PRESUMABLY BE EIGHT UNITS OF AFFORDABLE CONGREGATE CARE LOCATED AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON SO DO YOU THINK IT'S IN THE REALM OF POSSIBILITY THAT THE OPERATOR OF THREE ELEVEN SITE COULD MANAGE THOSE PROPERTIES I CERTAINLY WOULDN'T TAKE IT OFF THE TABLE. OK I NEED YOU. OK DID YOU AND HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT THEM AND SO THEY INDUCED RIGHT AND YOU NEED TO IF HE MAY PUT ENDED ALL OF THEIR AFFORDABLE HOUSING ON SITE THEY REQUIRE NINETEEN

[189:01] THAT'S CORRECT. YET IF THEY PUT HIM ALL OVER IT FOR HAAS THEY WOULD REQUIRE THIRTY FOUR THIRTY FOUR SO I MEAN IS SEARED JUST A SIMPLE FACTOR THERE HOW DO WE GET EIGHT UNITS IN TWENTY TWO UNITS AND JUST HAVING A PROBLEM ADDING THAT UP TO EITHER NINETEEN OR THIRTY FOUR RIGHT SO WE WILL LOOK AT. WE LOOK AT THE SIZES AND BETTER EMBRACE THAT SORT OF THING INTO A CAN DO SORT OF RATIO BETWEEN THE TWO PROJECTS SO WE WOULD LOOK AT THE END WE WILL LOOK AT ALL ALL THE SIZES IN THE COMPOSITE OF THE SIZE OF THREE ELEVEN WE WOULD DO THE SAME THING FOR US AND COME UP WITH A SORT OF EQUAL RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE TWO BUT THE MEANWHILE THIS FRUIT HERB SAUCE SO I GUESS THERE'S A LOT OF ONE BEDROOMS OR SOMETHING BUT WHEN THEY'RE ALSO BE SOME KIND OF A MIX OF

[190:03] TYPES OF UNITS IN THERE THE APPLICANT WOULD HAVE TO ANSWER THAT I DIDN'T ACTUALLY DO THE COMPLETE TO EMBARRASS MYSELF SO I WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO ANSWER THAT I'M I ARE SAYING IS THAT THEY ARE ALMOST ALL ONE VETERANS AT IT FOR HER OFFICE. OK OTHER ON THE HILL AND THEN ON THE NUMBERS PART. ONEIDA HAD ON THE NUMBERS PERCH YOU MENTION THAT YOU'VE JUST LEARNED ABOUT THE EIGHT ON SITE AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON WAS THE PROPOSAL PRIOR TO PUTTING EIGHT ON SITE WHERE THEY'RE MORE AT FOO HOUSE AND YES THE MANY ORIGINAL PROPOSAL WAS FOR ALL OF THE AFFORDABLE UNITS FROM THREE ELEVEN TO BE BUILT ON THE FRUIT OFF SITE WHICH ARE IN THIRTY FOUR. THAT'S CORRECT SO THAT WE HAVE THE TWENTY FIVE PLUS THIRTY FOUR. SO ESSENTIALLY WE ARE LOSING FOUR UNITS BUT YOU'VE CALCULATED THAT BY SIZE SOMEHOW RIGHT CORRECT. OK SAM

[191:05] SO I HOPE THIS DOESN'T CONFUSE THINGS MUCH BUT CAN WE LOOK AT THE EQUIVALENT TO WHAT IS A UNIT IN CONGREGATE CARE FOR SO BE IT DEFINES THEM AND MIKE THREE DIFFERENT WAYS RIGHT ONE OF THEM IS DETACHED WHICH I DON'T THINK WE HAVE MUCH OF YEAR ONE OF THEM IS LIKE FIVE BEDS WHICH SHARE A COMMON FACILITY OR ANY OF THESE LIKE THAT MULTIPLE AT THREE ELEVEN NOT THAT I DON'T BELIEVE SO. OK SO THEY'RE ALL THESE ARE ALL APART SELF CONTAINED UNITS CONTAINED UNIT THEY WOULD BE REQUIRED TO TO GET LIGHT ACT FUNDING TO SUPPORT FOR OFFICE AS WELL. I SEE AND SO WHEN WE LOOK AT DIFFERENCE BETWEEN HOW MANY UNITS WERE YET IN ONE SCENARIO AND HOW MANY IN ANOTHER. SOME OF THAT LOSS IS JUST THAT THE UNITS THAT ARE ELEVEN MAPLETON ARE POTENTIALLY BIGGER UNITS THEY'RE RIGHT AND SO IT'S IT

[192:01] MAY BE PERCEIVED AS LOSING A UNIT THAT THESE UNITS ARE DIFFERENT ONE NUMBER MIGHT BE SET TO HOUSE A COUPLE ARE MORE PEOPLE WERE THE OTHER COULD HAVE WIDER SO THAT THE IF IF I COULD MAKE IT A LITTLE MORE CONFUSING THE TREE SO IN THEIR FIRST PROPOSAL WHAT YOU ARE GETTING OUT OF THE TWO PROJECTS WAS ONE HUNDRED AFFORDABLE UNITS IN THEIR SECOND PROPOSAL YOU ACTUALLY MEAN. HUNTER NATE FARLEY UNITS. HOWEVER IT'S IN A PREVIOUS CONVERSATION WITH THE APPLICANT WE EXPECT THAT THEY WOULD BE COMING TO THE CITY FOR SOME FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO HELP SUPPORT SOME OF THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS ABOVE THAT REQUIREMENT FROM THREE ELEVEN AS WELL AS FOUR UNIT THE TWENTY FIVE PERCENT REQUIREMENTS FOR THE FOR OFF SITE SO AS THOSE RATIOS CHANGE COULD IMPACT THE AMOUNT OF FUNDING THAT

[193:00] THEY WOULD REQUEST FROM THE CITY BUT I CAN'T REALLY GO TOO FAR DOWN THAT PATH BECAUSE THEY HAVEN'T MADE AN APPLICATION FOR FUNDING THERE HAS BEEN NO PROCESS AROUND THAT GOT IT BUT WE DO YOU JUST SAY THERE THEY WEREN'T GOING TO APPLY IF IT WAS ONLY A HUNDRED BUT THEY ARE IF IT GOES OVER A HUNDRED IN BOTH CASES MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THEY WOULD BE A SIGN FOR FUNDING. I JUST HAVE A THOUGHT HERE WHICH IS THAT I COULD CONTROL IS TO TELL US WHAT THE RULES ARE RIGHT AND HOW WE RESPOND TO THEM. I'M ALSO INTERESTED IN THE APPLICANT'S RESPONSE ABOUT HOW THEY INTEND TO BEFORE BELIEVES THE PROPOSAL HAVE THE INTENT OF THEM RIGHT WHICH IS WITH HIS MORE AFRICAN QUESTIONS. YEAH AND I THINK IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT TO TO RECOGNIZE THAT THIS IS THE PURPOSE OF TONIGHT IS TO GET GENERAL FEEDBACK AND DIVING TOO FAR INTO THE REGULATORY REALM IS A LITTLE BIT DIFFICULT AT THIS EARLY STAGE WE CAN ANSWER QUESTIONS ABOUT THE GENERAL

[194:02] CONCEPTS THOUGH. OK SO THE SUB QUESTION HIS ERRANDS BUT IT LOOKS LIKE DIFFERENTLY EACH YEAR JUST ON WHAT THE BARE MINIMUM IS BUT WHEN WE HEAR FROM NAPKIN I THINK WE HEAR THAT THE APPLICANT WANTS TO PUT MORE THAN THE MINIMUM NUMBER OF UNITS WHETHER THEY DO SOME IN MAPLETON AND SOME A TRUE AFTER ALL THAT FOR US I THINK WE CAN HEAR MORE THAN THE MINIMUM SO I THINK WE SHOULD NOT GET TOO HUNG UP ON THE MINIMUM NUMBERS BECAUSE I THINK THAT EXCEED THE MINIMUM UNDER EITHER OPTION OK SO JUST ADD ONE MORE ITEM THAT YOU MAY WANT TO BE AWARE OF WITH THIS THESE TRADE OFFS AS WELL WHICH I'M HOPING THE APPLICANT WILL BE ABLE TO ANSWER IS THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON IS GOING TO BE PROVIDING A CERTAIN STANDARD OF SERVICES WHICH IS FAIRLY HIGH FROM WHAT I UNDERSTAND A DIFFERENT LEVEL OF SERVICES AT FOR OFFICE IN UNDERSTANDING HOW THOSE EIGHT UNITS WOULD RECEIVE OR NOT RECEIVE UNITS. I'M SORRY SERVICES WOULD BE SOMETHING WE WOULD BE CONCERNED ABOUT

[195:00] FROM AN AFFORDABILITY STANDPOINT WE CAN MANAGE THE RENT AND UTILITIES. WE CAN'T REALLY MANAGE TO HAVE NO MECHANISM FOR MANAGING THE COST OF SERVICES. SO THAT'S ANOTHER CONSIDERATION THAT WITCHES HAVE TO BE LOOKED AT WITH THE APPLICANT OK SO ON DISCUSS THEIR PROCESS WISE BECAUSE WE ENDED UP SPENDING A FAIR AMOUNT ON OUR CONSENT AGENDA WHICH IS FINE. WE'RE WAY OVER AND WE'RE ON TARGET TO HAVE A VERY VERY LONG EVENING SHOW THAT IN MIND LET US. I WOULD PROPOSE WE GET THE APPLE CAN APPEAR AND THEN WE FOCUS ON MOST IMPORTANT INPUT TO THEM AND IT'S TO BE DONE WITH WORK AND I HAVE ONE QUICK ADDITIONAL QUESTION. OK SO AND THEN YOU GO ON THEM ARE GOING TO HAVE DATA CAN COME UP. I AGREE AND WHEN THAT COMES UP I'D LIKE TO ALSO UNDERSTAND THE INTERCONNECTEDNESS LIKE IF WE SUBSTANTIALLY CHANGE

[196:00] THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON FOR WHATEVER REASON HOW THIS MIGHT BE AFFECTED IS IT THEN COME BACK TO US FOR CONCEPT REVIEW OR WHAT HOW IS THAT LINKED THAT MIGHT BE A QUESTION FOR STEPHEN MEANWHILE PARENTS GOT A QUESTION OR DID YOU RESPOND YES SO THERE WOULDN'T BE ANY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS THEY WOULDN'T BE COMPELLED TO COME BACK WITH ANOTHER COMP PLAN IF ANYTHING CHANGES TO MY QUESTIONS HAVE PUT IN PARKING IS PROPOSED ON THE FIRST FLOOR RIGHT THE AND THEN THERE'S THE COURTYARD IN THE MIDDLE OF HUNGER CARE BUILDINGS IS THE PODIUM PARKING PROPOSED TO BE WALLED OFF FROM THE COURTYARD WERE SCREENED OR WHAT'S THE CURRENT PROPOSAL MM IT'S ALLOWING CLEAR BUT THEY'RE SCREENING AND IF SO IT'S A LITTLE UNCLEAR HOW EXACTLY THIS OPERATION WHAT HAPPENED BUT RIGHT NOW THEY'RE SCREENING FOR POST THINK YOU'RE OKAY WITH THAT BUT WE HAVE THE APPLE HIM COME UP

[197:01] AND GOOD EVENING GARY BIRD I'M CO FOUNDER AND MANAGING PARTNER OF THE ACADEMY UP ON THE HILL INTERESTING HERE ALL THE CONVERSATION LOOKING TO LEARN A LOT MORE IN TERMS OF WHAT YOUR PREFERENCES ARE TONIGHT I'LL TRY TO BE VERY BRIEF TALK ABOUT THIS FOR A LONG TIME IN TERMS OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING HOW DID WE GET TO WHERE WE ARE RIGHT NOW IN THIS CONFUSED POSITION STARTED OFF OF COURSE LOOKING AT THE TRADITIONAL OPTIONS WHICH WOULD BE PROVIDING UNITS ON SITE AT MAPLES AND THREE ALONE MAY PUT AN ARM OR WRITING A CHECK FOR CASH IN LIEU WHEN THE FOR OFF SITE BECAME AVAILABLE TO US WE LOOKED AT IT AND SAW THAT WE COULD DO SOMETHING PRETTY EXTRAORDINARY WE SAW AS WAS MENTIONED BY KURT NINETEEN UNITS ON SITE AND WE COULD DO A HUNDRED AT THE OFFICE AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE NEED AS YOU KNOW PROBABLY BETTER TO ANYBODY NOR POPULATION SIXTY FIVE PLUS IN THE COUNTY IS GOING TO GROW FROM FORTY THOUSAND TO NINETY OR A HUNDRED THOUSAND OF THE NEXT

[198:00] TWENTY YEARS NEED FOR SENIOR HOUSING IS GREAT. YOU ALSO KNOW BETTER THAN ANYBODY THE NEED FOR FOUR WAS IN AND THE NEED FOR SENIOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING SO WE JUMP TO THAT OPPORTUNITY AND THOUGHT THAT'S A CHANCE TO REALLY DO SOMETHING SPECIAL IN OUR THOUGHTS ABOUT THAT HAVEN'T WAVERED HOWEVER I WILL SAY THAT WE HAVE GOTTEN SOME PUSHBACK SAYING WELL WAIT A MINUTE WHY DO TO THE AFFORDABLE UNITS OFF B A FROM OFFICE WHY CAN YOU HAVE SOME UP MAPLETON AND SO WE LOOKED AT THAT AND SAID WHAT CAN WE AND WE WENT BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD AND SAID YES WE CAN. WE CAN TAKE ROUGHLY HALF THE UNITS THAT WE WOULD BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE AND PUT THOSE IN MAPLETON AND THEN TAKE FLEW OFF TO PAINT WITH A BROAD BRUSH AND SAY OKAY MAKE FROM OFFICE HALF AFFORDABLE HALF MARKET RATE SITUATION THE NET IMPACT ON THAT IS YOU WIND UP WITH US THEY WERE FOR THE SAKE OF SIMPLICITY SAY NINE UNITS AT MAPLETON THAT ARE AFFORDABLE AND FIFTY UNITS AFTER HAWKS THEREFORE WILL SEE WIND UP WITH A TOTAL

[199:00] OF FIFTY NINE. IF INSTEAD YOU SAY NO THE NUMBERS ARE MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE LOCATION YOU COULD SAY OK ZERO AM ABLE TO NINE HUNDRED FOR OFFICE WERE BASICALLY INDIFFERENT I SEE BOTH SIDES OF THAT ARGUMENT. I UNDERSTAND WHY PEOPLE RESIST CREATING AFFORDABLE UNITS WITHIN A CAR REPAIR FACILITY PHRASE RECENTLY ADDED NINETY FIVE UNITS DID THE WHOLE THING OFF SITE IN TERMS OF THE LAND DONATION. IT'S COMPLICATED BUT IS IT DOABLE ABSOLUTELY DOABLE AND I CAN GET INTO MORE OF THAT WITH QUESTIONS IF YOU WANNA KNOW MORE ABOUT THE DETAILS ARE UM I'M ALSO INTERESTED AND YOUR POSITION IN TERMS OF OUR OUR DESIRE TO BE THE FIRST THAT I KNOW OVER TIME A COMMUNITY THAT BANS PERSONAL AUTOS LOT OF ISSUES THERE ARE BASICALLY WE'RE GOING TO HAVE A FLEET OF ELECTRIC CARS THAT RESIDENTS CAN CHECK OUT I'D RATHER SPEND TWO HUNDRED AND TWENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS ON FOR

[200:00] ELECTRIC CARS THAN THREE PARKING SPACES UNDERGROUND ARMOR OF A RESTAURANT THAT'S OPEN TO THE WILL PRIMARILY SERVE THE RESIDENTS THAT LIVE FOR OFFICE BUT WE'VE GOT AN EXCITING PARTNERSHIP OR NEGOTIATING WITH A CHANCE TO CREATE SOMETHING THERE THAT I THINK COULD BE REALLY DYNAMIC AND BENEFICIAL FOR THE CITY AND THEN FINALLY I WOULD JUST SAY THAT THE ABILITY TO COLLABORATE WITH THE ACADEMY ON THE HILL AND THE ACADEMY OF MAPLETON HILL GIVES FOR OFFICE AS UNAFFORDABLE RETIREMENT COMMUNITY WHETHER IT'S FIFTY PERCENT AFFORDABLE OR A HUNDRED PERCENT AFFORDABLE THE OPPORTUNITY TO DO A LOT OF THINGS THAT COULDN'T OTHERWISE TOO. WE'VE GOT COMMON TRANSPORTATION WE CAN SHARE NURSES GOT A CONCERT PROGRAM THAT'S TREMENDOUS. THERE CAN BE SHARED SAME WITH OUR SPEAKER SERIES ARE JUST LOTS OF SYNERGIES THERE IN TERMS OF THE REQUEST FOR MONEY FROM YOU FOR AFFORDABLE UNITS SO FAR OUR GOAL IS TO COME FORWARD AND DO THIS WITH NO MONEY FROM YOU IF WE ARE REALLY OFFERING SOMETHING SPECIAL. IT ISN'T AS SPECIAL FOR SAYING HEY WE'RE GIVING

[201:01] YOU THIS BUT BY THE WAY TO PAY X AMOUNT FOR. SO OUR HOPE IS TO ASK FOR NO MONEY FROM YOU. I WANT TO TURN OVER TO THE LACK OF CORPORATE STRUCTURE ABOUT THE ARCHITECTURAL JUST SAY ON THAT FRONT THAT I'M EXCITED WITH WHAT THEY CAME UP WITH BECAUSE I HAD TWO BASIC GOALS WHICH IS ONE. DON'T ALLOW IT TO LOOK LIKE A RETIREMENT COMMUNITY AND DON'T ALLOW IT TO LOOK LIKE AFFORDABLE HOUSING. I THINK THEY'RE GOING TO CHOP THINGS SCARY AS AFOREMENTIONED IT'S JUST IT'S INSIDE THE PRODUCT INSIDE THE CROSS WAS PLANTED JUST OUTSIDE OF THE BOULDER VALLEY REGIONAL CENTER SO IT DOES HAVE A FOR OFA ARE ON THE SITE THIS IS WHAT A MAC STYLE SITE WOULD LOOK LIKE OF COURSE WE'RE TRYING TO DO WE'RE TRYING TO MAKE SOMETHING THAT'S A GREAT PLACE TO LIVE SO WE START BY TAKING THE BOX AND CURVING INTO IN THE FIRST THING WE DO IS CREATE ET-CETERA LIGHT WELL. IT ALSO IS THE RECREATION AREA THAT CAN BE SECURED FOR THE SENIORS SO IT'S A SAFE PLACE TO TO BE AND ALSO CREATES THE RIGHT WITH WERE SIXTY FIVE OR SEVENTY FEET WIDE WHICH IS A REALLY GOOD SUSTAINABLE WITH

[202:02] BUILDINGS BECAUSE WE GET LIKE A LADY AND LET EVERYBODY HAVE WINDOWS. WE RODE THE SITE ON THE FRONT BECAUSE WE WANT TO MAKE A GREAT STREET FACE FIRST AS GARY SAID WE'RE NOT TRYING TO CREATE A PROJECT THAT SCREAMS SENIOR HOUSING OR AFFORDABLE HOUSING WERE TRYING TO MAKE A GREAT NEIGHBORHOOD PLACE AND A GOOD STREETSCAPE. SO THAT'S DROPPED TO TWO STORIES ON THE FRONT THAT'S WHAT WE CAN PUT THE SERVICES IN THE INTERFACE FOR THE PROJECT PARKING IS ALL TUCKED UNDERNEATH YOU CAN REALLY SEE IT VERY WELL ON THIS BECAUSE IT IS HIDDEN IT'S THE ORANGE UNDERNEATH THE BLUE BAR SO ALL OF THE PARKING IS HIDDEN BEHIND THAT FRONT PARTS NOT VISIBLE TO THE STREET AND TUCKED AWAY AND THEN AGAIN WE WANT TO ERODE AS MUCH LIGHT IN AIR INTO IT WHILE STILL KEEPING THAT CENTER RECREATION AREA SECURED INDEFENSIBLE. SO WE RODE THE CORNERS TO CREATE THAT SPACE AND SO YOU LOOK AT THE FINAL FOUR MINUTES VERY DIFFERENT ENOUGH FOR OFA ARE WERE ABOUT TWO AND HALF OBVIOUSLY IT'S CONCEPT PLAN WE'RE STILL KIND OF CHANGING THINGS BUT THAT CREATES OR THAT WE'RE TRYING TO GET FINER GRAIN SCALE WHICH IS REALLY NOT IN THE AREA WILL TALK ABOUT THAT MINUTE SO

[203:02] AGAIN JUST I'M GOING THROUGH THIS VERY BRIEFLY WE'RE HAPPY TO ANSWER QUESTIONS AS MUCH DETAILS LIKE THE BLUE BARS ARE THE FACE OF THE RESTAURANT AND THEY'RE JUST CLEAR UP SOMETHING REALLY QUICKLY THERE'S NO RETAIL PROPOSE AND THERE'S NO OFFICE HAS PROPOSED BE ON THE ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE FOR THE SPACE ALL THE SURVEY ALL THE SPACES ARE EITHER RESTAURANT OR A ADMIN OR SERVICE SPACES FOR THE RESIDENTS SO THAT RESTAURANT IS ON THE FIRST FOUR SHOWN HERE IN BLUE IN THE ENTRY IS UP ON THE NORTH SIDE. IT'S CHANGED A LITTLE BIT BUT THAT WAS THE ORIGINAL CONCEPT PLAN ON THE UPPER FLOORS THIS IS THE SECOND FOR THE PINK BECOMES A SERVICE PAYS FOR THE RESIDENTIAL UNITS MAY BE THAT YOGA OR CRAFTS OR ANY OF YOU KNOW COME SPEECHES OR SMALL CONCERT KIND OF PERSON THAT ARE KIND OF THING. THAT'S WHERE THAT HAPPENS THERE'S A SECOND STORY TO THE RESTAURANT THAT'S A MORE PRIVATE AREA FOR THE RESIDENTS WHEN THEY MAYBE DON'T WANT TO BE IN THE VIEW AND THEN THE ADMIN OFFICES IN BLUE ALL THE UNITS IT BEHIND IN THAT FUN PART IS THAT

[204:01] THE SECOND STORY SO WE END UP WITH THIS KIND OF SPACE AND AGAIN IS AS GARY KIND OF SAD WE WERE CHARGED WITH THIS WOULD BE AT HOME ON PEARL STREET DOWNTOWN ON BROADWAY IT'S NOT DESIGNED TO BE ANYTHING BUT A GREATER AND BUILDING. SO AGAIN CZ THIRTY THREE IS TRANSITIONING ITS STARTED WITH A PALLET ON. WE HAVE A LOT OF SERVICES ON THE STREET SHOULD BE AND COULD BE A GREAT STREETS OR TRYING TO HAVE THIS BUILDING MEET THAT ACTUALLY THIS CRITERIA FOR THIS ZONE IN THE LAND USE CODE THAT ENCOURAGES REALLY GREAT SPACES IN ST ST MAKING THE INSIDE IS OF GREAT CONCERN TO US ALSO BECAUSE THAT'S WHERE THE SENIORS CAN RECREATE SO WE'RE GOING TO KIND OF THE NTH DEGREE THEY'RE RIGHT SO YOUR QUESTION ABOUT WHETHER OTHER SCREEN SORT OF BE ON SCREENS PLANTINGS BENCHES THEIRS OVER HANGS. WE HAVE THIS BRIDGE THAT CONNECTS THE TWO BUILDINGS THE IDEA THAT THE CENTER OF THE BRIDGE IS A COMMUNITY SPACE THAT COULD BE USED FOR YOGA CAN USE FOR THINGS AND THE INTERACTION BETWEEN THE OUTSIDE IN THE INSIDE ESPECIALLY USEFUL DURING INCLEMENT WEATHER FOLKS THAT MAYBE DON'T WANT

[205:01] TO BE OUTSIDE SO THIS GIVES YOU A SENSE OF HOW WE'RE WORKING ON THE SCALE OF THE BUILDING IN THIS AREA AND AS CONTEMPLATED BY THE SUNRISE PLAN IN THE BOULDER VALLEY REGIONAL CENTER IS REALLY BIG FORMAT THINGS AND AS A COMMUNITY WE'VE TRIED TO KIND OF MOVE BEYOND THE SUPER BLOCK RAIN BUT PALETTE ON AND SAFEWAY OR KING SUPER GROCERY STORE AND THE BUILDINGS TO THE SOUTH AND AUTO PARTS STORE TO THE NORTH ARE BIG FORMAT BUILDINGS. SO DESPITE THE FACT THAT THAT'S WHAT'S CONTEMPLATED HERE WE'RE TRYING TO BREAK THAT DOWN CREATE SMALLER SCALE SMALLER SCALE TO STREET TRADER PRESSED INTO ACTION AS YOU MENTIONED THROUGH ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THE SITE ON OUR SITE WE CAN TALK ABOUT THAT IF YOU'D LIKE TO BUT THAT'S THAT'S ESSENTIALLY WHAT WE'VE DONE NOW I SHOULD SAY SINCE WE PRESENTED THIS IS THE CONCEPT PLAN WE PRESENTED A PLAIN BORED THERE HAS BEEN EXTREMELY CONSTRUCTIVE FEEDBACK WITH THE NEIGHBORS ON BOARD AND STAFF SINCE THAT POINT WE HAVE CONTINUED TO EVOLVE IT ESSENTIALLY FLIPPED THE WHOLE SITE TO CREATE MORE OPEN SPACE AND LESS VIEW BLOCKAGE

[206:01] ON THE CELL SO THE SITE OF THE FIRES WE'VE ALIGNED THE ROAD THE ENTRIES BETWEEN THE PALETTE ON THIS SITE FOR A LOT ON HOW THE ENTRY WORKS THAT WE DON'T HAVE STACIE WE CAN DO DELIVERIES ON OUR SITE WE'VE CREATED THIS PEDESTRIAN PATH ON THE SOUTH SO WE CAN GET INTO IT I HAVE A SLIDE. I DON'T WANT TO GET INTO THAT IF YOU DON'T WANT TO SEE IT BUT I JUST WANT TO THANK ALL THOSE PARTIES NEIGHBORS PLAYING BOARD AND STAFF FOR REALLY CONSTRUCTIVE FEEDBACK TO PRESSURE CONTINUES TO CHANGE BASED ON THE JUST WHEN THE QUESTION THAT FOUR OR FIVE STORY THING IS THAT THIS BUILDING. I MEAN IN THIS IS PART OF IT. YES SO THE THING YOU SEE ON THE FRONT WITH A SLOPED ROOF HIT THE STICK SO THAT'S THE RESTAURANT THE SECOND FLOOR MEZZANINE RESTAURANT FOR THE RESIDENTS AND MORE TRUST ON THE FIRST FOUR BEHIND AND WE HAVE A BETTER VERSION OF THIS NOW BEHIND IS THE RESIDENTIAL ENTRY AND THE UNITS AND THAT CONCEPT WHEN WE REALLY HAVEN'T DEVELOPED THAT BELIEVE VERY MUCH CAN SEE IT'S KIND OF AMORPHOUS SCANNED WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT ARCHITECTURE IS BUT WE'RE WORKING ON IT NOW SO IF YOU ENVISION ADDING MORE

[207:00] WINDOWS AND A NEW VERSION THE MORE RECENT VERSION HAD ITS VERY GLASSY ENTRY ALL THE WAY UP. CAN YOU SHOW US THE SLIDE AHEAD HERE I'LL SHOW YOU THE PLAN THROUGH IT I ANSWERED SOME QUESTIONS HERE. SO COUPLE THAT COMES FROM PLAYING BUT REALLY GOOD COMMENTS CAN GET MORE LIGHT AND SUN INTO THE CENTER AREA SO WE MOVED THE ERODED PORTIONS BOW TO THE SOUTH SO THE SUN MOVES THROUGH THE DAY WE GET MORE ENLIGHTENING AFTERNOON LIGHT. WE HAVE ERODED THE BUILDING SO THERE'S LESS BUILDING ON THE SOUTH SO THE SITE WHERE THERE'S MORE ATTRACTIVE YEARS FOR THE MAJORITY OF THE PALETTE ON. WE'VE LINED UP THE ENTRY SO THAT ENTRY NOW THAT WE HAVE ON THE DRIVE LINES UP DIRECTLY WITH THE PALETTE ON HER FOR CITY TRANSPORTATION STAFF AND THE NEIGHBORS THAT THERE WAS AN IMPORTANT THING THERE IS A TURNAROUND YOU COME INTO THE NEIGHBORS ACTUALLY POINTED OUT HEY YOU KNOW WHAT IF YOU HAVE GOD FORBID AN AMBULANCE HERE YOU KNOW PART TRYING TO SERVICE PEOPLE WHAT HAPPENS TO ALL THE CARS AND PEOPLE ARE SHOWING UP WITH

[208:00] HIS YEARS OF DELIVERY TRUCK SO WE HAVE DELIVERY SPACES WE HAVE STACKING FOR CARS WE HAVE A PLACE FOR AN AMBULANCE TO COME IN THERE'S ACTUALLY A TERM OR ELSE I CAN COME IN AND DO A FULL TERM WITHOUT BACKING UP ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THE SITE THAT IS BOTH A PEDESTRIAN PATH THAT COULD LEAD TO THE GROCERY STORE TO THE WEST AS WELL AS FIRE ACCESS ONLY EMERGENCY VEHICLES WOULD BE USED BY ANY OTHER VEHICLE SO THAT'S PROTECTED AND PRESERVED THERE'S NOT A CURB CUT EXCEPT FOR A FIRE TRUCK YOU CAN GET IN IF YOU'RE A WESTERN DISPOSAL OR SOMETHING WE HAVE STARTED CONVERSATIONS WITH THE NEIGHBOR TO THE WEST OF THE ORDER OF THE GROCERY STORE TO SEE IF IF YOU LOOK AT THE SITE ONCE YOU GET TO THAT WEST SIDE. IT'S A LOADING DOCK RIGHT SO THERE'S NOT A REAL SAFE PATH EVEN IF YOU GO THROUGH THE BANK. SO WE'RE WORKING WITH THAT OWNER AND INITIALLY THEY EXPRESS AN INTEREST IN TRYING TO AUGMENT THAT BECAUSE THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT THEY COULD BRING OVER. I THINK IT'S A SAFE PLACE TO WALK UP REAL QUICK HIGHLIGHTS SOME MORE BUT I KNOW THAT YOU HAVE OTHER

[209:01] THINGS IN YOUR MIND TO SOME DO HAVE AN OUT OF ISOLATION OF I DIDN'T BRING THAT JUST USE OF A SIMILAR BUILDING FORM BILLY THAT THE FRONT BUILDING IS EXACTLY THE SAME MIRROR IMAGE TO THE BACK WERE STILL WORKING ON. IT'S OKAY TO SHOW GOODNESS. THANKS BILL UM SO HAVE SEVERAL QUESTIONS FOR YOU. FIRST OF ALL THERE'S LIKE FIVE TYPES OF SERVICES THAT ARE BE REQUIRED TO PICK THREE OF THEM FOR IT THAT CONGREGATE CARE DO YOU KNOW YET WHAT THOSE THREE WILL BE GOING TO DO EITHER FOUR OR FIVE KERRY CAN SPEAK TO THAT IT WILL PROVIDE THE FOOD WILL OFFER HOUSEKEEPING LINENS ET-CETERA WILL BASICALLY OFFER EVERYTHING IT'S JUST THAT IT WILL NEED TO BE ALL OR PART IN THE SENSE THAT IT'S TOUGH ENOUGH TO MAKE THE REAL ESTATE PORTION OF THAT WORK FOR THE RIGHT SIDE AND THEN WHAT WILL DO IS OFFER ALL THE CART BUT WE CAN DO AGAIN AS OFFER SOME SYNERGIES WITH THE ACADEMY

[210:01] FOR EXAMPLE WE HAVE OUR OWN HOME HEALTHCARE AGENCY AND WE DON'T SERVE THE ENTIRE CITY WHICH IS SERVE OUR COMMUNITY AND WE WOULD DO THE SAME THING HERE SO PEOPLE CAN GET A FIFTEEN MINUTE THIRTY MINUTE FORTY FIVE MINUTE INCREMENT AS OPPOSED TO A TWO HOUR MINIMUM. THERE'S JUST THERE'S MANY DIFFERENT WAYS BUT WILL ATTEMPT OFFER EVERYTHING BY AL A CARTE YOU'RE SAYING THAT THE RESIDENTS WOULD GET TO PICK THEIR THREE OUT OF THE FIVE TWELVE. THEY'D ALL BE MADE AVAILABLE BUT YOU'D HAVE TO PAY FOR THEIR MEALS FOR EXAMPLE STATUS IS A SIMILAR CONCERN ELISA YOU'RE CONCERNED THAT YOUR XRAYS ABOUT HOA FEES WHICH IS REALLY GREAT CONCERN IF THESE FOLKS ARE THE SAME LEVEL OF SERVICE FOR EXAMPLE AT THREE ELEVEN MAPLETON IT WOULD BE VERY COST PROHIBITIVE SO IN ORDER TO CREATE AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THEY HAVE TO BE ABLE TO AVOID THE HOA FEES IN THIS CASE THE SERVICES FEES THAT THEY DON'T WANT TO PAY SO IT'S KIND OF AN UN BUNDLED KIND OF CONCEPT THAN DISAGREE WITH. OK WHICH LEADS TO MY NEXT QUESTION THE OCCASSIONAL THAT THE HOUSING IS

[211:01] AFFORDABLE FOR THE SERVICE IS AFFORDABLE. WHAT'S THE DEAL YOU KNOW IT BUT YEAH I THINK THE SERVICES HAVE TO BE AFFORDABLE TO PAY FOR IT RIGHT. I GOT THAT PART OF IT PUT ME ON HIS OWN WHAT MECHANISM PROTECTS THE AFFORDABILITY OF SERVICES I ASK THAT IN IGNORANCE ACTUALLY THE FACT THAT THEY ARE UN BUNDLED REQUIRES THAT THEY BE AFFORDABLE IF YOU BUNDLE THE SERVICES OF A CAPTURED AUDIENCE THAT HAS NO CHOICE THEY HAVE TO EAT THERE THE PARTY PAID FORM AFTER UN BUNDLED WE HAVE TO MAKE IT WORTH THEIR WHILE MAKE IT WORTH A DOLLAR AND FEEL THAT THEY'RE GETTING A GOOD VALUE BUT OKAY BUT I THINK I DID INDEED STEAL FROM EACH TIME I WAS JUST THAT. OK SO I JUST WANNA FOLLOW UP THOUGH BUT IN ORDER TO HAVE THAT PACKAGE OF SERVICES THEY AND YOU HAVE TO HAVE IT IN NOAA FUNDED. I MEAN IF NOBODY'S TAKING THOSE SERVICES BECAUSE HER TOO

[212:01] EXPENSIVE THEN YOU CAN KEEP THOSE SERVICES SAY OR WRITE THE FEWER PEOPLE TO TAKE ON THE MORE EXPENSIVE THAN RE I MEAN IF THEY'RE REALLY YOU KNOW IT IS THIS HOA THING YOU KNOW AND AND IN HOA FEES FROM MANY TIME PEOPLE AREN'T ANTICIPATING OFF OF CONTROL BECAUSE FORGETTING THE SAME SERVICES AS EVERYBODY ELSE SO MY QUESTION IS YOU KNOW IF YOU'VE BEEN TO PROVIDE THREE YEAR FOUR OR FIVE OF THE FIVE REQUIRED SERVICES THEN HOW DO YOU MAKE SURE THAT THOSE SERVICES ARE ARE TAKEN SO THAT PEOPLE SO THAT THEY HIRE SERVICES OR PROVIDE WELL WHICH WAS HOUSEKEEPING FOR EXAMPLE THERE ARE PEOPLE THOUGH SAY I DON'T PAY FOR ALL PEOPLE WHO CLEAN MY OWN APARTMENT AND I THINK THAT'S FINE AND THE THING THAT WE HAVE THE ADVANTAGE OF HAVING OTHER COMMUNITIES IS WE'VE GOT A TEAM OF HOUSEKEEPERS AND SO IF THE DEMAND FOR THAT SERVICE INCREASES WHICH A

[213:02] SHIP SOME OF OUR PERSONAL DAY SO ALL THREE OF THESE WOULD BE KIND OF CONNECTED OR WAS JUST OKAY. YES AND THAT OFFERS THEM SOME SOCIALIZATION OPPORTUNITIES THAT WOULD OTHERWISE EXIST FOR EXAMPLE A COMMENSURATE CONCERT PROGRAMS HEARD LECTURES ET-CETERA NO REASON WE OPEN UP TO OUR NEIGHBORS AND WILL HAVE A WONDERFUL CONCERT. THAT SHOULD HAVE TWO HUNDRED PEOPLE THERE AND WHY FIFTY. IT'S IT'S A CRIME AND TO BE ABLE TO TAKE OUR VAN AND BRING A DOZEN PEOPLE FROM FROM OFFICE A DOZEN PEOPLE FROM MAPLETON UP TO THE ACADEMY ON THE HILL TO HEAR THE MUSIC I THINK IS A GREAT THING PREMIER OK SO JUST A KIND OF FOLLOW ON IN MY OWN QUESTION. SO CONGREGATE CARE REQUIRES THAT THREE OF THE FIVE SERVICES BE REQUIRED SOME JUST WONDERING IF MAYBE THE QUESTION FOR STAFF HERE SOMEBODY DOESN'T TAKE ANY OF THE SERVICES THEN IT STUCK UNDER HER CARE. IT IS THE SERVICES JUST NEED TO

[214:00] BE PROVIDED AND AVAILABLE PEOPLE DON'T HAVE TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF. OKAY GREAT THANK YOU AND I WOULD ALSO JUST ADD QUICKLY THAT THERE ARE A LOT OF RETURN TO COMMUNITIES THAT MAKE THINGS ALL ARE A LOT OF SNOW AND IT'S UNDERSTANDABLE IF IT'S IF IT'S FOR THE PURPOSE OF AFFORDABILITY YOU YOU DETACH THAT FROM THE HOUSING IN ORDER TO LOWER THAT THE HOUSING COSTS SO THE PARKING DURING THE PRESENTATION SLOAN MENTIONED THAT IN THE PARKING THE SEVENTY FOUR SPACES ARE FOR RESIDENTS WORKERS AND AND SERVICES SO I THE ONE IT UNDERSTAND MORE ABOUT THE PARKING FOR RESIDENTS AND IS THAT UN BUNDLED AS WELL THAT IS ON BUNDLED IN FACT IT'S SO UN BUNDLE THAT WE'RE GOING TO PROHIBIT RESIDENTS FROM HAVING THEIR OWN CARS OK SO THAT LEADS TO MY NEXT QUESTION WHICH IS IF YOU'RE GOING TO PROHIBIT RESIDENTS ARE GOING TO HAVE THE FLEET OF CARS THAT YOU MENTIONED

[215:01] WILL YOU ALSO MAKE AVAILABLE SOME SORT OF PARA TRANSIT FOR THOSE WHO MAY NOT BE ABLE TO DRIVE. ABSOLUTELY WE ARE THE DRIVING PROGRAM ALREADY ANOTHER AND ANOTHER GOOD SYNERGY WITH THE OTHER COMMUNITIES IN THAT IT'S TOUGH TO HAVE A NICE FAN FOR A RETIREMENT COMMUNITY WITH THE LIFT AND EVERYTHING ELSE BUT WE ALREADY HAVE TWO THREE OR FOUR THAT POINT THERE'S NO HARM IN SHARING AND SO IF A RESIDENT WANTS TO GET TO SAVE FROM THIS SITE TO KAISER OUT IN LAFAYETTE YOUR BAND WILL TAKE THEM FOR FREE GREAT AND THEN I HAD A QUESTION ABOUT THE NUMBER OF CURB CUTS AND IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU'VE REDUCED ME THIS IS A BILL QUESTION YOU'VE RIOS THEM. IT WAS A GOOD COVER BY STAFFORD ON THE ONES THAT WE DO HAVE AN EMERGENCY RULE OVER CURB THAT ISN'T REALLY COUNTED AS A CURB CUT BECAUSE IT'S ONLY IN THE CASE OF EMERGENCY BUT WE HAVE ONE CURB CUT IS COMING INTO THAT TURN AROUND RIGHT

[216:00] THERE AND IT'S DIRECTLY ACROSS THE PALATE ON DRY GREAT THANK YOU AND THEN WITH RESPECT YOU. AGAIN KIND OF GOING BACK TO PARKING AND UM AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING TYPES ONE OF USES OF THE PARKING IS GOING TO BE THE SERVICES AND YOU MENTION THAT YOU ARE GOING TO BE PARTNERING WITH BRIDGE HOUSE TO RUN THE RESTAURANT AND DO PROVIDE JOBS FOR READY TO WORK. I'M WONDERING IF YOU HAD CONSIDERED AT ALL PROVIDING UM I GUESS IT WOULD BE TRANSITIONAL HOUSING SIMILAR TO WHAT'S AT FORTY FIFTH FOR THE SECOND AND TABLE MESA THAT BRIDGE HAS ALREADY HAS HOUSING PEOPLE THERE IT IS AN ALLOWED USE IN THIS ZONE AND SO I WAS JUST WONDERING IF YOU CONSIDER DEBT AND IF YOU HADN'T WOULD YOU BE OPEN TO IT BECAUSE IT WOULD FURTHER REDUCE THE NEED FOR PARKING AND BELIVE WORK YES BE A NICE COMMUTE WHEN

[217:01] WE'RE NOT WE HAVEN'T RULED IT OUT RIGHT NOW WE'RE NOT LEANING THAT DIRECTION OF MY PARTNERS ARE DOING THE ROB'S MUSIC TRANSACTION ON THIRTIETH STREET AND THEY'RE DEFINITELY LOOKING AT TRYING TO TIE THAT TOGETHER AND SO WE MAY BE AGAIN MAKING SOME LOOPS WITH BANDS EVERYTHING AMONGST THE VARIOUS COMMUNITIES FOR TRANSPORTATION BUT IT'S A LITTLE BIT TRICKIER IN THAT WE HAVE A VULNERABLE POPULATION IN TERMS OF THOSE IN THE EIGHTIES NINETIES AND WE HAVEN'T RULED OUT. WE TALKED AS WELL ABOUT IT WE TOURED THEIR FACILITY AT FOUR SEVEN FOR SEVEN TO TELL MYSELF YES IT'S EXTREMELY INTERESTING WHAT THEY'RE DOING I THINK IT'S GREAT. OK GREAT AND THEN ANOTHER THOUGHT THAT THAT UM ARE TO ME IN TERMS OF THE USES THAT COULD BE BROUGHT THERE PERHAPS AS PART OF THE HOME THE FIRST FLOOR SECOND FLOOR KIND OF FRONT PART OF

[218:00] THE BUILDING IS ONE OF THE THAT SINGS AT THE CITY HAS A REAL SHORTAGE OF IS IS DAYCARE AND SO A DAYCARE FACILITY THAT WOULD ALSO KIND OF MAKE USE OF THE RESIDENTS WHO MIGHT WANT TO STILL BE YOUNG ENOUGH TO WANT TO HAVE THAT SORT OF JOB. SO AGAIN ANOTHER SORT OF LIVE WORK SITUATION WHERE YOU WOULD HAVE DAYCARE ON SITE AS WELL AND IT COULD SERVE A LOT OF FOLKS THAT ARE NEARBY AND THE VARIOUS BUSINESSES AND COMMERCIAL WE ARE ALL ABOUT EXPLORING THE INTERGENERATIONAL CONNECTIVITY OPTIONS AND THAT WOULD BE ONE. UM THERE'S SOME GREAT STORIES ABOUT THAT ONE OF THE CHALLENGES THOUGH IS THAT CONNECTION. WELL IT'S LIKE BEING A GRANDPARENT OR GREAT GRANDCHILD FOR AWHILE AFTER LAST WEEK AKA KNEW EXACTLY WERE UP AND THE POLICE LOOKING AT IT OKAY GREAT THANK YOU. JUST ONE THING I SHOULD ADD TO THAT ONE OF THE THINGS WE HEARD LOUD AND CLEAR FROM THE NEIGHBORS IS THAT THEY WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE MANAGING TRAFFIC. SO ONE OF

[219:00] THE ORIGINAL CONCERNS WITH THE FIRST PROPOSAL IS THAT IT LOOKED LIKE WE WERE PROPOSING RETAIL AND OFFICE JUST BECAUSE OF THE WAY WE LABELED THE INSIDE SPACES AND WE'RE NOT AND I THINK THAT WAS A RELIEF TO THE NEIGHBORS BECAUSE IT LOWERS THE PARKING LOT I WOULD BE A LITTLE CONCERNED WITH THE DAYCARE AND HOW THE NEIGHBORS WOULD FEEL ABOUT LET'S BE HONEST BOTH EVERYBODY DRIVES A KID TO DAYCARE DROP THEM OFF AND PICK SOME UP SO THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF A RUSH HOUR THAT MIGHT CLOG UP THAT STREET MORE THAN THEY WOULD LIKE TO SEE THEIR CONSIDERATION THANK YOU AND THEN WITH RESPECT TO THE COURTYARDS OF THIS BE A QUESTION FOR BILL. SO THE COURTYARD THAT IS ABOVE THE PODIUM PARKING SO THE COURTYARD SITS IN A FULL SIZE CLICK THE COURTYARD IS AT THE SAME LEVEL AS THE PARKING IT IS SEPARATED OH BOY BECAUSE I CAN'T GO BACKWARDS OR GO. MICHAEL THANKS SO THE PARKING IS BEHIND THAT SCREEN PLAN TEEN ON EACH SIDE. OK GOT IT SO THERE'S AN ALTERNATIVE HERE

[220:00] WE TALKED ABOUT BEFORE WE'RE NOT GOING TO HAVE RESIDENTIAL PARKING PARKING FOR RESIDENTS OF THE PARK IS TO SERVICE OUTSIDE PEOPLE ARE COMING TO A RESTAURANT SERVICE WORKERS THE CAR FLEET AND GUESTS BUT OVER TIME SENIOR POPULATION SHOULD BE ONE OF THE FIRST POPULATION THAT GETS MORE SERVED BY SELF DRIVING CARS SO AS WE CAN REDUCE THE NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES IN THIS WE COULD REPURPOSE THAT IN A RING OF PARKING AS MORE OPEN SPACE BECAUSE AT THE SAME LEVEL. SO ONE OF THE THINGS WE COULD DO IS CREATE SHADED OPEN SPACE OR SHIELD OPEN SPACE OR OR UM YOU KNOW GOING TO THE FIRST OF ALL PARKING FOR PLACES FOR PEOPLE HANG OUT SO THERE'S KIND OF IT'S ENERGY AND HOW IS BEING DESIGNED. OK GREAT I WAS UNDER THE IMPRESSION FROM LOOKING AT THE UM THE PACKET WAS THAT IT WAS ON UP ABOVE THE PODIUM PARKING SO I WAS MISTAKEN. ALSO THE REST ARE THIS WAY USES THE SAME LEVEL THAT THE RESTAURANT IS DESIGNED TO BE VERY TRANSPARENT YOU CAN SEE THROUGH STILL PROTECTED AND THE INSIDE THE RESTAURANT HAS

[221:00] OUTDOOR SEATING AT THE SAME LEVELS THE OPEN SPACE TO THINK YOU KNOW WE DO ON YOUR LIST. I'M THAN EVER BEFORE OK GO FAST. OK GO FEST OK SO TALKING ABOUT USES I THINK ONE THING A LOT OF SENIORS THING TO DO IS GARDENING AND I WONDER IF YOU'VE MADE ANY THOUGHTS WITH RESPECT TO GARDENING AND IT'S GREAT IT'S JUST A WONDERFUL THING TO DO FOR ANYBODY THAT WE'VE BEEN TALKING TO P C S ABOUT PEACE IS A LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT THERE'S VERY GOOD AND WE'VE REALLY ENJOYED WORKING WITH THEM SO WE'VE BEEN TALKING TO THEM ABOUT THAT AND I THINK THAT WE HAVE A CONVERSATION SCHEDULE WITH GARY TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND HOW MUCH DOES IT HAVE TO BE RAISED BEDS WE DON'T QUITE KNOW HOW TO MAKE IT WORK BUT IT IS ON OUR LIVES SHOULD BE ONE OF THOSE ACTIVITIES. THEN I HAVE SOME QUESTIONS ABOUT FLOODING. AND I UNDERSTAND YOU'RE NOT YOU'RE IN THE FIVE HUNDRED YEAR FLOOD PLAIN BUT NICE OUTSIDE THAT ONE HUNDRED AND NINETY IS ONE OF THE REASONS

[222:01] YOU HAVE THIS IT'S A SPARKLING CALLED HIM A PODIUM TO PODIUM TO PODIUM PARKING IS THAT NONE OF YOUR BUILDINGS IN THE FLOODPLAIN SO YOU CAN TO HAVE TO THINK AT SOME POINT I READ THE MEMO CORRECTLY YOU CAN HAVE TO GET A FLOOD PLAIN PERMIT IS SET CORRECTLY AND SO ALTERED REALLY BRIEF. WE'RE OUT WE'RE IN THE CITY WERE ALSO THE HUNDRED YEAR SO IN THEORY IS ALSO THE HUNDRED YEAR AREN'T REGULATED WE DON'T HAVE TO CHANGE THE WAY WE'VE DESIGNED THEM SO THE PODIUM PARKING WAS REALLY NOT DESIGNED TO GET OUT OF THE FLOOD PLAIN BUT IT DOES HAVE A NICE EFFECT OF TAKING ALL OF THE UNITS OUT. NOW WE ARE A CRITICAL CARE FOR A STRIKING THAT SO ANYTHING IS CRITICAL CRITICAL FACILITIES REGULATED IN THE FIVE HUNDRED YEARS AND WE'RE ACTUALLY WORKING WITH STAFF TO UNDERSTAND EXACTLY HOW THAT WOULD WORK UNITS BEING OUT OF THE FIVE HUNDRED YEAR IS HELPFUL BUT ONE OF THE MAIN REQUIREMENTS IS THAT THERE IS A EMERGENCY PLAN SO WHAT HAPPENED EXACTLY HOW DO WE DEAL WITH IT HOW WE CAN

[223:01] SERVICES TO THE RIGHT AND YET I WAS WONDERING IF YOU HAD AN EAGERNESS PLAN IN CASE OF FLOOD WE WILL HAVE TO HAVE ONE AND WE'RE WORKING WITH STAFF ACTUALLY WE HAD A CONVERSATION ABOUT THAT TODAY SO IT'LL TAKE A LITTLE WHILE TO WORK THROUGH IT BUT WE'RE WORKING THROUGH TWO DIDN'T WANT TO FOLLOW UP ON THAT REAL QUICK. ISN'T ONE OF THE FIRST ORDER THINGS YOU DO AS AN OPTION SHELTER IN PLACE FOR FLOODING LIKE FOR SOME PERIOD OF TIME. YEAH THAT'S ONE OF THE REASONS WAS THAT THE RESULTS ARE OUT OF THE TOP OF THAT MAY BE THE FIRST PART OF A PLAN THAT WOULD BE LYING IF I SAID IT WAS A FULL EXPERT ON FLOOD EMERGENCY RESPONSE PLANS BUT THAT IS YOU KNOW WE CAN CERTAINLY DO THAT HERE YES AND I WOULD LIKE TO JUST FOLLOW UP ON THAT TOO IF I RECALL CORRECTLY IN THE CRITICAL FACILITIES ORDINANCE THERE IS FLOOD PROOFING REQUIRED AND IS IT NOT REQUIRED IN THIS CASE BECAUSE THE UNITS ARE ABOVE THE PODIUM THAT'S ACTUALLY ONE OF THE QUESTIONS WE HAD FOR STAFF THAT WE'RE WORKING THROUGH SO WE HAVE TO

[224:02] UNDERSTAND TO WHAT EXTENT THE RESTAURANT WILL BE CONSIDERED PART OF THE FACILITY AND THEREFORE PROVED WE WE THINK IT WOULDN'T BE BUT WE NEED TO VERIFY ALL THAT. OKAY GREAT THANK YOU IN THEN JUST JUST A COMMENT ABOUT THE DESIGN AND YOU KNOW I LIKE YOU SAYING SPILL BUT I GUESS YOU KNOW ONE OF THE THINGS I AM A LITTLE BIT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT IN TERMS OF IF YOU CAN YOU GO BACK TO THAT KIND OF THE AREA IS THERE'S A WHOLE LOT OF FLAT ROOFS THAT ARE ALL HE THE SAME HEIGHT AND ONE OF THE THINGS AND I LOOK AT THEM ARE CHANTED VILLAGER BOULDER JUNCTION ONE OF THE THINGS THAT MAKES IT JUST UGLY. IS THERE IS NO VARIATION IN IN THE HEIGHTS AND EVERYTHING'S FLATTEN EVERYTHING IS LIKE BEEN MAXIMIZED FOR SQUARE FOOTAGE IN SO IT'S REAL BOXY AND IT ALMOST LIKE AMSTERDAM OR IMEEM MADRID OR ANY OUTSIDER

[225:03] THE MAIN CITY IN EUROPE KIND OF COMMUNIST TYPE IN STRESSING AMSTERDAM YET WELL THIS IS REALLY PRETTY HERE YOU HAVE THESE BEAUTIFUL CITIES AND THEN YOU HAVE THIS RING OF OUTSIDE CONCRETE UGLY BUILDINGS THAT PEOPLE ARE FORCED TO LIVE AND SO I GUESS YOU KNOW YOUR ARCHITECT YOU NOW AND OUR SPACES SHAPE WHO WE ARE AND JUST SEEING THOSE JUST FIVE STORY ALL THE SAME HEIGHT. I GUESS IN THIS IS A CON TO PLAN AND I'M TRYING TO BE CONSTRUCTIVE BUT IT WOULD BE NICE TO SEE SOME VARIATIONS IN I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU DO THOSE VARIATIONS BUT I GUESS I WOULD LIKE SOMETHING TO COME BACK TO THAT WOULD ALLOW SOME VARIATIONS IN I WOULD THINK ALSO ONE OF THE THINGS YOU DON'T HAVE UP THERE AND AGAIN IT'S FIFTY FIVE FEET IN SOME BUT I'M WONDERING IF YOU MIGHT NOT BE ABLE TO DO A

[226:00] GARDEN ON THE ROOF OF ONE OF YOUR BUILDINGS AND GIVE PEOPLE A SPECTACULAR VIEW. SO AND YOU'D BE USING THAT STUPID THROUGH SPACE FOR SOMETHING THAT WOULD BE PRODUCTIVE. SO FIRST OF ALL GREAT COMMENTS AND APPRECIATED THE FALLEN ON DEAF EARS SO CON SUPPLANT THE BACK PART IS NOT AS FAR ALONG AS THE FUN PARTS OF THE FUN PART YOU CAN SEE THAT WE DROPPED IT WAS TRYING TO DO. RUFUS NOT FLAT SO I'M WITH YOU MUCH APPRECIATE TRULY ON THE BACK. HONESTLY WE HAVEN'T REALLY DONE THE MATH TO CALCULATE THE SESSION EXACTLY FIGURE OUT HOW MUCH ROOM WE HAVE TO PLAY WITH AND SO WHAT I CAN SAY IS YOU KNOW I AGREE WITH YOUR COMMENTS. THE GOOD COMMENTS BUT WHEN WE MOVE THIS FORWARD LET US LOOK AT AND SEE WHAT WE CAN DO IN TERMS OF VARIANCE. OK AND COULD BE COULD BE MAKING SOME ADDITIONAL GREAT PIECES COULD BE. THAT'S RIGHT SO I'M GOING TO PAUSE HERE APPRECIATE ANSWERS NONE BUT I WANT TO SEE WHAT THE HEARING AND

[227:03] THE SLOT RIGHT INTO COMES KATE WE ARE OPENING AND CLOSING THE HEARING ON THE STAND. OKAY SAMMY ARE UP AND I GUESS I WOULD ENCOURAGE US TO WAIT FOR IT QUICKLY. I THINK WE HAVE BEEN DOING AS AS WE'VE BEEN GOING. SAM TAKE IT AWAY SO I JUST WANTED TO RETURN TO THE DISTRIBUTION OF UNITS ON THREE ELEVEN VERSUS WHAT MIGHT HAPPEN HERE BECAUSE I THINK WE RAISED IT BUT WE HAVEN'T HEARD FROM YOU GUYS YET. YES I'M SORRY COULD YOU REPEAT SERVICE SO WE SAW ON THE MOTIVATOR FOR SLIDES THAT THERE IS POSSIBILITY OF EIGHT AFFORDABLE UNITS LOCATED AT THREE ELEVEN WHICH WOULD REDUCE SOMEWHAT THE AMOUNT THAT YOU WOULD HAVE TO SEND TO THIS SITE SO WHEN KURT SAID THIS MYSTERIOUSLY COOL THING THAT THERE COULD BE HUNDRED AND EIGHT UNITS AS A RESULT OF ALL OF THAT AT THE FRUIT OFF SITES I THOUGHT I'D LET YOU HOLD FORTH ON WHAT YOU IMAGINE TO DO A SMALL NUMBER

[228:01] OF AFFORDABLE UNITS AFTER ELEVEN. WOULD YOU BE WILLING TO MANAGE THOSE AND WHAT WOULD THE IMPACT BE ON THAT FOR US. I THINK WE NEED TO MANAGE THEM IF WE DO EIGHT OR WHATEVER THE NUMBER IS UNABLE TO AND I THINK IT MAKES SENSE I WOULD ENVISION THOSE BEING SPREAD AMONG WHAT WE KNOW IS BUILDING IN BUILDING B WE'VE ACTUALLY LOOKED AT SPECIFIC UNITS AND FOUND SOME THAT WE THINK WOULD BE WORKABLE FOR US. I SAW THREE ELEVEN THREE ELEVEN I DON'T THINK IT MAKES SENSE TO SAY IT'S THE FIRST FLOOR THE FIRST EIGHT UNITS I THINK IT MAKES MORE SENSE TO MIX THEM UP WITHIN THE COMMUNITY LIKE I SAY THERE ARE ISSUES THERE SOMEWHAT NUANCED BUT I ALSO THINK THAT IF THAT'S WHAT THE CITY COUNCIL WANTS ON THINK WE CAN MAKE IT WORK GREAT AND WHAT WE WOULD THERE BE AN NEGATIVE IMPACT ON AFFORDABILITY AT FOR US. I SEE THEM PERSONALLY KNOW I'VE GOT A LOT OF PARTNERS OF ALL FORMER BOULDER RIGHTS AND MANY OF WHOM ARE HERE IN BUT I PERSONALLY SEE IT AS MORE

[229:00] LEST A TRADE OFF WHEN WE LOOKED AT IT AND SAID WE COULD DO EIGHTEEN OR NINETEEN IN MAPLETON. OR WE DO A HUNDRED FOR OFFICE. I THEN LOOKED AT AND SAID WELL IF WE DID HALF OF THE EIGHTEEN OR NINETEEN SAY NINE EIGHT WAS IN THERE BUT SAY IT'S NINE BUT I WOULD SAY TAKE MAPLETON AND CUT THAT HALF YOU HAVE TO REALIZE THAT MELTON IN SAREE CUT FOR US AND HELP ME FOLLOW AT MATH SO IT WAS THIRTY FOUR FOR US TO BEGIN WITH ACCORDING TO KERR WRITES EGOS TO SEVENTEEN KNOW WHAT I WOULD DO IS I WOULD SAY EIGHT OR NINE AND MAKES A NINE AM ABLE TO AND I WOULD SAY WELL WE WERE DOING A HUNDRED AFFORDABLE FOR US NOW IN TWO FIFTY AFFORDABLE TO WIND UP WITH FIFTY NINE WEISER DRAMATIC WHY GO FROM ONE HUNDRED TO FIFTY NINE IS OR NOT SOME WAY AND MAYBE EVEN DOES HAVE MONEY FROM THE CITY'S AFFORDABLE HOUSING BUT IS OR NOT SOME WAY TO LOOK AT RATHER THAN ITS SO DRAMATIC OF A CUT BY HALF TO LOOK AT MAYBE TWO SEVENTY

[230:00] FIVE PERCENT AND MAYBE IF THE CITY HAS FUNDING TO HELP MAKE THAT WORK FINANCIALLY IS THERE ROOM FOR DISCUSSION AND BABA BROUGHT UP ANOTHER CREATIVE SOLUTION WHICH IS YOU KNOW THERE'S MIDDLE INCOME AFFORDABLE WHICH IS A REQUIREMENT WHICH I DON'T THINK YOU FALL UNDER PERHAPS BECAUSE OF THE TIMING FOR YOUR SITE PLAN SUBMISSION BUT ANOTHER WAY TO MAKE THE NUMBERS WORK FINANCIALLY MIGHT BE RATHER THAN PASS YOU DO SIXTY PERCENT AT SIXTY PERCENT AM I A SIXTY UNIT AND THEN ANOTHER SET OF UNITS AT A MIDDLE INCOME AFFORDABILITY TWO HUNDRED TWENTY PERCENT AM I AND SOME MARKET SO I JUST WANTED TO PUT OUT THERE THAT I THINK THE HASS IS PROBABLY GONNA REMOVE THE APPETITE FOR WHAT I THINK IS OTHERWISE A REALLY GOOD IDEA FOR PUTTING AFFORDABLE UNITS THREE ELEVEN I THINK THAT WILL HELP EVERYONE IN THE COMMUNITY FEEL BETTER ABOUT THAT PROJECT AS SOME AFFORDABILITY THERE BUT IF IT MEANS GIVING UP FIFTY UNITS AT FROU HAAS

[231:00] THAT'S REALLY PROBLEMATIC SO THIS IS A QUESTION THAT'S LED TO FEEDBACK BUT I WOULD LIKE THAT CONVERSATION TO CONTINUE AND INCLUDE THE CITY ABOUT THE CITY ROLE AND WHETHER CREATIVE WAYS TO LOOK AT THIS SO WE DON'T HAVE SUCH A NEGATIVE IMPACT FOR HAAS BUT WE STILL MAKE SURE THAT YOUR WHOLE ENOUGH THAT IT'S A GOOD PROJECT AND EVERYONE IS IS PLEASED WITH THE SERVICES OFFERED AND THE MIX OF UNITS YES I THINK THAT'S DOABLE COUPLE THOUGHTS FIRST OF ALL WHEN WE MET WITH HER EARLIER YOU KNOW HE WISELY POINTED OUT THAT IF WE ARE LOOKING TO THE CITY FOR MONEY WE NEED TO REALIZE THAT THIS ISN'T JUST A GIFT WERE AS I MENTIONED EARLIER WE'RE GIVING YOU SOMETHING BUT ASKING TO PAY FOR PART OF IT SO WE'VE TRIED TO KEEP THAT BRIGHT LINE WHERE WE'RE NOT ASKING FOR MONEY THE CITY SAYS NO WE WANT MORE UNITS BUT WILL PAY SOME MONEY FOR THOSE ADDITIONAL UNITS OF HER OFFICE. I THINK THAT'S WORKABLE. ANOTHER POSSIBILITY IS TO LOOK AT IT AND TAKE MY

[232:00] MATHEMATICAL EXAMPLE AND SAY INSTEAD OF THE NINE AFFORDABLE TAKE HALF THAT FOR NOW FOR FOUR OR FIVE AND GARY ARE SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT FOR OFFICE. K I NOT GOING TO TRY AND SOLVE IT HERE WITH FUTURE BUT I THINK THAT CONVERSATION IS A GREAT ONE TO CONTINUE BECAUSE A THING TO THE EXTENT THAT WE CAN MIX AT BOTH SITES IT'S GOING TO FEEL LIKE A GREAT PROJECT WHICH ALSO HAS THE SOCIAL JUSTICE SOCIAL CONSCIOUSNESS OF HAVING ECONOMIC DIVERSITY AND THE SITE SO I JUST FOR ME THAT DROP AND I HEARD ABOUT IT IN THE DISCUSSION WITH OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS. IT'S TOO MUCH WE DON'T WANT TO GIVE UP THAT MANY UNITS IN ORDER TO GET THAT MIX BUT WHAT WE COULD DO TO GET THE MIXES BE CREATIVE WITH NOT QUITE THAT DRACONIAN SO SEVERLY PAS HERE. MY SENSE IS THAT INTEGRATING BOTH SITES BUT HAVING LOTS OF AFFORDABILITY ARE TWO REALLY STRONGLY HELD VALUES IT TO

[233:01] PEOPLE KIND OF CURRY WAS WHAT SAM ST. YET NO TALE OF TWO CITIES BUT WITH WHITFIELD JILL HAS WHY I GUESS I'LL BE LOOKING PURSE ALL THIS IS EXCELLENT I THINK THIS IS OUTSTANDING AND MUCH NEEDED I'LL BE LOOKING AT MORE OF A QUANTITY OF HOW MANY AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS ARE GETTING OVERALL. SO IF IT IS FIFTEEN UNDER HUNDRED ARE HAVING EIGHT UNITS ON THREE ELEVEN IS NOT GOING TO BE OF VALUE TO ME I THINK IT'S A BIG DIFFERENCE IN THE NIGHT IF WE ARE GOING TO THEN COME BACK TO THE CITY AND SAY OK WE GET CREATIVE WITH THE PAD LIKE TO KNOW WHAT THE TRADE OFFS ARE SO HOW MUCH WOULD WE BE FINDING IN WHERE'S THAT COMING FROM AND HOW MUCH COULD IT BE CREATING ELSEWHERE AGAIN WITH THIS IDEA THAT TOTAL UNITS OUR WORLD WHAT ALL BE EVALUATING IT OKAY BUT I THINK BO'S INTEGRATION IN TOTAL UNITS ARE KIND OF BETRAYED US. OK SO I INTERRUPTED YOU SALMON YOU WANT AN HONOR TO SHARE MY

[234:02] THOUGHTS ARE QUICK BUT I THOUGHT IT WAS IMPORTANT TO RETURN TO THAT BECAUSE THAT'S YEAH THAT'S SUBSTANTIVE ISSUE I AM THE OTHER HAND I MIGHT SHOW WOULD BE WILLING TO SACRIFICE SOME SMALL NUMBER OF UNITS TO HAVE A SPECTRUM YOU KNOW AT THE SITE SO IF WE HAVE SOME THAT ARE ALSO A DEED RESTRICTED HUNDRED TWENTY PERCENT YOU KNOW THAT SOMETHING THAT WE'VE SAID IS A VALUE AS WELL BECAUSE THERE'S A HOLLERING OUT OF THE MIDDLE GOING ON AND SERVING JUST LOW AND JUST HIGH IS SOMETHING THAT WE'VE STRUGGLED WITH IN THE PAST SO I WANT TO SAY IS A FANTASTIC PROJECT AND I WANT TO THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR BEING WILLING TO LOOK AT ONE HUNDRED PERCENT AFFORDABLE FOR US BECAUSE SHE DIDN'T HAVE TO DO THAT ABOVE AND BEYOND. IT'S PROBABLY GOING TO BE EASIER TO MANAGE IF IT'S ALL KIND OF SIMILAR AND SO YOU HAVE THOSE DIFFERENT MANAGEMENT CHALLENGE WITH THE MIX BUT STILL THAT'S PIONEERING AND THAT WOULD BE SOMETHING THAT BECAUSE YOU HAVE THESE OTHER TWO FACILITIES INVOLVED YOU MAY HAVE SOME SCALE ADVANTAGES THAT OTHERS DON'T. SOMEONE SAY THANK YOU FOR THAT I WOULDN'T TALK ABOUT IT IS A

[235:02] CARB AND IT'S MORE OF AN AGREEMENT BY BETWEEN THE RESIDENTS AND OWNERS THAT THIS IS A BETTER WAY TO GO AND IT'S SOMETHING THAT PEOPLE ARE CHOOSING TO BUY INTO KNOWINGLY YOU KNOW AS THEY COME INTO IT BUT ALSO THINK IT'S FANTASTIC BECAUSE IT IS A WAY TO REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF PARKING AREA THAT WE NEED. IT'S LOOKING AHEAD TO BE ABLE TO REPURPOSE THAT PARKING IS SOMETHING ELSE IF THIS MAGICAL ABILITY FUTURE COMES TO BE AND IF NOT VENDOR SPACES FOR WHAT ARE NEEDED BUT A LOT LESS THAN YOU WOULD OTHERWISE NEED AT THAT FACILITY. CONGRESS DECLARES A BIG NEED YOU FIT THIS IN BOTH PLACES IN TWO DIFFERENT WAYS. THE OTHER THING I WANT TO COMPLIMENT YOU ON IS THAT I THINK THIS YEAR'S IS VERY GOOD FOR THE TRAFFIC PROBLEMS THERE IN THE SENSE THAT THERE ARE REAL TRAFFIC PROBLEMS THERE I'M ON THAT STRETCH OF ROAD FREQUENTLY AND YOU KNOW YOU GET BACKUPS THAT CAN WRAP AROUND SO BOTH THE USE AND WHAT YOU'VE DONE WITH THE CAR

[236:00] STACKING OFF ST. I THINK WILL SERVE YOU WELL IN THE LONG RUN SO I JUST WANTED TO SAY THUMBS UP WITH THAT AND AT THE END OF THE DAY I LOOK FORWARD TO WHERE WE'RE GOING WITH THIS AGREE WITH LISA'S COMMENTS CLEARLY STARTED LOOKING AT HOW YOU CAN HAVE SOME VARIANCE IN HEIGHT ON THE SITE AND SO I THINK THE RESTAURANT IS A GOOD START. I HAVE TO SAY THE ARTICULATE SIAN AT THE PALATINE IS NOT WHAT I'D BE LOOKING FOR FOR SOME KIND OF VARIATION I NOT SURE THAT THAT MAYBE IT'S NOT THE WAY WOULD BE DONE TODAY BUT I THINK THE GREEN ROOF IDEA AND I THINK SOME WAY TO GET SOME VARIATION AND THE BUILDING WOULD BE FANTASTIC SO THOSE ARE MY COMMENTS THINKER OF AGREE WITH JEN LEE WHAT SAM WAS SAYING GREAT JOB ON THE PROJECT AND IT LOOKS REALLY GOOD TO GREAT USE OF THE NEED FOR SENIOR HOUSING IS SO DESPERATE IN OUR SOCIETY RIGHT NOW IN OUR COMMUNITY AND GET A HUNDRED

[237:01] PERCENT HUNDRED UNITS OF AFFORDABLE SENIOR HOUSING IS JUST MAGNIFICENT. I THINK HE DID A GREAT JOB OF ADDRESSING STAFF PLANNING BOARD AND RESIDENT CONCERNS WITH YOUR RE SHUFFLING SO THANK YOU FOR DOING THAT A TESTAMENT TO THE SUCCESS OF A RE SHUFFLING IS THAT NOBODY IS HERE SPEAKING ABOUT HOW UNHAPPY THEY ARE WITH THIS PROJECT SO NICELY DONE THAT WAY PRESERVE SOME OF YOU QUARTER'S FROM SOME OF THE RESIDENTS OVER THERE I WAS LOOKING FOR THAT SIDEWALK CONNECTION ON THE SOUTH SIDE NEAR SOLUTION WITH THE EMERGENCY ACCESS LOOKS LIKE A GOOD ONE FOR SURE. I GREW THE COMMENTS ABOUT THE DESIRABILITY OF VARIED HEIGHTS BUT AS LONG AS WE STILL GET A HUNDRED UNITS OF AFFORDABLE SENIOR HOUSING RIGHT LIKE DON'T CHOP US TWENTY UNITS OFF IN ORDER TO GIVE US MORE REFINED THAT WOULD BE MUCH THOUGHT THAT IF WE CAN ACCOMMODATE WITHIN THE PROGRAM SOME VARIED HEIGHTS THAT WOULD BE WOULD BE GREAT THE ONE SUGGESTED WOULD HAVE IS COMING BACK TO THAT PARKING AT THE CRIME LEVEL BECAUSE I DO SEE IT AS HER CONCERN FOR THE LIVE ABILITY OF THAT COURTYARD. IF YOU HAVE THE CARS MOVING IN OUT AND FUMES AND NOISE AND THEN THE VISIBILITY OF THAT

[238:01] IT'S UNSIGHTLY SAID REALLY ENCOURAGE YOU TO DO MORE THAN JUST LANDSCAPING AND A KIND OF A SCREEN AND MAYBE SOME THREE QUARTER HIGH WALLS OR SMALL HIGH WALLS ARE IN ADDITION TO LANDSCAPING AND THINGS LIKE THAT I THINK BY ARE REALLY GIVING A BARRIER TO MUCH OF THAT PODIUM PARKING YOU'RE GOING TO REALLY INCREASE THE LIVE ABILITY THE COURTYARD AND I'LL JUST MAKE THE FINAL COMMENT ON THE AFFORDABILITY I DO SEE A VALUE TO INTEGRATING ON SITE AFFORDABLE ONE WE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY IT'S ALTHOUGH I LIVE IN THE HOLIDAY NEIGHBORHOOD WHICH SAYS THAT REALLY WELL TO VALUE MY BUT NOT AT THE EXPENSE OF LOSING A LOT OF UNITS COULD I COULD LOSE COUPLE HAVE TO GET THAT BUT BUT NOT CERTAINLY THE FIFTY AND NOT TWENTY THERE SO IF YOU AND BY THAT I MEAN UN SUBSIDIZED BEING ABLE TO GET A HUNDRED UNITS OF UN SUBSIDIZED AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS AMAZING COMMUNITY BENEFIT AND I WOULDN'T WANT TO LOSE THAT OK WITH MARY AND THEN

[239:02] IT'S ALREADY BEEN SAID MAYBE WE CAN LEAVE IT AT THAT. SO I WOULD AGREE WITH WHAT SAM HAS SAID AND MOST OF WHAT AARON SAID I WOULD WANT TO SEE WHAT WHAT YOU CAN DO WITH THE NUMBERS ON UM ON EITHER SITE. I THINK I THINK THAT IT'S AN IMPORTANT COMMUNITY VALUE TO HAVE INTEGRATED SOCIO ECONOMIC LEVELS AT DIFFERENT SITES SO I I WOULD I WOULD PREFER TO SEE SIGHTS AT MORE THAN THE SAT THROUGH ELEVEN MAPLETON AND THAT'S SOMETHING THAT THE COMMUNITY HAS BEEN ADAMANT AND ABOUT AND ASKING FOR SO UM I UM THERE WAS A COMMENT ABOUT THE FOUR STORY BUILDING THAT YOU COULD SEE AND THAT WHEN VIEW AND WHERE THERE WERE VERY FEW WINDOWS AND THEN BILL YOU SAID THAT IT WAS NOW VERY GLASSY AND NOT SO MUCH GLASS MAYBE MORE WINDOWS BUT

[240:00] NOT GLASSY BECAUSE GLASS IS KIND OF COLD AND VERY APPEALING AT THE STREET LEVEL I THINK SO. I WOULD RATHER SEE MORE WINDOWS AND A BUNCH OF GLASS SO AND IN FOLLOWING ALONG WITH THE COMMENTS I WAS MAKING ABOUT MAYBE MAKING IT MORE LIVE WORK IN TERMS OF UM ESPECIALLY WITH THE BRIDGE HOUSE READY TO WORK CREW IF YOU COULD FIND A WAY TO HOW SOME OF THOSE FOLKS THERE THAT WOULD BE EXCELLENT WITH US ALSO REDUCE ON THE AMOUNT OF CAR TRIPS THAT WOULD BE HAPPENING THERE. UM BUT UM OTHER THAN THAT I'M I WAS REALLY HAPPY TO SEE THAT YOU'RE ADDRESSING A LOT OF THE COMMENTS THAT WERE IN THE IN THE PLANNING BOARD REVIEW ESPECIALLY WITH RESPECT TO ACCESS TO THE SUNRISE SHOPPING CENTER AND MAKING IT A LITTLE MORE WORKABLE THERE SO JUST KEEP DOING WHAT YOU'RE DOING AND I APPRECIATE THAT YOU HAVE HOME TAKING THOSE COMMENTS TO HEART. THANK YOU THINK YOU'RE

[241:00] NEXT IS VERY I THINK THE INTEGRATION IS AN IMPORTANT FACTOR UM I DON'T LIKE LIKE SOME OF THIS BECAUSE I WANT TO GIVE UP A TON OF UNITS AND I UNDERSTAND YOU GUYS GET TO PENCIL THIS OUT I GUESS IT SAYS TWO THINGS ABOUT THAT AS YOU DO THE MATH ON THIS WERE A JOB HE WOULDN'T GET TO SEE THREE OF THEM ABLE TO HEAR SOON FOR YOU TO MAKE SOME DECISIONS PRETTY QUICK. I LIKE TO PLAY FOR OFFICE BECAUSE YOU'D HAVE TO BECAUSE THESE ARE TIED TO NEED TO SEE WILL WHERE YOU GO IN THREE ELEVEN SO OF SOME MATH TO DO OVER THE NEXT COUPLE WEEKS BUT AS YOU DO THE MATH I GUESS I'D LIKE TO SUGGEST TWO THINGS AS SAM'S POINTED OUT LET'S LET'S REMEMBER THERE'S THREE COHORTS WOULD LIKE TO HOUSE HERE. IT'S NOT JUST THE PEOPLE BELOW SIXTY PERCENT AM I AN IN YOUR NORMAL NORMAL MARKET RATE RESIDENTS BUT ALSO THE MIDDLE INCOME FACTOR IN AND SEEK A LITTLE HIGHER AND MAYBE THAT CAN FACTOR IN WHETHER IT'S AT THREE ELEVEN OR THROUGH OFFER BOTH SO THERE'S I THINK ONE THING ABOUT ALL THREE COHORTS DO THE MATH ON THAT SECOND IS WHY VERY MUCH APPRECIATE THE FACT YOU HAVEN'T YET

[242:00] ASKED TO SEE FOR MONEY. DON'T BE SHY. KIRK A BIG BAG OF MONEY I GUESS NOBODY TOLD ME I THINK I THINK WE'RE RUNNING OUT. ACTUALLY YES HAS BEEN SAYING AND THAT'S WHAT IS FOR THE VISITS TO SUPPORT YOU NO END IN WE SO UNUSUAL FOR US TO PAY EIGHTY EIGHTY FIVE THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS A DOOR TO SUPPORT AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS WHY I REALLY RESPECT THE FACT THAT YOU HAVEN'T HAD YOUR HAND OUT ON THIS. THAT'S WHAT IT TAKES TO BRIDGE THE GAP AND GET US WE HAVE OF POTENTIALLY CONFLICTING GOALS WHICH IS INTEGRATION BUT AS MANY AS POSSIBLE IF ASKING HER FOR SOME MONEY SOLVES BOTH OF THOSE DESIRES WERE TO BE REALLY HAPPY CAMPERS THANK YOU THE GOOD AND IT SANK YOU THIS IS HAS ALL THE PROMISE OF BEING A REALLY WONDERFUL PROJECT THAT HITS ON SO MANY VALUES WE CARE ABOUT. SO

[243:02] THANK YOU. THIS IS WHAT CONCEPT PREVIOUS POST WE LEARNED A LOT TONIGHT WE APPRECIATE IT. AND YES I DO HAVE ONE COMING AND THAT IS MARY SCANLON ABOUT ALL THE GLASS BUT I APPRECIATE MORE FENCED RATION WOULD BE REALLY NICE TO MAKE IT NOT LOOK LIKE A N I NOE DAT BACK BUILDING SOMETHING BUT NOT TO MAKE IT LOOK LIKE AN OFFICE BUILDING BUT LIKE OH IT'S MY RESIDENT'S NAME COMING HOME TO IT TO YOU WHEN THAT BREAKS MEANT FEEL AS YOU COMING IN SUGAR AND BILL EXPECT ELEVATIONS WON'T SHOW THE GLASS BE TOO TRANSPARENT BECAUSE THEY CARE FOR THE REALLY GOOD COMMENTS ITS APPRECIATED THANK YOU THANK YOU OFF YOUR SECOND HEARING OR TWO ORDINANCES RELATED TO OIL AND GAS REGULATIONS EMERGENCY ORDINANCE EIGHTY TWO FIFTY FOUR AN EMERGENCY ORDINANCE EIGHTY TWO FIFTY THREE K GOOD EVENING I'LL BE HANDLING THE PRESENTATION ON THIS NIGHT SO THESE ARE

[244:00] THE QUESTIONS I DECIDE TO PUT THEM UP FRONT AND AT THE END SO YOU KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT WHAT I'M GOING TO ASK YOU AS YOU PROBABLY ARE AWARE THE COUNT THE CITY HAS A MORATORIUM ON THE ACCEPTANCE OF NEW APPLICATIONS FOR OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT ON THE OPEN SPACE OUTSIDE OF THE CITY AND ON TITLE NINE APPLICATIONS FOR SITE REVIEW FOR WHAT WE CALL MINING INDUSTRIES IN THE CITY THAT EXPIRES ON JUNE THIRD TWENTY TWENTY EIGHTEEN PRIMARY PURPOSE FOR TONIGHT IS TO TWO FOR COUNCIL TO CONSIDER WHETHER OR NOT TO INTRODUCE AND PASS AN EMERGENCY A PROPOSED ORDINANCE EXTENDING THE MORATORIUM. WE'VE GIVEN YOU IN THE PACKET TWO OPTIONS ONE OPTION IN ATTACHMENT A WOULD EXTEND THE MORATORIUM TO NOVEMBER SEVEN TWENTY EIGHTEEN TO ALLOW FOR COUNCIL TO PUT A MORATORIUM ON THE BALLOT THE SECOND ATTACHMENT B WOULD EXTEND THE MORATORIUM TO JUNE THIRD TWENTY TWENTY THAT THE THIRD QUESTION IS WHETHER OR NOT

[245:00] COUNCIL WOULD CONSIDER A SEPARATION TAX THE FOURTH IS WHETHER OR NOT O S M P SHOULD DEVELOP PLAN FOR PRIDE AS ACQUIRING MINERAL RIGHTS AND IF SO THE FIFTH QUESTION IS IS THIS COUNCIL WANTS TO HAVE TO WORK ON A POSSIBLE MECHANISM SO GO THROUGH THOSE MULTI TO ALL TRY TO GO QUICKLY I KNOW THAT YOUR TIRED AND IT'S BEEN A LONG NIGHT ARE READY BUT THIS IS AN IMPORTANT TOPIC I WANT TO PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF I'M GOING TOO FAST SO THE LITTLE BACKGROUND. COUNCIL ADOPTED A ONE YEAR MORATORIUM EFFECTIVE JUNE OR TWENTY THIRTEEN VOTERS EXTENDED A MORATORIUM OR ACTUALLY PROPOSED A NEW MORATORIUM AT THE NOVEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN ELECTION THAT EXPIRES ON JUNE THIRD. AND AS I SAID BEFORE IT HAS TO HAVE TWO THINGS IT IS MORE TIME ACCEPTING APPLICATIONS FOR OPEN SPACE AND FOR USE REVIEW OF NEW MINING INDUSTRIES MINING INDUSTRIES IS ON THE USED TABLE. IT IS ONLY ALLOWED IN TWO DISTRICTS INDUSTRIAL MANUFACTURING AND AGRICULTURE THE TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN ELECTION RESULTS I WAS ASKED

[246:02] FOR THIS AS YOU CAN SEE ALMOST EIGHTY PERCENT OF THE VOTERS VOTED IN FAVOR OF THE MORATORIUM IN NOVEMBER OF TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN SO AS YOU PROBABLY KNOW ONE OF THE REASONS OF THE FREE ORIGINAL MORATORIUM WAS AT THE TIME THERE WERE CASES PENDING BEFORE THE COURTS TO CONSIDER TWO DIFFERENT LEGAL AT TWO DIFFERENT ACTIONS OF A LONG ONE HAD A A BAN ON OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT AND MORE FOR COLLEGE AT A FIVE YEAR MORATORIUM. THE SUPREME COURT STRUCK DOWN BOTH OF THOSE IN SEPARATE DECISIONS ISSUED ON THE SAME DAY IN TWO THOUSAND AND SIXTEEN THERE'S CURRENTLY A CASE PENDING THAT'S VERY INTERESTING YOU'VE HEARD ABOUT THIS BEFORE CAUSE YOU TO PROVE THE CITY'S PARTICIPATION IN AN AMICUS BRIEF SUPPORTING RESPONDED TO THE SUPREME COURT OF PLAINTIFF IN THE CASE IT'S AN INTERESTING CASE THERE'S LANGUAGE IN STATE LAW THAT REQUIRES THE COLORADO OIL AND GAS COMMISSION TO CONSIDER

[247:01] PROTECTION OF SAFETY HEALTH SAFETY AND WELFARE. PRIOR TO APPROVING ANY DEVELOPMENT THE COLORADO OIL AND GAS COMMISSION HAS ALWAYS VIEWED THAT AS A BALANCING TEST THAT IS THEY BALANCE THE ECONOMIC INTEREST OF DEVELOPING THE OIL AGAINST THE HEALTH IMPACTS OF THE DRILLING PLATFORMS THE COURT OF APPEALS IN MARCH OF TWO THOUSAND AND SEVENTEEN IN A CASE BROUGHT BY A BOULDER RESIDENT WHO YOU ALL KNOW IS HE'S BEEN HERE MANY TIMES SAID THAT WASN'T A BALANCING TEST THAT SHOULD BE A PRECONDITION THAT IS THE APPLICANT SHOULD PROVE THAT THERE ISN'T GOING TO BE A DAMAGING EFFECT ON THE HEALTH SAFETY AND WELFARE AND IT WAS SO WOULD BE A PRECONDITION NOT A BALANCING TEST THE SUPREME COURT GRANTED CERT SHARI OTHER THAT'S THE THAT'S THE MECHANISM TO REVIEW A SUPREME COURT IN JANUARY AND YOU CAN SEE THE SCHEDULE THE OPENING BRIEF HAS BEEN FILED THE ANSWER BRIEF IS DUE MAY TWENTY FIVE TWENTY EIGHTEEN THE REPLY BRIEF IS DUE JUNE FIFTEEN TWENTY EIGHTEEN ORAL ARGUMENT

[248:00] PROBABLY GOING TO OCCUR IN THE FOURTH QUARTER OF TWENTY EIGHTEEN. IT'S HARD TO TELL ONE WILL GET A DECISION THE ASPEN BAG FEE CASE WAS ARGUED ON JUNE SEVEN TWENTY SEVENTEEN AND WE HAVEN'T GOTTEN A DECISION YET OUR MUNICIPAL IS A SIAN CASE WAS ARGUED ON FEBRUARY FOURTEENTH TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN WHEN THE DECISION THAT SO THE SUPREME COURT ISSUES DECISIONS WHEN THEY'RE READY IT'S HARD TO TELL WHAT THAT MEANS BUT IT'S SAFE TO SAY THAT IT'S ON LIKELY THAT I DOUBT THAT WE WOULD SEE A DECISION THIS YEAR PROBABLY SOME TIME IN TWENTY NINETEEN BUT I WOULDN'T GIVE YOU A HIGH ODDS ON THAT. SO THIS WEEKS THAT'S FORCE BETWEEN NINETEEN NOT TWENTY EIGHT I'M SORRY IT SHOULD BE TWENTY NINETEEN I APOLOGIZE SO THAT'S MOST LIKELY BUT IT COULD BE LATER SO ONE OF THE REASONS WE'RE ASKING FOR COUNCIL TO CONSIDER A TWO YEAR MORATORIUM IS BECAUSE AS YOU DEVELOP ITS REGULATIONS DEALING WITH THIS THE OUTCOME OF THE MARTINEZ CASE WILL BE CRUCIAL IF THE SUPREME COURT

[249:01] SAYS THAT C O G C C C HAS TO CONSIDER HEALTH AND SAFETY BEFORE ISSUING A THREAT THAT MAKES YOUR JOB ALOT EASIER IF THEY CONTINUE WITH THIS BALANCING TEST YOU MIGHT WANT TO CONSIDER STRICTER REGULATIONS SO WE HAVE THIS IN THE MEMO GO THROUGH SPECIFICALLY ONE OF THE THINGS WE'VE LEARNED IN THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS SINCE WE'VE LOOKED AT THIS IS THAT THING WITH THE PROLIFERATION OF OIL AND GAS OPERATIONS THERE IS THERE SEEMS TO BE SOME HIGH LEVEL OF DANGER. WE'VE HAD PEOPLE KILLED IN EXPLOSIONS AND IT'S NOT CLEAR TO ME BECAUSE SOME PEOPLE LOOKING AT THIS THAT OIL AND GAS OPERATORS REPORT EVERY SPILL OR EXPLOSION IN SO WE'VE HAD PEOPLE CALL AND SAY WELL I SAW SOMETHING GO UP BUT THIS WAS NO RECORD OF IT SO I THINK THE COUNCIL'S HIGHEST DUTY IS TO PROTECT THE SAFETY. IT'S NOT CLEAR TO ME FOR MY REVIEW OF JUST WHAT WE'VE SEEN IN THE LAST YEAR THAT THE SAFETY IS BEING

[250:00] PROTECTED AT THIS AND AS YOU KNOW MOST OF THESE ARE IN LESS URBAN AREAS THE BOLDER BOULDER IS ONE OF THE AREAS IN THE STATE AND THEY'VE ALREADY BEEN TRAGEDIES IT WOULD IT WOULD BE SOMETHING THAT YOU WOULD. WE WOULD ASK YOU TO CONSIDER VERY SERIOUSLY BEFORE PERMITTING ANYTHING ON IN IN OUR AREA TOO TO LOOK AT SEPARATION OTHER THINGS SO WANT TO TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT POTENTIAL CITY REGULATIONS. YOU KNOW THAT THE COURTS TO SORT OF SAY THAT THE CITIES WERE PREEMPTIVE BUT THEY DIDN'T PREEMPT US COMPLETELY. THERE ARE STILL THINGS THAT YOU CAN LOOK AT AND AS YOU ALL KNOW OUR PLANNING DEPARTMENT HAS A VERY HEAVY WORKLOAD AND EVERYTHING THAT THEY NEED TO LOOK AT REQUIRES SOME TIME AND SO WHAT I'M ONE OF THE OTHER REASONS THAT WE'RE SUGGESTING A MORATORIUM IS SO THAT THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT COULD LOOK AT ZONING CONDITIONS THAT ARE MORE DETAIL THAN THE ONES WE HAVE THINGS SUCH AS SETBACK VISUAL IMPACT OF NOISE WHICH THE COURTS HAVE SAID WE CAN

[251:00] LOOK AT AND MOST IMPORTANTLY IN MANY WAYS WATER QUALITY THE CITIES I THINK THE CITY'S MOST VALUABLE ASSET IS ITS WATER RIGHTS AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE PROTECT MOST DEARLY IS THE ABILITY TO PROVIDE WATER TO OUR COMMUNITY DAMAGING THOSE WATER WAS RIGHT RIGHTS COULD SUIT SEVERELY IMPACT QUALITY OF LIFE IN BOULDER SO AS YOU KNOW THAT NOT ONLY ARE WE CONCERNED ABOUT THE LAND INSIDE THE CITY THE CITY HAS EXTENSIVE HOLDINGS OUTSIDE FORTY FIVE THOUSAND ACRES OF OPEN SPACE BUT ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE'VE LOOKED AT MORE RECENTLY BECAUSE OF RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IS THAT THE LAND THE WATER UTILITY OWNS THE WATER UTILITY OWNS MILES OF LAND UNDER PIPELINES AND SOME AREAS WHERE THEY OWN THE LAND OR WATER RESOURCES FOR THE PURPOSES OF PROVIDING WATER HERE AND SOME OF THOSE ARE AREAS THAT ARE AFFECTED BY DRILLING SO YOU'VE ONE OF THINGS I WANT YOU TO TALK A LITTLE BIT TONIGHT IS WHERE WE ARE IN TERMS OF OWNERSHIP OF MINERAL RIGHTS AND OPEN

[252:00] SPACE THE CITY OWNS ALL OF THE GUESTS USE FOR APPROXIMATELY TWENTY THOUSAND OPEN SPACE ACRES THE CITY OWNS A FRACTIONAL ANSWERS THAT MEANS WE SHARE IT WITH ANOTHER PARTY ON THE OTHER ABOUT TWO THOUSAND ACRES OTHER ALL PARTIES OWN OIL AND GAS RIGHTS UNDER NINETY ONE HUNDRED ACRES AND WE'RE STILL LOOKING AT ABOUT FIFTY FIVE HUNDRED ACRES. SMU SO MY RECOLLECTION IS THAT WE HAVE ABOUT FORTY FIVE THOUSAND ACRES OF OPEN SPACE JUST DOWN AND SO THIS HAS ABOUT NINE THOUSAND THAT AREN'T ACCOUNTED FOR THIRTY FIVE THIRTY SEVEN SO MAYBE LITTLE LESS THAN MATT PALM ON HERE THERE SHE SHE'S HIDING IN THE BACK. BETHANY COLLEGE FROM THE OPEN SPACE DEPARTMENT MIGHT HAVE AN ANSWER FOR SAM AT NISSAN'S PROPERTY AGENT WITH OPEN SPACE MOUNTAIN PARKS THE DATA YOU SEE ON THE SCREEN OF THE FORTY FIVE THOUSAND ACRES INCLUDES OUR CONSERVATION EASEMENT PROPERTIES AS WELL AS JOINT HOLDINGS WITH BOULDER COUNTY OR OTHER AGENCIES THAT ARE ACCOUNTED

[253:00] FOR YET SO THESE RIGHT NOW WHAT WE'VE BEEN FOCUSED ON SO FAR OUR FEE TITLE PROPERTIES THAT WE OWN THANK YOU THAT'S VERY HELPFUL THIRTY NINE THOUSAND ACRES THE OTHER PARTY'S OWN OIL AND GAS RIGHTS DO WE KNOW WHERE THOSE ARE THOSE CONCENTRATED AND WE KNOW WHERE THOSE ARE SO FAR AND A HUGE AMOUNT OF CONCENTRATED TO THE SOUTH AND WEST OF OUR SYSTEM TO THE SOUTH AND WEST OF OUR SYSTEM SO THEIR INSTANCE BEAR PEAK WAS A US PATENT INTO THE CITY OF BOULDER AND NEIGHBORS ARE AND AND THE US GOVERNMENT STILL OWNS ALL THE MINERALS UNDER UNDER THE BEAR PEAK WHICH IS WELL OVER A THOUSAND ACRES I BELIEVE YES SO TO THE EXTENT THAT IT'S ON THE WESTSIDE AM LESS WORRIED ABOUT IT BECAUSE IT'S NOT TYPICAL DRILLING TERRAIN. UM SO OKAY THANK YOU SO I THINK IM BETTER THAN YOU ARE WRONG SO FAR OPEN SPACES REVIEW IS THAT A LOT OF THE ACRES THAT WE DON'T OWN THE MINERAL RIGHTS ARE ONES WHERE WE WOULDN'T REALLY BE THAT CONCERNED AND SO I THINK THEY'VE PRIVATIZED PURCHASING MINERAL RIGHTS IN AREAS WHERE

[254:01] THERE'S POTENTIAL FOR EXPLORATION. SARAH BETHANY CORRECT THAT'S WHAT OUR EXERCISE THAT YOU'RE SEEING IS IS TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH IS LOOKING AT THE GEOLOGY THE ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY THAT WHERE WE DON'T OWN MINERALS UNDER THE WEINBERG SO WE DO HAVE A PRELIMINARY SENSE OF THAT OF PLANS THAT YOU WOULD CONSIDER PRIORITY FOR ACQUISITION GIVEN THEIR PROXIMITY. I THINK ANN AND TOM I BELIEVE IS GETTING TO FURTHER DISCUSSION RELATED TO HOW THOSE MINERAL INTERESTS MY WORK. WE'RE ALSO LOOKING TO YOU TO TELL US WHETHER OR NOT TO PRIORITIZE BASED ON THE LIKELY BASED ON THE POSSIBILITY OF POOLING IN THINGS LIKE THAT WHERE WOULD THAT WOULD ACQUIRING THAT INTEREST MATTER. YES MY QUESTION DIFFERENTLY AND HOW MANY ACRES DO WE THINK ARE AT RISK NO CLUE. I KNOW FORCE PULLING CHANGES EVERYTHING SO JUST SET THAT ASIDE FROM IT DO WE KNOW OF PLANS THAT WE

[255:00] THINK ARE ON THE SIDE THAT MIGHT BE MORE RISK. WE HAVE A SENSE OF HOW BIG THAT ACREAGE IS EARLY SERVE BALLPARK SENSE I DON'T NECESSARILY WANT A BALLPARK THAT YET I CAN PROBABLY DO THAT WITHIN THE NEXT MONTH OR SO ON AS WE WE FINISH THOSE OTHER FIFTY FIVE HUNDRED ACRES A GOOD MAJORITY AT ONCE A MAJORITY TO SEVERAL OF OUR OF A LOT OF THOSE TWO THOUSAND ACRES ARE SAYING WITH FRACTIONAL INTERESTS ARE IN THE NORTH AND EAST OF OUR SYSTEM SAID THOSE ARE WHERE WE'RE LOOKING AT WEINBERG SAID WE WOULD HAVE TO OR THE AREA OF INTEREST RIGHT NOW FOR THE MOST AMOUNT OF OIL AND GAS DRILLING AND SO RESEMBLING THOSE INTERESTS WILL BE VERY VERY DIFFICULT AND A FRACTIONAL INTEREST IN THIS SENTENCE MEANS FOR SOMEBODY AND DEIDRE TYPICALLY RESERVE LIKE A QUARTER OF THE OIL AND GAS INTERESTS UNDER THE PROPERTY SO AND THEN MAYBE THE NEXT PERSON IN THE DEED RESERVED ANOTHER QUARTER SO WE MAY HAVE ENDED UP WITH HALF A CALM AND THEN

[256:01] YOU'VE GOT TWO PARTIES WHO HAVE A QUARTER AND THEY MAY HAVE THE BAND ALSO DID THEY'RE THERE WHEN GAS RIGHT AWAY SO YOU KNOW WE'RE TRYING WE'RE LOOKING AT IN DOING SO WE'RE BASICALLY DOING CHAIN OF TITLE ON EVERY ONE OF OUR PROPERTY MINERAL INTERESTS OF EVERY ONE OF OUR PROPERTIES FROM PATENT FORWARD AARON AND THEN LISA THANK YOU BETHANY I UNDERSTAND THIS IS A VERY DIFFICULT OF YOU KNOW HOW HARD IT CAN BE TO REVIEW MINERAL RIGHTS OWNERS BUT IT IS IN PART OF YOUR ANALYSIS OF THIS WHERE YOU'RE SEEING HOW MUCH WE OWN ARE YOU ANALYZING THE RISK FROM FORCED POOLING FROM THE AREA WHERE OTHER ADJACENT MINERAL OWNERS COULD COULD FRACTURE UNDERNEATH OUR OPEN SPACE LANDS WITHOUT OUR PERMISSION OR IS THE RARE STEP THAT WOULD BE A PRETTY MASSIVE UNDERTAKING BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT YOU KNOW UM IF IT'S PRIVATELY OWNED AS WELL AS IF IT'S IF THERE'S A LEASE HOLD INTEREST IF THEY RELEASE THEIR THEIR MINERALS AS WELL AS WHAT THE LIKELIHOOD IS OF

[257:01] DEVELOPMENT AND AND THEN LOOK AT THE AT THE ASSETS UNDER THE DRILLING THE POSSIBILITY OF DRAWING OUR PROPERTY THANK YOU LISA AND THEN TO MY RECOLLECTION IS RIGHT WE ALSO SET A SOMETIMES BY THE WATER RIGHTS WERE BUYING OPEN SPACE PROPERTY TO DO YOU HAVE A SIMILAR TYPE STUDY AND OR SURVEY ON THE WATER RIGHTS THAT WE WERE CAUGHT ACQUIRED FOR OUR OPEN SPACE. YES WE WE HAVE A PRETTY THOROUGH WATER INVENTORY ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO TEACHERS THAT WE'VE ACQUIRED WITH OPEN SPACE. I'M DEFINITELY A SEPARATE SOME WAY OF DOING CHAIN OF TITLE RATE BUT I GUESS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I AM JUST RECALLING A OPEN SPACE PURCHASE WE DID SOME YEARS AGO IN THE WATER RIGHT ALREADY BEEN SOLD AND AND SO IT WAS UNFORTUNATE BECAUSE WE COULDN'T THEN USE THOSE WATER RIGHTS TO IRRIGATE THE LAND

[258:01] AND SO WE WERE ABLE TO MAKE THE LAND BE IN ITS OPTIMAL FUNCTIONING ENVIRONMENT BUT ALSO I'M CONCERNED ABOUT ACCESS TO WATER FOR THE EXPRESS PURPOSE OF DRILLING AND SO I THINK IT WOULD BE REALLY HELPFUL AT LEAST TO ME TO GET MORE INFORMATION ON THE WATER RIGHT AND WHERE WE HAVE WATER RIGHT WHERE WE DON'T AND HAVE KIND OF AN OVERLAY ON WHERE THE MINERAL RIGHTS ARE AND WHAT A RETURNER AND WE WERE MISSING. DO YOU MEAN THE RIGHT TO DRILL A WELL VERSUS I MEAN WE CAN GET TO A DISCUSSION OF HOW THE MORATORIUM APPLIES WE CAN'T REALLY SEARCH FOR CONVEY WATER RIGHTS THE CITY WATER RIGHTS FOR ANY KIND NO AND I STAND THE CAT IF WE DON'T KNOW THEM VERY WELL BUT WATER DOESN'T COME NECESSARILY WITH THE PROPERTY EXCEPT FOR THE RIGHT TO DRILL THE GROUNDWATER ASSOCIATED WITH THE PROPERTY WHO WRECKED AND SO YOU CAN'T FOR K SAID

[259:01] THAT WOULD BE WHAT I'M OKAY OIL AND GAS CANNOT SOME IN THE STATE CARO CANNOT DRILL WAS BASICALLY RESIDENTIAL WELL OR THINGS LIKE THAT IN ORDER TO USE THAT WATER ON THE PROPERTY FOR OIL FOR FRACKING FOR OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT THAT IS THAT I AM USING WATER FOR TOMMY GOING TO COVER FORCED POOLING LITTLE BIT FURTHER TO THE SPOTLIGHT IF YOU WANT. HE JUST WON THE BEST LOOKING LADY KEEP THEM SOO SOO ONE OF THINGS ABOUT OWNING THE WILLING GUEST INTERESTS IS IF SOMEONE ELSE OWNS THE MINERAL RIGHTS ON YOUR PROPERTY UNDER COLORADO LAW YOU HAVE TO MAKE A REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION TO LET THEM DEVELOP THEM AND SO THAT COULD MEAN THEM COMING ON TOO AND WE NEGOTIATE THAN WE HAVE RULES ABOUT IT BUT THEY COULD STILL MEAN THEM COMING ON YOUR LAN FORCE PULLING DOESN'T NECESSARILY EXPLAIN THE CONCEPT OF FORCED POOLING AS BEST I CAN. THIS IS MY OWN ARTWORK I SO ASSUMING THE CITY OWNED PARCEL B AND

[260:02] SOMEONE ON OWNS OWNS THE MINERAL RIGHTS UNDER PAR SO LATE AND WE OWN THE CITY OWNS ALL RIGHTS UNDER PARCEL BE THE PERSON WHO OWNS PARCEL A AND THE PERSONAL LOANS PARCEL C CAN GET TOGETHER AND SAY WE WANT TO DEVELOP THE MINERAL RIGHTS THEY CAN MAKE AN OFFER TO THE OWNER PARCEL B TO SAY WE WANT YOU TO JOIN US AND THE CITY CAN SAY NO THANKS AND THEY THEN HAVE A RIGHT TO DEVELOP THE MINERAL RIGHTS AND UNDER THE COLORADO LAW. THIS THIS THIS HAS KIND OF INCENTIVE PENALTY SCHEME IN COLORADO SO WHAT HAPPENS IS THEY GO AHEAD AND DRILL AND EXPLORE AND DRILL AND THEY PAY YOU THE OWNER OF THE NON CONSENTING PARCEL OF THE REVENUES BUT THEY DEDUCT FROM THAT ONE HUNDRED PERCENT OF THE DRILLING COSTS AND TWO HUNDRED PERCENT OF THE EXPLORATION COURTS. COS THAT'S THE PENALTY SO YOU GET A VERY SMALL AMOUNT ULTIMATELY IN THE END IF YOU DON'T AGREE SO THAT THE WAY

[261:00] THE LAW SET UP IN COLORADO THEY WANT TO AGREE. SO THIS IS WHERE THE CITY IS AT GREATEST RISK ALTHOUGH I AGREE COMPLETELY BETHANY WOULD BE ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE HE WOULD HAVE TO MAP EVERY FIELD AND FIGURE OUT THE MINERAL RIGHTS ALL AROUND OUR OPEN SPACE TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THE RISK IS FROM FORCED POOLING. I STILL BELIEVE IT'S WISE TO ACQUIRE MINERAL RIGHTS WHERE WE THINK THERE'S RISK I THINK THAT'S WHAT OPEN SPACES DOING BECAUSE YOU DON'T WANT PEOPLE COMING ONTO OUR OPEN SPACE PROPERTY IN DRILLING BUT THIS STILL PRESENTS THE SAME RISK OF YOU HEARD TONIGHT ABOUT THE HEALTH RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH WITH DRILLING IF SOMEONE STROLLING ON THE NEXT PROPERTY EVEN THOUGH THEY'RE NOT COMING ONTO YOURS THEY'RE STILL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS THAT THAT COULD AFFECT THE QUALITY OF OUR OPEN SPACES WELL SO I WANTED TO TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE CREST OWN APPLICATION. WE ATTACHED THE CITY'S COMMENTS THAT SAYS HIS DIRECTION TO IT CHRIS STONE HAS DONE A COMPREHENSIVE DRILLING APPLICATIONS BOULDER COUNTY IT'S A TWELVE SQUARE MILE

[262:00] AREA THAT THEY'VE ASKED FOR YOU SEE THAT LITTLE BLACK CIRCLE I PUT ON THERE THAT'S THE WILLMAR PONCE THE CITY'S WATER UTILITY OWNS WOULD MAR PONCE AND THE REASON THE CITY OWNS THOSE PONDS IS BECAUSE WE SOMETIMES DO WHAT WHAT ARE CALLED EXCHANGES. IF YOU WANT TO GET WATER UPSTREAM THAT TAKES IT OUT OF THE BASIN YOU SOMETIMES CAN PUT IT BACK DOWN STREAM SO THE WATER IS YOU'RE OBVIOUSLY WE'RE NOT USING THE WATER IN THE CITY FOR ONE OF OUR PARTS BUT SOMEONE ELSE IS BECAUSE ITS DOWNSTREAM AND SO WE WE ACQUIRED WATER UPSTREAM AND WHERE RE FILLING THE BASIN BY THE WATER WE'VE ACQUIRED IN WILLMAR PARTS SO THE CITY HAS A VERY IMPORTANT INTEREST IN THE QUALITY OF THAT WATER COULD AFFECT OUR ABILITY IF IT BECAME NON POTABLE I SAY COULD BECAUSE IT WAS UNCLEAR ON THIS BUT TO TAKE WATER UPSTREAM WHICH WE NEED FOR OWN USES. SO ALTHOUGH EVEN THOUGH ITS DOWNSTREAM FROM THE CITY. IT'S STILL A VERY

[263:00] IMPORTANT PART OF THE CITY'S WATER SYSTEM AND AS YOU CAN LOOK CLOSELY THAT LITTLE YELLOW SQUARE UP THERE WITH THE BOX NEXT TO IT. THAT'S WHERE THE DRILLING PLATFORM IS SUPPOSED TO GO ONE OF THEM SO AS YOU'VE SEEN FROM THE ATTACHED CUT THE COMMENTS ATTACHED IS A DETACHMENT SEE I THINK THE D TO THE MEMO THE CITY HAS BEEN VERY ACTIVE LED BY BETHANY IN WITH A BUNCH OF PEOPLE HELPING IN COMMENTING ON THIS AND TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT C O G C'S PROTECTS THE CITY'S WATER RIGHTS THERE BUT THIS IS A SORT OF THING THAT IS VERY CONCERNING TO US BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT DRILLING ON CITY LAND. THIS IS NOT OPEN SPACE BUT THAT DRILLING PLATFORM COULD HAVE A SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE CITY'S WATER RIGHTS OR SOME EFFECT ON THE CITY'S WATER RIGHTS SO WE'RE TRYING TO GET THEM TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT IF THEY DO ALLOW THIS THAT THEY DO IN A WAY THAT PROTECTS THE CITY'S WATER RIGHTS ON IS THERE ANY PLAN ICE AND THAT THIS WILL GO THROUGH BECAUSE THIS YEAR GCC IS MORE ABOUT EXTRACTION THAN ANYTHING ELSE MA'AM IS THERE

[264:01] ANY WAY TO BASELINE WHITMIRE PONCE LIKE BENZENE CONTENT AND SOME OTHER CONTENT SO THAT WE HAVE SOME KIND OF BASELINE BEFORE THIS WHOLE INDUSTRIAL PROCESS STARTS FROM OURS. I BELIEVE SOURCE WATER PROGRAM IS ACTUALLY ALREADY UNDERTAKING THAT FOR OK SO THAT'S GREAT WE'RE AHEAD OF THAT BECAUSE I'VE BEEN GETTING A BASELINE IS IMPORTANT TO TAKE THEM TO COURT LATER FOR THE HARM THEY MIGHT CAUSE US AND TO CLARIFY LITTLE BIT OF WHAT TOM SAID THAT THEY'VE ACTUALLY IN THE MOST RECENT ROUND OR TWO ROUNDS I BELIEVE OF THEIR APPLICATION IS ACTUALLY TWO WELL PADS ON THE ADJACENT PROPERTY TWENTY SIX WELLS EACH A POLICE POST AND IT'S THE WELL PADS WOULD EACH BE ABOUT TWENTY ACRES IN THE BEGINNING STAGES AND THERE ARE ABOUT FOURTEEN WELLS PROPOSED TO BE DRILLED UNDER THE WHAT ARE MY PROPERTY ON WHICH WOULD SET US UP FOR A POOLING WITH EITHER APPROACHING TO BEING APPROACHED TO IT FIRST LEASE THE LEASE THE OIL OIL AND GAS

[265:01] INTERESTS THAT WE HOLD OR TWO BEFORE SPORT TO DO IT TO DEATH OF TRUE I BELIEVE IT'S ABOUT NINETY NINE TO TEN THOUSAND FEET SO THE OTHER SO WE OWN THE LAND UNDER THEM OR POND AND DO WE IN THE MINERAL RIGHTS TO GET THAT RIGHT CORRECT THEN THE MINERAL RIGHTS UNDER JACQUES A THANK YOU SO I'LL HAVE A FEW MORE SLOTS SO THE SEPARATION TAX TO ONE OF THE THINGS WE WANTED WE DIDN'T PUT THIS FORWARD AS PART OF A BALLOT MEASURE DISCUSSIONS WAS ONE OF THE PEOPLE IN THE OIL AND GAS ISSUES TOGETHER. THIS WOULD BE A TAX ON DEVELOPERS WHO DEVELOP OIL IN THE CITY OF BOULDER BECAUSE OBVIOUSLY WE CAN'T TAX OUTSIDE THE CITY IT WOULD NOT BE EXPECTED TODAY TO GENERATE ANY REVENUE BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE ANYBODY EXPLORING IN BOULDER THE IDEA WOULD BE ONE TO PUT THIS INTO PLACE NOW SO THAT THERE'S SOMETHING IN EFFECT IF SOMEONE DOES COME IN SO THAT WE CAN HAVE A REVENUE SOURCE TO PROTECT THE COMMUNITY FROM

[266:00] THE IMPACTS ASSOCIATED WITH OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT IN BOULDER. IT WOULD BE THE FIRST ONE OF ITS KIND IN THE STATE OF COLORADO. OTHER CITIES HAVE EXPRESSED INTEREST IN DOING THIS YOU WOULD BE LEADING IF YOU DID WE HAVEN'T DECIDED EXACTLY WHAT IT WOULD TAX. WE'VE WE BECAUSE WE HAVEN'T REALLY DONE A LOT OF LEGAL RESEARCH ON THIS ONE THING WE KNOW THAT WE CAN'T DO IS WE CAN HAVE AN EXTRACTION TAX LIKE THE STATE DOES BECAUSE THAT'S BASED ON REVENUE AND ONE THING THAT'S CLEAR IN THE STATE CONSTITUTION IS A CITY CAN IMPOSE AN INCOME TAX SO WE HAVE TO FIND ANOTHER STRUCTURE THAT WOULD BE COMFORTABLE WITH TO DO THIS KIND OF TAX SO IT'S POSSIBLE THAT WE COULD DO IT ON PRODUCTION THAT IS NUMBER OF GALLONS OF OIL OR CUBIC FEET OF NATURAL GAS EXTRACTED WE CAN ALSO MODEL IT ON THE OCCUPATION TAX THAT WE HAVE FOR THE ELECTRIC UTILITY BILL FOR A LUMP SUM SO ONE OF THE THINGS I'D LIKE DIRECTION ON TONIGHT IS THIS SOMETHING

[267:01] YOU'D LIKE TO RESEARCH AND BRING FORWARD KENDRA TOPPERS HERE SHE'S BEEN LEADING THE EFFORT ON THIS AND KNOWS LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT IT BUT OBVIOUSLY WE HAVE NOT SPENT A LOT OF TIME ON IT YET WE COULD HAVE DEVELOPED THE CONCEPT WORKED A LITTLE BIT ON IT BUT WE'RE LOOKING FOR YOUR DIRECTION ON WHETHER OR NOT YOU WANT TO GO FORWARD IN FREEDOM IS WOULD WE IN TERMS OF SETTING A RATE FOR THE STACKS OBVIOUSLY WE HAVE A LOT TO EXPLORE HERE BUT DEPENDING ON THE MECHANISM OF HOW WE IMPLEMENT IT. WOULD WE NEED TO TIE THE RATE TO LIKE US PARTICULAR IMPACT TO THE COMMUNITY OR WOULD WE BE ABLE TO SET A RATE OF OUR CHOOSING KNOW SO THERE'S FOR ATTACKS. IT'S JUST THAT ACTUALLY CONTACTS WHATEVER THE VOTERS WILL SUPPORT. IT'S NOT A FEE WHERE YOU'D HAVE TO HAVE SOME RATIONAL BASES TYING IT TO THE IMPACT I WOULD RECOMMEND THAT YOU EXPLORE THAT JUST BECAUSE WE USUALLY DO WHEN WE LOOK AT TAXES ABOUT WHAT WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO WITH THEM BUT THERE ISN'T THE SAME LEGAL

[268:02] REQUIREMENT IS THERE IS FOR FEAR THEY TOO FEEL IT FROM A LEGAL PERSPECTIVE WE HAVE LATITUDE TO SET THAT YES I BELIEVE SELF. OK THAT'S GREAT THANK YOU HERE'S A RELATED WONDERS USE RELATED GO AHEAD AND THEN ABOUT A QUESTION I HAVE IS LIKE THE OTHER PREVIOUS TEXAS WITH AN UNCOMMONLY WE DO UP TO SOME VALUE. SO WE STARTED THEM SO WE WOULD DO SOMETHING LIKE THIS CAN WE DO GENERALLY AS WE SET A MAXIMUM OF THE COUNCIL DECIDES BASED UPON THE BUDGET PROCESS HOW MUCH TO IMPOSE. OKAY SO I'D BE INTERESTED. VERY. THE SO IF IF IT'S GOING TO BE A TAX FOR EXTRACTION WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS WORD AN OPTION BE TO TAX AND ROAD ACCESS UR ROAD USAGE. I DON'T SEE WHY NOT. SO IF COUNCIL GIVES US DIRECTION TO GO FOR

[269:00] WITH THIS WE LOOK AT IT BRING BACK SOME OPTIONS OF IN JUNE OR JULY SO THAT YOU COULD CONSIDER PUTTING ON THE BALLOT IN AUGUST. SO IS THIS SOMETHING THAT COUNTIES CAN DO AS WELL. I DON'T KNOW NOT A COUNTY LAWYER THAN THE COUNTY IS NOT A HOME RULE COUNTY SO I DON'T KNOW. SO KENDRA WAS THAT BECAUSE THE COUNTY ISN'T HARMFUL THEY DON'T LEAVE THE ABILITY TO DO THIS SO LAFAYETTE AND LONGMONT ARE CONSIDERING IT BUT BOULDER COUNTY BELIEVES THAT THEY DON'T HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO DO IT. I DO THINK IT WOULD BE NO OTHERS ARE HAVING CONVERSATIONS TO ME THAT WOULD BE INTERESTING TO DISCUSS WITH OTHERS BUT BUSH ASKING QUESTIONS REAL QUESTIONS THE NEXT LIGHT I ALSO KNOW THAT WE HAVE SOME PEOPLE HERE WANT TO SPEAK ON THE SWIM SO WE SHOULD ALSO MAKE TIME FOR THAT PEOPLE HAVE GENERAL QUESTIONS OF TIME HOW MUCH STAFF TIME YOU FIGURE IT'LL TAKE YOU KNOW WITH THIS BURDEN BECAUSE IS NOW ON THE WORK PLAN SEPARATION TAX THAT

[270:05] THE SEPARATION TAX IMPACT OF IT WILL BE A BURDEN WE ARE A LITTLE BIT LIGHTLY STAFFED RIGHT NOW WE'RE DOWN AN ATTORNEY BUT WE GENERALLY GET THE BALLOT MEASURES DONE SO IF YOU ASK US TO DO IT WILL DO IT AND KENDRA HAS DONE A LOT OF THE WORK ON THIS AND SHE WOULD HAVE THE LEAD SO WE JUST BE DRAFTING SO KINDA DO HAVE AN ESTIMATE ABOUT HALF TIME WOULD TAKE FOR YOUR SHOP I THINK IT DEPENDS ON HOW MANY VARIATIONS OF OPTIONS WE WANT TO LOOK INTO AND HOW MUCH WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT TYING THE TAX RATE TO THE IMPACT BECAUSE COMING UP WITH THE COST ESTIMATES FOR SOCIETAL EXTERNALITIES RELATED TO OIL AND GAS EXTRACTION. THERE'S NOT A LOT OF DATA OUT THERE SO BECAUSE WE'RE NOT LEGALLY REQUIRED TO DO THAT. I THINK WE HAVE SOMEONE TO DO THERE. I'M NOT I THINK WE CAN HANDLE IT ON OUR END AND IS THERE IN TERMS OF TIMING FOR DONE WITH

[271:02] THE IDEA THAT HE TENDED TO SHARE BUT YOU COULD ALSO DO NEXT OR YOU JUST TOOK AN X RAY. ERM. JOEY HEAR FROM SOME PUBLIX AND THEN WE CAN OK MANY PEOPLE WHO HAVE SIGNED UP. OK LET'S HOP RIGHT TO GET EACH PERSON I HAVE THREE MINUTES YOU NOT OBLIGATED TO USE IT ALL AND IF YOU CAN START WITH YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS THAT WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL SELF WILL START WITH DUNCAN AND IF FOLKS CAN BE LINED UP FOR A CUT THAT'S GREAT AND I WILL BE NEXT OR I SHOULD SAY AN IPOD CASE YOU GUYS HAVE WAITED LONGER THAN ANTICIPATED. Q YOU GUYS WILL BE LONGER THAN WE WERE PROBABLY SO THANK YOU. I'M SOMETIMES AUGUST. I'M TWENTY FOUR YEARS OLD RESIDENT OF BOULDER I LIVE AT THE MOREHEAD AVENUE SO MY KNICKERS AREA HAVE BEEN WORKING MOST OF MY YOUNG ADULT LIFE TO ADVANCE SOLUTIONS THE CLIMATE CRISIS ON THE LOCAL LEVEL. I'M A MEMBER OF COMMUNITY ACTION

[272:01] AND EMPOWER OUR FUTURE AND A MOVIE DAY JUST EXPRESS MY MOST SUPPORT FOR CITY COUNCIL TAKING WHATEVER ACTION WOULD BE APPROPRIATE TO PREVENT OIL AND GAS EXTRACTION WITHIN BOULDER WHETHER THAT BE AN EXTENSION OF THE MORATORIUM ON APPLICATIONS FOR OIL AND GAS OR SEPARATION TAX. I AGREE STRONGLY WITH THE RASH NOW THAT WAS USED TO PASS ABOUT MEASURE WHICH IS THE PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE ESSENTIALLY SAYING THAT IF WE CAN BE SURE THAT THIS ACTIVITY IS NOT HARMFUL TO HUMAN HEALTH AND SAFETY IN THE ENVIRONMENT THAT WE SHOULDN'T ENGAGE IN THAT AND SO IT'S FIVE YEARS LATER AND I YOU KNOW I THINK IT'S ONLY BECOMING MORE CLEAR WHAT THE EFFECTS OF GAS EXTRACTION ARE AND SO NOT ONLY WOULD AN EXTENSION THE MORATORIUM TRULY BE PROUD PROTECTING OUR BODIES OUR AIR OUR WATER THROUGH THE SOO. I THINK BE VERY STRONG RE AFFIRMATION OF OUR VALUES AS A COMMUNITY ESPECIALLY AT A TIME WHEN COMMUNITIES ACROSS THE STATE

[273:00] ARE MOBILIZING TO PUSH BACK AGAINST THE ENCROACHMENT OF FRACKING ON THEIR HOMES AND SCHOOLS AND WATERWAYS. SO I'LL WRAP IT UP BY JUST SAYING I REALLY APPRECIATE THE READERSHIP OF THIS COMMAND WILL SHOW IN THE PAST AND I WOULD REALLY APPRECIATE CITY COUNCIL TAKING WHATEVER STEPS NECESSARY TO CONTINUE THAT LEADERSHIP AND THE TEACHER THANK YOU THANK YOU EMMA AND THEN WHY CAN'T THE NAMES AT THIS ARE THAT HELLO HIGH COUNCIL THANK YOU SO MUCH DYNAMISM ARE A FAN AND I LIVE AT SEVEN FORTY THIRTY SECOND STREET SIDE OVER BY THIRTY AT THE BASELINE ITS NAME REPRESENTING BOULDER DA EARTH WHICH IS FORMALLY KNOWN AS C3 BOULDER CLIMBING CULTURE COLLABORATIVE AND I WILL KEEP IT VERY SHORT SO ON A PERSONAL NOTE SINCE MOVING TO BOULDER ABOUT SEVEN YEARS AGO I HAVE DEVELOPED WHAT THE BOULDER COMMUNITY HEALTH PULMONARY SPECIALISTS TEAM POLLUTION INDUCED ASTHMA FROM

[274:03] BIKING AROUND TOWN. UM WHICH IS QUITE IRONIC BUT WITH TWENTY TWO THOUSAND ACTIVE WELLS IN WELD COUNTY. IT'S ALSO NO SURPRISE ON A COMMUNITY KNOW UM AS YOU ALL KNOW BOULDER AS A PART OF THE CARBON NEUTRAL CITIES LANTZ AND WE HOPE TO ACHIEVE A ONE HUNDRED PERCENT RENEWABLE ELECTRICITY COAL BY TWENTY THIRTY. OBVIOUSLY IF WE OPEN OUR LAND TO OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT. UM THERE'S ABSOLUTELY ZERO CHANCE OF US ACHIEVING THESE GOALS AND AN AURA OF BEING A CARBON NEUTRAL CITY SO I ENCOURAGE ALL TO DO THE RIGHT THING WHICH I IMAGINE YOU WELL AND PLEASE EXTEND THE MORATORIUM TO TWENTY TWENTY AS WELL AS SET A POWERFUL PRECEDENT BY PASSING A RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF COLORADO RISING TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND FOOT SETBACK BALLOT INITIATIVE THAT WILL PROTECT SOME HOMES

[275:01] SCHOOLS PLACES HOUSES OF WORSHIP PARKS AS WELL AS SPORTS FIELDS AND PLAYGROUNDS THANK YOU SO MUCH HEALING CLEAR THE QUESTION YOU MEAN TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOOT SETBACK GREAT BUT I SAY FORTY FIVE THOUSAND JUST FOR THE GREATER THE GIRL CAN DREAM THE KEY. THANK YOU EMMA THEIR CASH SKINNED I GET A FELLOW COUNCILMEMBERS MY NAME IS MARY CASH MAXWELL. I LIVE AT TWENTY NINE TO FIVE FIFTEEN STREET IN NORTH BOULDER. I'M ACTUALLY A SENIOR AT ALEXANDER DAWSON SCHOOL AN AREA NEIGHBORING WHERE CRUDE STONE PEAK RESOURCES IS TRYING TO PERMIT THE SEVERAL MULTI WELL PADS IF WE WERE TO DRILL IN BOULDER IT WOULD SEVERELY LIMIT THE WELL BEING OF THIS BEAUTIFUL CITY AND WOULD BE A TRAVESTY TO MY GENERATIONS AND GENERATIONS TO COME IF IT

[276:01] DOESN'T AFFECT YOU ALL SOONER WHEN I GET MY FIRST REAL JOB I WANT IT TO AN OLDER BUT I WILL NOT TAKE A JOB IN A CITY THAT JEOPARDIZES THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF THEIR COMMUNITY FOR THE SAKE OF SHORT TERM ECONOMIC GAIN. I KNOW THAT YOU ALL MAKE THE RIGHT DECISION TO EXTEND THE OIL AND GAS MORATORIUM AND PLEASE CITY COUNCIL PASSED A RESOLUTION SUPPORTING THE COLORADO RISING BALLOT INITIATIVE FOR TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED BUFFER ZONE FROM ALL BUILDINGS OPEN SPACE WATER SOURCES IN SCHOOLS. THANKYOU THANKYOU THANKYOU FOR COMING MARLOWE AND THEN DAMAGING MY NAME IS MARLA VEINS. I'M SIXTEEN AND LIVE ADJACENT TO CITY OF BOULDER OPEN SPACE AND UNINCORPORATED BOULDER COUNTY. I'M THE ORIGINAL CREW

[277:00] DIRECTOR FOR EARTH GUARDIANS THESE PLAINTIFF OF THE MARTINEZ VERSUS THE GCC CASE SHOULD HAVE CAUGHT MARTINEZ IS A YOUTH DIRECTOR I APPLAUD THE CITY OF BOULDER FOR CONSIDERING TAKING THE STEPS THAT NOT EVEN THE STATE COUNTY OR SURROUNDING CITIES HAVE TAKEN IT IS ALL THE RIGHT DIRECTION I SPEAK TODAY ABOUT WHY AS A HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT KEEPING A BEAUTIFUL OPEN SPACE FREE OF INDUSTRIAL DRILLING IS IMPORTANT TO ME WHEN I'M SAD OR TROUBLED OR JUST NEEDS TIME TO THINK I LIKE TO GO ON A WALK AND TYPICALLY I LIKE TO TAKE MY WALKS IN NATURE IT'S QUIET THERE. NO ONE BOTHERS ME BECAUSE WE ARE OUTSIDE TO SEEK THE PEACE OF BEING OUTSIDE THE SPACE IS A PLACE TO THINK WHETHER IT'S ABOUT BOYS OR BEST FRIENDS SUPER JOB OR HOW SOMETIMES IF FEELS LIKE THE WORLD IS CALLED CRUMBLING AROUND US. I CAN CATCH A BREATH OF FRESH AIR UNDER THE GIANT COTTON WOODS WATCH BIRDS DART FROM ONE PLACE TO ANOTHER. IT ALMOST FEELS LIKE I'M ONE WITH THE WIND OR THAT I CAN FLOAT AWAY ON THE RIVERS OR LAKES. HAVE NO PLACE ON THIS OPEN SPACE. I GO TO THE OPEN SPACE TO PROPERLY PROCESS

[278:00] THE HEARTBREAKING NEWS OF MULTIMILLION DOLLAR COMPANIES EXPLOITING A COMMUNITY FOR PROFIT AND ECONOMIC GAIN. NOT TO BE CONFRONTED WITH A I DON'T WANT MY COMMUNITY TO BE NEXT. WE NEED TO SUPPORT THE HALF MILE SETBACK OFFERED BY CAR ARISING AND INITIATIVE NINETY SEVEN BECAUSE IT WILL PREVENT OUR COMMUNITY FROM BEING TOUCHED BY THE POISONOUS TOUCH OF UNCONVENTIONAL OR CONVENTIONAL DRILLING IT WILL ALSO KEEP OTHER COMMUNITY SAFE BECAUSE IF EXTRACTION OIL AND GAS OPERATING AS A NORTH SEA CREST ON OIL AND GAS JUST MOVES THE PROPOSED SITES FOR MORE FROM RICH WHITE BOULDER TO LATINO COMES THE COMMUNITY THAT WILL BE A LOSS A TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND TWENTY THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED FOOT SETBACK TWO THOUSAND THE BACK GO TO TWENTY THE PROTECT ALL OF US NO MATTER RACE MONEY GENDER OR PUT POLITICAL AFFILIATION CITY OF BOULDER COUNCIL MEMBERS YOU HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE ROLE MODELS FOR THE STATE THE BOULDER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND OTHER

[279:00] SURROUNDING CITY COUNCILS EXTEND THE MORATORIUM FORMALLY ENDORSE COSTS ARISING AND INITIATIVE NINETY SEVEN STAND WITH YOUR CITIZENS. THIS LAND THAT I HAVE GONE UP ON HAS MADE ME THE PERSON I AM TODAY. PLEASE PROTECT IT FOR ME PLEASE PROTECT IT FOR THE YOUTH AND ADULTS HAVE SIMILAR STORIES TO MINE. PLEASE PROTECT IT FOR THE FUTURE CHILDREN THAT HAVE NOT BEEN BORN YET THANKYOU THANKYOU ENGINE AND THEN HE IS SAID IN AN THE LIKE TRYING TO BE LIKE AN OVEN. THE CORRECT SPELLING MAIN THING IN THE DIETS I MOVED HERE TO THIS BEAUTIFUL PLACE EIGHT YEARS AGO. I'M HERE TO JUST HUMBLY REQUEST THAT YOU LISTEN TO THE VOTERS AND YOU LISTEN TO PEOPLE HERE AND I'M SURE YOUR HEARTS MANY OF YOU ARE IN THE SAME PLACE AND THERE ON THE SIDE OF CAUTION AND EXTEND THE MORATORIUM UNTIL TWENTY TWENTY SO THAT WE CAN WE CAN FIGURE OUT A WAY TO CREATE

[280:00] PROTECTIONS ARM AND ON YET TO PROTECT THE LAND THE WATER THE PEOPLE THE ANIMALS OF THIS PLACE ON AND YOU KNOW NOT NECESSARILY BAD FOR CORPORATIONS THAT WOULD EXTRACT THE RESOURCES AND THE WEALTH AND HAVE A TRACK RECORD OF GENERALLY BEING CARELESS AND GUNG ON AND NOT DOING THINGS IN THE CORRECT WAY ON. SO THANK YOU THANK YOU AND AN AFTER AND WE HAVE HAD. HELLO I AM AND LEE FOSTER. I LIVE ON IN MARTIN ACRES AS WELL. I AM HERE REPRESENTING COLORADO RISING AND I JUST WANTED TO SHARE WITH YOU GUYS SOME I HAVE FACTS ABOUT THE OIL AND GAS INDUSTRY RELATED TO COLORADO SO WE HEARD A LITTLE BIT EARLIER ON THERE BEEN FOURTEEN OIL AND GAS RELATED

[281:00] FIRES AND EXPLOSIONS IN COLORADO IN TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN ALONE AND THAT WAS AFTER THE FIRESTONE TRAGEDY THE INDUSTRY USES FOUR POINT FIVE BILLION GALLONS OF WATER A YEAR IN COLORADO AND THAT IS PERMANENTLY TAKEN OUT OF THE WATER CYCLE AND IT'S ALSO RADIOACTIVE. AND THERE'S NO WAY TO TREAT THAT I MUST STUDY OF TEN MILLION BABIES AND PENNSYLVANIA FOUND THAT INFANTS BORN WITHIN ONE KILOMETER OF A WELL OR TWENTY FIVE PERCENT MORE LIKELY TO BE BORN WITH LOW BIRTH WEIGHT AND WELD COUNTY HAS TWENTY TWO THOUSAND ACTIVE OIL AND GAS WELLS. THEY ALSO GET FIFTY PERCENT HIGHER INFANT MORTALITY RATE THAN ALL SURROUNDING COUNTIES SEEMS LIKE THERE'S A CONNECTION THERE. I CU BOULDER STUDY SHOWED THAT CHILDREN'S RISK OF BLOOD CANCERS LIKE LEUKEMIA INCREASED EIGHT TIMES IF THEY LIVE ON FIVE HUNDRED FEET FROM A WHILE FIVE HUNDRED FEET IS THEIR

[282:01] CURRENT SETBACK IN COLORADO AND THEIR TWO REPORTED SPILLS A DAY IN COLORADO OF TOXIC FRACKING FLUID AND THAT'S JUST REPORTED SO IT HAS TO BE OVER A CERTAIN AMOUNT ON THE GETS BILLED FOR IT TO BE REPORTED SO THAT'S JUST WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT. I ALSO RECENTLY AN EERIE MOTHER ON THE BOULDER SIDE ON HOW HER SON'S BLOOD TESTED FOR VOC VOLATILE ORGANIC COMPOUNDS ASSOCIATED WITH OIL AND GAS AND HER SIX YEAR OLD SON TESTED IN THE EIGHTY FIFTH PERCENTILE FOR BENZENE AND ETHEL BEEN SEEN AND SHE HAS ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY EIGHT WELLS WITHIN A MILE OF HER HOME. THESE ARE UNPRECEDENTED NUMBERS IS NO REASON A SIX YEAR OLD SHOULD BE TESTING AT THE LEVEL OF A DECADE LONG SMOKER FOR BENZENE METHYL BENZENE I ANOTHER THING I JUST FOUND OUT I RIGHT BEFORE THIS WAS EXTRACTION OIL AND GAS JUST CAME BACK WITH THEIR FIRST QUARTER EARNINGS REPORT UM THEY'RE ONE OF THE TWO

[283:00] COMPANIES IS TRYING TO DEVELOP IN BOULDER COUNTY. UM JUST IN THIS PAST QUARTER ALONE THEY REPORTED A FIFTY TWO MILLION DOLLAR LOSS AND THEIR LIABILITIES INCREASED BY ONE POINT NINE BILLION DOLLARS SO THAT'S NOT THE TYPE OF PEOPLE YOU WANT DOING BUSINESS IN BOULDER COUNTY. I AM REQUESTING THAT YOU EXTEND THE MORATORIUM AND ALSO ADOPT A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT COLORADO'S TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOOT SEA FOR SEP BACKED BALLOT INITIATIVE THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU HEATHER AND THEN CHRIS MY NAME IS HEATHER BAINES I LIVE IN TWENTY ONE O NINE OF LAKE DRIVE IN UNINCORPORATED BOULDER COUNTY AGAIN ADJACENT TO CITY OF BOULDER OPEN SPACE ABOUT TEN MINUTES NORTH OF NORTH BOULDER THIS JUST CAME UP FOR ANY OF US WHO ARE ACTIVE CITIZENS NOT PAID. NOT ON ANY PAYROLLS IS REALLY ACTIVE REALLY ENGAGED AND

[284:00] REALLY INTERESTED AND THIS JUST CAME UP TONIGHT ABOUT AN HOUR AND A HALF AGO COURTESY OF BROOMFIELD A DOCTOR THEIR NAME DOCTOR DAVID NOLAN MEMBER OF THE BROOMFIELD COMMUNITY SPOKE UP ABOUT THE LACK OF ATTENTION GIVEN TO VALUABLE RESEARCH ON THE DANGERS OF RESIDENTIAL FRACKING AND WARNS ABOUT THE POTENTIAL FUTURE DANGER THIS IGNORANCE POSES. HE'S A GASTROENTEROLOGIST WORKING WITH KAISER PERMANENTE COMPLETED HIS SCHOOLING AT CHICAGO MEDICAL SCHOOL AND THEN POST GRADUATE TRAINING AT THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE IN INTERNAL MEDICINE. HE THEN LATER ON TO BECOME CHIEF RESIDENT COMPLETED HIS FELLOWSHIP AND THE MOVE TO COLORADO STAR LIFE HERE. HE BECAME AWARE OF THIS ISSUE WHEN HIS COMMUNITY WAS ESSENTIALLY BEING ENTERED INTO A FORCE PULLING AGREEMENT AND ONE OF THE NURSES THAT HE WORKS WITH SHARED WITH HIM SOME INFORMATION THAT HE'D NEVER NEVER HEARD OF BEFORE

[285:01] INCLUDING INFORMATION BEING ADVANCED BY THE C D P HAHAH RIGHT OUR HEALTH COMMISSION AND THE COLORADO OIL AND GAS CONSERVATION COMMISSION C GCC ACRONYMS THAT HE WHEN YOU HAD PREVIOUSLY THOSE WERE FOREIGN TO HIM I'M SORRY BEGAN LOOKING INTO WHAT WE KNOW AND WHAT THE STATE IS DOING AND THAT MESSAGING FROM THE STATE AND FROM THE DOCTORS AT THE C D PH HE HE BECAME EXTREMELY DIS ORIENTED AND DISAPPOINTED ON READING SUMMARY STATEMENTS FROM THE C O G C C AS WELL AS ARTICLES CITED WITH THEM HE REALIZED QUICKLY THAT THE PROCESS OF FRACKING WAS NOT SAFE AND AT THE VERY BEST IT WAS. THAT COULD BE SAID THERE'S NOT ENOUGH DATA TO CONCLUDE THAT IT'S HARMFUL BUT HE KNOWS THAT IT'S NOT SAFE. SINCE THEN THERE'VE BEEN SINCE THAT TIME HE CAME

[286:00] TO THAT CONCLUSION. THERE'VE BEEN SEVERAL HIGH IMPACT ARTICLES PUBLISHED FROM POWERHOUSE ACADEMIC INSTITUTION INSTITUTIONS ALL THESE ARTICLES HAVE BEEN WELL WRITTEN AND PEER REVIEWED AND UNFORTUNATELY ALSO SIGNIFICANT MEDICAL RISK THE MOST CONFOUNDING OF WHICH ARE THOSE DEMONSTRATING AND UP TO FOUR FOLD INCREASED RISK OF ACUTE LYMPHATIC LEUKEMIA LEUKEMIA AND PEOPLE LIVING WITHIN ONE THOUSAND FEET OF OIL AND GAS OPERATIONS. MORE RECENTLY THIS HAS BEEN BACKED BY A CITY FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO SHOWING AN EIGHT FOLD INCREASED LIFETIME RISK OF CANCER IN THOSE CLOSEST TO OIL AND GAS OPERATIONS WITHIN FIVE HUNDRED FEET HE GOES ON AND ON AND ON TO TALK ABOUT THE HEALTH RISKS AND WHAT HE BASICALLY SAYS IS THAT NOT ONLY DO WE NEED A TWENTY TO TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOOT SETBACK WE WOULD DO BETTER TO GO THIRTY FIVE HUNDRED FEET SO PLEASE DO ADOPT A RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THE TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOOT SETBACK AND PLEASE ALSO EXTEND THE MORATORIUM THANK YOU THANK YOU CHRIS AND THEN

[287:04] MICAH CRYSTAL RED LONGMONT GOOD EVENING COUNCIL. I'M HERE TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF ROCKY MOUNTAIN PEACE AND JUSTICE CENTER. THANK YOU TO THE COUNCIL FOR HAVING THIS ITEM ON YOUR AGENDA TONIGHT AND THANK YOU TO EVERYONE HERE FOR SPEAKING ON THIS ISSUE TONIGHT WE'RE LEARNING MORE EACH DAY ABOUT THIS ISSUE AND SEEING MORE NEWS AND MORE RESEARCH AND I WOULD LIKE TO ASK THAT THE COUNCIL PLEASE EXTEND THE MORATORIUM UNTIL TWENTY TWENTY I'M ALSO HERE IN SOLIDARITY WITH COLORADO RISING AND WOULD LIKE TO ASK THAT THE COUNCIL PLEASE PASS A RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF THE COLORADO RISE IN BALLOT INITIATIVE AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME THANK YOU MICAH AND THEN THE SHARMA

[288:02] HIGH COUNCIL MEMBERS MAYORS MIKE A PARK AND I RESIDE AT TWENTY EIGHT SIXTY ONE ELLISON PLACE. I'M SPEAKING TODAY ON BEHALF OF THREE FIFTY BOULDER WE ARE PRESENT AROUND TWO THOUSAND BOULDER RIGHTS AND FOURTEEN THOUSAND MEMBERS STATEWIDE WHO ARE CALLING FOR SAFE JUST AND HEALTHY FUTURE FOR CHILDREN AND FUTURE GENERATIONS. WE URGE YOU TO EXTEND THE MORATORIUM ON OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT ON CITY OF BOULDER LANDON OPEN SPACE FOR AS LONG AS POSSIBLE WITH SEVENTY EIGHT PERCENT VOTER SUPPORT FOR MORATORIUM ON FRACKING DURING THE LAST VOTE AND WITH THREATS ARE NEIGHBORHOODS IN OPEN SPACE LAND EVEN MORE IMMINENT NOW WE DO NOT FEEL THAT A VOTE IS NECESSARY BUT INSTEAD ENCOURAGE COUNCIL TO TAKE ACTION TO PROTECT RESIDENTS DIRECTLY IN ADDITION WE ASK COUNCIL TO PASS RESOLUTION OF SUPPORT FOR THE CAR ARISING BALLOT INITIATIVE WHICH WILL CREATE TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOOT BUFFER ZONES BETWEEN OIL AND GAS OPERATIONS UNOCCUPIED BUILDINGS SUCH AS HOMES AND SCHOOLS AND VULNERABLE AREA SUCH AS PLAYGROUNDS OPEN SPACE LAND WHICH THE PORT OF COURSE FOR ALL OF US AND WATER SOURCES THE BALLOT INITIATIVE CAMPAIGN IS COLLECTING SIX SIGNATURES NOW FOR PLACEMENT ON THIS

[289:00] NOVEMBER'S BALLOT AS OTHERS HAVE NOTED TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOOT BUFFER ZONES ALIGN WITH HEALTH STUDIES INCLUDING THE DOCTOR LISA MCKENZIE WHO PRESENTED TONIGHT SHOWING INCREASES IN CERTAIN TYPES OF CANCERS BIRTH DEFECTS RESPIRATORY PROBLEMS LOW WITH LOW BIRTH WEIGHT BABIES AND OTHER ISSUES TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FEET NEARLY A HALF MILE IS ALSO THE DISTANCE THAT IS FREQUENTLY EVACUATED WHEN THEIR FIRES AND EXPLOSIONS AT OIL AND GAS SITES HAVE BEEN FOURTEEN SUCH FIRES EXPLOSIONS IN COLORADO SINCE THE FIRESTONE EXPLOSION THAT KILLED TWO MEN SEVERELY BURNED WOMAN TEACHER AND INJURED A CHILD IN A RECENT POLL SIXTY NINE PERCENT OF VOTERS STATEWIDE AND ACROSS THE POLITICAL SPECTRUM SUPPORT INCREASING CRACKING SETBACKS TO TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FEET OF CITY COUNCIL SUPPORT FOR THE INITIATIVE WOULD BE IN ALIGNMENT WITH VOTERS' VALUES OF PROTECTING OUR OPEN SPACE LAND APART PRIORITIZING HEALTH ENVIRONMENT AIR WATER AND OUR GLOBAL CLIMATE SO WE HOPE YOU'LL PASS THE RESOLUTION OF SUPPORT FOR THE TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED FOOT SETBACKS IN THE SHIP'S NIGHT THAT I JUST PASSED AROUND AN EMAIL TO YOU EARLIER TODAY WE SAW IT

[290:00] UNFORTUNATELY STATE NATIONAL AUTHORITIES ARE UTTERLY FAILING THE PEOPLE OF COLORADO ARE STATE REGULATORY BODY THE SU GCC HAS APPEALED THE MARTINEZ COURT DECISION THAT DIRECTED THEM TO PRIORITIZE HEALTH AND SAFETY AS A PRECONDITION TO PERMITTING OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT RUBBER STAMP BODY FOR THE INDUSTRY APPROVING WAS ONLY FIVE HUNDRED FEET FROM HOMES A THOUSAND FEET FROM SCHOOLS AND RIGHT BY PLAYGROUNDS AND BALL FIELDS WE THINK CITY COUNCIL ARE ACTING RESPONSIBLY IN THE FACE OF THIS THREAT FROM A FINANCIALLY FAILING FRACKING INDUSTRY THAT IS BEING KEPT IN BUSINESS TO WALL STREET INVESTORS WHO SKIM OFF PROFITS FROM THE LENDING INDUSTRY ALREADY LEAVING ABANDONED WELLS ENVIRONMENTAL DESTRUCTION AND RUINED LIVES IN THEIR WAKE DURING THESE PAST THREE YEARS MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED AND SIXTEEN U S OIL AND GAS COMPANIES FILED IN BANKRUPTCY COURTS. THE BIGGEST SIXTY FIRMS IN AGGREGATE HAVE AROUND NINE BILLION PER QUARTER ON AVERAGE FOR THE LAST HAVE LOST HIM SORRY AROUND NINE BILLION PER QUARTER ON AVERAGE LAST FIVE YEARS WHICH IS CUMULATIVE ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY BILLION DOLLARS IN OPERATING LOSSES

[291:00] WE ENCOURAGE EVERYONE WATCHING THIS MEETING TO GO TO CO RISING DOOR TO FIND OUT WHERE TO SONIC ON THE RISE IN BALLOT INITIATIVE AND THANK YOU SO MUCH COUNCIL MEMBERS FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE. THANK YOU MICHAEL. OH DID YOU AND SHUT THE ARE THOSE STAFF. HELLO COUNCIL AND THE SHAM ABRAHAM I LIVE IT FOURTEEN SIXTY QUINCE AVENUE BOULDER. THOUGH THREE OF FOUR AND SOME OF YOU HAVEN'T MET BEFORE HELLO I WANNA THANK FIRST STAFF BETHANY FOR THAT REALLY GREAT STATS AROUND THEM IN OR RIGHT IT'S REALLY HELPFUL TO US AND I'M HERE TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF ORDINANCE EIGHT TWO FIVE THREE TO PUT IN PLACE EMERGENCY MORATORIUM ON OIL AND GAS DRILLING PERMITS ON CITY OWNED OPEN SPACE THROUGH JUNE THIRD TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY. I SAY THAT ON BEHALF OF MYSELF ON BEHALF OF THE ORGANIZATION I HELPED CO

[292:00] FOUND CULT UNDERGROUND WHERE THE CITIZEN GROUP TO HELP PROTECT BOULDER COUNTY OPEN SPACE AGAINST ANY NEW OIL AND GAS ABOUT AND ALSO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THE SIERRA CLUB CHAIR OF THE OIL AND GAS TEAM FOR BOULDER COUNTY. SO I WAS PART OF THE GROUP SIX YEARS AGO MY HELP START TREK FREE BOULDER AND WE GOT SEVENTY PERCENT OF THE VOTES AT THAT POINT AND THAT WAS BEFORE THIS REALLY IMMINENT THREAT I MEAN OVER ELEVEN THOUSAND ACRES OF OPEN SPACE AND CONSERVATION EASEMENT SO IF I WAS GOING TO MAKE A GUESS I WOULD SAY PROBABLY NINETY FIVE TO NINETY EIGHT PERCENT OF BOULDER VOTERS WOULD BE IN FAVOR OF THIS AVOIDANCE EIGHTY FIVE THREE SO I WOULD SAY THERE'S NO NEED TO BRING IT TO VOTE WE KNOW WE HAVE VOTER SUPPORT FOR THAT EXTENDED TO TWENTY TWENTY ONE AND I THINK VERY MUCH CITY

[293:00] ATTORNEY TOM CARR FOR REALLY GREAT PRESENTATION I WANT TO ECHO SOMETHING HE SAID ABOUT THE MARTINEZ CASE THAT CASE HE SAID THE OUTCOME WILL BE CRUCIAL. SO AT THIS POINT I'M THE MARTINEZ CASE IS COLORADO LAW AND I DON'T THINK THAT THIS IS NECESSARILY GOING TO BE A SLAM DUNK THAT WE'RE GOING TO GET. WE HAVE TO FIGHT AGAINST THESE OIL AND GAS DRILLING PERMITS THE STONE AND EIGHT NORTH EXTRACTION FOR RIGHT NOW THEY SHOULD NOT BE ISSUING ANY DRILLING PERMITS. THAT'S WHAT THE MARTINEZ'S DECISION SAYS SO I'D LIKE TO INVITE COUNCIL TO PLEASE CONSIDER ACTUALLY ADDITION TO THE AMICUS BRIEF CONSIDER HELPING FUND THAT BECAUSE THE ATTORNEY THAT IS BRINGING THAT FORTH THAT GOES TO THE CAR OCCUR APPEALS WHICH WE AGREE IS AND THE TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN THAT WE NEED EVERY HELP POSSIBLE AND THAT ACTUALLY IS WHAT WILL PROTECT THE OPEN SPACE READING THAT DECISION AT THE COURT OF APPEALS AND

[294:00] SO YES AN ORDINANCE EIGHT TWO FIVE THREE. I GUESS OUR CAR RISING. WE NEED THAT ORDINANCE SO YOUR SUPPORT WITH JUST AGAIN EXTEND THE LEADERSHIP THAT YOU'VE ALREADY OFFERED. IT'S GREAT THAT WE HAVE ALSO THE LAWSUIT AGAINST EX AND SOME COURSE OR JUST GREAT WORK CITY COUNCIL THANK YOU THANK YOU SHAWNA LYNN YET THIS LITTLE TABLE THE ONE AND ONLY RECENTLY WENT ON A FIRST NAME BASIS AND THE NOISE SAME FIRST NAME FIRST WHEN SINGLE THEN DIRI ARE ACTUALLY SINCE I DON'T HAVE TO SAY MY DRESS. IT'S A MOUNTAIN HEIGHTS. I LIVE IN MOUNTAIN HUTS AND I WANTED TO SAY I AM I'VE BEEN COLD AND HIDE FOR SEVENTEEN YEARS BECAUSE HALF OF MY HOUSE THE ADDITION PART DOESN'T

[295:00] HAVE HEAT OR COOLING AND NICK AND I WAS ALMOST READY TO PUT MANY SPLITS UP. THIS IS YOU KNOW A GOOD THING TO DO AGAINST GAS. I JUST WANTED TO PROVE THE POINT THAT I'M I'M STAYING COLD AND HIGH BECAUSE I'M WAITING I'M NOT WANTING TO USE GAS SO THE AND AND I'M WAITING IN PARTICULAR FOR APOLLO HYBRID WITH AN INVENTION THAT SAYS GAS FIRED STEAM GENERATOR BUT IT REDUCES OUR GAS USAGE BY FIFTY OR SIXTY SIX PERCENT DEPENDING ON IF YOU HAVE AN ELECTRIC OR GAS DRYER SO I THINK THAT'S PRETTY GOOD AND ALSO I BROUGHT UP ISSUES WITH THAT GUY THAT'S INVENTED IT ABOUT ITS USE OF GAS AND HE SAID HE WAS PLANNING ON RETROFITTING IT TO HYDROGEN PRESSURE HYDROGEN THAT SAFE SO UM THAT'S ALSO

[296:04] ENCOURAGING AND I WANTED TO BRING UP ALSO MY MOM I BELIEVE DIED OF AND PART YOU KNOW THE RADIOACTIVE CONTAMINATION BIT LEUKEMIA SO I'M PRETTY COGNIZANT OF THE BENZENE AT LISA MCKENZIE WAS TALKING ABOUT AND YOU KNOW HER AND RANDY WERE WHINERS TESTIMONY IT HE CAME A FEW MONTHS AGO TO TALK ABOUT HOW WE HAVE A LOT OF WINS HERE AND I'D NEVER REALIZED MY MOM COULD HAVE BEEN EXPOSED SHE DIED IN THE LATE SIXTIES BUT WE WERE HERE THERE'S A GERMAN CAFE'S THIS IS WHY KENYANS ARE PROBLEMS YOU CAN'T TRACE PEOPLE COHORT STUDIES AND STUFF SO IT COULD HAVE BEEN SHE WAS EXPOSED HERE AT THAT WAS PROBABLY IN SALT LAKE CITY RADIO ACTIVE PART OF THE PARTICULARS BUT THEY MOVED THE POINT IS YOU KNOW THESE FRACKING AIR POLLUTION ISSUES WERE AROUND ALOT AND

[297:01] RANDY TO BRING THAT UP AND I'D NEVER REALIZED HERE SO I ALSO WENT TO THE LINE FROM I MEAN OF COURSE I SUPPORT ACTUALLY A BAND BUT YOU KNOW MORATORIUM EXTENSION. THANKS THANK YOU SO WITH THAT WE'RE GOING TO CLOSE NOTE NO NO SORRY SORRY SORRY. YET JUST EMAIL US. I'M SORRY I HAVE TO ACHIEVE LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE IN THE CLOSING OF THE COMMENT EVER GOING TO TURN TO THE LIST OF QUESTIONS. I'M READY TO JUMP RIGHT IN THE STATE MAKING DECISIONS TODAY HAVE TO HAVE WHEN YOU HAVE ONE QUESTION TO TOM. WHY IS THIS BEING EXTENDED OR IF WE VOTE ON THIS TWENTY TWENTY WHY NOT FARTHER OUT BECAUSE

[298:00] THE SUPREME COURT SAID FIVE YEARS WAS TOO LONG THOUGH AND I'M WORRIED EVOCATION YEARS MIGHT BE TOO LONG THEY DIDN'T SAY HOW LONG WAS OKAY. ROUTE NINE AND MY RECOMMENDATION IS TWO YEARS IS ABOUT AS LONG AS I THINK IS DEFENSIBLE AND I THINK ALSO WE MAY HAVE A BETTER IDEA BOTH IN WHAT WE CAN DO IS A PLANNING STAFF AND WHAT THE MARTINEZ CASE ASIDE IN TWO YEARS SO THAT'S THAT YEAR I WENT THINKING OKAY SO I'D LIKE TO JUMP IN AND LEAD ON THE FRONT AND SAY THAT THE DISCOURSE TO THIS BUT I THINK THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT CLEARLY A PEOPLE CARE ABOUT I THINK THE I SUPPORT FOR THE LESS MORATORIUM AND SEVENTY PERCENT STANCE AND I THINK RATHER THAN PUTTING ON A BALLOT AGAIN WE SHOULD JUST EXTEND THE MORATORIUM TO ENTER TWENTY TWENTY. DOES ANYBODY DISAGREE WITH THAT YOU'RE HERE. OK SO THAT JUST FOR THE FIRST TO THINK WE NEED THAT TIME TAMMY MARTINEZ

[299:01] CASES AGAIN IT COULD BE A GAME CHANGER AND SO CLEARLY WHEN THE OUTCOME OF A HUGE IMPACT ON WHAT HAPPENS. AND OF COURSE WE WERE GOING TO UPDATE OUR REGULATIONS IS GOING TO TAKE A LITTLE WHILE SO I THINK THAT'S JUSTIFIED THREE OTHER THINGS SEPARATION TECH SHE WANTED TO SPEAK TO THAT IF YOU IF YOU DON'T MIND I BROUGHT THIS IDEA FORWARD EVAN TALKING TO SOME FOLKS IN OTHER PARTS OF THE COUNTY IN LONGMONT AND LAFAYETTE LEWISVILLE BROOMFIELD ABOUT THIS IDEAS CAN BE MOLDED AROUND US AS A POSSIBLE NEW TOOL IN THE PREVENTION AND MITIGATION OF OIL AND GAS DRILLING. SOO I MEAN HASN'T BEEN DONE BEFORE BUT THERE ARE OTHER PEOPLE TALKING ABOUT AND THERE'S THE POTENTIAL FOR MULTIPLE CITIES TO PASS THIS THIS YEAR IN THE NEXT YEAR IN A WAY THAT COULD BECAUSE YOU DRILLING IS POSSIBLE IN PART BECAUSE IT'S ARTIFICIALLY CHEAP BECAUSE PEOPLE HAVE TO PAY THE TRUE COSTS OF EXTRACTION AND THIS WOULD BE A WAY OF MITIGATING THAT SO I THINK IT'S AN IDEA WORTH CONSIDERING AND I THINK WE

[300:00] CAN ALSO CONTINUE TO WORK WITH POTENTIAL PARTNERS IN OTHER CITIES ABOUT THE BEST WAY CUZ APPRECIATE CANDOR THE WORK THAT YOU'VE BEEN DOING ON THIS END AND WE STILL HAVE SOMETHINGS TO GET FLESHED OUT AS WE CAN MAYBE HAVE SOME PARTNERS AS A WAY TO EXPLORE THAT SIDE LOVE TO SEE THIS MOVE FORWARD AND HAS CONTINUED AND NOW YOU DO YOU THINK YOU SHOULD TRY TO HIT THIS BALLOT WE SHOULD TRY IT A TRY IF WE GET FURTHER INTO THE YEAR AND STUFF STILL NEEDS TO BE FLESHED OUT WE COULD CONSIDER NEXT YEAR BUT WAS TO CLARIFY THAT OUR FOLKS IN SUPPORT OF EXPANDING STEP FURTHER EXPLORE THE EDGE THAT ONE COMMENT ON ONE AND THE REASONS I HEARD FROM SUPPORTERS OF THE STATEWIDE RESOLUTION TO GO AHEAD AND MOVE FORWARD WITH PASSING A MORATORIUM AT THE COUNCIL LEVEL WAS SO THAT THEY DIDN'T HAVE TO PUSH FOR A BALLOT MEASURE IN BOULDER'S I JUST WANT TO MAKE THE COMMENT THAT THE ONLY COUNTER BAILING. I'M ALL FOR THIS I WOULD LIKE TO EXPLORE IT. THE OWNER

[301:01] COUNTERED RAILING THING TO HAPPEN ON THIS PALETTE WOULD JUST BE GOING TO DISTRACT AND I THINK WE CAN HEAR FROM THE COMMUNITY AS WE MOVE FORWARD TO DEVELOP IT ON WHAT THEIR THOUGHTS ARE BUT I'M ALL FOR THE IDEA AND IN PRINCIPLE I WOULD PUT IT ON THIS BALLOT IS WHEN I THINK IT WOULD BE MORE POWERFUL FOOD ENDS UP BEING THAT OF THE COMMUNITIES ARE FEELING SIMILARLY. AND THAT'S A CONVERSATION TO BE AT TEL IN GENERAL PEOPLE I AGAIN AGREE WITH STEPH EXPLORING THIS AND WE CAN CONTINUE TO DISCUSS TIMING. OK ON ERM OPEN SPACE STAFF. I GUESS MY THOUGHT ON THIS TO RESEARCH ARE DOING IS VERY HOPEFUL I WOULD LIKE TO HAVE A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT'S MOST AT RISK. I ALSO THINK THAT ACTUALLY SPENDING MORE MONEY TO ACQUIRE RATES ARM WARMERS FORCED POOLING IS WHAT IT IS I IS LESS POWERFUL BUT I GUESS WE WILL SAY IS I THINK

[302:00] WE SHOULD WORK HARD TO GET THE FORCE PULLING LAWS IN TRUE STATEWIDE. I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW MORE ABOUT WETLANDS ARE AT RISK. HOWEVER I WOULD JUST SAY ALSO THAT THE ONE BENEFIT THAT THIS HAS IS FORCING DRILLING OFF OF THE LAND ITSELF SO IF YOU ACQUIRE THE MINERAL RIGHTS AND FORCE POOLED WITH SOMEBODY ELSE THEY CAN'T PUT THE WELL PAD ON YOUR PROPERTY ON YOUR OPEN SPACE PROPERTY SO I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING YOU SAID BUT IF WE'RE GOING TO PRIORITIZE THINK IT SHOULD BE PLACES WHERE WE'RE AT RISK FOR HAVING THEM COME ON BECAUSE FORCE PULLING YOUR RIGHT THAT THE STATE LEVEL THING BUT I WOULD REALLY HATE TO SEE A DRILL RIG ON SOME OF OUR OPEN SPACE AND I DISAGREE THAT I GUESS THE QUESTION IS IN TERMS OF ACTUALLY DOING TO DEVI DEVELOP THE SPECIFIC PLAN OR MORE TO SPEND A TON OF TIME GIVEN THE PRICE TAG IT WOULD BE HUGE. SO ANYHOW

[303:00] FOUR DOWN THAT ROAD WE WANT TO GO WITH IT YET. I AGREE IN THAT I THINK CONTINUE YOUR EFFORTS TO TO INVENTORY AND FIGURE OUT ALL THE DETAILS AND THEN WHAT THE RISKS ARE AND THEN YOU KNOW OVER TIME WE CAN LOOK AT WHAT THE MAPS ARE IN RISK LEVELS AND POSSIBLE PRESENT YOU KNOW THIS IS I THINK WORTH HAVING ON OPEN SPACES WORK PLAN ITEM TO CONTINUE LOOKING AT THIS BUT BUT I WOULDN'T SAY THAT NOW IS THE TIME TO JUMP IN AND SPEND TENS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS ALL KNOW THAT THERE WAS A BILL IN THE STATE LEGISLATURE IN THE HOUSE TO SPECIFICALLY EXEMPT OPEN SPACE LANDS FROM FORCED POOLING AND PASSED THE HOUSE AND SENATE FAILED IN A SENATE COMMITTEE BUT IF THE LEGISLATURE CHANGES WE COULD VERY WELL SEE A SIMILAR BILL THAT WOULD SPECIFICALLY EXEMPT OPEN SPACE LANDS FROM FORCED POOLING AND WE GET SOMETHING LIKE THAT DONE THEN I THINK WE MAYBE THINK A LITTLE BIT MORE SERIOUSLY ABOUT SPENDING THE MONEY TO ACQUIRE THE RIGHTS TO SET SO OKAY TO CONTINUE RESEARCH ARM

[304:00] BUT STOP SHORT OF COMING UP WITH A PLAN TO SPEND LOTS OF MONEY ON AND FOCUS ON TRYING TO GET FORCE PULLING IMPROVED AT THE STATE LEVEL I GUESS I WOULD SAY THAT I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE RESULTS ONCE THE INVENTORY IS COMPLETE BECAUSE IF THERE'S SOME PARTICULAR AT RISK LAND SO IT WOULD BE A FEW MILLION DOLLARS OUT OF THE FUNDS AND WILL KIND OF SLOWING DOWN ON LAND ACQUISITION ANYWAY IT MIGHT BE WORTH IT SIA. I JUST WANNA HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO RETURN TO THAT AND REVIEW IT SO HAVE OPEN SPACE BOARD OF TRUSTEES REVERED AND HAVE US LOOK AT IT WITH THEIR RECOMMENDATION AND I TOTALLY AGREE WITH THAT. SO I'M HAPPY TO SPEND SOME OPEN SPACE MONEY ON ACQUISITION OF THAT IS AN IMPORTANT PIECE TO WRITE SO FINISHED RESEARCH AND MOST HAVE A REVIEW BY BOTH THE BOARD IN US ON THE LAST ONE I WOULD SAY IT'S PREMATURE PREMATURE FOR THIS FALL TO ADD A BULLET TO THIS

[305:01] YEAR WHICH IS THE REQUEST BY THE PROPONENTS TO DO A RESOLUTION. I MEAN I SIGNED THE INITIATIVE FOR THIS ARM AND SUPPORT OF THE INITIATIVE I WOULD LIKE TO TAKE JUST A LITTLE TIME AND HAVE STAFF LOOK AT THIS AND I ALSO THINK IT WILL BE MORE POWERFUL THE PASS IT AT SEVEN O'CLOCK ONE NIGHT WHEN MORE PEOPLE ARE WATCHING BENNETT WILL BE TO PASS THAT TEN THIRTY SO I GUESS I WOULD JUST SAY IF WE CAN SEND THIS TO STAFF AND HAVE CC SCHEDULE IT PRETTY SOON I'M HAPPY TO DO A RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF IT BUT I WOULD LIKE TO JUST GET A TWO PAGE STAT MEMO AND WE MIGHT PUT OUR BOWL DISH BEEN ON THIS. YES AND IT'S LAST QUESTION HIS COUNSEL INTEREST IN CONSIDERING A BALLOT ISSUE I GUESS I WANT TO HEAR FROM OPEN SPACE ABOUT WHAT IT WOULD TAKE TO ACQUIRE MINERAL RIGHTS AND ARE OPEN SPACE. ME AND I DON'T THINK THIS IS

[306:01] SOME THAT WE CAN JUST SAY OH WELL NEXT YEAR OR WE CAN DO THAT AND THE FOLLOWING YEAR WE CAN DO THAT RIGHT. I AM BLOWN AWAY AT HOW QUICKLY WINTER BEING DEVELOPED FOR OIL AND GAS IN ALL WE HAD TO DO IS LOOK AT THE MAGAZINE LAST MONTH COLORADO MUNICIPALITIES AND THE AMOUNT OF OIL AND GAS BEING PRODUCED IN ALONG THE FRONT RANGE IS EXPONENTIAL AND I AM VERY CONCERNED ABOUT IT AND IT'S JUST GOING TO CONTINUE GOING UP THAT CURVE AND TELL IT'S COMPLETELY DEPLETED SO I I WOULD REALLY LIKE THE EMERGENCY SO COULD I ANSWER THAT I PREFER NOT TO HAVE BETHANY IT RESPOND TO THAT IN BECAUSE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SORT OF IMPORTANT REAL ESTATE TRANSACTIONS AND PROVIDE YOU WITH MORE INFO CAJUN GOOD OF FRIENDS CRUMB ANY NUMBER WE GAVE YOU TONIGHT WOULD JUST BE A GUESS OKAY BECAUSE I THINK THAT WE NEED TO COME

[307:00] THE NEED TO COMPLETE THE WORK THAT THEY'RE DOING AND HAVE A MORE STRATEGIC APPROACH TO WHAT THEY'D WANT TO ACQUIRE AND LET US BRING THAT THROUGH THE PROCESS RATHER THAN JUST GIVE YOU A NUMBER TONIGHT THAT'S FINE BUT YOU HAD THIS QUESTION AND AT THE BOTTOM WHEN I AM INTERESTED BUT I'D LIKE TO GET MORE INFORMATION. SO I DON'T WANNA JUST TAKE IT OFF YES FOR NON CONSIDERATION SO IF ALREADY A COULD PUT A MOTION FORWARD TICKETS TO ONE OF THE QUESTIONS OWN UNLESS YOU WANTED TO AND WOULD LOVE TO OK THE I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO INTRODUCE AN ORDER PUBLISHED. WELL SORRY A MOTION TO INTRODUCE AND ADOPT EMERGENCY ORDINANCE EIGHT TWO FIVE THREE TO IMPOSE A MORATORIUM ON THE ACCEPTANCE AND PROCESSING OF APPLICATIONS FOR DRILLING PERMITS ON CITY OF BOULDER OPEN SPACE PROPERTIES FOR USE PREVIEW OF NEW MINING INDUSTRY USES INVOLVING OIL AND GAS EXTRACTION EXTENDING THE EXISTING MORATORIUM UNTIL

[308:01] JUNE THIRD. TWENTY TWENTY SECONDS IT'S A ROLL CALL UP LIVES CAN SAY FOR ME TO SPEECHES I THINK IF WE THINK THE SORT OF SET IT. OK THEN LET US VOTE. OK WE START WITH COUNCILMEMBER WEAVER YATES YOUNG I ROCK A CARLISLE. I KNOW I JONES. I MERGE DOWN ENTHUSIASTICALLY I IN A BOW ALSO ENTHUSIASTICALLY I MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY THANK YOU THANK YOU THE KID A THANK YOU ALL FOR COMING APPRECIATE THEIR FINAL HEARING IS A MOTION TO ADOPT ORDINANCE EIGHTY TO EIGHTY FOUR REGARDING THE FIRST ADJUSTMENT TO THE BASE BUDGET FOR TWENTY EIGHTEEN THE US SO

[309:02] SPECIAL RECOGNITION TO KATIE DOLING OUR BUDGET OFFICER FOR STAYING SO LATE. TALK ABOUT YET. HOPEFULLY THIS WILL TAKE FIVE MINUTES AND HELPFUL THE PRESENTATION THING IS THAT WE HAD A SUPPLEMENTAL TICKETS ARE GOOD EVENING AND GAVE A QUICK PRESENTATION THE NICE THING IS THAT WE HAD A SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION A FEW MONTHS BACKS A LOT OF THIS INFORMATION HAS ALREADY BEEN SAID BUT IF YOU HAVE CLARIFYING QUESTIONS HAPPY TO ANSWER AT THAT TIME AS A REMINDER THE SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET IS OPPORTUNITY FOR COUNCIL TO APPROVE BUDGET APPROPRIATION ABOVE AND BEYOND WHAT THE TWENTY EIGHTEEN BASE BUDGET IS REALLY BASED PIONEER NEW OR ADDITIONAL REVENUES I RECEIVE THAT WE DIDN'T ANTICIPATE IN THE PRIOR YEAR WHEN DEVELOPING THE BUDGET PROJECTS THAT MAN STARTED IN THE PRIOR YEAR BAKED INFORMATION WE NEED TO CARRY OVER THAT BUDGET OR AGAIN ADDITIONAL GRANT REVENUES THAT MAY SPAN MULTIPLE YEARS THE CITY OF BOULDER'S TO FORM ALL SUPPLEMENTAL PROCESS AS

[310:03] AN OCCASION LIKE I MENTIONED WILL DO A APPROPRIATION THAT IS OUTSIDE THE NORMAL CYCLES SUCH AS WE DID BACK IN FEBRUARY FOR THE SPECIAL TAXES THAT WERE PASSED LAST YEAR IN THE BALLOT ARE TWO TYPES OF ADJUSTMENTS THAT WE TYPICALLY CATEGORIZE AND ONE IS A CARRY OVER SARAH AGAIN THE PROJECTS ARE THE TREE AND SO OR OPERATING AND PROJECTS THAT BEGAN IN ONE YEAR AND BUYS COLORADO LAW YOU NEED APPROPRIATE THE FULL DOLLAR AMOUNT IN THE FIRST YEAR BUT WE KNOW THAT OFTENTIMES THESE PROJECTS PAN TO THREE YEARS SO THEN CARRY OVER DOLLARS ALLOW DEPARTMENTS TO FINISH UP THEIR PROJECTS. YEAR OVER YEAR AND THEN THE SECOND TYPE IS WHAT WE CALL BUDGET SUPPLEMENTAL AND TYPICALLY THIS WILL COME FROM NEW REVENUES AND OCCASIONALLY THEY'LL COME FROM FUND BALANCE OR SAVINGS THAT HAVE BEEN ACCUMULATED. SO FOR THIS TWENTY EIGHTEEN BUDGET SUPPLEMENTAL YEAR FOR SUPPLEMENTAL IS TYPICALLY THE LARGEST BECAUSE OF THOSE PROJECT CARRY OVERS SO THE GENERAL FUND. WE HAVE A

[311:00] TWELVE POINT SEVEN SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS OR ASK FOR SUPPLEMENTAL IS A LARGE PORTION OF THE ELEVEN PLANE ALMOST NINE MILLION DOLLARS IS COMING FROM KERRY OVER APPROPRIATIONS BOTH FROM THOSE OPERATING PROJECTS AS WELL AS YOUR CAPITAL PROJECTS ARE INCUMBENT SAYS AND THEN EIGHT HUNDRED AND NINETY FOUR THOUSAND IS FROM BUDGET SUPPLEMENTAL THEY THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT OVER HALF OF THOSE ARE COMING FROM ADDITIONAL REVENUE SOURCES SO GRANTS ARE TYPICALLY IN THAT CATEGORY AND THEN FROM THE RESTRICTED FUNDS WE HAVE A HUNDRED AND FORTY TWO MILLION DOLLARS IN BUDGET APPROPRIATION BEING REQUESTED AGAIN THE LARGEST PORTION OF IT CARRYING OVER FROM CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS AND THEN OUT OF THE BUDGET SUPPLEMENTAL WHICH IS ABOUT THREE POINT FIVE MILLION AND NINETY TWO PERCENT ARE COMING FROM ADDITIONAL REVENUE SOURCES A WHILE SO WE JUST WANT PROVIDE A FEW EXAMPLES OF SUPPLEMENTAL ZOMBIE SENIOR PACKAGE FOR FULL DETAILS OF WHAT EACH ONE IS REQUESTED TO

[312:00] CARRY OVERS IN THE GENERAL FUND IT'S EXAMPLES LIKE THE HILL GARAGE PROGRAM OR THE E FLEX REBATE PROGRAM AS WELL AS OUR RENEWABLE ENERGY PROGRAM THAT THESE ARE PROGRAMS THAT CAN T O YEAR OVER YEAR AND WE BASE ADDITIONAL REVENUES OFF OF THIS CARRY OVER PROJECT AND IN THE BUDGET SUPPLEMENTAL AND NEW FOR THIS YEAR BASED ON THE DIRECTION OF THE COUNCIL RETREAT IS ONE A HALF TEA FOR PLANNING YOU'LL SEE THIS IN THE RESTRICTED FUNDS AS WELL JUST HOW THEY SPLIT UP HOW THE GENERAL FUND AND CAPTURE SOME OF THE WORK IN THE RESTRICTED FUNDS DO AS WELL. CITYWIDE COMPENSATION STUDY AND ALSO ACKNOWLEDGING A GRANT THEY RECEIVED FOR A MAYOR'S CHALLENGE TO THE BLOOMBERG RAM PROCESS ONE IMPORTANT THING TO KNOW HERE IS THAT UM ADJUSTMENTS TO BASE ARE TYPICALLY CONSIDERED ONE TIME IN NATURE THE ONE EXCEPTION DURING THIS ADJUSTMENT A BASE IS GOING TO BE THESE THREE ATC'S FOR PLANNING ONE AND HALF IN GENERAL FUND AND ONE HALF IN RESTRICTED FUNDS AND IN

[313:02] RESTRICTED FUNDS SOME OF THE CARRY OVERS ARE CARRY OVER PROJECTS RELATED TO THE FIRST NEW CULTURE AND SAFETY TAX ALSO FINDING FOR OUR CAMI HOUSING ASSISTANCE PROGRAM AND THE LEAK REPLACEMENT PROJECT AND THEN SUPPLEMENTAL ZZ AGAIN JUST A FEW EXAMPLES BECAUSE MOST OF THEM CAME FROM REVENUE SOURCES INCLUDE THE PLANNING POSITIONS AS WELL AS ON THE BOULDER RESERVOIR WATER TREATMENT SOLAR PROJECT WHICH THEY RECEIVED GRANT FUNDING FOR SCHOOL. RIGHT VERY QUICKLY KAY SAID. AND SO ARE REQUESTING THAT STAFF CONSIDERS A MOTION IN THE FORM OF ADOPTING HORNETS EIGHTY TWO FORTY EIGHT NEW QUESTIONS QUESTIONS TO YOU BECAUSE I HAD A DECISION ABOUT THIS SPECIFICALLY BUT I HAD A REQUEST THAT IN SOME OF THE BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS YOU'RE MAKING ITEMS WAS REDUCTION IN TRANSIT FUNDING AND GIVE ME

[314:00] FURTHER UPDATES ON ON THAT YES WE DO AND HAVING TO SHARE A FEW I INCLUDE SO AS YOU KNOW AND THE TRANSPORTATION DIVISION IS SUPPORTED LARGELY BY SALES AND TAX OVER SEVENTY PERCENT SO IN LIEU OF THE RECENT DISCUSSIONS AROUND FLATTENING SALES AND TAX THEY HAD TO REALLY LOOK HARD AT THEIR BUDGET AND DECIDE WHAT BOTH IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN AND THEN FURTHER OUT THEY NEEDED TO CUT SO THE REDUCTION IN TRANSIT SERVICE IS RELATED TO THE JUMP AND BOUNCE SERVICES SO AS YOU KNOW WE JOINTLY FIND WITH RTD THE CITY AND CEO SOME OF THESE PEAK HOUR SERVICE WITH THE JUMP IN THE BOUND AND SO THE REDUCTION FOR TWENTY EIGHTEEN WOULD BE BUT THEY SAY REDUCING OUR BUY UP SERVICE SO BASICALLY IT'S INSTEAD OF HAVING A TEN MINUTE SERVICE RUN FOR THOSE TWO BUSSES GO TO FIFTEEN MINUTES SO WE BUY TO GET QUICKER SERVICE AND SOME OF THE PEAK TIMES AND THIS JUST WAY TO REDUCE IT BACK TO THE NORMAL STANDARD FIFTEEN MINUTE CYCLES FOR THOSE TWO ROUTES ARE LOSING THE PIPES

[315:00] THEIR DEWY EYED NOT RIGHT NOW BUT TO HAVE RIDERSHIP NUMBERS ON WHAT THOSE HAVE CURRENTLY LIKE PURSE AN HOURLY BASIS WE ALWAYS WONDER IF WE HAVE RIDERSHIP NUMBERS FROM RT SO I DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER BUT I WILL ASK MIKE AND KATHLEEN HELP US GET THAT INFORMATION TO BE GREAT I MEAN IF THOSE BUSES RUNNING FOR MOST THE TIME WE CAN PROBABLY SUPPORT THAT IF IT'S STANDING ROOM ONLY THAT WOULD BE A PROBLEM SAID LIKE TO KNOW MORE I COULD THINK YOU HAVE ANYBODY SIGNED UP TO SPEAK AT THE OPENING AND CLOSING THE AIRING. I SAY A WORD COMMENT ABOUT THE REDUCTIONS AND I JUST WONDER. I JUST WANNA KNOW WITH SOME SADNESS THAT CRAIG THE BEARS POSITION IS IS ENDING MORE EASILY IN CIA OFFICER AND I WHO WHEN ON SEVERAL TRIPS WITH HIM WHERE WE WERE INVOLVED LOOK AT THE CLINTON GLOBAL INITIATIVE AND END WITH SEVERAL EVENTS OF THE ROCKEFELLER FOUNDATION

[316:02] BEHALF OF THE RESILIENCY PROJECT AND I JUST WANNA SAY SOMETHING ABOUT THE GOOD WORK THAT WAS DONE THERE AND I GUESS I KNOW THAT OUR RESILIENCY WORK GOES MUCH BEYOND ONE PERSON EVEN ON. I AM SAD TO SEE THAT POSITION AND DID I KNOW WE'LL BE LOOKING AS WE GO FOR TO SEE HOW THAT IS INTEGRATED BROADLY INTO THE WORK WE DO SO AND IF YOU WANT TO SAY THING ABOUT THAT BUT I THINK THAT'S VERY IMPORTANT BY FOR US. YES IT'S A REALLY HIGH VALUE FOR US AND WE HAVE ALREADY BEGUN WORKING WITH COUNTERS GROUP IN CLIMATE AND SUSTAINABILITY AND TAKING OVER THE RESILIENCY WORK AND IN FACT THE LEAD ON THAT WILL BE BRED CAN KAREN AND HE WILL BE WORKING WITH A GROUP OF EMPLOYEES ON A CROSS FUNCTIONAL WORK TEAM THAT GREG HAD STARTED AND WILL BE CONTINUED BY BRETT ACROSS THE ORGANIZATION SO WE HOLD IT AS A VERY VERY HIGH VALUE ON AND TANYA AND HE'S ALSO

[317:01] WORKING ON THAT. SO WE ARE ON IT THAT THIS COULD HEAR OK WITH THE QUESTIONS IN THE MORE DISCUSSION ON MORE MOTION PROMOTION AT WORK OR THAT WE ADOPT ORDINANCE EIGHTY TWO FORTY EIGHT APPROVING SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATIONS TO THE TWENTY EIGHT IN BUDGET OF A SECOND HERE OK A COUNCIL MEMBER YATES I NEVER GET TO GO FIRST THE PIECES OF GREAT I DIE YOUNG. I BROKE IT AND NEVER KNOWS HE'LL GET USE OF SOME OF THESE NAMES THE CREDIT YES CARLISLE. YES I KNOW I JONES. I WAS O NAGEL I BELIEVE ARE IN MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. GREAT THANK YOU

[318:03] FOR THAT YOU ARE RIGHT ABOUT BEING QUICKLY APPRECIATE THAT GAVE ONE LAST THING ONE LAST THING ITS APPROVAL OF THE TWEEN TEEN BOARD AND COMMISSION APPOINTMENTS K OUR DID NOT EVEN FOR LOVE IT'S OK CAN YOU PUT UP OUR LIST OK AND YOU'LL REMIND US. OK FIRST YATES UNITY THE HEAD AND TAIL SAYING OVER THEIR HEADS IS GOING TO BE ALL STAR FROM THE TOP TALES WILL BE ALL STAR FROM THE BOTTOM OKAY YET TO VERIFY SO SHE CAN DO AND WERE STARTING ALPHABETICALLY FROM THE TOP YES OK SO YOU GUYS MAY RECALL WE HAVE TWO BOULDER JUNCTION POSITIONS ONE AS ONE SPOT AND THE OTHER ONE HAS TO GAIN WEIGHT TO APPLICANTS SO SO FOR THIS WE HAVE ONE WE

[319:04] HAVE NOMINATIONS THIS WILL BE ONE POSITION WRITE THIS SO I'LL NOMINATE KEVIN KNAPP SEC SECOND. OK ANY OTHER NOMINATIONS IN THE TREE. OK HE'S ON BOTH. HE'S I MEAN JUST TO SPEAK TO IT HE GOT APPOINTED ONE YEAR AGO SIX MONTHS AGO SIX MONTHS AGO SO HE'S JUST STARTING THE TERM RACE IN JUST A SPEAKER WE GET TO APPOINT BOTH OF THEM TO THE NEXT PORT ARE BOTH FANTASTIC AND I'M CHOOSING KEVIN ON THIS ONE BECAUSE HE'S ALREADY GOTTEN STARTED AND HE'S TWO AND WORKS IN PICKING OFF RIDERS WHO GET GOING. OKAY I WAS JUST CONFUSED BY THE BOARDS BUT YOU'RE STRAIGHT NOW SEE HE HAD SAID WAS I THOUGHT HE WAS ON THE TRAVEL DEMAND. SO WHEN SEEING THESE ON BOTH OF THEM I MEAN I DON'T KNOW I'M GETTING OKAY I CAN'T RECALL MAY HAVE BEEN APPOINTED TO A SIX MONTH ON THE AM AS WELL

[320:02] IT DOESN'T MATTER BECAUSE THERE'S TWO FOR TM AND TWO APPLICANTS. OK SO IF HE'S THE ONLY APP CAN BUY AFFIRMATION IS THAT FINE OKAY NEXT WE HAVE TWO APPLICANTS TO VERY WELL QUALIFIED FOR TO YOU BY AFFIRMATION WEEKS BEFORE THEIR ONENESS TO BE FOR MATURE ENOUGH TO BE FAIR WHEN WE MAKE WILLIAM THE FIVE YEAR TERM THAT WORK FOR EVERYBODY WILLIAM FOR FIVE J NEXT URBAN BIRD A JEWELER TO MAKE A RECOMMENDATION SURE CENTS ON THE COUNCIL LIAISON ABROAD LIKE TO NOMINATE DAVID BECAUSE THEY ARE DOMINATING THE REASON A NOMINEE IN THE NEW NEWS DAY. PEOPLE WANT TO BRIEFLY SPEAK TO THEIR CANDIDATES. I JUST THINK YOU'RE LOOKING TO VARIOUS

[321:01] PEOPLE I APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT HE HAS APPLIED FOR SEVERAL BOARDS JUST LOOKING THIS IS ACTUALLY ENTIRELY POSSIBLE THAT YOU'RE ACTUALLY MAY DO SOMETHING THAT SHE HER EYE WHICH HASN'T FOR SEVERAL YEARS I JUST THINK UM DAVID IS SUPER SUPER QUALIFIED FOR FOR THIS POSITION I CAN GO IN QUALIFICATIONS BUT UM IF IF WEREN'T FOR THE FACT THAT WE'RE ACTUALLY I DO SOMETHING I WOULD BE A BORE AGNOSTIC ABOUT IT BUT DURING THE TWO YEAR TERM THAT HE MIGHT SERVE I THINK HE BRINGS A LOT OF FOAM CASE TO DO SO THE ONE THINGS I LIKED ABOUT DINO WAS IN THE QUESTIONS THAT I ASKED EACH OF THEM ABOUT WHERE OUR CANDIDATES FOR URBAN RENEWAL I LIKED HER EAST FOCUS A LITTLE BIT I THINK THAT'S A PLACE THAT WE REALLY NEED TO BE ESPECIALLY EAST ARAPAHOE LIKE TO RESPONSE ABOUT MARY'S QUESTION ABOUT GENTRIFICATION THAT IT NEEDS CAREFUL PROGRAMMING AND STUDY SO THAT'S WHAT MY TENSION OK YOU

[322:00] SUPPORT DAVID BECAUSE HE HAS AN ENORMOUS MAN OF EXPERIENCE AND HE'LL BE BRINGING PORT AND QUALIFICATIONS THE BOARD I DO WANT TO GIVE A SHOUT OUT TO DINA. SHE'S BEEN SHE'S BEEN PARTICIPATING IN VARIOUS FORMS AROUND THE COMMUNITY FOR A FEW YEARS NOW HAS GOOD IDEAS AND HOPE THAT SHE'LL CONTINUE TO APPLY AND WE CAN FIND A PORT SPOT FOR THE FUTURE. OK LET US VOTE WHICH FROM THE TOP THAT UP OK ALL THOSE IN FAVOR OF DAVID B CRAZY HAND ONE TWO THREE FOUR FIVE O K WILL SUFFER THEIR CHAIR. NEXT IS DOWNTOWN MANAGEMENT COMMISSION ABOUT ADAM BY AFFIRMATION LOO K NEXT LANDMARKS THAT GOOD THE MINI JOHN DECKER ANY OTHER NOMINEES. I'M AN AMISH AREA

[323:00] BOASTS OKAY TO SPEAK TO THAT OR YEAH I UM I THINK EITHER OF THESE KENNEDY TO BE GREAT BUT A I'M GOING AFTER CHEN TICKER BECAUSE HE APPLIED FOR I THINK PLANNING BOARD ARTS TOUR AND ART ANY APPLIED FOR TWO OF THEM AND UM AND SO I INCLUDE BECAUSE HE ONLY HAD ONE NOMINEE FOR THIS I ENCOURAGE AS MANY PEOPLE AS POSSIBLE TO APPLY IN JOHN WAS ONE OF THOSE PEOPLE SO FAIR ENOUGH BUT I THINK THEY WOULD BOTH BE ANYTHING TO DO I THINK THEY BOTH AGREE TO AND SHERRY JUST IS WHAT I KNOW HER ARCHITECTURE WORK SHE'S LIVE IN BOULDER FOR VERY VERY LONG TIME VERY SENSITIVE ARCHITECTURE GREEN IT FOCUSED HE THINK HE BRINGS. I'VE REALLY BEEN AS SOON AS UNIQUE OR THE ARCHITECTS THAT WE HAVE IN HER HER STYLE AND

[324:01] FOCUS AND THINK THAT HER HER WAY OF THINKING CAN BE HELPFUL TO THE LANDMARKS FOR ME AND JUST ON SALE PROBABLY SUPPORT JOHN DECKER HERE LIKE THE FACT THAT HE'S WORKED IN DESIGNATED DISTRICTS IN THE PAST AND I THINK THAT BRINGS A PARTICULAR KIND OF PERSPECTIVE OK I TOO THOUGHT THEY WOULD BOTH BE GOOD OK SO STARTING FROM THE BOTTOM UP ALL THOSE IN FAVOR OF JOHN DECKER AND EIGHT. OKAY I'LL STOP THERE. OK LAST BUT NOT LEAST YOU KNOW HE'LL HAVE A NOMINATION LIKE TO NOMINATE I'M SURE LORI ANY OTHERS APPRECIATED JOHN'S SOME OF JOHN'S ANSWERS AND ENTHUSIASM I JUST WANT TO STAY THAT CHERYL HAS BEEN DOING A LOT OF GOOD WORK ON THE HILL REINVESTMENT WORKING GROUP ARM SHE'S BEEN I THINK

[325:00] THERE'S A GOOD CHANCE THAT A BID COULD HAPPEN THIS YEAR IT'S A SUBJECT OF ACTIVE DISCUSSION AND WITH THE HOTEL COMING UP THERE THEY'RE ACTUALLY HELPING SUPPORT THAT WHICH I THINK IS A REALLY GOOD THING AND SO ANYWAY THE BID BEING A BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT OR JUST OR CORRECT EMAILS BEEN TALKING ABOUT ONE OF THOSE FOR THIRTY YEARS I THINK ALL YET AND SHE HAS BEEN A LOT OF GOOD WORK. OK SO I WUN NOMINEES THEM BY EXCLAMATION CHERYL OK I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION THAT WE ADOPT THAT WE ARE AWAY. I'M SORRY DOES HE WANT TO SPEAK TO THIS OKAY YOU OPEN AND CLOSED A HEARING. I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION THAT WE APPOINT ALL THE FOLKS THAT WE JUST JUST DISCUSSED AND STARR VOTED ON SECOND. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR OR OPPOSED. OK WAS HE SEE ANY

[326:00] DUE PROCESS. THE BRIEF FOR TONIGHT. I THINK WE SHOULD WAVE TO REPORTERS SHE CASTLE YES SOME WELCOME SHADE WELCOME ABOARD. I'M SORRY THIS ONE WHEN ALONE OR WITH THE MAID OF TIME THEY WERE DONE BY ELEVEN AFTER K ANYTHING ELSE UM PROCESS GUNS IN OIL AND GAS IN THEM BY ELEVEN I STAND RIGHT. WE ARE GENTLE THE IN